5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (19 July - Results & Review)
Cody Rhodes is helpless; SummerSlam matches made official; WWE needs to rethink Bayley.
WWE taped a double shot of SmackDown goodness for fans in the house on Friday, and that typically changes how the show comes across on TV. Marathon tapings mean there's a ton of filler spread across all four hours of telly on back-to-back weeks, but that's unavoidable due to the roster's upcoming mini-tour in Japan.
SmackDown still got the main story beats right.
A major title bout was locked in for SummerSlam, and Solo Sikoa's Bloodline 2.0 continued wrecking the competition as the would-be 'Tribal Chief' stared down on a fallen Cody Rhodes. There's enough meat on the bone between those guys to make the next PLE clash fun, but it's also true that people want Roman Reigns back in a hurry.
How about the downers? Well, Carmelo Hayes has zero direction right now, creative made an odd choice during Bayley's sit-down snarl-fest with Nia Jax, and one women's match topped Booker T vs. Edge for a shampoo commercial in terms of "high stakes". Look out for some, 'They're Fighting Over A Queue' signs soon.
WWE's product is undeniably hot, but a strange malaise has crept over Friday nights lately. Here's hoping Roman's return and the emergence of some new stars like Tiffany Stratton can change that.
Here's all the good and bad!
Downs...
3. Decent But Directionless
Andrade vs. Carmelo Hayes was always going to be solid bell-to-bell, but you've got to question what the point of this mini-feud is. They're pretty much fighting over who was less of a loser at Money In The Bank, and that makes for a sh*tty dynamic. Andrade winning out is good for him, but man...Hayes needs something better soon.
Hanging tight before losing vs. top stars like Randy Orton and Cody Rhodes was one thing, but staring at the lights for a clear midcarder like 'El Idolo' is another. Good workers can offset losses, but they need some sense of direction to help out with that. Melo doesn't have that right now.
It's a wee bit worrying.
Look, he'll surely be fine, but it's a crappy vibe to have Hayes going around saying things like, "Melo don't miss" when he most certainly does. It's really the lack of a satisfying story back up that dropped this one in the 'Downs'. Scrapping over who's less of a loser won't cut it.
2. Not Sure This Is The Way To Go
Speaking of weird story choices.
Bayley pointing out that Nia Jax is "clumsy" and prone to hurting people she wrestles? Yeah, the lines are a little too blurry there. Why would a heel like Nia get bent out of shape because she's called out for hurting opponents? If anything, Jax would laugh that off. Instead, Bayley managed to get under her skin.
Then, Nia stormed out of their sit-down interview in a huff. Hmm. This fan still believes these women will deliver the goods come SummerSlam, but he's not sold on WWE going there with the build. So, Nia is a cold, callous heel who's also self-aware and self-conscious about her spotty record of injuring other members of the roster.
Nah, that's overdoing it and just isn't necessary for her title challenge. Sorry, but Bayley's stories since winning the Women's Title at WrestleMania have flat out sucked. Contrast and compare her aura to someone like Rhea Ripley over on Raw. It's night and day.
1. They’re Wrestling Over A Queuing System
Bianca Belair vs. Chelsea Green happened so both ladies could determine who gets to queue up and speak to GM Nick Aldis first. OK then. Worse than that, the match lasted less than a minute before Belair bagged the win and celebrated like she'd headlined 'Mania with Jade Cargill.
What was the point of this?
Older fans will recall Edge and Booker T warring over a fictional shampoo ad at WrestleMania X8. That was silly, but almost knowingly so. Here, peeps tuning into SmackDown were expected to believe that Bianca and Chelsea needed a wrestle to establish who was allowed to stand outside the General Manager's door first.
This is the kind of asinine nonsense Vince McMahon would've penned in 2019, and it cannot be excused. In short, nobody gives a toss which wrestler gets to queue outside Nick's door. Just get to the point and put the babyfaces back in the Women's Tag Title mix already.
Ups...
5. Not ‘Tiffy Time’…Yet!
This might come as a shock to regular readers, but your writer doesn't actually mind Michin scoring the win over Tiffany Stratton. That's largely due to the circumstances surrounding Mia Yim's moment. Tiff was distracted by Bayley attacking Nia Jax at ringside, then Michin grabbed the surprise victory.
