4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Nov 26)

WWE make Toni Storm look stupid; SmackDown reveals a new contender; Brock Lesnar is back.

Kayla Braxton Paul Heyman
WWE.com

Thank f*ck Survivor Series is over.

That pay-per-view is a creative noose round WWE's neck every year, and it will be until they quit pretending that anybody cares about the "brand supremacy" nonsense. The good news is that SmackDown pulled the nose up a bit this week - there are several interesting stories bubbling away.

Brock Lesnar will return on next week's episode too. That was the biggest takeaway by far, but there was backup in the form of Sami Zayn becoming a new Universal Title contender and the possibility that WWE will spin Sonya Deville out of her story with Naomi into a feud with somebody much higher-profile.

Then...there was the bad. The company's obsession with theming specific episodes around real-life holidays meant that Vince McMahon's love of "hilarious" food fighting continued. That spelled disaster for Toni Storm and an otherwise-well worked Rick Boogs vs. Angel match.

The brand new Day 1 show is looming, and WWE has the Royal Rumble to focus on beyond that. Being honest, anything will be better than the Raw vs. SmackDown tripe they've been serving for much of the month.

Here's all the good and the bad from Friday's latest.


Downs...

5. “Cesaro Steals A Win”

Cesaro Ridge Holland
WWE.com

Babyfaces like Cesaro shouldn't be "stealing wins".

That's how Michael Cole framed his victory over newcomer Ridge Holland on this week's show though. According to Cole, Cesaro nabbed a fast one over Ridge and left Sheamus speechless. The presentation was all over the place here; Sheamus hyped Ridge up, then watched him slip on the proverbial banana peel.

Meanwhile, Cesaro was presented as an opportunist rather than the pure wrestling machine he is. Who knows why the writing team felt this was the correct way to close this match when they had an easier solution (a more definitive win) staring them in the face. It's hardly a disgrace if Holland loses to Cesaro's finish, is it?

The Swiss cyborg was wrestling for the Universal Title earlier this year, and Ridge is a SmackDown newbie who needs some more seasoning. Everybody can see that, so why hide his first loss behind the annoying idea that Cesaro "stole one"?


4. Ignoring The Gimmick

Rick Boogs Angel
WWE.com

Rick Boogs and Angel (don't call him Garza!) did everything they could to offset the woeful "Thanksgiving Leftovers Throwdown" tag during their match? However, if WWE really wanted to hand them that food fighting guff, then the least they could've done was ensure that both guys wanted to use it.

Boogs and Angel barely went near the props.

Humberto was the only one who took a bump through the table after jamming on Rick's guitar - his legs were swept by Shinsuke Nakamura, who is still Intercontinental Champ by the way, and the heel ended up landing on some mashed potatoes and corn. Now that's a sentence.

WWE need to move on from this now though. A feud between Los Letharios and the Boogs/Naka combo doesn't make any sense anyway. One is a fresh tag-team, and the other combo features the IC Champ. What are they fighting over?!


3. Will They Waste Shayna Baszler Forever?

Shayna Baszler Natalya Naomi
WWE.com

Shayna Baszler's SmackDown career is almost two months old.

Since moving over from Raw, she's teamed with Sonya Deville to beat Naomi in a handicap match, beaten Naomi twice in singles, worked some tags and been background noise to Deville's storyline. It's...not good to see Baszler cutting such a peripheral figure when she's one of the best workers in the division.

Honestly, Shayna's entire main roster run had been a miserable flop thus far. She's gone from teaming with Nia Jax and screwing around with dolls on Raw to this horsesh*t on Smackers. Seeing her get totally lost in the shuffle when she should be a top contender for the SmackDown Women's Title is pretty crap.

So, the question must be asked of WWE. Will Shayna ever get close to her NXT peak again? Or, are creative content to let her merely exist in going-nowhere tags? Baszler must become a focal point soon. She's too talented for this role.


2. The Names In That Battle Royal

WWE SmackDown Black Friday Battle Royal
WWE.com

Adam Pearce and Sonya Deville, despite heelish flourishes from both, claim that they have Raw and SmackDown's best interests at heart. They're there to make each show as exciting as possible, right? Yeah, well that's not going to happen when they book main event Battle Royals starring this motley crew.

Check this for a list:

The Viking Raiders, Sheamus, Sami Zayn, Drew Gulak, Ricochet, Jinder Mahal, Los Letharios, Cesaro, Happy Corbin, Madcap Moss, Shanky, Mace, Rick Boogs, Mansoor, Ridge Holland and Jeff Hardy. That was the line up for the 'Black Friday' special to determine a new number one contender for Roman Reigns' Universal Title.

Gulak? Madcap Moss? Mansoor? Shanky? Seriously?! What did any of those dudes do to earn a potential crack at SmackDown's top title? Pearce and Deville picked them out ahead of Drew McIntyre too. Even if that turns out to be a storyline ("Who screwed Drew?"), it's still iffy.


