5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (2 May - Results & Review)

Tepid build towards PLEs is starting to become a worrying WWE trend in 2025.

WWE.com

WWE put Randy Orton into the same awkward shoes Cody Rhodes had to wear during the build towards WrestleMania 41, and it's become a concerning trend in company circles as 2025 nears its midway point. Sometimes, workers have to carry PPV/PLE hype solo, but that shouldn't be the general rule. Sadly, scheduling woes and a few too many part-timers near the top of the cards mean it's unavoidable.

That formatting didn't help one of SmackDown's lead segments this week, and it's fair to say star power was an issue overall. On the plus side, hard workers in the Women's Title, Women's United States Title and tag-team divisions gave fans attending the show something to shout about, but it would've been nicer to see a little more urgency considering Backlash is next weekend.

The show is already Saturday Night's Main Event under a different name. It has a historically fascinating finale between Randy and John Cena to entice people in, but Triple H appears obsessed with multi-wrestler affairs in lieu of gripping one on one feuds elsewhere. Meanwhile, one of his most promising newcomers is already spinning his wheels, and another could be heading down the same road in a few weeks.

Fingers crossed he doesn't, but 'The Game's' barebones approach to 'Mania season TV at times hasn't exactly filled everyone with hope.

Here's all the good and bad from a largely functional episode of SmackDown that seemed to be a 2 hour show stretched into 3. Thankfully, there were a bunch of positives to lavish praise on in amongst some of the grumbles!


Downs...

3. Some Of Those Lengthy Gaps

Nia Jax
WWE.com

What was that about stretching a 2-hour format across 3 solid hours of television?

This is a wider point about SmackDown as a whole since the turn of the year. Some episodes have still flown by due to excellent matches, loads of star power and the fact people were buzzed for WrestleMania season, but then there are the 'filler' editions. They struggle to fill the full duration with must-see content, and that was definitely the case this past Friday night.

There were multiple times on Friday when WWE went 25 minutes plus between major matches or in-ring segments, and that’s just far too long. It’s why many can’t wait for SmackDown to go back to the 2 hour format and drop this third hour stuff. Recent WWE news suggests that’ll happen in a month or so, and it can’t come soon enough for regular viewers - especially now that 'Mania is in the rear view mirror and there's a traditional drop in casual interest.

Lengthy gaps are bloody painful if you’re watching the show live without any ability to fast forward through some of the fluff, and it must be murder for those paying a fortune to sit in the arena. There are only so many WWE Shop ads, superstar-specific vignettes and backstage promos one audience can be expected to sit through at once.

Pacing is important for any wrestling show, and SmackDown just didn't seem to understand that. Poll WWE's writers and they'd probably agree that going back to 2 hours would be best. That's coming soon, but maybe not soon enough for episodes this thin on the ground.


2. Honestly? A Bit Lifeless!

Rey Fenix Santos Escobar
WWE.com

Being a passionate pro wrestling fan sometimes means it's easy to knee jerk react when everything falls short of being flawless. Fair enough, but the question must be asked: Is this simply an early wobble in the WWE career of one Rey Fenix, or should his biggest fans be worried? Fenix ate a loss at 'Mania 41 when subbing for the injured Rey Mysterio vs. Chad Gable's El Grande Americano gimmick, and now he's following that up with a less-than-thrilling scrap on SmackDown.

Fenix vs. Santos Escobar should've been fabulous. Sadly, it never really got going. On commentary, Joe Tessitore and Wade Barrett covered for this by claiming Rey had to show a different side of himself to overcome Santos. Cool, but the match was far too slow and ponderous throughout, and Fenix didn't spring into life until right at the very end.

The bout was a little too boring to score an 'Up', which was unexpected.

Here's the problem: Triple H has to avoid turning dudes like Fenix into 'just another worker on the roster'. He should sparkle weekly, and the only way to make sure of that is by having him go hell for leather (thus playing to his high flying strengths) whilst developing some sort of identifiable character during promos and other assorted segments.

Rey vs. Escobar came across as fairly lazy booking, truth be told. It was Tony Khan style, 'Get 'em in the ring and it'll be fine' fare, and that just isn't enough for weekly episodic TV. Of course, this could be that ol' knee jerking chestnut discussed at the head of this entry. That's possible, but this guy just wants more from somebody who's so fresh and new to WWE's product.


