4 Ups & 7 Downs From WWE Raw (Results & Review - 23 Oct)

Stilted dialogue, underwhelming moments mar Raw highlighted by Rhodes' heroic stand.

Dominik Mysterio Logan Paul
WWE.com

That thud you heard was WWE Raw hitting the mat Monday night.

WWE must have realized they had their backs up against the wall competing for viewers with high-stakes playoff baseball and Monday Night Football, because they put forth one of their most pedestrian efforts in a good while.

If it wasn’t for the mountain of reporting that Vince McMahon is no longer involved in the creative process, this would have been a show many would have pointed to as evidence that Vince was still steering the ship behind the scenes.

Instead, this was just a dull, bland, badly written and booked program. It lacked consistent energy, solid booking and smart writing. Instead, this show included some really bad segments involving wrestlers who should be better on a weekly basis. It resurrected a horrible WWE trope of bickering brand GMs, which was one of the worst parts of the previous brand split.

Several of the superstars highlighted Monday night elicited underwhelming reactions from fans, which has to be demoralizing in some ways. Worse, some of these wrestlers were getting spotlight matches/segments, and they weren’t landing with the live crowd.

As usual, Raw managed to be functional and deliver a few solid moments, but overall, this was a huge disappointment of a show.

Let’s get to it…


DOWNS…

7. Let It Play Out?

American Alpha New Day
WWE.com

How do you accurately rate the New Day/Alpha Academy tag match?

Both teams had legit reasons to win, with Chad Gable trying to get back to his winning ways, and New Day trying to do the same after their battles with Ivar. The match itself was fine, but not something anyone is going to remember in a few days, so then you have to evaluate the story being told.

And then later on, both tandems were backstage just hanging out and goofing around, which might be fine, except when you remember that Gable was supposedly obsessed with getting back to challenging Gunther for the Intercontinental Championship again. Instead, he was yukking it up with New Day and DIY about Akira Tozawa.

It’s fine to give this more room to breathe, but fans would also not be wrong to just kind of ignore this as filler that accomplished very little other than giving New Day a win.


6. At Least The Tag Match Will Rule, Right?

Johnny Gargano Tommaso Ciampa
WWE.com

There was a time when the very hint of a DIY/Imperium tag match would set the internet on fire, with fans eagerly anticipating the in-ring action.

That time, sadly, has passed. Although next week’s tag match will most likely be phenomenal, it’s not the mouth-watering contest that causes everyone to grow impatient. DIY’s reunion has been badly botched, with Johnny Gargano getting more muted responses every week and not getting the opportunity to showcase his talent in a meaningful way.

Monday’s match against Giovanni Vinci should have been a great chance for Johnny Wrestling, but it instead was mostly an angle masquerading as a match, with Tommaso Ciampa getting involved and chasing off Ludwig Kaiser, allowing Gargano to nail One Final Beat for the win.

DIY celebrated afterward, and the fans went… a bit more than mild. Can’t blame the crowd though when WWE has dedicated all of 90 seconds to explaining who they are and why they were so beloved in NXT.


5. Nikki Cross’ 37th Reinvention

Nikki Cross
WWE.com

Are there any fans out there who were enraptured by Nikki Cross’ latest character change/mood swing?

It’s just so damn hard to watch such a talented wrestler go out there and just play a different variety of “crazy” and expect fans to get behind the character. This time, the normally frenetic Cross walked slowly out to the ring like a zombie, stood on the apron during her tag match with Natalya against Chelsea Green & Piper Niven, and then climbed down from the apron after two minutes of unblinking terror and walked to the back.

The end.

Why is she an emotionless zombie? Even if fans get an answer will anyone actually care and get invested in her? They’ve done this a half-dozen times with Nikki, having her migrate between psycho, childlike babyface, superhero, super-villain, crazed heel, friendless loner, and now a zombie.

And for these latest iterations? Fans have barely reacted. So it’s clearly not working, and yet WWE thinks just giving Cross a wild mood swing will fix things.


