5 Biggest Winners & Losers From WWE Raw (Oct 17)
Welcome back, Mr. Goldberg.
As a complete show, last night’s Raw won’t live long in the memory. It was very much a “WWE by numbers” affair characterised by largely uninteresting in-ring action and odd booking decisions, but saved from complete tedium by a few standout individual performances. These New Era Raws have settled into a regular format now, and while they haven’t been terrible, fans can pretty much tell what they’re going to get every week.
As forgettable as much of last night was, however, one moment will live forever. Goldberg made his return to WWE television for the first time in 12 years, and it went better than anyone could’ve expected. For a man never known for his mic skills, the former WCW champion cut one hell of a promo to accept Brock Lesnar’s challenge, and while we’re still waiting for a date, the match looks inevitable.
Goldberg’s return was the biggest takeaway, but the cracks in Chris Jericho and Kevin Owens’ relationship are slowly widening. Their harmony has been shattered, and after Owens effectively cost his “best friend” another match against Seth Rollins last night, all three will meet in the ring next week. How will this impact KO’s forthcoming Universal Title defence against Rollins? We’ll soon find out.
The rest of Raw wasn’t as memorable, but still saw a number of wrestlers switch places on the ladder, for better or worse. Here are the 5 biggest winners and losers from WWE Raw.
5. Loser: Lita
Lita is a justified WWE Hall of Famer, one of the most important female performers in WWE history, and she was a “must see” woman wrestler at a time when WWE had no interest in pushing the division. Yes, she’s had more than her fair share of controversy, but she’s earned her spot in the company’s history, and likely has a WWE job for life.
There should always be a role for her in the company, but this is definitely not it. Last night saw the former WWE Women’s Champion interview Sasha Banks and Charlotte ahead of their historic Hell in a Cell match, and it just didn’t work. Sasha and Charlotte both came off well, but Lita was wooden, awkward, and clumsy. The segments were obviously heavily scripted, but you could almost hear her struggling to remember her lines as she spoke, and she almost completely derailed the interviews.
If WWE are to persist with Lita as an on-screen talent, they must find a more suitable role for her. It’s natural that someone of her stature would act as an ambassador for the Women’s Revolution, but this isn’t working out. From last night’s performance to her stuttering displays on WWE’s PPV Kickoff shows, Lita clearly isn’t comfortable in these heavily-scripted positions.
4. Losers: The Bookers
WWE’s bookers and writers take a lot of criticism. It’s not always entirely justified, but they don’t do themselves many favours, particularly on Raw. SmackDown mostly keeps things logical, but Raw’s creative direction has been a mess since the Brand Split kicked in. It reached a nadir at Clash of Champions, but they keep taking the weekly show in directions that satisfy nobody, and last night’s was very shoddy in this department.
Repetition and predictability are two things that kill interest levels, and Raw is rife with them. Next week’s Raw will see Cesaro and Sheamus meet The New Day in a non-title match one week before they face at Hell in a Cell, and Seth Rollins, Chris Jericho, and Kevin Owens will wrestle a Triple Threat that feels like a waste of a good PPV main event. Furthermore, last night saw Sheamus lose to Big E in the same manner that Cesaro lost to Kofi Kingston last week, and the night opened with Rollins vs. Jericho - a repeat of last week’s main event.
Raw may have the bulk of WWE’s most exciting wrestlers, but the bookers are doing a horrendous job of utilizing them. The show was stale long before the Brand Split, and somehow, it’s only getting worse. There are countless factors contributing to the red brand’s post-Draft failings, and extreme repetition is certainly one of them.
3. Loser: Neville
Neville seemed like a perfect fit for Raw’s rebooted Cruiserweight division. There weren’t many pre-existing WWE performers who fit the sub-205lb mould, but Neville is one of the best all-round wrestlers in the company, and he’d at least bring some familiarity to the division. It seemed a dead cert that they’d slide him in alongside TJ Perkins and co., but no, the Cruiserweights have taken off without him, and Neville has become pointless.
He lost to Bo Dallas in under three minutes, and if that doesn’t convince you of how unimportant he is to WWE, nothing will. It’s baffling that WWE haven’t thrown him in with the other Cruisers, but losing to a former Social Outcast? That’s a new low for Neville, even though WWE are trying to push Dallas. At the moment, it’s hard to see a bright future for him in the company.
