4 Ups & 6 Downs From AEW Dynamite (22 Feb - Review)

Buckets of blood, Revolution takes shape and just how important was that announcement after all?

Jon Moxley
AEW

Tony Khan has promoted announcements in the past before.

He made a “huge” in April 2022 when he announced that Forbidden Door would bring together AEW and NJPW for the first time since the former was launched amidst acrimony between the two sides. Huge.

Six weeks before that, he had a “major” one. He had purchased Ring Of Honor. Its past, present and future weren’t sold to Vince McMahon via Samoa Joe but in the hands of a man that happened to be a major fan and somebody keen to keep the brand very much alive. Major

Back in 2019, a “big” announcement amounted to being a homecoming show In Jacksonville in January 2020. It was pretty deflating on the surface but ended up extremely significant in hindsight - it marked the first show Khan booked on his own, it ruled, it steadied the ship right before a vital TV deal was struck before the pandemic hit, and The Elite actually felt like their name for the first time since the company launched. Big.

Going into this show, with little on the show worthy of significant speculation - a familiar problem in recent weeks - the most interesting aspect was Khan’s “important” announcement. Importance is in the eye of the beholder as the saying doesn’t go, but it felt like one of those calls that would be a gut feeling. Mich like a genuinely great Dynamite, you’d just know if it lived up to the billing.

Did it? And, when the Revolution build needed it, was this a genuinely great Dynamite?

Let's light the fuse...


Downs…

6. Tony Khan's Important Announcement

Tony Khan
AEW

"Important" did some heavy lifting in the graphic that first appeared on Friday's Rampage and then days later front and centre on the Dynamite line-up graphic. As did "Tony Khan", for that matter. He quite wisely dipped out lest he make himself even more of a meme, handing over to Adam Cole to confirm that "AEW All Access" was coming soon to TBS on Wednesday Nights.

It'll surely be a great show with a great roster full of great moments but this was a meeting-that-could-have-been-an-email first world problem supplanted onto a wrestling show.

The network possibly requested that they get more attention than a mere tweet, but after his interactions with Ariel Helwani, Khan's profile is a hotter space than Dynamite itself right now. Precedent has been set, and this got nowhere close to living up to any.


5. The Acclaimed Vs Lee Moriarty & Big Bill

The Acclaimed
AEW

Rampage-level stuff from the tag division yet again, and not even The Elite as trios champions can’t get get people to watch that show. Two battle royals in two weeks should speak to the tag division being loaded, dynamic and bursting with competition, but this inconsequential effort told the truth about the choice to take the Tag Team Titles off The Acclaimed in favour of The Gunns.

It was the wrong call.

The audience were incredibly hot for Max Caster and Anthony Bowens, and it had to be them because the match was basic TV fare at best. The Acclaimed are still super, super over, and pending next week’s final qualifying team could regain the gold at Revolution. But if they do, this elongated hotshot with their perennial rivals should categorically go down as a frustrating WWE-style failure rather than a noble one.

And speaking of noble failures in the tag division...


4. The Tag Team Battle Royal

Jeff Jarrett
AEW

Your writer is a fan of Jeff Jarrett to an enormous fault, and the Jarrett/Jay Lethal team were more than worthy of the Revolution spot they picked up here by virtue of 'Double J's victory. It's a shame, then, that the overlong battle royal that got them to the spot was uncharacteristically flavourless.

As usual, The Butcher did well in the melee, but his lengthy run amounted to little when he was eliminated before the true closing stretch. Lucha Bros and Rey Fenix specifically were far and away the most over duo in the match, and Fenix' rope-running elimination of Rush was the semi-regular reminder why. That all amounted to nothing as well, with the final moments saved for Trent? from Best Friends getting the last hope spots.

Satnam Singh propelling both Jarrett and Lethal back into the match with one hand each was cute, but cute's better in the first few seconds rather than the last gasps of an 18 minute affair. In another case of AEW getting sloppier with their matchmaking of late, Aussie Open made little impression but secured a match with The Young Bucks anyway because of course you book that match while you can. The details company should have featured Mark Davis or Kyle Fletcher in a more prominent spot to make this feel more organic than it came across. It's okay to have standards, and just as okay to want them to be upheld in the small ways as well as the big.


3. Jon Moxley Vs Evil Uno

Jon Moxley Evil Uno
AEW

Evil Uno's blood pouring through his mask like loose clay being forced through a Play-Doh fun factory was a reminder that Dynamite is again the home of the type of wrestling video nasty you used to have to wait eight days on dial-up to download.

The grisly impact of Jon Moxley's violence made for an effective visual, but the match only really lived up to the billing and that was the problem. Mox can (and has) elevate many while beating the ever-loving sh*t out of them, but this simply wasn't one of those nights, and the reminder of how easy it is to become unmoved by such visceral suffering is a damning call-back to the excesses of 2022.

As was the case in Dynamite's closing moments; Moxley had barely a minute left to escape the show without bleeding a gusher himself, but Hangman Page and some barbed wire (and when's that ever gone wrong in this promotion?) put paid to that dream.


2. Orange Cassidy Vs Wheeler Yuta

Orange Cassidy Wheeler Yuta
AEW

When William Regal left AEW, his group’s name might have made less sense than before. But who knew the B now stood for “bitch”?

That was the theme of the build for Orange Cassidy’s All-Atlantic Title match with BCC’s whipping boy Wheeler Yuta on last week’s Rampage, and it factored into the conclusion when the pair opened this week’s show.