4. Just In Time For Survivor Series

Adam Pearce Nick Aldis
WWE

Oh goodie! The bickering Raw and SmackDown GMs trope is back.

In case fans were bored and thought that what WWE programming needed was figureheads arguing, sniping and tampering with talent, then they were in luck Monday night.

SmackDown GM Nick Aldis showed up on Raw after kicking red brand GM Adam Pearce out of the arena Friday night, leading to “tension” between the two. Aldis was seen later chatting up Kayden Carter & Katana Chance, prompting Pearce to confront him and Nick to take his leave of Raw.

All of this presumably is to set up conflict heading into Survivor Series next month, which could mean that the return of Raw versus SmackDown is imminent. Hopefully, this isn’t the case, because that branding never really worked.

Either way, bickering GMs is a tired, awful trope, so seeing it again just doesn’t sit well at all.


3. Stilted And Forced

Rhea Ripley Seth Rollins
WWE

Rhea Ripley has been a nearly unstoppable force on Raw with a presence that is impossible to fake.

That’s why her backstage conversation with Seth Rollins Monday night was so disappointing. She might as well have been reading cue cards just to the right of the camera as they “bantered” back and forth about whether Rollins should accept help from the Judgment Day to hold onto his World Heavyweight Championship.

The game here is Ripley stirring the pot by playing both sides in the Rollins/Drew McIntyre feud, but this encounter came off as extremely fake, forced and scripted. When Rhea, who has had an uber-cool heel vibe going for the past year now, looks like a deer in the headlights running lines, you know you screwed up with this segment.

Fortunately, it’s likely a one-week blip and Ripley will be back to her usual awesome ways next week. But this still needs to be called out as a big disappointment.


2. Everyone’s A Dope

Nia Jax Raquel Rodriguez Shayna Baszler Zoey Stark
WWE.com

Nia Jax has infused the women’s division with some much-needed conflict and controversy (within storylines), which has been a welcome development.

But while the conflict has been a welcome addition, Monday’s contract signing was a reminder of how things can go off the rails and diminish what WWE has been establishing. Nia was the clear star of the four challengers facing Rhea Ripley for the WWE Women’s World Championship, being the only one to get promo time and cutting down other participants in the match with no rebuttal.

Jax even called it that Ripley was steering clear of the ring because she was secretly hoping Nia would flatten everyone else to make it easier for the champ. And then all four challengers brawled, leaving only Jax and home state girl Raquel Rodriguez, who eventually got hit with a Samoan Drop, rendering her inert.

Zoey Stark and Shayna Baszler might as well have not even bothered showing up. Rodriguez, who has been plagued by being the smiling babyface, got insulted and then got physically owned when she stood up for herself.

Even Jax looked a bit foolish – while looking dominant – acknowledging exactly what was going to happen, and then getting sucked into it all while Rhea watched and laughed. But hey, fans cheered and chanted “let them fight!”, so it couldn’t be all bad, could it?


1. Indi Doesn’t Impress

Indi Hartwell Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Sorry to anyone who are fans of Indi Hartwell, but after waiting for the former NXT Women’s Champion to finally get her shot on Raw, she delivered a mediocre match against Becky Lynch Monday night.

Hartwell of course was challenging for the title she never lost due to injury, while Lynch has been the living embodiment of the fighting champion, taking on all comers on both Raw and NXT each week. In fact, she’s facing Lyra Valkyria Tuesday night in a match that will likely put this bout to shame.

Since being called up earlier this year, Indi has languished on Raw, competing in just one other singles match, a three-minute squash by Rhea Ripley in August. Monday’s bout against Becky was plodding at times, as Hartwell seemed to be stumbling from one spot to the next. It’s not that she executes moves poorly, but she looks unnatural at times in the ring, allowing fans to see the strings as the match wears on.

