5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SummerSlam 2025 - Saturday (Results & Review)
A mixed bag of a show with a shocking conclusion after Punk, Gunther rule the ring.
Heading into the main event of SummerSlam Saturday, WWE’s biggest show of the season was teetering between mediocre and decent.
The first five matches of the announced six-match card had more or less split the difference, with the three tag matches more or less delivering and the two singles bouts falling short. But then CM Punk and Gunther stepped in the ring and put on an absolute masterpiece of a main event. If ever there was a time for a “This is wrestling” chant at a WWE show, this match was it. The World Heavyweight Championship bout served as a reminder that even the average WWE fan, who might be more excited about “yeeting” along with Jey Uso than watching a technical classic, can be wowed by good, old-fashioned professional wrestling.
That match, and what ensued afterward, was more than enough to elevate the first night of SummerSlam, but fans would be forgiven if they chose to watch the opening tag match, maybe the women’s tag title match, and then skipped straight to the main event.
The first two-night SummerSlam felt like it had filler content, not just the copious amounts of dead space before and between matches, but a couple of the matches themselves didn’t give off “major PLE” energy. Sunday’s card looks decidedly better – on paper – provided John Cena doesn’t tank another main event, but for now, Saturday’s show is in the books, so dive in and see how things shook out.
Let’s get to it.
Get 76% off, four free months, and a free Amazon gift card when you sign up to NordVPN here: http://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=564&aff_id=3013&url_id=31010&aff_sub1=WhatCulture.
Downs…
4. A Recipe For Boredom
If you watch WWE for the celebrities, the video packages, and the entrances, the opening 20 minutes of SummerSlam were your jam.
WWE’s third-biggest PLE of the year opened with the usual arrival shots, followed by a video package narrated by Druski, followed by a full entrance for SummerSlam host Cardi B. This all preceded the lengthy entrances for Jey Uso and Roman Reigns, making it about 20 minutes before the bell rang for the first match.
On its own, that might not merit a “down,” just a head shake, but then the first half of the tag match pitting the OG Bloodline against the Seth Riders was about as dull and basic as you could imagine. Punch, kick, clothesline, punch, slam.
Now, the match got better - much better - but the combination of filler, lengthy entrances, and a bland start to the opening match was a recipe for disinterest. They got it back, but that was not what you would consider an electric start to SummerSlam.
3. Can This Feud Finally Be Done?
If this truly is the end of Karrion Kross’ run in WWE, it’s nice that he got to go out with a singles match at SummerSlam, but otherwise, this was going out with a whimper, not a bang.
Kross battled Sami Zayn in the third match of their series, with Sami ultimately getting the win after about eight minutes of mediocre action. The “high drama” of the match came when Scarlett retrieved the lead pipe, and after Karrion swung and missed with it, gave it to Zayn to use, trying to tempt him to give in to his darker side.
Sami threw the pipe down, kicked out of a rollup, and nailed an Exploder and Helluva Kick to vanquish Kross. And that was that.
You can see what they were trying to accomplish – Kross playing the devil, tempting Sami to take shortcuts to get back in the world title hunt – but as a side quest for Sami, it seemingly accomplished very little. He didn’t really face that big of a trial or crisis of conscience or confidence. He got battered with a lead pipe and was supposed to be out “indefinitely,” and came back in two weeks, got battered again, and still won the feud.
At least it’s over, right?
2. End Of The Jade Experiment?
Say what you will, but Saturday felt like the big trial for Jade Cargill.
Jade’s WWE run has been a mixed bag: She has an incredible presence and charisma, and a tremendous look, and while she can impress in the ring at times, she also can look completely lost. At times, she appears to have regressed since her AEW run.
Still, WWE took a chance and crowned her Queen of the Ring, granting her a WWE Women’s Championship match at SummerSlam. Saturday, Cargill fell short against Tiffany Stratton in a seven-minute match that seemed to be going for one of Brock Lesnar’s sprints, where the wrestlers just go for big moves nonstop. No transitions, no headlocks. Just signatures and high-impact offense.
Despite that, the match still came off as clunky and not very well executed. Stratton’s Swanton Bomb looked good, as did Jade catching a handspring back elbow and putting Tiffany down with a backbreaker. But the finish, which saw Cargill trying to hit an avalanche Jaded – only to have it countered into a body scissors – took eons to set up and looked terrible.
