4 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Battle Of The Belts V

The Acclaimed mention WWE's Vince McMahon; BOTB needs AEW's World Title; Portland is hot.

Orange Cassidy AEW All-Atlantic Title
AEW

AEW didn't really take much of a break at all between this week's excellent episode of Rampage and the latest Battle Of The Belts special on TNT. Indeed, the company followed up those three dizzying bouts from the Friday night weekly with another trio of title matches that must've had hardcore All Elite-rs checking if it was Christmas morning all over again.

If it was, then Santa is a bit of a d*ck for keeping that AEW World Title under wraps instead of under your tree. When will Tony Khan learn that this semi-regular special sorely needs more star power and the bigger prizes if it ever has a hope in hell of surviving long-term? Brace yourselves for that whinge within.

It's a soapbox moment that's merited.

On the plus side, BOTB V slapped everyone around the chops with some sports entertainment style action that'd make Vince McMahon giddy. Speaking of the soon-to-return WWE boss, ol' Vinnie Mac actually got a mention on AEW TV here; for the record, that's in the 'Downs' section.

Here's all the good and bad from BOTB V.


Downs...

4. Yawn

The Firm Stokely Hathaway Lee Moriarty Big Bill
AEW

Stokely Hathaway mean-mugged for the cameras, then said that "everyone and their mothers" thinks The Firm isn't a threat to anyone in AEW. Erm...that was just a little bit too accurate to work here. Any audience apathy might be because the group started as a vehicle for MJF then quickly became one of the most listless factions in wrestling.

Just saying.

This promo didn't fit on Battle Of The Belts, and it should have been omitted from the format sheets. It's also so hard to get excited for anything these guys are doing in January 2023, including Wednesday's match vs. "JungleHook" (Jungle Boy and Hook).

Big Bill stands around looking like Big Show did as part of The Union, and Lee Moriarty gets nothing to say whilst Stokely pretends he's a hard man. Where are they even going with any of this, and why should fans care? Hathaway is too good a manager for this frankly garbage faction.


3. It’s The Little Things

Jade Cargill Leila Grey Red Velvet
AEW

Don't worry, Jade Cargill vs. Skye Blue gets an 'Up', and there's a lot of gushing praise for what those ladies achieved to come. However, it'd be a lie to suggest that the post-match shenanigans involving Red Velvet worked out as AEW might've hoped they would.

Jade strolled up the ramp whilst Velvet was still there, then turned her back on a rival before Red had headed for the exit. That was a bit silly, if only because there was nothing stopping Velvet from sprinting back out and attacking the TBS Champ from behind.

Why would a smart athlete like Jade leave herself vulnerable like that? She didn't even get Leila Grey to watch her back and make sure Velvet didn't try anything. This is the most minor of minor gripes, but it's still valid. The little things matter.

They matter a lot.


2. Point Off For The Vince McMahon Reference

The Acclaimed AEW
AEW

OK, so some aren't going to agree with this.

That's fine, but this fan is so damn tired of All Elite Wrestling mentioning WWE like they're SEGA telling you they do what Ninten-don't. Some of Max Caster's raps are clever and have the right amount of dig. Mentioning Vince McMahon when he's all over the news and about to make a comeback though?!

Why put even more focus on the competition during AEW's own TV time? This is something the promotion has done far too often during its first three-four years of existence, and it's something they really need to quit doing. 'Hey folks, start thinking about WWE and Vince McMahon instead of this AEW Tag Championship match'.

Tony Khan might as well have run a crawler across the bottom of the screen that said: 'Vince McMahon is returning to WWE LOL! That'll put some butts in seats!". This was an attempt to be controversial for the sake of it, but all it made this viewer do was open Google on his phone and see if there was any breaking Vince news.

That's...not a good thing.


1. Still No World Title?!

MJF AEW World Champion
AEW

We're five deep into this Battle Of The Belts concept and the AEW World Title still hasn't been defended on it. Not even once. The closest fans have come to a bonafide World Championship bout? All those AEW Women's and ROH World Title scraps that have been showcased before.

Where the fudge is MJF?!