1. Randy Orton’s Fired Up, But…

Randy Orton
WWE.com

...WWE is getting a wee bit too comfortable with these well-delivered but ultimately meaningless solo promo segments to build towards top matches.

Randy tried his best here, but he had no new ground to cover and was really just killing time. Granted, that can be fine every now and then, but yeah - WWE leans on this sort of thing too much at the moment. It defo hurt WrestleMania 41’s build, and that’s now bleeding over into Backlash. They need to be mindful of conditioning the audience to expect empty promos.

Personally, this WWE lifer can’t wait for the actual match between Randy and John Cena, because they had to run that one more time before JC's retirement. The issue is that Orton spat venom into the void on Friday night. His speech conjured up images of Cody doing the same in John's direction whilst Cena sat at home or was out on the road fulfilling media duties before bagging the WWE Title.

Look, everybody knew that John wouldn't be there at every single show during this send off run, but it's vital he feels like a part of things one week out from his biggest matches. One final Cena vs. Orton clash deserves more than obvious skits like this that make it painfully clear John's schedule is lighter than some would like.

He'll be on SmackDown next week as advertised, but would it have killed WWE to coax him into view here for a surprise revenge attack on the ranting Randy? That would've been a neat twist that toyed with fan expectations, but it wasn't meant to be. Good fire from Orton on the mic though. That's worth saying.


Ups...

5. Fraxiom Off To A Hot Start

Fraxiom Pretty Deadly
WWE.com

The tag-team division has been a regular highlight on SmackDown episodes for a long time now. Unfortunately, that didn't earn the show's squads a slot on either night in Las Vegas at 'Mania 41, but The Street Profits did win a banging TLC scorcher over DIY and The Motor City Machine Guns on last week's show. WWE's next step is finding Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins some new challengers.

Step forwards, Fraxiom.

Nathan Frazer and Axiom scored a win over Los Garza last week, then received another glowing recommendation from the writers by beating Pretty Deadly on Friday. Admittedly, there was a slight blip in the action; Elton Prince seemingly took a nasty elbow shot to the chops and was thus too dazed to kick out as planned. The ref had to call an audible and stop her count, which looked bad but wasn't a bout-breaker in the end.

No, the most important thing is that Fraxiom got to showcase their speed and synergy as a team. They bamboozled PD with energetic flurries that were very TNA-era MCMGs (which is something worth keeping an eye on if Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin ever run into them), and the pair got a nice reaction from fans enthused by their slick sequences.

As always, the big hurdle will be selling Frazer and Axiom as characters worth caring about once the honeymoon sheen wears off. However, it's nice to add another hot team to a division that's frankly been killing it for ages. Fraxiom vs. Machine Guns, DIY and eventually Street Profits makes sense.


4. A Surprise Women’s US Package

Zelina Vega Piper Niven
WWE.com

Cards on the table: This fan went into Zelina Vega vs. Piper Niven expecting to roll his eyes at an all too short, unsatisfying match that didn't do much to sell the former as a worthy Women's United States Champ. Then, something wonderful happened. The bell sounded, and...Vega was the spitfire babyface fighting from underneath against a sneering powerhouse who took her eye off the ball when it mattered most.

That's simple storytelling, but it worked a treat for this pairing. There was a neat power vs. speed element to their match, and the live crowd did come with Zelina as she gritted her teeth and sold like the rent was due. Again, can't lie, there was eye-rolling aplenty once Nick Aldis set this bout up in a backstage skit, but it's refreshing to get slapped in the face and told to shut up by two workers giving their all with a simple, easy to understand story.

Honestly, it's still an uphill battle to convince everybody that taking the title off Chelsea Green so suddenly was the right call, but you've got to treat each match/segment fairly too. It was lovely to go in with really low expectations then be pleasantly surprised by what these women accomplished.

Good on them for snapping back at preconceived notions!

Perhaps Zelina can work out as a sympathetic babyface getting a big push post-WrestleMania 41 after all. Immense credit has to go to Niven for knowing exactly when to lay it on thick with the heel heat sections and when to let Vega dazzle her with speed. This was a ring general's performance from the Scot.


