4 Ups & 6 Downs From AEW Rampage (Nov 11)

Malakai Black is reborn; AEW sets up Full Gear matches; Tony Khan needs a chat with TNT!

Jungle Boy Christian Cage
AEW

Rampage should be a condensed version of Dynamite every week.

The Friday night show needs to become more of a complement to the flagship rather than some standalone 'B' broadcast that lazily recaps some ongoing storylines via video packages. That's fine every now and then, but it's also a bit of a wasted opportunity to push things along and isn't going to grow the Rampage audience.

Tony Khan got some things right and some things wrong with this episode, but the AEW boss did try to keep some major stuff back for Friday. Seeing a marquee bout for Full Gear get laid out and announced on Rampage was awesome, and so was yet another tease for the rebirth of one Malakai Black.

On the downside, familiar problems keep popping up and stopping the weekly from focusing on a core strength of All Elite: ACTUAL PRO WRESTLING. Those picture-in-picture ad breaks are a regular pain in the t*ts, and it's on TK to find a solution here that satisfies both advertisers/the network and viewers.

Here's all the good and bad from a show that was definitely newsworthy, but lacked in some key areas.


Downs...

6. Dropping Down The Ladder

Lee Moriarty Hook
AEW

AEW presented Lee Moriarty as a young star who learned a thing or two despite coming up short against World Champ supremo Jon Moxley. That's fine, but they then immediately had him challenge "any champion" on Rampage, and the whole thing came across as a bit desperate.

Then, Hook randomly walked into frame.

Wouldn't it be nice to have some proper context and purpose for these title challenges rather than just exposing that they're random, one-off matches? That isn't really storytelling - it's just a constant merry-go-round of one-off matches for the sake of it, and it barely even makes champions look strong either.

Is Tony Khan for real? Moriarty can go from challenging Mox (without any momentum) and losing to...dropping all the way down the championship ladder towards the unofficial FTW belt? That's hardly doing much for The Firm member's career.


5. The Problem With This Sort Of Thing

Jake Hager Claudio Castagnoli
AEW

Then, this.

So, let's get this straight. Claudio Castagnoli has been in AEW since June, but Jake Hager waited until November to catch up with him and talk about their time spent teaming together in WWE? Even if one suspends disbelief to imagine that JAS man Hager is trying to manipulate BCC man Claudio, it's still daft.

Everyone knows that pro wrestling heels can be silly, but expecting Castagnoli to swallow this handshake was akin to believing that Vince McMahon will launch a company obsessed with Japanese joshi puroresu in 2023. It just ain't gonna happen!

It honestly just smacks of AEW trying to get another WWE mention in there for the sake of it, and there's really no need. If anything, this kind of segment needed to happen as soon as Claudio joined All Elite - not five months deep.


4. Same Old, Same Old!

Nyla Rose Marina Shafir
AEW

If creative are trying to make Jade Cargill look like an ineffectual moron, then they're succeeding. How many times is she going to run in on Nyla Rose stuff and fail to get that TBS Title back? Someone needs to run highlights to a Benny Hill soundtrack, or something. It's that silly.

Rampage could've done without Nyla's squash-meets-angle generally, being honest. Watching her mimic Jade's mannerisms during a routine win, then veeeeeeery sloooooowly escape with Cargill's prize (whilst her 'Baddies' bounce off Rose like they're made of rubber) didn't do the rivalry any favours.

This guy is still confused about who fans are supposed to cheer on in this feud too. Nyla's behaviour is heelish, but...Jade was a definite villain beforehand. Meanwhile, again, Cargill lets Rose slip through her fingers time and time again, so it's hard to have sympathy for her.

Meh.


3. ARGH!

AEW Bandido Ad Break
AEW

Brace yourselves for a picture-in-picture rant.

Having to watch Bandido's comeback in a tiny box with no sound is unacceptable. Get these pic-in-pic ad breaks on a one hour program to f*ck, Tony. Seriously, man! Folks tuning in missed one of the biggest and most exciting parts of a match that's part of the Eliminator tourney for a World Title shot.

Bandido hit multiple dives onto Rush whilst ads for other shows hogged the screen and whipped sound from Rampage to boot. Then, when the show did come back from break, Rush cut his opponent off and went back to slow heel heat for a bit. That's awful match formatting.

It's also a shame, 'cause these men were up and at it from the opening bell. Sacrificing rest holds or generic outside-the-ring brawling is one thing, but cutting away from babyface comebacks shouldn't happen. This needs to change, and fast.


2. The Cheapest Of Cheap Finishes

Bandido Rush
AEW

Some may disagree with this, but it didn't exactly make Bandido look like some hot new ticket for AEW when John Silver had to ride to his rescue vs. Rush. The insinuation here was that Jose was a game-changer for the heels, and so Silver had to take care of him if Bandido wanted to get back into things.

Really? Bandido can't handle Jose trying to rip his mask off?

