5 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (28 Nov - Results & Review)
Uncle Howdy returns on a surprisingly fun 'go home' SmackDown before Survivor Series.
SmackDown has ranged between decent to downright poor in recent weeks, so Triple H would've been hoping that sprinkling some Survivor Series flavour over the show would help Friday's episode out. It did, and so did some of the matches in the ongoing John Cena tournament. If nothing else, they kept things ticking along nicely, and the tourney has thrown up some interesting combos here or there.
Of course, WWE taped a double helping of SmackDown last week, so it was important to keep that in mind when watching this particular episode. The live crowd seemed a little worn down by the time a traditional elimination bout hit the ring, but the action was zippy enough to get everyone back onside come the end.
There's no getting away from it: Both WarGames matches feels very forced this year. That's been especially evident on the women's side of the fence, and no amount of tension between members on the babyface squad or Becky Lynch trying to big league her unit can stop that from being true. Even so, chemistry counts, and the sole women's match on Friday's show proved it.
It's gonna get a bit hairy around these parts (ooer!) if Hunter thinks these episodes can be stretched from 2 to 3 hours again though. WWE would need to put a bit more emphasis on SmackDown and up the level of star power on offer to get through that. The good news is that Royal Rumble-WrestleMania season is right around the corner.
Here's all the good and bad from Friday's pre-taped edition.
Downs...
2. “It Might Need To Be Me”
One would think that WWE would pause to put thought into some follow up for Jade Cargill before she won the Women's Title from Tiffany Stratton earlier this month, but no. They clearly didn't. That's why Jade is marauding around the place bullying everyone like she's some female retelling of Ryback. Don't get it wrong: That presentation works for her, but only when those she's running through have some credibility.
Sadly, the likes of B-FAB and Michin have none at the moment. Fans have been conditioned to view both as peripheral actors on the show. They're rarely a threat to anybody, and there's next to no actual character development put in place for them either. That's why it's genuinely difficult to get excited about the thought of Jade squashing Michin.
It'll achieve nothing. Also, if Hunter thinks he can just magically pull a title shot out of thin air for the ex-Mia Yim, then...yeah, not great. On SmackDown, Michin said she might have to be the one to put Cargill in her place. This promo aired after the Chelsea Green stuff earlier, which was a sizeable step up from anything Jade is doing with B-FAB and Michin; at least Chelsea has some worth and everyone watching is in on the gag that she's a clown who occasionally fails up the way.
That character is easy to write for, because there's no end to the number of hilarious scrapes and jams Green can find herself in. Contrast her to Michin and FAB. They're dull, and so is this pitch for the former vs. Jade.
1. Over The Whole Wyatt Sicks Things Now
First and foremost, fingers crossed that Bo Dallas/Uncle Howdy being back on WWE TV means his father is in better health. Any speed bumps in this Wyatt Sicks vs. MFT storyline occurred for the right reasons. Bo was away tending to his dad, and that's not something anybody should criticise. WWE's creative when he's present though? That's fair game.
Does anyone else out there just…not find The Sicks interesting at all? Howdy returned to confront Solo Sikoa after the elimination main event, so Sicks vs. MFTs is incoming. That’s been on the cards for a while, but hopefully it’s a short feud and ends with Solo’s crew grabbing tag gold. Then, move on. There's really no need to spin this out any longer.
Fans in attendance for SmackDown somehow managed to muster up a pop when the lights went down as Sikoa celebrated being the sole survivor in the elimination match. Then, the house lights came back on to reveal that Erick Rowan, Nikki Cross, Joe Gacy and Dexter Lumis were standing on the ring apron.
That allowed Howdy to attack from behind with a quick Sister Abigail.
Cool, but how long does this resumed feud have before it starts becoming a hindrance again? WWE completely ruined their own tag-team division on SmackDown by sticking the belts on Gacy and Lumis (who rarely defend them, by the way - their last title defence was against The Street Profits on the 10 October show), and there's unlikely to be much merriment for Tama Tonga and Talla Tonga holding them. Assuming that's the combo the writers go with.
Ups...
5. Jade Ruins Chelsea Green’s Celebration
Look, they’re obviously killing time with Jade Cargill until Bianca Belair is back, but gunning down Chelsea’s celebration was a step up from slapping Michin and B-FAB around. At least it fits with the whole, ‘Chelsea can’t have nice things’ characterisation she has going on. This was short, sweet and to the point. There's been some hate for it, but it's in-keeping with Green getting egg on her face constantly.
Admittedly, it was kinda weird initially that Jade went after another heel, but that’s the tale being told here. She doesn’t discriminate between babyface and heel. The new Women's Champ said so in a promo with Cathy Kelley after shooting Alba Fyre and Chelsea down without breaking sweat. If anybody in this division thinks they're better than Cargill, then she's coming to get them.
Just as well Vince isn't around or he'd turn her into the f'n Boogeywoman.
Seriously though, this all clicked into place. Chelsea was glorious when addressing her "adoring public", Fyre works as a temporary firewall (Fyre-wall?) to the Women's United States Champ, Jade looked like an absolute killer, then Green's planned pyro display went off for Cargill rather than for her. That was actually proper slick.
Hey, maybe WWE can get an unlikely babyface turn out of this for Chels. She's somehow likeable despite being an arrogant villain, and there's always the chance she'll go the Santino Marella route eventually. No, not being cuffed by Jim Cornette. Playing an endearing clown who shows some underdog spirit during matches.
