4 Ups & 2 Downs For AEW Collision (Jan 27 - Results & Review)

Two excellent matches highlight an otherwise solid AEW Collision.

AEW Collision Mark Briscoe FTR Daniel Garcia
AEW

Another week, another episode of AEW Collision in the books.

Of course, this week's Collision found itself in the unenviable position of going directly up against WWE Royal Rumble, which in addition to having a stacked card also often ends up being a must-watch event for those who may not even keep up with WWE. The point being, AEW was in somewhat of an uphill battle when it came to this latest Collision episode.

Still, that's not to say that Collision was phoned in, with the show headlined by a mammoth six-man elimination cage match pitting FTR and Daniel Garcia against House of Black. Adding to the drama of this bout, the episode also featured a show-long story of whether Daniel Garcia would be able to compete, whilst also offering up the possibility of Mark Briscoe as a replacement for Red Death.

Elsewhere, Serena Deeb made her return to the ring for the first time in 15 months, Mariah May had the spotlight put on her, Orange Cassidy defended the International Title against Komander, Eddie Kingston faced off against Willie Mack, Claudio Castagnoli and Jon Moxley battled Shane Taylor Promotions, and fellow Blackpool Combat Club man Bryan Danielson took on the legendary Yuji Nagata.

A solid episode with a couple of spectacular matches, Saturday night's alright for fighting...


Downs...

2. Laissez Faire Officiating Doesn't Cut It

AEW Collision Rick Knox
AEW

Yes, this may well come off as the classic 'old man shouts at clouds' sort of complaint to some, but the opening tag bout was just ridiculous when it came to the officiating.

Truthfully, your writer had to check online to see if they'd missed the announcement that Claudio Castagnoli & Jon Moxley vs. Shane Taylor & Lee Moriarty was being competed under some sort of tornado tag rules. As in, all four men are in action at once, with tags not needed.

In reality, this was simply a standard tag team match; a tag team match where referee Rick Knox couldn't give a shiny sh*t about making sure the rules of the contest are in play. It's not like that's the kayfabe job of a referee or anything, right?

In terms of the in-ring work, bar the slack officiating, the action was solid, with a hand injury making Moxley a target for Taylor's power and striking and Moriarty's fluid technical stylings, and also allowing for Claudio to be isolated. And while AEW is famous - or should that be infamous? - for how lax their referees can be, Knox was on particularly bad form here in that regard.

Sure, commentator Kevin Kelly can make mention of how Rick Knox is taking a "laissez faire" approach to this match, but that's solely due to how even Kelly was aware how foolish Knox was looking when illegal men were in the ring for long stretches or how the action spent an age on the outside without any even mild threat of a countout.

Blackpool Combat Club picked up the win as Moxley locked in the bulldog choke on Taylor, but for your writer's tastes, the utterly impotent refereeing badly took away from a match that clearly had plenty of bright spots.


1. Not Quite Firing

Some people may have appreciated this match more than others will, yet Orange Cassidy vs. Komander just felt a little, well, off.

Cassidy is great, Komander is fun in the right situation. For whatever reason, though, these two just didn't mesh as well as was hoped for. The end result was a somewhat clunky bout which at times merely went from one spot to another spot, rather than having any real fluidity or build to what we were seeing. Of course, the bulk of those spots did look good in isolation, but there needed to be more of an actual story here rather than a feel of simply going through sequences for the sake of sequences.

Whether it was a styles clash or just an off night for those involved, Cassidy vs. Komander never felt truly engaging. With Komander having earned a shot at OC's International Championship on Rampage, the wider story here was about Roderick Strong vs. Orange Cassidy at Revolution, and so this Collision contest had a sense of filler to it.

The finish of the match also felt a little flat, with Komander diving - admittedly impressively so - out on to Matt Taven and Mike Bennett, despite the Undisputed Kingdom duo not particularly doing all that much in terms of interference. Upon returning to the ring, Komander was immediately hit with the Orange Punch for the 1-2-3, and that was that.


Ups...

4. Willie Mack Always Makes For A Good Time, As Does The Mad King

Willie Mack is such a great, entertaining presence in the pro wrestling world, and any frequent reader of these Collision Ups & Downs will be well aware that there's always a good chance of an Up if Willie is in the equation. Likewise, Eddie Kingston clearly always makes for professional wrestling gold.

Mack vs. Kingston was great for what it was; a clean win for Eddie and some nice moments to shine for Willie. Even in defeat, Mack has somewhat of a get-out, for he kayfabe tweaked his knee during the early goings, but even then he didn't make it easy for the Mad King.

Kingston's win came after six minutes, nailing his Backfist to the Future to secure the victory. While this was a nice sprint of a contest, even more important was what occurred post-match. As Eddie began to make his way up the aisle, Bryan Danielson made his way out for his own upcoming match against Yuji Nagata and refused to even look in the direction of Kingston.

Of course, this follows on from the American Dragon literally spitting in Eddie's face last week, and adding more to this simmering rivalry is the fact that Danielson was now taking on someone who Eddie Kingston idolises. As such, Kingston decided to then take a seat at the commentary table to join the call for Danielson vs. Nagata, and obviously Eddie talking in any form or fashion is a bonus.


