4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SummerSlam 2025 - Sunday (Results & Review)

WWE closes show with a highly controversial move, overshadowing a really good main event.

WWE SummerSlam 2025 John Cena Cody Rhodes
WWE

These days, WWE has made it clear that they are all about “making moments” and “going viral” with their product, not producing the best wrestling show they possibly can. Their SummerSlam opening videos, narrated by Druski, explicitly stated that, showing video highlights and YouTubers reacting to them.

Well, after Sunday’s main event, there is plenty of online chatter and viral content being generated about WWE, though it might not be what they hoped to garner.

WWE welcomed Brock Lesnar back to the fold, bringing the formerly blacklisted superstar in to confront John Cena after a much better-than-expected main event against Cody Rhodes. The return of the Beast sparked immediate controversy and marred Cena’s best match in several years.

However, it also punctuated an underwhelming night that started strong enough with two good matches before descending into an overbooked plunder marathon, a boring steel cage match, and an inoffensive, but empty calorie tribute to Eddie Guerrero.

All told, SummerSlam 2025 was less about a quality wrestling show and more about the big moments, with CM Punk’s World Heavyweight Championship win and Seth Rollins’ immediate cash-in dominating the conversation Saturday night, and Lesnar’s return overshadowing everything on Sunday. The highlight videos will be extremely popular, but the number of fans going back and rewatching both nights in full is going to be much smaller.

Let’s get to it…

Get 76% off, four free months, and a free Amazon gift card when you sign up to NordVPN here: http://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=564&aff_id=3013&url_id=31010&aff_sub1=WhatCulture.


Downs…

5. Bump-Reluctant Team Triumphs

WWE SummerSlam 2025 The Wyatt Sicks Joe Gacy Dexter Lumis Erick Rowan Uncle Howdy
WWE

The six-team TLC match for the WWE Tag Team Championships was a chaotic orgy of bodies flying every which way through tables and ladders after getting smacked with chairs.

Well, at least 10 of the 12 bodies were flying around the ring and ringside area. The Wyatt Sicks, the defending champs, took a couple of bumps in the opening moments, but after a table spot spree, Joe Gacy and Dexter Lumis all but disappeared from the match, with the rest of the Wyatt Sicks running in to fill the space.

Meanwhile, the other five teams in the match bumped like crazy and carried TLC to its climax. Despite not being in the match, Candice LeRae might have taken more bumps than Gacy and Lumis combined.

It’s not that the Wyatts aren’t deserving, but fans seemingly would have been happy with any of the other five teams winning because they appeared to earn it, while the Wyatts emptied their bench to save their tag team, and then they showed up at the end to snatch the titles.


4. Save Fatu From This Mess

WWE SummerSlam 2025 Jacob Fatu Solo Sikoa Talla Tonga
WWE

Cooldown matches exist to bring down the emotions, noise, and energy level of crowds during wrestling shows. It’s virtually impossible to keep an audience at a “10” for a four-hour show, so you throw a short match out there that will take the temperature down a bit while not leaving the crowd comatose.

The steel cage match for the United States Championship likely was not intended to be a cooldown match, but it had all the elements of one. Solo Sikoa and his MFTs have to be one of the most comically bad stables in recent WWE history, up there with Retribution and Zelina Vega’s charges during the pandemic. They’re almost entirely composed of goons who get owned on a regular basis, and Sunday was no different.

Solo and Jacob Fatu had what could be described as a paint-by-numbers WWE cage match, just chugging along with wrestling moves happening and a few tosses into the cage. Then the MFTs arrived, only for Jimmy Uso to show up and take out JC Mateo and Tonga Loa. Talla Tonga would put Uso down, though. Talla managed to handcuff Fatu to the cage (the second consecutive match where a wrestler was cuffed), but Jacob broke free and tried to stop Solo from escaping. One slammed door later, Sikoa fell out of the cage for the win

The match was just as exciting to watch as it was to read that description. It happened, and no one is going to watch it again. They jobbed out Fatu, who then demolished Loa and Mateo inside the cage while Solo and Talla retreated up the ramp. Terrible stuff. They need to get Jacob away from these goons before his aura dissipates completely.


3. More Physical Prop Comedy Than Blood Feud

WWE SummerSlam 2025 Becky Lynch Lyra Valkyria
WWE

No-disqualification matches that rely heavily on plunder are a risky proposition: They have to be balanced between an actual fight and a series of weapons spots. Fall back on the plunder too much and it becomes almost cartoonish, especially in WWE, where blood and violence are downplayed, taking the “oomph” out of many weapons shots.

Becky Lynch versus Lyra Valkyria had all the potential in the world. Their previous matches have been mostly class, and they have excellent chemistry. Giving them a bit more latitude should have opened the door for a more intense, reality-based battle for the Women’s Intercontinental Championship.