Silver became the focal point of the story when the real shine should've been on Bandido rallying against the villains for a big win. The masked man also went all 'WWE finish 101' by rolling up Rush from behind for a quick one, two, three. That spot has been done to death this year alone.

Here's an idea: If AEW don't want to beat Rush cleanly, then don't put him in there vs. Bandido. Definitive wins and losses should matter, but nobody can build momentum when screwy hijinks like this litter otherwise-important tournaments. Surely.


1. AN AD BREAK RING STEPS PILEDRIVER?!

QT Marshall Danhausen Piledriver AEW Ad Break
AEW

Can we please have some common sense?

QT Marshall hitting a piledriver on the ring steps during a commercial break is overkill and frankly ridiculous. That spot should only happen when it'll lead to something major, or if heels map out a coordinated attack to eliminate a hated foe. It definitely should not be going down whilst an ad for HBO runs on the same screen.

Worse, you just know Danhausen will magically recover by next week's Dynamite/Rampage. It'll be like nothing happened, thus rendering the bump totally meaningless and infuriating those who want to care about this stuff. Urgh, this was flash but no substance.

AEW's audience barely reacted anyway, so what's the point? They've been trained to know that this kind of headfirst trauma isn't any more painful or damaging than your average hip toss. Someone backstage should've cut this from the main event immediately.


Ups...

4. Appreciate The Competitive Spirit

Brian Cage Dante Martin
AEW

Granted, Brian Cage vs. Dante Martin had a pesky pic-in-pic ad break of its own (not many matches escape that fate on this weekly), but the pair still managed to put on one of the show's better bouts. Seeing Cage win a decent little back-and-forth was way better than a 90-second squash would've been.

Martin got to do some flying, Cage got his main power stuff in, and then big Bri advanced in the World Title Eliminator. It's hard to argue with this kind of match when both workers get to look good and there's a clear stylistic difference between them. That gives the announcers something to talk about, which is great.

Solid stuff all over.

Cage has looked like a man with something to prove since returning to the AEW mix. Here's hoping that continues, because he defo got lost in the shuffle a bit towards the end of the Team Taz run. This is a step up from that sort of fare.


3. These Guys Clicked

Lee Johnson Orange Cassidy
AEW

Both The Factory and Best Friends interfered like their lives depended on it during the show's All-Atlantic Title headliner. The run-ins and distractions were pretty much constant, but both Orange Cassidy and Lee Johnson showed enough to merit a proper follow-up at a later date.

They've got chemistry, people.

Both guys kept the energy high, and it'd be sweet to see them get 15-20 minutes without all the ringside bells and whistles at some point. They'd be a great fit for the Full Gear pre-show to get the live crowd rocking, put it that way. This was another strong title defence for Orange into the bargain.

It might be flying under the radar for some, but Cassidy is excelling with a title that most figured would be utterly useless. If this continues, and assuming TK wants to program some proper stories for this reign, then Orange will make something of the All-Atlantic belt after all.


2. House Of Black Is Reborn

Malakai Black AEW
AEW

Right, after slagging AEW for sort of/almost mentioning WWE, this writer is about to do the same! It's a compliment though, to be fair. That vignette for House Of Black was WWE production team-levels of fab - WWE's crew get a lot of praise for their vids, and rightfully so, but this was on par with that kind of quality.

High praise indeed, eh?

The way both Brody King and Buddy Matthews were reborn from water then shook off ash was very well done. It was like they'd been slowly dying a death since Malakai Black disappeared from screens, but were now totally rejuvenated due to his impending re-arrival on AEW's roster.

Julia Hart uncloaking her leader looked snazzy too. Yep, everything about this vignette worked a treat and got yours truly excited to see what's in store for HOB once they're reunited. Hopefully not more six-mans vs. Fuego del Sol.


1. Jungle Boy’s Steel Cage Challenge

Jungle Boy Luchasaurus
AEW

Rampage kicked off with a top segment that saw Jack Perry challenge old pal Luchasaurus to a steel cage match at Full Gear. Then, predictably, things got heated and Lucha chokeslammed him onto a chair as the announcers cried foul (though Tony Schiavone earns a cookie for questioning what Jungle thought would happen).

Meanwhile, Christian Cage smirked away in the background.

The whole thing was really well-worked from start to finish, and it's the kind of thing fans need to see more of on Fridays. This was Dynamite-worthy. The fact it also lined up a major pay-per-view match is wonderful too - again, that should be happening more on Rampage.

Delivering in-ring promos like this will only drive people towards the show and make it must-see. No recaps in sight here, just straightforward underdog babyface vs. rampaging heels goodness. It sets the scene for more carnage inside the cage to come.

What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more wrestling, check out 10 WWE One-Offs So Bad You Forgot They Existed and 10 Best Candidates To Be WWE King Of The Ring 2023!


In this post: 
AEW Rampage
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.