The former NXT Champion just isn’t working out on the main roster. He’s never been the most charismatic performer, but he’s an outstanding, well-rounded wrestler who can do so much more than the flips and dives that made him famous. Sadly, WWE’s writers aren’t content to let workers get over on the strength of their wrestling ability alone any more, and wrestlers like Neville are a casualty of this.
2. Loser: Bayley
Bayley has fallen off immensely since slipping out of the Raw Women’s Title scene. She took a hard pinfall at Clash of Champions, partook in an unconvincing (and unnecessarily competitive) match with a local talent last week, and now looks set for a long-term programme with Dana Brooke. Last night saw Charlotte’s sidekick pin Bayley after posting her on the top rope, and neither woman impressed.
Brooke’s offense isn’t good at all. She’s sloppy and uncoordinated in the ring, and while WWE apparently see her as the division’s long-term star, it’s quite clear that she’s not ready for this level of exposure. Bayley couldn’t drag her to a good match last night, and in losing to someone with so little polish, the former NXT Women’s Champion has slipped far down the ladder.
Bayley’s lucky that there isn’t much going on in Raw’s women’s division outside her, Charlotte, and Sasha Banks, because she’d be near the bottom of the pile otherwise. She remains immensely popular and one of the company’s best wrestlers, but in terms of momentum, Bayley is dead at the moment. Unfortunately, she suffers from a lack of quality opposition, because if she’s not wrestling Sasha and Charlotte, she’s working with duds like Dana.
1. Loser: Hell In A Cell’s Mystique
Hell In A Cell has suffered greatly through the PG Era. Once WWE’s most dangerous and foreboding match gimmick, the change in rating has reduced it to a watered down shell of its former self. Sure, Shane McMahon leapt from the cell at WrestleMania, but WWE’s PG HIAC matches are largely safe, sanitized affairs where the structure is little more than a prop, and the participants would be just as well wrestling without it.
The past couple of weeks have only hammered this point home. Sasha Banks and Charlotte will make history as the first women to ever step foot in the structure, but therein lies the problem: the focus has been on “making history,” and not their immense dislike for one another. This completely drains away the match’s heat, and yes, it’s empowering for them to have this opportunity, but the build is completely devoid of menace.
The Kevin Owens/Seth Rollins build has benefitted from KO’s references to Mick Foley shortening his career by competing in such matches, but the US Title feud has descended into name-calling. Six competitors will step into the once-demonic cell at the PPV, but only one appears to be taking it seriously. Instead of building a sense of dread, five HIAC participants are gleefully skipping towards a match that once guaranteed utter devastation.
Click "next" below for the winners...
5. Winner: Bo Dallas
WWE’s rebuild of Bo Dallas has been pretty disjointed so far. From the poetry readings to the heat-free squash matches, Bo’s revival hasn’t really connected with the fans, and a quick tag loss to Sami Zayn and Neville last week suggested WWE had nipped it in the bud. Last night saw things get back on track, however, and after beating Neville, Dallas attacked Curtis Axel when his former stablemate tried to celebrate with him.
For all Raw’s predictability, the Brand Split necessitates WWE coming up with new things for the curtailed roster to do, and Bo finally has a direction. It might not be the most exciting story on the card, but it’s got genuine traction at the moment, and that’s more than you can say for most of what’s happening on the red brand right now.
Is anyone truly excited for a Dallas vs. Axel feud? Probably not, but Dallas is unquestionably in a better position than he was a couple of weeks ago. Whether or not WWE find a use for him long-term remains to be seen. They looked to be onto something with the “motivational speaker” schtick he debuted with, but that fell apart quickly, and Bo has struggled ever since. Nonetheless, he’s a decent wrestler with a certain goofy charisma, and he deserves this shot at redemption.
4. Winner: Rusev
No, Rusev, Lana, and Roman Reigns focusing on belittling each other instead of selling their Hell In A Cell match probably isn’t the best idea. They, more than anybody else, have done more to downplay the match’s reputation, and it doesn’t help that Reigns is still hideously out of place as a sassy babyface. This feud is no more than something you’d find in any school playground across the country, and it likely ends in a Reigns victory.