Instead, the match was a long series of plunder spots, with kendo sticks, a crowbar, chairs, tables, a toolbox, a wrench, a fire extinguisher, a chain, and an uncooperative zip-tie being employed.

The zip-tie was a true low spot, as they clearly wanted to get across Lyra as a beaten-down underdog, being pummeled while her hands were literally tied, and then miraculously making a comeback, all without the use of her hands.

The problem was that Valkyria’s hands came free at one point, and Lyra put the zip-tie back on while on-camera. It didn’t help that this heat segment went on for what felt like an eternity, with Lyra running all over the ring looking for something to cut her hands loose. It’s not like there’s sharp metal anywhere at ringside… oh wait.

Beyond the zip-tie nonsense, the match just kept going… for a full 25 minutes, well past the peak. Then they stapled on a Bayley save and errant swing with the chain, costing Lyra the match. Bayley looked comically bad, standing on the apron too stunned to save Valkyria from the pin, like an ineffective goober rather than one of the Four Horsewomen.

Overall, this was an overbooked, long, cartoonish match that wanted to be taken more seriously. It had some good moments, but this has to be the weakest of the Becky/Lyra collection.


2. Who Booked This Card?

WWE SummerSlam 2025 DIY Tommaso Ciampa Johnny Gargano Uncle Howdy TLC
WWE

By the time Sunday’s show got to the third match of the night, it became pretty apparent that WWE had not paid particular attention to the match types when they booked both nights’ cards.

Saturday’s show featured six announced tag and singles matches, all straightforward bouts with no special stipulations. Then came Sunday, which went like this: triple threat (no disqualifications), TLC, no-DQ, steel cage, singles match, street fight.

That’s six matches, five of which carried essentially a no-DQ stipulation and allowed for plunder and interference galore. By the time we got to the Undisputed WWE Championship street fight, fans had seen a dozen tables broken, a bunch of steel chairs wielded, ladders broken, and kendo sticks swung.

This was poor booking, especially when it came to the TLC match for the WWE Tag Team Championship and the Women’s Intercontinental Championship, which ran back-to-back. Trying to watch Becky Lynch and Lyra Valkyria batter each other with weapons after seeing 12 wrestlers absolutely obliterate each other moments earlier was quite the effort. You unconsciously become desensitized to the weapon shots and have a more difficult time registering the impact of those attacks.

Flipping one or two matches on each night would have made a tremendous difference.


1. WWE Flips Off Sex Trafficking Allegations

WWE SummerSlam 2025 Brock Lesnar
WWE

There is a very good reason Brock Lesnar had not been seen on WWE programming in two years, and why an appearance in the 2024 Royal Rumble was suddenly scrapped at the last minute.

Lesnar is implicated in Janel Grant’s sex trafficking and assault case against Vince McMahon and WWE. He was on WWE’s no-fly list for the past year and a half, a huge liability being referenced in an active suit against the company.

So, what does WWE do at the conclusion of SummerSlam after John Cena turns back the clock with his best singles match in probably seven years? They trot Brock out to pop an unsuspecting crowd and to confront Cena.

This is terrible, disgusting, and flat-out gross for a few reasons. Wrestling-wise, Cena/Lesnar in 2025 likely isn’t going to reach the level of their 2012 showdowns. Brock legit hasn’t wrestled in two years, and Cena has had exactly one good match since the pandemic.

As a business decision, it really says something for a company that tries to promote parity with its women’s division to constantly sidestep an active lawsuit alleging that former higher-ups trafficked a female employee and then rehired one of the people whose name shows up multiple times in the suit.

Worse yet, WWE’s decision to scrap the post-PLE media availabilities that they typically hold after major shows was clearly a way for Paul “Triple H” Levesque to avoid having to answer questions about Brock and the lawsuit. Either have the courage to stand behind your convictions and decision to rehire Lesnar despite the active sex trafficking suit, or don’t bring him back.


Ups…

4. The Eddie Tribute Match

WWE SummerSlam 2025 AJ Styles Dominik Mysterio
WWE

Honestly, had WWE worked the Eddie Guerrero references into the story between AJ Styles and Dominik Mysterio before Sunday, their Intercontinental Championship match could have worked a lot better.

Styles doing solid comedy patter on Raw in recent weeks helped create interest in this feud, but there was nary a mention of Eddie until AJ showed up in a lowrider at SummerSlam, and the announcers pointed out that it was the 20th anniversary of the Custody of Dominik Mysterio match between Guerrero and Rey Mysterio.