It's always tough to criticize someone who takes bumps for a living, but at the same time, you have to call this what it was: a one-woman carry job by Lynch.


UPS…

4. Ivar Now A God?

Ivar Viking Raiders
WWE

Norse mythology is an immensely popular genre, with a rich history that has permeated literature and film for generations. Unfortunately, that doesn’t automatically mean that WWE can throw together a vignette using Viking imagery and call it art.

Still, Monday’s video package was effective at one important thing: establishing Ivar as more than a tag team wrestler competing while his partner is out injured. During the video, Valhalla noted that the gods smile upon a great warrior, and that they can become a god themselves. She warned the rest of Raw to “tremble at the feet of the one, true warrior.”

The entire segment served as a means to make clear that Ivar is (for now) a solo act and a serious threat. Fortunately, there has been a body of work built up in recent weeks with the Viking crushing the New Day. Whether this now translates into Ivar being groomed to challenge Seth Rollins or Gunther (who has just beaten another heel monster in Bronson Reed) is an open question.

But seeing this video reinforced that fans can invest in Ivar, that his recent successes were not just for the sake of filling three hours in the mid-card. It appears that WWE is carrying on with this push, so fans can buy in.


3. Heat Machines, Unite!

Logan Paul Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

A few months back, WWE did the unusual thing of sticking a mid-card goof and heat machine Dominik Mysterio against the ultimate babyface in Cody Rhodes, pitting two men at the opposite ends of the reaction spectrum against each other, and it was glorious.

Monday night, they tried something a bit different in sticking two giant heat machines in the ring together to see what would happen, and it was equally fun, but in a different way. Logan Paul came out to talk about how he was a free agent, so when he defeats Rey Mysterio for the United States Championship at Crown Jewel, he’ll come defend the title on Raw.

Enter Dominik to a chorus of boos (your mileage may vary on how much of that was authentic). The two had a mutual admiration society and shared in their disdain for Rey, declaring that he needed a humbling. From there, they picked on ring announcer Samantha Irvin, hazing her until Ricochet ran in for the save for his fiancée. Logan saved Dirty Dom from a Shooting Star Press, and the vile heels retreated.

Even with the crowd sweetener, it’s obvious that these two can rile up a crowd, and together they could make magic as entitled, hated villains. Maybe put a pin in this act until after the Judgment Day has run its course.


2. McIntyre Still On Fire

Drew McIntyre Sami Zayn
WWE.com

The glacial-paced heel turn of Drew McIntyre has been a consistent joy to watch on Raw each week.

McIntyre continued his slow waltz toward the dark side Monday, giving Jey Uso a “pep talk” about losing the tag titles last week, advising him to “get over it,” as some have suggested Drew do about his distrust of the former Bloodline member. Then he went out and beat another former member of the Bloodline, toppling Sami Zayn – with a little help from Rhea Ripley.

Drew is still slapping hands with fans, and he’s not outright cheating to win, but he’s picking up victories due to others’ involvement, and he’s clearly over being the virtuous babyface who stands up for what’s right. He’s out for himself and very clearly stating that position.

It’s fun to watch, especially while competing against someone beloved like Zayn, showing enough shades to reveal that a change is coming.


1. Super Cody To The Rescue

Cody Rhodes Damian Priest
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes has been walking a fine line as the ultimate babyface hero, but the crowd reactions show he clearly has not crossed that line.

Monday night was another example of the American Nightmare’s heroics, as the Judgment Day Pillmanized his ankle, only for Cody to return at the end of the show on one leg and beat down Finn Balor and Damian Priest to save Jey Uso from the same fate. Meanwhile, the fans lost their collective minds.

It’s impossible to deny the positive energy surrounding Rhodes as he hobbled out to make the save just two hours after he was carried out of the arena. One would think cynical fans would have turned on his superhero act by now, but instead, fans seem to be getting louder.

But man, that visual of a wounded Cody just itching for a fight. If that doesn’t fire someone up, they need to check their pulse.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.