5 Match Star Ratings For WWE Royal Rumble 2023
Cody Rhodes and Sami Zayn co-exist on a night where WWE did the hard bit - but failed an easy test.
The worry, ahead of Royal Rumble 2023, was that Sami Zayn's popularity might undermine the corporate machine's push of Cody Rhodes.
Rhodes looks far more the part as a face-of-WWE type in the eyes of whomever is sitting in gorilla. Triple H, Vince McMahon, it doesn't matter: they're far more similar than some might think, and they're both behind the telegenic, media-savvy, superstar babyface.
But how founded was this worry?
While parallels existed between this "situation" and the events of 2014 and 2015, the complexion of the modern WWE audience has changed drastically in the intervening years. These WWE fans actually like WWE, and the subsection of noisy fans that once defied its booking and hijacked the shows have since migrated to AEW. Very rarely is anything rejected outright. If these current, actual WWE fans don't like something, they'll just sit there in almost polite silence.
Also, Cody Rhodes isn't Batista or Roman Reigns. He's in WWE full-time, those fans haven't seen the best of him, and he's exceptional at playing babyface. The fans love him.
If there is a situation here, one with the potential to disrupt the feel-good vibe heading into WrestleMania, it wasn't resolved on the night; if nothing else, WWE handled the men's main event scene to near-perfection...
5. Men's Royal Rumble Match
A divisively received but ultimately very successful Royal Rumble.
Triple H has a reputation as a dry, back-to-basics booker, but that's not strictly true. Some of his ideas are odd, and he sometimes struggles to grasp or even define babyfaces and heels. Booking heel GUNTHER to emerge at #1 and conquering babyface Cody Rhodes at #30 should have failed, frankly. That it didn't underscored why Cody is the man chosen to headline WrestleMania; his match-within-a-match versus GUNTHER was exceptional.
The suspense in the near-elimination sequences was so dramatic that both men cast significant doubt over what should have been far more predictable fare. Undisputed WWE Universal champion Cody Vs. GUNTHER instantly became a worthy SummerSlam main event across those several minutes, even if the dynamic, strictly, was wrong.
The action was repetitive and unexciting for much of the match. A wrestler entered, went through their spots, and subsequently joined the heaving indistinguishable mass. This is a common flaw in most Rumble matches that aren't built around a unique idea - à la 2020 - but it was pronounced here. Only when Ricochet and Logan Paul performed their dumb/spectacular aerial warfare spot, and Cody and Seth Rollins worked together - and exploited the premise of multi-man action - did the match fulfil the inherent promise that the genre offers.
Now, Triple H did use its layered storytelling potential elsewhere, but the problem was that few of the stories teased were particularly exciting. Brock Lesnar Vs. Bobby Lashley is not as epic as WWE thinks it is (Brock and GUNTHER's all too brief stand-off was received with far more enthusiasm). Edge Vs. Finn Bálor was the logical thing to do; necessary without being exhilarating. Drew McIntyre and Sheamus failing to combine forces against GUNTHER was another strange failure to grasp the babyface and heel dynamic. Revisiting the very recent past even approached masturbatory; what did the Braun Strowman Vs. Omos sequence actually accomplish?
The story beats Triple H touched upon were nothing like the Shawn Michaels/Chris Jericho or Michaels/Kurt Angle confrontations of 2003 and 2005 respectively. Nothing fresh with vast potential was teased as an upper midcard attraction for WrestleMania 39. Logan Vs. Rollins might have acted as that moment, but who's the babyface there?
The way in which Sami and Cody both got over on the night was a skilful political triumph, but those difficult questions lingered over the second half of the match to its detriment. Who was or wasn't going to enter, and when, was more intriguing than the actual action.
Gentleman's three Rumble, ****1/2 finishing sequence - so, with that in mind...
Star Rating: ★★★½
4. LA Knight Vs. Bray Wyatt - Mountain Dew Pitch Black Match
Think about the luminous confetti that was stuffed within the announce desk.
The confetti existed only to burst out across the ringside area as LA Knight smashed Bray Wyatt through the table (a spot, incidentally, they nearly blew after Wyatt almost fell off the ring steps). It was put there to facilitate a stupid spot WWE thought looked cool (it did not; the spot and indeed the entire presentation looked like a hipster microbrewery with a lame, passé rave aesthetic). There was, to reiterate, no logical reason for the confetti to be placed where it was. They didn't know that the table would break, did they?
Except they did, because it's fake, of which you were cruelly reminded.
Contrived nonsense that was nothing except woefully superficial: this match epitomised the Bray Wyatt character.
As ever, the action was unremarkable and the atmosphere wasn't scary. It was antithetical to scary; it was laughable. The wrestling was either drab or dangerous; Knight almost took a header when being driven from the top turnbuckle to the carbonated soft drink logo below. Wyatt simply won in an anticlimactic scene following the table bump, after which WWE presented a stunning entry into Wyatt's inimitably terrible canon of sh*t.
Wyatt donned a mask, which allowed him not to feel any pain (he could have worn it from the start, he barely sold the table bump, and he'd make far more money selling this magical talisman than he ever will in the wrestling industry).
The post-match brawl found its way to a set that only existed for this purpose (the purpose being the worst thing you'll see in wrestling all year, and Tyrus remains NWA World champion).
As Wyatt stood near Knight's prone body, Uncle Howdy emerged on a raised platform. In a hilarious visual, early 2000s shindie spot monkey Howdy attempted to execute a twisting elbow drop from some 10 feet, and missed entirely. Flames erupted for some reason.
"Uncle Howdy didn't get all of it" is really funny; he's meant to be some awful sinister presence in complete control, and he looked like a no-mark who got ideas above his station after seeing a GIF of Fénix.