Tony needs to think about where he's taking BOTB as a standalone special, because it won't pop great ratings without properly-built title bouts involving the company's biggest stars and top prizes. The commentators even spoke about MJF when referencing Bryan Danielson's match on Rampage.

Friedman isn't alone here, but it'd be nice to see him go to TK and suggest sticking him on one of these cards. Even an exhibition match vs. some hastily-arranged challenger would be better than nothing. It's either that or the next one is called 'Battle Of The Belts VI: Not The World Title'.


Ups...

4. A Competitive Match & Prep For More

Jade Cargill AEW TBS Title
AEW

As promised, folks.

Skye Blue brought the best out in Jade Cargill during their competitive 10-minute showing. Cargill actually did some selling (not a criticism, but she's rarely tasked with looking weak), and Red Velvet was there to build towards her own eventual challenge for the TBS Title.

This was all super-solid, and another reminder of how 2023 should be a breakout year for Blue. She's a star in the making, and it'd be awesome to see what these women could go together 12 months from now. Future AEW Women's Title match? It could be, you know.

The final few moments of this one machine-gunned along, then Cargill nailed her transition into Jaded for the win. That was an unreal visual, and it's the kind of thing AEW can use in highlight packages for banner moments from her unbeaten run.

Oh yeah, Jade is now 48-0.


3. Sports Entertainment Sports Entertains

Aubrey Edwards Sonjay Dutt
AEW

The opener for those AEW Tag straps was overbooked to the point of parody, but it was still a barrel of laughs from beginning to end. The Acclaimed and the team of Jeff Jarrett and Jay Lethal probably had to go this road after the earlier Dynamite match anyway.

Everybody had something to do here.

Sonjay Dutt donned a ref shirt, which prompted Aubrey Edwards to come out and snap his pencil. Bet you fellas just crossed your legs reading that one, eh? Seriously though, Excalibur earns praise for pointing out that Aubrey was the one who caught Sonjay's interference on Wednesday night in the first match.

Score one seriously popular win for The Acclaimed (who are over as f*ck with these crowds, man). This should be heralded as one of the most entertaining BOTB matches thus far. It was something a little bit different and a big bit chaotic.

Bring on Aubrey vs. Sonjay. 60-minute 'Iron Man', here we go. Kidding.


2. Another Quality All-Atlantic Defence

Kip Sabian Orange Cassidy
AEW

Orange Cassidy has been having some seriously slick matches since becoming All-Atlantic Champion in October 2022, and this was another one. Kip Sabian challenging him had some decent build if you've been checking out Rampage, and they got a decent chunk of time to work with in the BOTB main event slot.

That's never to be sniffed at.

Despite any grumblings people may have with the whole Battle Of The Belts concept and where it's going (this writer is one of those peeps), there can be no arguments against this match. Kip came through, there were enough bells and whistles to keep things interesting, and Orange picked up a clean win to send fans home happy.

There was a parallel to draw between this and the TNT Title match from Rampage. Both belts are held by AEW pet project babyfaces who are over with crowds, and both are on champs who can work with just about anybody.

Fingers crossed Sabian doesn't go back to putting cardboard boxes on his head after thriving here.


1. That Portland Crowd

AEW Portland Crowd
AEW

AEW can visit Portland anytime. Any. Freakin'. Time.

The Oregon crowd came alive for absolutely everything put in front of them, and they didn't let up for the entirety of Rampage or Battle Of The Belts. Folks in the stands were so on form that the commentators had to mention their booming chants and sustained noise throughout.

BCC were over, Top Flight were over, Britt Baker and Jamie Hayter were over, Darby Allin was over, The Acclaimed were over, Jeff Jarrett and Jay Lethal were over, Jade Cargill was over, Orange Cassidy was...you get the (well-laboured) point. Portland loved everybody.

Preston Vance, The Renegade Twins, Skye Blue, Kip Sabian and even bloody Sonico all got treated like mega-stars by a fired up live audience who had clearly waited for the chance to see some All Elite action. There was a peak 'Attitude Era' feel to this crowd, and that's meant as a compliment.

What did you think of AEW's Battle Of The Belts V? For more like this, check out 10 Things Everybody Hates About AMAZING Wrestling Matches and 10 Moments That Made Sasha Banks WWE's MVP!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.