It'd be silly to argue about Michin being unimportant because she never wins matches then turn around and bitch when she wins a match here or there. A lot of people will dump all over Stratton snagging MITB then staring at the lights on Friday, but her long-term prospects remain brighter than most.
She'll be fine.
Tiffany will presumably be next in line for a shot at Bayley unless Nia springs a title shocker at SummerSlam. This union between the heels is doomed to fail at some stage anyway - you're not looking at BFFs for life, let's be honest. This match was serviceable and pushed the idea that Stratton caring about Jax's business is detrimental.
That's a win.
4. The US Title Match Is Set!
LA Knight has been carrying a lot of the build towards SummerSlam on his own, but Logan Paul has popped by to do some good work during certain pre-tapes. On Friday, both did well in front of a live crowd. Special mention to GM Aldis for performing his role to perfection as well. It isn't his fault WWE thinks wrestlers having matches to queue outside his door is compelling TV!
Right, enough moaning about that.
Knight goaded Logan into signing the contract by saying his brother would have the balls to do it. That was a killer line, and the same could be said for Paul pointing out that LA has been wrestling hard for approx 20 years without winning as much as he has at a top level. Smug sh*thousery from LP there.
Even a blind man can see that Knight should win the United States Title on the next PLE. That'll be a sweet success for LA personally, and it'll get a monster pop from the crowd in Cleveland. Who knows what's next for Logan after SummerSlam? He'll find some way to get heat and then impress, that's for sure.
3. Cody Rhodes References History
Cody's opening promo was a vehicle for two things. One, kill time for A-Town Down Under's ambush to set up the main event tag later on. Two, shine a spotlight on boxer Terence Crawford at ringside. He handed Cody a steel chair so he could fend off the heels. Apparently, nobody wanted to take an uppercut. Shame.
The opening speech from Rhodes was all functional stuff, but it did include one gem: Cody mentioned that he previously looked Solo Sikoa in the eye before WrestleMania 39 in 2023 and told him he wasn't ready. Then, Solo was a difference maker in helping Roman retain vs. Rhodes on the big night.
Fast forward to today, and Sikoa is about to challenge Cody for the gold. This guy always appreciates it when WWE acknowledges the past. That's even true when it's the recent past. The company produces so much content that April 2023 feels like a lifetime ago, so it's nice Triple H didn't forget some history between current title foes.
Cody's promo was worth it for that bit alone.
2. KO Returns To Team With Cody
First off, it's amazing to hear that KO's mother is doing better in hospital. Next, as much as this was defo a house show style bout, Cody and Kev gelled well together and the live crowd loved it. Problems continue to mount for Austin Theory and Grayson Waller too, although WWE need to pull the trigger on Theory's babyface turn soon.
It's time, people.
There was more miscommunication between the A-Town Down crew throughout the match. On the other side, the babyfaces acted like they've been a regular tag for years. It's anyone's guess whether or not the actual R-KO unit of Owens and Randy Orton will get a tag title reign before finishing up that experiment.
If Cody's earlier promo was a mere vehicle for the heel attack, then this match was one for The Bloodline waiting to pounce. Anyone who has been following SmackDown over the past few months could see that coming, but Solo Sikoa leading the charge doesn't deserve some of the eye-rolling it's getting.
1. More Of The Same (But That’s Fine For Now)
Yes, there's a fair amount of tut-tutting on socials about The Bloodline 2.0 constantly ending these SmackDown shows on top, but WWE shouldn't take flak for making a new heel group look strong. Sure, it's a lot of the same stuff, but that's the point; nobody can stop them until Roman Reigns rides in and shuts Solo's rebellion down.
Besides, Sikoa is challenging Cody at SummerSlam, so it'd be daft if his version of The Bloodline looked anything less than dominant right now. The same folks criticising these heel-heavy closing shots would be spitting the dummy if Solo was eating finishers from the babyfaces at the end of TV every single week.
Jacob Fatu has added a much-needed edge to the faction, and Solo still has numbers like Tama Tonga and Tonga Loa to help overwhelm Cody, KO and Randy Orton when he's around. It looks like WWE plans to add yet another member to the stable soon too. Then, Reigns can hit the comeback trail for a mega-pop.
This was fine and made Solo's troops look vicious.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 Fascinating Facts About WWE In 2010 and 10 Fascinating Facts About WWE In 2011!