5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE Backlash 2024 (Results & Review)

Molten French crowd, superb AJ/Cody main event carry mostly middling show.

The Bloodline
WWE

WWE’s first PLE to emanate from France is in the books, and it can best be described as a supercharged house show with a molten crowd.

That isn’t meant to be a derogatory or demeaning term. House shows can be a lot of fun, and sometimes they are better than anything that’s on television because the wrestlers have more freedom to perform. But the action sometimes is paint-by-numbers and “safe,” and the outcomes are all fairly predictable – no titles are changing hands.

Backlash France relied on a red-hot crowd that was clearly amped to get their first PLE to obscure matches that were mostly average, save for the main event. None of the matches were actively bad, though the women’s tag title match suffered during its middle portion, but other than Cody Rhodes/AJ Styles, nothing will be remembered as a great in-ring performance.

The show suffered from being a B-show with limited matches and a lack of top-tier star power. Last year’s Backlash in Puerto Rico had Bad Bunny, Brock Lesnar, Rhea Ripley and all the LWO surprises. This year had none of that, but did add Jade Cargill.

The crowd reactions and Cody/AJ definitely carried the day, and many will look back on Backlash France as a triumph for those reasons, but few will go back and rewatch this show as a huge in-ring success. Overall, this was a good -- but certainly not great -- show.

Let’s get to it…


DOWNS…

3. ‘Tiffy Time’ A Broken Watch

Tiffany Stratton
WWE

Wrestlers having a signature call to the crowd is almost as old as WWE itself. But it is possible to overdo the sign and become obnoxious, threatening to make the superstar a one-dimensional character known only for that call.

We’re nowhere near there yet with Tiffany Stratton, but the rookie SmackDown superstar has hit upon her own signature hand sign, which she proceeded to use about 1,000 times during her triple threat match for the WWE Women’s Championship at Backlash.

“Tiffy Time” was a cute line Stratton used a few times in NXT that proved effective in conveying her ascension on the developmental brand. Upon heading to SmackDown, the line quickly became central to her character. The phrase is the lead-in to her new entrance theme, and someone in the back clearly has told her to tap her imaginary watch to convey that it is indeed “Tiffy Time.”

During her entrance and the match itself, Stratton did it so much that it became almost comical. Whenever she got five seconds of daylight, she made sure to tap her wrist to remind fans what time it was. It got so excessive that you had to wonder if it was a crutch for her to “play” to the fans, or if she was under orders to do it as often as possible.

Overall, this is a minor gripe and doesn’t diminish Stratton’s star power or budding aura, but she also should be careful to not become a one-note punchline character. This was more of an annoyance than anything else.


2. High Expectations, Subpar Delivery

Bayley
WWE

In what will feel like a theme here, most of the matches on Saturday’s card fell just on either side of “mid,” with the main event being the exception. Individual mileage may vary, but the WWE Women’s Championship match fell on the “blah” side of things.

The triple threat match pitting Bayley, Tiffany Stratton and Naomi against one another wasn’t bad, but given the talent in the ring, it felt like they were going at about 75% rather than an all-out war for the title. They got lost in at least one spot and had a couple stumbles, which isn’t a cardinal sin, but it did knock things down a peg.

The finish also felt anticlimactic, with Bayley and Naomi polishing Tiffany off with a 1D, setting up their big showdown… which ended about 30 seconds later with a cradle pin out of nowhere. Yes, that sort of thing should happen from time to time to remind fans that a match can end at any moment and not after a killshot finisher, but this just fell flat.

The simple way to judge this: Will anyone seriously go back and rewatch this match from start to finish?


1. Women’s Tag Match Falls Apart

Kairi Sane Bianca Belair
WWE

Does a fantastic finishing sequence and title change override the middle portion of a match going completely off the rails?

That’s the question at hand for the Women’s Tag Team Championship match between the Kabuki Warriors and Bianca Belair and Jade Cargill. At 17-plus minutes, it was the longest match in which Jade has competed, albeit a tag contest. That length, combined with Cargill having to sell for a couple sequences, might have contributed to some very noticeable sloppiness during the middle segment of the match.

Cargill and Kairi Sane struggled to get on the same page multiple times, with Jade having to get into position and people visibly calling spots. It wasn’t pretty.

Really, the blame has to be laid at the agenting of the match. Forcing Jade to sell and take such a large portion of the offense at this stage wasn’t wise. She and Belair have been dominant and should have just run through the Warriors in about eight or nine minutes to win the titles. Instead, they stretched it out to twice that long to fill out the runtime on a five-match card, and the match suffered as a result.

Still, great finishing sequence and a deserved title change to a team that should be near-impossible to beat.


UPS…

5. Street Fight Survives On Chaos

Kevin Owens Tama Tonga
WWE

The moment the Bloodline/Kevin Owens and Randy Orton match was turned into a street fight, it became clear WWE was going to use plunder and a red-hot crowd as a cheat code rather than going all-out with ring psychology and traditional tag action.