Star Rating: Minus ★★★
3. Bianca Belair Vs. Alexa Bliss - SmackDown Women's Title Match
It's not often that work dread (or as the yanks call it, the "Sunday Scaries") factors into this job, but Christ almighty, how do you get 200 words out of Bianca Belair Vs. Alexa Bliss, a match contested for the WWE SmackDown Women's title at the Royal Rumble Premium Live Event (sponsored by Mountain Dew Pitch Black - Do The Dew!), which, as you know, is the first step on the Road to WrestleMania?
That's a start.
Wrestled at middling quality to a near-silent backdrop - which the immense scale of the backdrop brought into focus - it felt nothing like a title match. The action was fine at best, until the hesitant choreography crept in as often happens between these two performers, but it is easier to state what this match wasn't than what it was (a nothing match).
It wasn't intense. It wasn't state-of-the-art, nor was it a timeless throwback to a classic style. It wasn't dramatic. It wasn't heated. It wasn't creative. It wasn't believable, nor was it so thrilling that you forgave its exaggerated action. It wasn't so-bad-it's-good. It wasn't good. In-house WWE wrestling occurred in the regulation order in accordance with what WWE "logically" prescribes. It ended on an anticlimactic note, after which Uncle Howdy appeared onscreen and said his usual b*llocks.
He had no-sold a dive from several feet in the year, surrounded by fire, in the previous match.
But PWG bad!
Star Rating: ★½
2. Women's Royal Rumble Match
The women's Royal Rumble match followed almost the exact same pattern as the men's, which was hardly ideal.
The number one entrant lasted the duration - as did #2, even though she wanted to be #1, even though there's no discernible difference. Just have her come out at one! Even if it's woefully contrived!
It was another weird Triple H deal. Ostensibly, Morgan is a babyface for relishing the challenge, but actually manifesting it is stupid. Also, she somehow contrived to be smarmy about being hard-working. So she's an arrogant, stupid babyface who wants to do things the right way.
What are we doing here?
What Triple H was actually doing here was more of the same: wrestlers enters, works a sequence of uneven quality, joins the mass of bodies lurking by the ropes and turnbuckles. The abject state of the wider division became apparent as the match dragged on. So few performers generated a pop, and too many worked overtly choreographed sequences that looked like somebody trying to wrestle.
It wasn't all an indictment of Triple H's lazy, shortsighted booking. The rebooted Asuka was hugely over, and while she struggled against certain wrestlers, the new/old look is at least a promise of a push. Roxanne Perez impressed to a considerable extent. Fans jeered her exit. Pat McAfee - who basically said "I don't watch this sh*t on my own time, what's going on here?" for four and a half hours - was actually, earnestly upset by what was far too short a stint. He wasn't being enthusiastically loud because that's his onscreen gimmick on this occasion.
The countdown and pop bit - the thing that makes the Rumble the Rumble - developed into something depressing. So many of these women aren't over, and that's because Triple H debuts them to little fanfare with no long-term plan. Vince McMahon was pilloried for doing that. Triple H, in one division anyway, is doing the exact same thing.
Few intriguing stories were advanced meaningfully. Nothing feels interesting on the road to WrestleMania. Bayley Vs. Becky Lynch already feels as overdone as Dolph Ziggler Vs. Kofi Kingston.
The finish was outstanding, mind. The last two pulsating moments were worked almost entirely on the apron. Rhea Ripley - whose selling was almost comical at certain points - did eventually elevate the whole thing with her masterful, risky body control. It was rapid palpitations stuff by the finish. Almost special-tier.
For almost a full hour before that, it was sloppy and tepid.
Star Rating: ★★★
1. Roman Reigns Vs. Kevin Owens - Undisputed WW Universal Title Match
The main event was pretext to a fantastic angle, and WWE realised that. They didn't short change Kevin Owens, who has a significant part to play in the events to come. Nor did they take the piss and pretend this was some epic in and of itself, which meant - thankfully - the rest holds, narration and stalling were kept to a minimum.
The balance was ideal.
The big bombs were arrived at quickly, and the Stunner spot extracted an improbably believable near-fall, given that nobody thought KO was actually winning. This was an unfussy, physical greatest hits - enhanced by two gruesome bumps against the steel steps, which justified the sell-job cuffed to the ropes - the real intrigue of which lay in Sami Zayn's performance on the outside. He was exceptional. Subtly conflicted, he's so over now that he didn't have to play it broad. The fans were already drawn to him, and he knew it. He passed his test, just, when he eventually passed a steel chair to Roman Reigns following a ref bump.
He failed it in an exceptional post-match angle, which was an immortal WWE moment.
Zayn could not bring himself to smash Kevin Owens in the face with a chair. There are babyface turns, and then there is this. Zayn in one seminal moment - and what a nuclear eruption of a pop it generated - stood up to his bully and forgave a man, in Owens, who might not even be worthy of it. Reigns was superb too. "You just wanna do Jackass sh*t?" he said to a conflicted Sami, locating a sacred cow even in this major moment.
The Jey Uso twist - he walked out on Roman and a very well-executed beat-down - was exceptional. Inconceivable a few months ago, heartwarming on Saturday, it was a shocking, fascinating plot development.
It was thought for certain that this was going to be the last big scene before the Sami/Roman match in Montreal and the Sami/Owens Vs. Usos match at 'Mania, but they've blown the whole thing wide open and executed a monster of an angle at the same time.
Sami and Owens Vs. the Usos might now have to take a similar form to the classic Elite melodrama at Revolution 2020, if that match is even happening. This Bloodline saga was incredible when the predictable, but good, ending was in sight. WWE took its best story in years to even greater heights on Saturday night.
Star Rating: ★★★½