In the end, Stratton won, handing Jade her first truly clean singles loss in WWE. If WWE was going to push forward with Cargill as a megastar, this would have been the time to pull the trigger, or at least not have her lose to a single Prettiest Moonsault Ever. Perhaps they’ll try again in Paris, but this was a disappointing match, and it felt more like a sidestep away from Jade than anything else.
Even if they continue the feud, they will need a different approach in the ring.
1. So. Much. TALKING.
Welcome to WWE in 2025, where every wrestler must monologue during their matches.
Dear God, the level of superstars carrying on full conversations in the ring Saturday night was near-unbearable. Bron Breakker carried on quite a bit in the ring, even singing to Roman Reigns at one point (“Roman! You suck!”). Karrion Kross kept urging Sami Zayn to “just say it”, that Kross was right, over and over. Scarlett got involved, too, yelling from the floor for Sami to pick up the lead pipe and use it on her husband.
During the celebrity tag match, Jelly Roll and Randy Orton had an entire hype-up session on camera before Jelly turned around and crapped himself trying to face off against Drew McIntyre. The Scottish Warrior also got in on the chattering action, mocking Jelly Roll and telling him he didn’t belong in a wrestling ring. And of course, Gunther talked some trash on CM Punk during the main event.
Not all chatter during a match is bad, but WWE has gone full overkill with the melodramatic diatribes in the ring, viewing a match more as a televised representation of competition and inserting dialogue to really lay it on thick for the viewing audience. It’s similar to any sports-based movie where they cut to the players between the action, and they have entire conversations to set the scene.
Recently, though, it seems like more than half the matches on WWE programming default to this chattering on camera, which cheapens when something critical happens verbally. Get this under control, WWE, before it becomes an epidemic and wrestlers are delivering full monologues every time out there.
Ups…
5. Celebrity Tag Match Delivers
The notion of an overweight country music star “wrestling” on one of WWE’s biggest shows of the year sounds ridiculous on its face, but sometimes you need to just lower your expectations and roll with it.
Jelly Roll teaming with Randy Orton to take on Logan Paul and Drew McIntyre is not going to be everyone’s cup of tea. It might downright piss some people off. But giving WWE a bit of latitude, this wasn’t all that bad of a match. It was structured decently, with Jelly taking everything seriously – the training clips helped show that he wasn’t just walking into the ring blindly – and knowing he was overmatched in the opening minutes against McIntyre.
Orton basically had to wrestle a handicap match, with Jelly being useful in very small spurts… until Logan splashed the musician through the announce desk in another highlight reel spot. Kudos to Jelly for taking that move. Randy was on his own until Jelly bravely(?) climbed back onto the apron and tagged in. Jelly got in a bit of offense on Paul before McIntyre leveled him with a Claymore, and Logan finished him with a frogsplash for the win.
Basically, a celebrity came in, trained on camera to show he was taking this seriously, got blasted through a table, hung in there and delivered a couple of nice spots, and ultimately ate the pin because he was overmatched.
That’s a surprisingly simple formula, with a fair amount of ga-ga stapled on. Some will hate this, but it ultimately was inoffensive.
4. Bliss Makes Flair A Fan Favorite
When the story of WWE 2025 is written, there is going to need to be a chapter dedicated to Alexa Bliss managing to turn Charlotte Flair into a bona fide babyface after countless failed efforts to get fans to cheer the Queen.
Their tag match against the Judgment Day for the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship wasn’t a classic from an in-ring perspective. The action was perfectly fine, but it wasn’t the wrestling that was the story – although Charlotte’s hot tag blitz was quite impressive and had the crowd rocking, which was really impressive.
Flair and Bliss are a modern-day Odd Couple, mismatched heroes trying to get along (and possibly pretending they don’t get along as well as they actually do) was the story at play here, and everything nearly came crashing down.
Raquel Rodriguez had Charlotte in her clutches, and Alexa charged to lay out Big Mami Cool, only for Roxanne Perez to pull Raquel to safety. Bliss nailed Flair, which very nearly led to Charlotte taking the fall, but the heroines persevered, and just as Alexa had Roxanne in position for the Sister Abigail, Charlotte rose up and charged… right past Bliss to boot Rodriguez, allowing Alexa to finish Perez and capture the tag titles.