A kind-of awesome match undeniably suffered from the continuity calamity that set it up - the crowd were hot for the big moments, and this one had a few. But Yuta as a heel and/or playing the wronged party in his split from Best Friends was flawed the slicker the work got. The quality action didn't fit where his character's currently at, which itself is a little hard to parse.

Following the most disgustingly brilliant gum spot of all time, Cassidy retained, but that resulted in an another less-than-satisfying development. After being out-wrestled, the wrestler from the wrestlers’ club wanted to make amends before his stablemate Claudio Castignoli pulled him away from a handshake. The BCC are in turmoil, but not the most captivating kind, and both Jon Moxley and especially Bryan Danielson still have huge matches at Revolution that undermine that premise anyway.

Great matches don’t always make for great episodic TV and unfortunately this was all-too-perfect example.


1. MJF Speaks With Bryan Danielson

MJF AEW
AEW

A segment of two halves, MJF and Bryan Danielson’s verbal sparring left a lot to be desired even if the physicality that followed was god-tier pay-per-view setup stuff. But more on that momentarily.

‘The Salt Of The Earth’ let us in to yet another part of his fractured past (that was, by all accounts, rooted in recent reality) but the sociopathy deep dive - like the gauntlet stipulation - feels like an MJF well that’s been visited once too often lately. It’s a measure of just how great the Champion is; a five out of ten idea was nonetheless delivered like a twenty, but Bryan threatening to “kick the sh*t” out of him for mentioning his kids then simply not doing so as Friedman raged down the lens at them was a weird rare production and blocking flub from AEW. Never mind climbing over an invisible wall, Bryan barely needed to hop an invisible fence and he would have been able to reach him.

Though never threatening to go off the rails, the bit had the air of something we’ve seen better versions of before, and got nowhere close to establishing the challenger as somebody that might actually win when the two fight for the gold.

Until…


Ups…

4. Bryan Danielson Fights With MJF

MJF Jon Moxley
AEW

It was when MJF threatened to give Danielson's kids the gift of their Dad having "early onset CTE" that the 'American Dragon' finally snapped and an incredible fight to conclude the pair's penultimate segment before Revolution.

This ruled really, really hard.

Entering the glittering pantheon of awesome AEW pull-aparts, this was brutally intense and constantly captivating. The cameras couldn't guide the viewer where to look, such was the amount of movement from the warring sides. Danielson breaking free and clattering MJF's skull with one of the best worked forearms in recent memories was enough to set the goons back on both men, and the whole segment couldn't have ended hotter.

The talking segment wasn't bad at all, but the standards of both have raised expectations beyond that. The physicality flew beyond what might have been assumed of their chemistry, and was an absolutely tantalising glimpse of what AEW are going to dish out for 60 absorbing minutes on March 5th. In that respect, there couldn't have been a better sales pitch for the big show.


3. Ricky Starks And Chris Jericho Make A Deal

Chris Jericho
Fite/AEW

Up for what they did here, rather than for what they’ve been doing for what feels like about four hundred years by this point. Because the pop was audible, loud and damning when Ricky Starks said he was done with Chris Jericho.

It was all too apparent that the JAS leader would be the one lining up against ‘Absolute’ at Revolution, but the building’s telling response didn’t bode well for Starks’ open challenge with the contest on the horizon.After a decent back-and-forth with the nonsense at long last stripped back, the pair turned it around by the end of their latest tête-a-tête. Phoenix, Arizona came up huge for Jericho’s bluster, just as they did when Starks called his bluff by producing a pen. The veteran fell into his younger opponent’s trap, inked the paperwork and promised to fight him alone, and Starks’ masterplan was complete.This will, at very least, be finished in March.

It’s just a shame December was the last time it was all the way over.


2. Saraya Vs Skye Blue

Skye Blue Saraya
AEW

The one major women’s feud in AEW desperately needed a good week after the inconsequential fluff that overwhelmed last Wednesday’s disappointing main event, and Saraya Vs Skye Blue was an unexpected step in the right direction.

The match was neither great nor terrible thanks to time constraints and the gap in star power between the two, but Saraya’s stuff yet again had good snap, and the heel turn has at least afforded her more time to shake of the rust in situations such as these.

With (the still-woefully miscast) Toni Storm running interference, she picked up the win with ease before tensions were reset with Jamie Hayter and Britt Baker. Ruby Soho’s arrival reclaimed some agency after last week’s phoney rock-and-a-hard-place acTING. She wanted the belt, not any part of this turf war, and Hayter obliged for a Revolution three way later in the night.


1. Christian Cage Speaks...

Christian Cage Jungle Boy
AEW

...or can't. And the show was surprisingly better for it.

For a programme that required promos to keep it hot, the wordless brawl between long-standing rivals Christian Cage and Jack Perry was one of the more memorable exchanges between the two.Perry drilling Cage before he got a chance to spout his bile was as logical as it was hard-hitting, and the wily veteran ending the segment on top preserved his character while further enhancing the morals and ethics of his former partner.

Bloodying up the babyface might have been more effective if the floodgates (bloodgates?) hadn’t been flung wide open of late, but Christian doing this instead of verbally going low when MJF also had to was quietly inspired booking. The match - surely a stipped-up brawl planned for Revolution - no longer feels like a non-kayfabe case of a company getting around to finishing what they started. The hatred feels renewed, and very real.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.