From there, though, they were off to the races, with Styles wearing tights reminiscent of Eddie’s gear that night. Dominik went for the Three Amigos as usual, while Styles attempted a frogsplash. Both men did the Eddie “chair fake-out” behind the referee’s back as well.

In the end, it was Dominik stealing a page from Uncle Eddie at WrestleMania 20, unzipping his boot so that when AJ applied the Calf Crusher, the boot slipped off and Mysterio used it to wallop Styles, then finished him with a frogsplash.

As a match, this wasn’t much, but as a sub-main event and some light fare, this worked just fine.


3. TLC Car Crash

WWE SummerSlam 2025 Johnny Gargano Tommaso Ciampa Montez Ford Axiom TLC
WWE

TLC matches are not designed for psychology or methodical pacing. They are usually chaotic frenzies of action, with bodies flying through tables, racing up ladders, and being yanked back down to Earth.

SummerSlam’s six-team TLC match started off looking like it was crowded with too many wrestlers, but the match eventually settled into a good rhythm, with everyone getting opportunities to shine. The Street Profits, Fraxiom, and Andrade and Rey Fenix in particular looked strong throughout, with Fenix coming an eyelash away from winning the match in the early going without a ladder (Rey stood on Andrade’s shoulders and lunged for the titles).

Everyone’s seconds and stablemates got involved (ala TLC at WrestleMania X-Seven), with Candice LeRae, B-Fab, and Nikki Cross having their own exchange while all 12 men were down from everyone going through tables. This would lead to Candice climbing the ladder to try to retrieve the titles for DIY, only to be inadvertently knocked to the floor and through a ladder bridge.

The highlight of the match came when Tommaso Ciampa found himself hanging from the title hanger when the ladder was pulled away. Nathan Fraser went to do his best Edge impersonation and tried to spear Ciampa from the ladder, but Tommaso curled himself up to avoid the spear.

All told, this was a fun car crash of a match, not on the level of the classic TLC matches, but certainly not slacking in the chaos department.


2. Another Solid Women’s Triple Threat Opener

WWE SummerSlam 2025 Naomi Iyo Sky Rhea Ripley
WWE

Hot take: Rhea Ripley and Iyo Sky are pretty good at opening PLEs in title matches.

The two challenged Women’s World Champion Naomi to kick off Sunday’s show, and all three wrestlers delivered a pretty solid title match. Naomi started out by bailing to the outside, but once she was forced back in, the champ dominated the early part, which kept Rhea and Iyo from getting physical for the first several minutes. That was a clever move, building the anticipation while establishing that Naomi was on equal footing with the more established main-eventers.

The back half of the match was solid action, with all three women getting chances to shine. Naomi had a great moment where she hit Rhea with a split-legged moonsault, then rolled off her own pinfall when she saw Iyo flying in with a moonsault of her own. It showed ring awareness from the champion. Ripley and Sky continued to dazzle in their one-on-one segments, naturally.

The finish saw Rhea hit Iyo with an Avalanche Riptide, only for Naomi to roll Ripley up for the pin. You could call that a cowardly heel move, but Naomi was in the mix throughout the match and kept attacking – this was just an opportune moment for her.

While nowhere on the level of the WrestleMania triple threat opener, this was a pretty good match to kick off the show.


1. Cena Turns Back The Clock

WWE SummerSlam 2025 John Cena Cody Rhodes
WWE

Whatever you think of John Cena’s abrupt about-face on SmackDown, abandoning his heel turn suddenly, he and Cody Rhodes redeemed themselves from WrestleMania 41 on Sunday night.

Cena turned in his best singles performance in probably seven years, battling Cody for more than 35 minutes in a finisher-kickout-heavy match that saw both men unload their entire arsenal on the other several times, to no avail. Rhodes even broke out the dreaded piledriver, which Wade Barrett noted is technically banned in WWE, and used the turnbuckle assembly to batter Cena multiple times. Cena hit more than a half-dozen Attitude Adjustments, including through the Spanish announce desk, on the ramp, and off the top rope, but none of them kept Cody down.

Despite being comprised mainly of both men swinging for the fences, the match didn’t drag. It probably went a good five to 10 minutes past its peak, but the drama never really subsided.

For Cena, this felt like a return to form, as if being unshackled from a dismal heel run emboldened him to just go for broke with some of the spots. The match probably wouldn’t chart against Cena’s best stuff from his full-time run, but it vastly surpassed everything he’s done since the pandemic.

And for Cody, the match felt like a passing of the torch moment, with Super Cena finally being felled after a superhuman effort from Rhodes. Now, Cody can move forward with the title, and Cena can continue his farewell tour.

Get 76% off, four free months, and a free Amazon gift card when you sign up to NordVPN here: http://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=564&aff_id=3013&url_id=31010&aff_sub1=WhatCulture.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.