3. Two Veterans Once Again Deliver Big

AEW Collision Yuji Nagata Bryan Danielson
AEW

For those looking for a hard-hitting war between two iconic greats, look no further than Bryan Danielson vs. Yuji Nagata on this week's Collision.

While it's amazing to see how Danielson is able to still consistently put on such high quality matches after a 25-year career of intense, stiff action, it's even more remarkable to see Yuji Natata delivering to such a level at the ripe ol' age of 55. And here, both men absolutely brought it!

Strikes, grappling, submissions, suplexes, a top-rope exploder, a focus on Bryan's shoulder, and likewise a focus on Nagata's knee; this bout was just a thing of beauty to watch play out. Added to that, as alluded to, everything was just so crisp, so physical, so outright violent, and looked so impactful.

Unsurprisingly, it was the American Dragon who got the win, eventually putting Blue Justice away with the Busaiku Knee after 15 minutes. Making this even better was the commentary soundtrack of Eddie Kingston, with Kingston eager for one of his hero's to make an example of Bryan, yet also giving out praise through gritted teeth to Danielson for more than holding his own against someone who Eddie holds on such a high pedestal.

Of course, while Bryan Danielson had plenty of post-match respect for Nagata - a handshake, an arm raise, a bow - there wasn't that same sentiment towards Eddie Kingston, with Danielson flipping off Eddie before making his way to the back; all as the Mad King refused to rise to Bryan's bait.


2. Mild Progress For The Women, Excellence From Serena Deeb

They may have both been relatively short and designed to be dominant wins, but for what is the first time ever, AEW Collision featured two women's matches.

Now, ordinarily that wouldn't be seen as a major deal, yet the utilisation of its female talent is a long-standing problem of AEW programming. By that, the ladies tend to have one match per show, stuck in the same spot on the line-up, and often with a picture-in-picture commercial stuck in the middle of it.

Yes, Mariah May vs. Lady Frost did feature a picture-in-picture ad, but the simple fact of there being two contests for the AEW women should be seen as some sort of mild progress - which may well be a backhanded compliment to AEW booking.

While Frost can be such a fun talent to watch - full of extreme athleticism, snug strikes, and tight suplexes - clearly this bout was about giving a strong win to Mariah May in only her second AEW match. As such, May got a fairly straightforward W after hitting her May Day finish, although Frost did got moments to impress. That said, it didn't help that Tony Schiavone referred to Lady Frost as Lady Storm on several occasions, but that seemed to be restricted to just the picture-in-picture portion of the bout.

As for that second women's match, that was Serena Deeb's first match since October 2022. Deeb is one of the very best in the game, and so it was great to see her back between the ropes and putting away Robyn Renegade in quick fashion, hitting the Deebtox before tapping Renegade out with the Serenity Lock. Robyn could've maybe sold the post-tap impact of that hold rather than immediately exiting the ring, but that's a small gripe - especially as the greater focus was on Deeb cutting an excellent promo to reintroduce herself and put the women's division on notice.

Welcome back, Professor. You've been very much missed.


1. Car Crash Carnage Main Event

The basic notion of putting six people in a steel cage in and of itself offers up the potential for some major carnage. Throw in a heated rivalry and the fact that all six people are exceptional professional wrestlers, and this was always going to be spectacular.

Of course, the early goings of Collision found a bloodied Daniel Garcia laid out backstage, with the audience then given the episode-long story of whether or not Red Death would be able to compete. As a contingency plan, FTR had Mark Briscoe offering up his services to fill in for Garcia against the House of Black should he be needed.

It would actually be Briscoe who'd come out to partner with Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler, but that was immediately brought to a halt as House of Black attacked Chicken on the stage and threw him through a table. Fear not, though, for the bandaged, steel chair-carrying Garcia would eventually make his way out to get this match started as was originally intended.

From the get-go, things started off hot as these two teams went to battle, with an early highlight being Cash Wheeler hitting an insane crossbody from the top of the cage. That wasn't the only big bump of the night for Cash, mind, for he took a spill through a table on the outside as he was eliminated - and he'd soon be followed by Buddy Matthews likewise landing on a table as he was taken out of the match.

In fact, the elimination of Matthews was a particular highlight of the match, with Daniel Garcia smartly throwing Malakai Black into the cage in order for Black's momentum to knock his House of Black cohort from the outside of the cage onto that waiting table. With Dax Harwood and Brody King the first two men eliminated, it came down to Garcia vs. Black in the final stretch, with Garcia brilliant as the underdog, scrapping, never-say-die babyface who essentially gave Malakai the "please sir, may I have another!" treatment as he refused to stay down.

Such a simple, small thing, but another highlight was the way in which FTR rallied behind Garcia when it came down to the final two competitors. It may sound so basic, but Dax and Cash cheering on their man from outside the cage was so, so effective and continues to cement this trio as such a great fit together.

For the finish, Mark Briscoe would resurface to slam the cage door into Malakai Black's face, allowing Garcia to secure the win for his team by climbing over the top of the cage - in turn giving Daniel Garcia a huge win against all odds.

Sure, there was some mild stretching of logic at times, and the match was a little all over the place at points, but that's kind of to be expected when you put six men in a ring, let alone in a steel cage and with an elimination stipulation in place.

Another fantastic AEW Collision main event, and one worth going out of your way to check out if you happen to be one of those who opted to tune in to the Royal Rumble rather than AEW's Saturday staple.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.