Fun stuff that the fans ate up with a spoon. Bliss and Flair as unlikely tag champs could make for good television, if their antics thus far are any indication.
3. Roman Brings Character Work To The Ring
During the entire OG Bloodline run, one of the constant criticisms was the melodrama and overacting that took place inside the ring. Saturday, Roman Reigns did some different character work that actually worked to advance his arc more than any lengthy promo possibly could.
One of the biggest criticisms of Reigns’ “face turn” since returning post-WrestleMania 40 last year was that he never really took ownership for being the biggest villain on the roster for nearly four years. He bullied and alienated his family, tormented authority figures, and cheated his way into an epic title reign. When he returned, he took next-to-no responsibility for those actions, but because he was opposing a rogue, heel Bloodline, he became a face by default.
During the tag match alongside Jey Uso against Bron Breakker and Bronson Reed on Saturday, Roman showed affection for his cousin, even sacrificing himself at one point to protect him. Early on, Reigns joined Jey in calling for Uso’s music to be played again (a dumb move mid-match, but a lighthearted show of support).
When Roman got the hot tag late in the match, he ran wild with more energy than he’s shown in a while - he actually overshot the heels with his dive to the floor, clearly amped - but when the match got to the climax, he and Jey hit the 1D on Reed, then Reigns saved Uso from a Breakker spear, taking the bullet himself. That sacrifice allowed Jey to take out Bron and put Reed down for the win.
Roman’s selfless act allowed his cousin to get the glory, something the Reigns of 2020-2024 never would have done. A nice character development that helped elevate a fun final five minutes of the tag match.
2. Rollins Pulls Off Another Heist
Ever since Saturday Night’s Main Event last month, fans have been playing detective to determine whether Seth Rollins’ knee injury was real or if it was all part of the show.
After collapsing and quickly losing to LA Knight on that Saturday show, Rollins disappeared from television. Reports about the severity of his knee injury were inconclusive, with no details emerging and stories circulating that this was all a work, designed not just to throw fans, but also the wrestlers in storylines.
Sure enough, Seth made his way out to the ramp after CM Punk won the World Heavyweight Championship, hobbling on crutches while wearing a big ol’ knee brace, only to ditch everything and run to the ring, cash in, and dethrone Punk.
For Rollins and his stable, this was a necessary next step. The group could not continue to talk a good game about taking over Raw and just continue to flounder as a heel act without the top prize, especially after Bron Breakker and Bronson Reed lost to Roman Reigns and Jey Uso in the opening match. The title lends credibility to the act and shows commitment to the story.
For Punk, it’s payback in a strange way. At WrestleMania 40, a sidelined Punk battered new World Heavyweight Champion Drew McIntyre at ringside, opening the door for Damian Priest to cash in and end his title reign at five minutes. Saturday, it was Punk whose WHC run was ended via Money in the Bank cash-in after about five minutes with the belt.
1. Best In The World X 2
Wow. Just, wow.
In recent months, the chatter about CM Punk has circled around whether he still has enough in the tank to deliver a classic. Saturday night, Punk and Gunther took a half-hour to dispel any notions and leave fans breathless with a simple, yet suspenseful, World Heavyweight Championship match that eschewed ga-ga in favor of rising, methodical, physical drama.
Gunther clearly had the upper hand throughout, battering Punk with chops, boots, and a few slams, suplexes, and powerbombs mixed in, but Punk would not stay down. Punk masterfully timed his brief comebacks, staying in the fight and peppering Gunther with punches and chops while targeting the champ’s arm.
Punk would mount a sustained comeback with a leg lariat and a neckbreaker, but Gunther turned a rising knee into a powerbomb to snuff out that rally. The two countered submissions, but Gunther finally looked to put Punk away with two powerbombs and a ragdoll toss into the post.
However, the Ring General’s arrogance would be his downfall, as he celebrated on the Spanish announce desk and Punk tripped him, bloodying the champion. From there, it was all downhill for Gunther, as Punk saw red (literally) and charged ahead with a flurry, finally putting him down with two GTSs for the win and the World Heavyweight Championship.
Wonderful, masterful stuff. Possibly the best WWE match this year, with the Women’s World Championship triple threat at WrestleMania 41 being the obvious competition.
Get 76% off, four free months, and a free Amazon gift card when you sign up to NordVPN here: http://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=564&aff_id=3013&url_id=31010&aff_sub1=WhatCulture.