5 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dark (Nov 8)

Even AEW were in the dark about this surprise double-helping.

AEW Dark Hikaru Shida Big Swole
AEW

If you're an AEW fan (and honestly, who on earth isn't?), Christmas has came very early this week.

Not only did we have an absolutely, well, dynamite episode of Dynamite, but we have the utterly mouthwatering Full Gear to look forward, headlined by a Cody vs. Chris Jericho match only rivalled by Tim Storm vs. Nick Aldis in anticipation.

Even better, we got not just one but two episode of Dark, after AEW unexpected dropped a bonus episode last night, in the hope of building up even more fervour for their big blowout in Baltimore.

It might seem a little hypocritical to laud the promotion for inundating us with content given the regular criticisms of oversaturation levelled at rivals WWE, but when it's generally so stellar, it's actually appreciated.

Admittedly, the previous episode of Dark was a bit of a dud. Good news then, that AEW got back on track with a, though haphazard, largely excellent go-home, lights-out lead-in.


Downs...

3. A Slapdash Affair

AEW Dark Studio
AEW

The week's second edition of AEW Dark was so unexpected that it seemed to catch even the company themselves by surprise. There was absolutely no suggestion of its existence until literally five minutes prior to the show airing, when AEW's official Twitter account dropped the news.

Now, there's nothing inherently wrong with a bonus episode - a surprise such as this is the perfect entré building up appetite for Full Gear - but it may have been more effective with a little more forethought. The show generally felt like a hurried production, featuring a lengthy Control Center piece updated from earlier this week, and cutting to black almost as soon as the main event was over. If it serves the purpose of building up PPV interest, then no harm done - but it did come over a tad amateurish.


2. A Literal Lack Of Focus

AEW

Speaking of a tad amateurish, that green-screened studio setup simply has to go. There's an element of tongue-in-cheek retro chic to Tony Schiavone and new regular broadcast partner Dasha Gonzalez peculiarly floating on a digital soundstage, but this isn't NWA Powerrr, and the low-rent CGI jars strikingly with the rest of AEW's slick production - not to mention the match graphics shown during these very segments.

During the Control Center run down, Gonzalez wasn't even in focus, which is fairly unforgivable. Sure, a green-screen is a cheap production trick, and crucially, it's easy to relocate to whichever town AEW are gracing. But can't a company as well funded as this one afford a more permanent, tangible and above all else, less naff set-up?


1. Rose Slows Things Down

Nyla Rose Leva Bates AEW Dark
AEW

There's a way to do squash match, and it isn't to have your monstrous heel slowly chug to victory - even if its over two opponents.

The story of Nyla Rose being forced to select a partner after claiming she could beat Shazza McKenzie and Shalandra Royal alone was a neat one, as was her picking the most useless member of the roster in Leva Bates to prove a point (even if it did echo the Braun Strowman/Nicholas Cone farce). Unfortunately, she didn't prove that point emphatically, putting in a performance akin to continental drift; Rose destroyed her opponents, but it took her an age.

Bantering Leva Bates off in using her as a hazard rather than a partner was a menacing heel move, but it couldn't mask the crowd gradually cooling, showing a distinct lack of heat in contrast to the opener. The result also means that, in a company where wins and losses matter, The Librarian now has a farcical notch in the 'W' column despite doing absolutely sod all in this match.


Ups...

5. Commentary Brings It's Double-A Game

Arn Anderson AEW Dark
AEW

Thus far, AEW's Dark has cycled a number of guest commentators alongside Excalibur and Goldenboy, amongst them Cody's buddy MJF and former SmackDown and Impact voice Taz. They saved arguably the best until this week, in the form of bona fide living legend and multiple time Hall of Famer Arn Anderson.

Double A's broadcast partners were evidently in awe of the Horsemen, to the point of distraction during the opening stages of Hikaru Shida's match against Big Swole. Once they settled into their rhythm (Goldenboy impressed Arn with the word 'prowess'), Arn's legacy was able to imbue the contest with a degree of prestige and gravitas it would otherwise have struggled to attain. The sheer presence of the man was highlighted when he was swapped out for Chuck Taylor in Dark's second match, a noticeable downgrade.


4. Shida Shines

Hikaru Shida AEW Dark
AEW

Shida's fiery defeat of Big Swole, making her first singles appearance within the company, was a big improvement on the women's tag match in which the latter featured last week.

Whereas the current Phoenix of RISE was misrepresented as a brute last week, Arn Anderson was keen to put over her technical strength and tenacity this week, a smart contrast to Shida's indefatigable offence.

The pairing seemed to work wonders, as the Charlotte crowd - though possibly symptomatic of their general high investment throughout all of AEW this week - reacted big time to both competitors. Shida, unquestionably a future AEW Women's Champion, provided a necessary transition between Riho, eventually picked up the win, but both women picked up enormous credit. Based on this showing, it won't be long before Swole makes her Dynamite debut.


3. After Match Promos

Hikaru Shida Promo Dark
AEW

One of the most frequent - and actually legitimate - criticisms of AEW Dynamite thus far has been a lack of promos either before or after matches to help sell the contests. As something of a testing ground for the flagship show, AEW Dark this week looked to redress the issue in experimenting with backstage interviews with two of its three victors.

There wasn't time for Cima and SCU to speak after the main event bell, but both Hikaru Shida and Nyla Rose caught up with Jenn Sterger in Gorilla to speak about their respective victories. Shida, though not 100% comfortable speaking outside her native language, came across every bit the endearing babyface we see in the ring, whilst Rose more than re-established her mean streak following her decidedly cumbersome squash.


2. The Total Video Package

Chris Jericho Dynamite
AEW/TNT

If there's one thing you can say WWE do better than any other company, even their darling rivals down in Jacksonville, it's the hype video package. From Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels WrestleMania XII meeting of masters to the unanimously agreed all-time-greatest, reverential trail ahead of WrestleMania X-Seven, Stamford's editors have hitherto went unmatched.

Well, they may need to watch their backs. The video package promoting Cody's clash with Chris Jericho, airing during Dark, was the sort of legitimately stirring rhetoric we'd have expected from WWE in their pomp. If anyone was still on the fence about checking Full Gear out, they'd have been thoroughly converted after watching it.


1. The CIMA Team

SCU CIMA
AEW

Dark's main event trios contest pitting SCU and CIMA against TH2 and Kip Sabian was mostly standard fare from the six-men involved, but it did highlight, ridiculously, one of the few reasons we're grateful for AEW.

If this match had occurred in WWE, there's absolutely no question whatsoever that the tag champions would have lost heading into Full Gear, in the misplaced belief that it makes the outcome of their match less predictable. As it happened, SCU prevailed - courtesy of CIMA's Meteora - meaning any defeat in Baltimore will be seen as a greater accomplishment. It's ludicrously simple, and galling that it even needs explaining, but here we are. The match also escaped an AEW-specific criticism of poorly enforced tag rules, so that - again, something we should expect - is a vague positive.


Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.