That’s not a negative, but it did inform what unfolded next. The plunder brawl was steaming along like any other WWE street fight/no-DQ/hardcore match in predictable fashion – brawl in the crowd, use trash cans and kendo sticks, break a table or two – until Orton went on a tear and then Owens decided to drop Tama Tonga with an avalanche Fisherman’s Buster through a bunch of chairs.

That brought things up for the reveal of Tonga Loa as the newest member of the Bloodline, paving the way for Tama and Solo Sikoa to get the win. It was a solid match with a really good finishing sequence, which is enough for passing marks here, but again won’t be something many will go back and rewatch with great anticipation.


4. An Unhinged Bloodline

WWE Backlash 2024 France Paul Heyman
WWE.com

If you objectively assess it, the Roman Reigns version of the Bloodline had really run its course by WrestleMania 40.

The Tribal Chief was little more than a part-timer, and Jimmy Uso was an impotent goof. Restocking and rebooting the group was essential for it to continue, and they might have stumbled up a pretty decent angle.

Tama Tonga’s debut and Jimmy’s dismissal certainly helped give the stable a new, fresh feel, but even more so, Roman’s absence and Paul Heyman’s exasperation has fed into a feeling that this version of the Bloodline is functioning as its own, independent group rather than Reigns’ loyal army.

Things took an even bleaker turn Saturday when Tonga Loa made his WWE return (he was Camacho in his previous run) to aid his brother Tama and Solo Sikoa in defeating Randy Orton and Kevin Owens. The reaction of Heyman, who appeared completely confused and frightened by the surprise appearance. The Wiseman’s helplessness only punctuates how unhinged this new Bloodline is (or at least is supposed to be).

When you factor in Jacob Fatu, who also is signed to WWE and just awaiting the right moment to debut, you know the Bloodline will continue to grow, change and be an unpredictable stable. It might be a tremendous success, or it might fail, but at least the group isn’t stagnant.


3. Jey’s Best Singles Match?

Jey Uso Damian Priest
WWE

Jey Uso versus Damian Priest never felt like a world title-level feud, despite WWE reminding fans repeatedly that they were fighting for the World Heavyweight Championship.

And as great as Jey’s entrance and presence is, the bell still has to ring, and more often than not, he’s turned in average performances.

However, Saturday’s title match between Priest and Uso was actually a lot better than one might have expected, with some solid exchanges and big move bombs being thrown around. Priest hitting two cyclone kicks before Jey countered with three thrust kicks, a spear and a splash was a particularly great moment. The action felt befitting of a world title match, even if the build and wrestlers themselves weren’t oozing that feeling – if that makes sense.

Even the Judgment Day drama, which could have overtaken the atmosphere of the match, worked well, with JD McDonagh being chastised for interfering and then paying dividends on the aforementioned spear/splash combo when he put Priest’s foot on the ropes. Damian lashing out and bossing JD and Finn Balor around afterward will likely play into more drama on Monday.

Good night overall for the World Heavyweight Championship.


2. French Audience Reaches Unreal Levels

Cody Rhodes
WWE

What can you say about the Lyon crowd during Backlash?

It’s difficult to quantify to adequately describe the fans’ interactions and reactions throughout the PLE other than to say it was other-wordly. If last year’s Backlash in Puerto Rico was a 10/10, Backlash France might have to be rated a 10.5/10.

The crowd was into everything from start to finish – they were even popping for Byron Saxton during the kickoff show and chanted for Charles Robinson – and they elevated what at times felt like a supercharged house show and turned it into a memorable experience.

Atmosphere is an important element of a wrestling show, and the Lyon audience deserves credit for creating a tremendous atmosphere that masked the at-times mid show.


1. Cody Survives First Defense

Cody Rhodes
WWE

First title defenses are a tricky situation: Unless the title-holder is purely a transitional champion, the outcome really isn’t in doubt, especially in this era of longer title reigns. The challenge is making that obvious match compelling for fans, both in the arena and at home.

For those reasons, you have to take your hat off to AJ Styles and Cody Rhodes, who turned in a really, really good performance at Backlash France. The outcome was never in doubt – there was no chance Cody was losing the title a month after finishing the story – and yet they made their Undisputed WWE Universal Championship match a must-see affair.

AJ stood toe-to-toe with Cody during their standoffs, delivering probably his best performance in a while. Rhodes was his usual superhero self, firing up the crowd (as if they needed help) while revving himself up – the kickout of the Burning Hammer at one was a great example.

What makes the match even more intriguing is that they left some spots and sequences on the table for a rematch down the line. They made such a big deal about Styles defeating Dusty Rhodes 21 years earlier and barely scratched the surface on that during Saturday’s match itself.

Great first defense for the American Nightmare, and hopefully it’s a good sign for the future for Rhodes.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.