That being said, how good was Rusev last night? He might have made his name as an America-loathing monster heel, but he’s become ridiculously good on the microphone. The Bulgarian Brute was in hilarious form as he ran through his family’s accomplishments: there’s just something about his silly insults being delivered in that accent that make him quietly one of the most entertaining guys on the roster, and it’s a shame he isn’t allowed to explore this side of his character more often.
Furthermore, Rusev was finally allowed to lock Reigns in the Accolade and leave the segment on top. The feud has largely revolved around Reigns’ dominance, and Rusev really needed to regain some lost ground this week. That’s exactly what happened, and even if he loses to Reigns as expected, Rusev’s performances will keep this feud from being considered a complete washout.
3. Winner: Charlotte
Lita was poor in her interviewer’s role last night, but you can’t say that for her first interviewee. Conducted in the style of the old Michael Cole interviews, Charlotte was fielded a number of questions on Sasha Banks, Hell in a Cell, and her general position in the company. While Sasha smiled and nodded her way to making HIAC seem like a mere exhibition match, Charlotte was imperious, and stamped her position as one of WWE’s most effective heels.
Upon debuting, it was often said that Charlotte was a step or two behind her fellow Horsewomen. This allegation has been completely overturned: Charlotte might not be as slick as Sasha or Bayley in the ring, but she absolutely has the strongest character, and last night proved it. Charlotte came off arrogant, obnoxious, and completely detestable in her interview, and while most of WWE’s roster garner cheers from the crowd, Charlotte is one of only a handful capable of getting legitimate heat.
Yes, it would’ve been nice if Lita had mentioned HIAC’s real danger, but you can only work with the script you’re given. Charlotte’s message was simple and straightforward - “I’m better than everybody” - but her delivery was immaculate, and her superiority complex has never came-off stronger.
2. Winner: Seth Rollins
The Architect had a big role in Raw's first hour. Rollins appeared during Kevin Owens and Chris Jericho’s opening in-ring segment to answer KO’s claim that he was going to retire Seth at HIAC. This, of course, prompted Rollins to drive a further wedge between Jericho and Owens’ relationship by bringing up the fact that KO had done nothing to save his “best friend” from last week’s Pedigree, before Jericho issued a challenge for a repeat of last week’s main event.
For the second week in a row, Rollins and Jericho wrestled Raw’s best match, and The Architect came out on top. The finish owed much to Owens’ distraction interference (after promising he’d stay in the back), but Rollins rubber-stamped his dominance over Jericho with a second consecutive victory, and he looks strong ahead of his Universal Title challenge at Hell in a Cell.
More importantly, however, is the damage done to Jericho and Owens’ relationship. Jericho came within a hair of dropping a “STUPID IDIOT!” on Owens last night, and Rollins’ goading influence played a big role in their escalating issues. For a while, Jericho and Owens were each other’s biggest strength, but now? They’re falling apart, and for Rollins (their biggest enemy), that’s a huge bonus.
1. Winner: Goldberg
There’s little to suggest that Goldberg and Brock Lesnar are going to put on an epic match at Survivor Series. Bill hasn’t wrestled in 12 years, and while their WrestleMania XX match was marred by external circumstances, it was an absolute stinker. Goldberg is now 49 years old, and he was never known as a particularly refined in-ring performer, so fans are entirely justified in their scepticism towards the match. It likely won’t live up to the hype, and Goldberg’s career may end on a whimper.
That being said, last night was electric. Goldberg cut what might have been the best promo of his whole career, and his presence on last night’s Raw closed a so-so show on an almighty high.
Goldberg received a gigantic pop from the moment his music hit and footage cut to him stomping through the backstage corridors. The entire building chanted his name in unison, and the former WCW was legitimately tearing up at the tremendous reception. His passion was evident throughout, and his return couldn’t have gone any better.
Goldberg recognised his past failings in WWE, but said he missed being a superhero for the kids, because there aren’t many of those around anymore. The best part, however, was that his wife and son were finally watching in a wrestling ring for the very first time, and as Goldberg accepted Lesnar’s challenge, it was impossible not to get behind him.
Who knows how the match itself will go down, but Goldberg and WWE are off to an incredible start. From the crowd reaction to Bill’s passionate delivery, there was nothing to complain about in Raw’s show-closing promo whatsoever.