Green would be awesome at that.
4. The Miz Sneaks In Then Loses Again
Yes, R-Truth has gone from being one of the most popular rehirings ever to talking endlessly about his balls in quick backstage skits with SmackDown GM Nick Aldis. WWE has laboured this joke to the point of torture throughout the John Cena tourney. Aldis is ready to spin his tombola, then BOOM! Here comes Truth to crack lame gags about his nuts.
This week, The Miz successfully sneaked his name into the ball Aldis had opened when the GM was distracted by R-Truth’s nonsense. The whole segment was definitely silly, but Miz's sneaky heel behaviour did come off smoothly. His resultant quarter final vs. LA Knight was good clean fun as well. Neither guy pulled up any trees out in the ring, but they kept everyone entertained for a solid 10 minutes or so.
Back on the tournament front, both LA Knight vs. Jey Uso and Gunther vs. Solo Sikoa are interesting enough semi finals. They feel a little different because it’s face vs. face and heel vs. heel, which isn't something WWE typically goes for if they can avoid it. Being honest, it's a surprise they didn't go with Jey vs. Solo and Knight vs. Gunther. Uso vs. Gunther wouldn't have been in line for the semis, because that looks likely to be the grand finale, but dual babyface vs. heel bouts were right there.
Seeing Miz sneak his way back into the running after previously losing to Jey was exactly the sort of thing the crafty veteran would do. Bonus points if Nick pulls him up on this at a later date.
3. Asuka & Charlotte Flair Showcase Their Chemistry
They’ve always had it, and this was another example.
Charlotte Flair and Asuka put in some effort for their clash on SmackDown when it would've been easy for them to phone it in and let the story (the winner's team would get the advantage come WarGames) do most of the heavy lifting. At this point, it's clear to see that Flair and Asuka go into automatic 'let's have a banging match' mode whenever they're inside a wrestling ring together.
No, this guy can't lie and say he's particularly hot about the babyfaces having the advantage in any WarGames match, but WWE already handed the edge to the heels over on the men’s side. Saturday night's women’s WarGames match still feels crumblier than the last cookie in the pack, but this singles between Charlotte and Asuka was a nice watch.
Again, like with Knight vs. Miz, it won't win any 'Match Of The Year' awards or anything. That's OK. Not every single match needs to be some balls to the wall 5-star marathon. Sometimes, it's perfectly fine for 2 workers to get in, trade some nice stuff, then get out and celebrate a job well done. Flair and Asuka know they can crank it up hotter than this, but they also know they can have good matches without overexerting for no reason before the next PLE.
Chemistry carried them through, and the missed mist spot involving Asuka and a member of WWE's production team got over well with fans there live before the finish. Overall, this was the kind of gig you'd expect from solid pros who realise they've got a bruising bout to look forward to at the weekend.
2. Opener Sets A Good Pace
Jey Uso vs. Rusev was a fine 10-minute opener. Again, if the crowd sounded just a tad muted, then that probably had something to do with this being a double taping for SmackDown. They had a lot of matches thrown at them last Friday. Credit to Jey and Rusev though, 'cause they managed to have everyone eating from the palms of their hands during the final few minutes here.
Bizarrely, some on social media are criticising Jey for being sloppy in this one, but yours truly didn’t really see that. Some of the more cutting comments just come across as attention seeking, almost like 'Uso can't work anymore' is a trendy phrase people need to repeat for likes. There was next to no evidence of him being off the pace vs. Rusev. None at all.
One of the best things about the musclebound Bulgarian's bouts is that you always get the impression he’s going for the Accolade and trying to win. That’s refreshing in an age of sizzle over substance spot hopping. His usual focus played into the story of the match too - the thing that ultimately cost Rusev was going away from his game plan and trying to mock John Cena by hitting an Attitude Adjustment.
Jey then splashed him for the popular win and rolled on to the semi final stage of the tournament. Later, it was revealed that he'll be working LA Knight on Raw. He can be proud of his work on this occasion. It was rock solid, and this fan honestly doesn't know what people are talking about with the sloppy stuff.
1. This Should’ve Been On The PLE
That subheading probably sounds negative. It kinda is, but more so for Survivor Series and not SmackDown itself. After all, it'd be churlish to give Friday's show a 'Down' just because Triple H decided not to put a traditional Survivors elimination bout on the PLE named after those matches. He really should've, and this match showed why.
The traditional eliminator was all action and worked well. It was never less than watchable, and it put across the merits of these elimination style collisions. If someone's putting together a body of evidence for next year's PLE, then they should start here. The graphics WWE included to help keep track of who’d been eliminated and who was still around were a welcome addition too. They're not essential (it's 5v5, so it isn't hard to count!), but they were a nice quality of life improvement anyway.
Also, dudes the size of Talla Tonga really benefit from this kind of formatting. He wasn’t asked to do a whole hell of a lot, but could look like a difference maker by scoring some eliminations, and the company protected him with a countout elimination rather than pinfall or submission.
Then, there was the closing stretch: Sami Zayn was up against 3 guys (Solo Sikoa, Talla and Tama Tonga), but almost took out everybody to seize the win. That was really, really good, and it had fans around ringside glued to what was going on. Man, Zayn’s such a great underdog babyface.
In summary, the traditional elimination match should've been kept back for Survivor Series. Lesson learned. Hopefully.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 25 Things You Didn't Know About John Cena and 12 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE SmackDown From 2003!