1. Stupid Babyfaces Are Stupid

Charlotte Flair Toni Storm
WWE.com

Congratulations, WWE - you've officially made Toni Storm look like an idiot.

Previously, Storm had roared out and put herself forward for a shot at Charlotte Flair. The reigning champ laughed at her, dismissed such suggestions and then offered a non-title bout. Apparently, Toni was happy with that. Then, here, Storm was literally pie-faced by Charlotte.

Twice. She was pie-faced twice. That italics overload is worth it, because this was a dreadful segment that made poor Toni look like an insignificant punk. She took a cream pie to the chops early, then fell for Flair's 'come at me' trick a second time. How is this supposed to be help her level up and look anywhere close to worthy of a title shot?

WWE's writers need to rethink their strategy here. They've switched from serious heat between Becky Lynch and Charlotte to Flair slapping pies into her next challenger's face. Tonally, this is garbage. Remember this when Storm is suddenly cast as a threat overnight.


Ups...

4. Something WWE Should Explore

Sonya Deville Sasha Banks
WWE

Meanwhile, better things are brewing elsewhere in the women's division.

Sasha Banks approached Sonya Deville behind the scenes and warned her not to mess with her career like the authority figure has been doing with Naomi. That prompted Deville to jaw back and come away with a clever/smug line about being the 'Boss' because she wears those power suits.

This is already one million times more intriguing than Deville vs. Naomi. WWE probably don't want that, but it's true, and it owes a lot to Sasha's superior star power. She's actually standing up to Sonya ahead of time too, which Naomi didn't really do. She just sort of moped around hoping things might change, which made her seem weak.

WWE will book that Sonya vs. Naomi match at some point. After it, they've got a ready-made tale that'd get Deville out of the suits and back into in-ring competition full-time. Banks would bring out the best in Sonya, and maybe get her back to the glory days of 2020's summer months.


3. A Fine Opening Tag

Drew McIntyre Jeff Hardy Madcap Moss
WWE.com

Granted, it remains to be seen exactly where they're going with this Jeff Hardy/Drew McIntyre association, but good matches are good matches. It's hard to argue with this opening tag. Happy Corbin and Madcap Moss bumped around nicely throughout, and the finish was really popular.

A hometown win. Imagine that.

No, there was nothing earth-shattering here. Is that a problem? Hell no. The live crowd popped big for Drew smashing Madcap with a Claymore Kick, and Jeff's Swanton Bomb later got the reaction of the night. That's encouraging for those who believe Hardy needs another main event run (even if it's a brief one).

Side note: Happy/Madcap showed they're capable of moving into the tag division proper here. They'd be nice heel foil for the next babyface champs post-Usos, that's for sure. Both guys work well together, so hopefully Corbin eliminating Moss in the headline Battle Royal won't lead to a split.


2. A Surprising Winner

Sami Zayn
WWE.com

He did it! He did it! He. Did. It!

Nobody could've predicted that Sami Zayn would emerge from the main event 'Black Friday Battle Royal' as the new Universal Title contender, but it happened. Of course, WWE will probs change their minds on their and pivot into a multi-man scenario at Day 1. That wouldn't be the worst plan though.

A heel vs. heel showdown pitting Roman Reigns vs. Sami would be tough to produce anyway, especially when Zayn is so easy to dislike. It'd also be risky to put him in there with Roman full stop, 'cause WWE won't want either of these guys getting cheers. Meh, they've got a fun story to tell now if nothing else.

Roman laughed at Sami coming out on top. His arrogance is unmatched; the 'Tribal Chief' stopped just short of licking his lips and asking for that title defence to happen immediately. Zayn winning is a neat curveball from SmackDown's creative team.


1. Brock Is Back

Paul Heyman Roman Reigns
WWE

Then, this happened too.

Zayn barely had time to celebrate before Kayla Braxton got word (from some mystery source) that Brock Lesnar's "indefinite suspension" had been lifted. That led to sighs from Adam Pearce, a miffed look from Sami and a tense exchange of glances between Roman Reigns and Paul Heyman.

Heyman's 'oh sh*t I'm in trouble now' expression was priceless, but so was Roman struggling to keep a lid on his anger. Now, SmackDown has a main event story it can slow-burn through until the Royal Rumble at the earliest. They surely won't put Reigns vs. Lesnar on Day 1. Surely.

It'd be more logical to book a multi-man effort on that show. Sami Zayn is due a shot at the Universal Title, and Roman still has some issues with King Woods after wrecking his crown pre-Survivor Series. Add another body in there and WWE can script an easy four way.

Brock's comeback is big news, but his next title shot can wait.

What did you think about this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 4 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Rampage (Nov 20) and 10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE Raw From 2000!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.