3. Aleister Black’s Steady Reintroduction

Aleister Black The Miz
WWE.com

Incoming ex-AEW man Aleister Black beating The Miz wasn’t the squash some might’ve been predicting to kick off his second WWE stint, but that shouldn’t really be Aleister’s thing anyway. He’s someone who dishes out strike-based punishment but crucially sells a bit during his matches too, and this was therefore a decent way to fill 10 minutes of airtime.

Rather conveniently, Black also has a match vs. Carmelo Hayes lined up off the back of beating Miz. That'd be the kind of scrap people would've been tripping over to see on old NXT TakeOver specials, and it should land with a thump on the main roster if WWE decides to give them some time. Such minutes should be a given when creative needs to pad out these lengthy SmackDowns, let's be honest.

It'd be churlish to moan about anything here just for the sake of it. Black beat a legacy star and former multi-time WWE Champ, so it’s hardly anything to complain about. Of course, Triple H will need to learn from history and give Al some more purpose longer term so he doesn’t just repeat old problems ("Pick a fight with meeeeeeeee" over and over, basically!), but this was a solid reintroduction to WWE fans.

Black didn't try to do too much just because he can, and The Miz played his role like a grand old wizard who's comfortable in his WWE skin. Dude's teflon at this stage in the game - he could lose every match from now until 2030 and still get a response from crowds. In that respect, he was the ideal opponent for Aleister's first showing back in the promotion.

Solid.


2. Women’s Division = Ultra Competitive

Nia Jax Naomi Jade Cargill
WWE.com

Firstly, that was a fairly rough promo/brawl segment involving Nia Jax, Tiffany Stratton, Naomi and then Jade Cargill, but their main event tag bout was good clean fun and it represented yet another pleasant surprise package for this week's show. Cargill is coming on leaps and bounds in-ring, and the more she tangles with workers with Naomi the better.

Next up for Jade: Nia in a singles next week to determine Tiffany's new contender. The likely outcome of that is a screwy finish though, because Naomi is firmly in the mix for gold too. She was the one holding Stratton's belt aloft right at the end of Friday's SmackDown, which strongly implies that there's a multi-woman match coming your way at Backlash.

That's fine in this instance, because at least the division looks really competitive and has some strong characters pinning it down. Tiffany is riding high after vanquishing Charlotte Flair at WrestleMania, Jax has returned with vengeance on her mind after Stratton cashed in Money In The Bank to scoop her glory, Jade will only get better the more reps she gets, and Naomi has a dangerous vibe as a heel.

Some out there might think it's way too soon for Tiffy's reign to end, but there are sure worse ideas creatively than going all the way with Naomi as a reckless villain who'll stop at nothing to achieve her own selfish goals after years of looking out for others. Put it like this: WWE must book Stratton vs. Naomi in a series of one on one matches this year.

Tidy, compact and well-worked main event here.


1. LA Knight & Damian Priest Deliver

LA Knight Damian Priest
WWE.com

Delivered on the mic and inside the ring.

It would've been easy for their pre-match promo battle to sink, but LA Knight and Damian Priest believably jabbed one another for respective losses at WrestleMania. Knight was especially annoyed that Priest caused Drew McIntyre to win via DQ against him on last week’s SmackDown, and all that verbal sparring led to one hell of a match between the pair to kick things off this week.

There's something so pleasing about babyfaces acting like real human beings who don't just become fast friends because they're both good guys. Knight and Priest acknowledged that there's respect between them, but they want to be winners. That gave the segment an edge, and it clicked neatly into place as a sub-story to Jacob Fatu's United States Title reign.

Everybody's coming for that gold, probably including Jacob's so-called ally Solo Sikoa. He ran in on Knight vs. Priest to cause the stoppage, but don't let that ruin your enjoyment of what LA and Damian produced here. They were cooking right up until the interruption, so hopefully this isn’t the last time they go one on one.

Triple H just found babyface opponents who can make that trope work.

Bonus points go to the writers for making sure that Fatu got to look dominant by the end yet again. That's kinda his thing, and it works for the new US Champ. If you only check out one full match from this week's episode, make it Knight vs. Priest. Ignore the typical TV ending, because the main meat of the match is worth seeing regardless.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling content, check out WWE Black Wednesday Releases 5 Years Later - Where Are They Now? and 15 Wrestlers WWE Debuted In The WORST Way Possible!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.