5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (21 Feb - Results & Review)
The Rock played WrestleMania mind games with Cody Rhodes on SmackDown.
Eyebrows were raised when news broke that none other than The Rock would be there live for Friday's SmackDown. WWE didn't give everyone a few days notice to get pumped. Nope, they dropped the bombshell late then the 'Final Boss' waltzed onto set to announce that WrestleMania 42 will take place in New Orleans. That wasn't his only piece of business on the blue brand though.
Rock's promo segment with Cody Rhodes will divide opinion. It's fair to let things shake out, because there's clearly a long-term story going on, but isolating this one skit makes things less...glossy. Whilst it's defo important to give stories room to breathe, it's also important to judge individual segments on their own merits.
That lengthy bit messed with Triple H's format sheets before SmackDown went on the air. As a result, parts of the broadcast came across rather spotty, but a few spirited matches raised the bar and kept things motoring along. Kevin Owens might've just dropped some handy hints for Rocky to follow in the future too. He's a master at getting to the point quickly, put it that way!
A cracking main event was bolstered by a fabulous opener. Annoyances still persist in the Women's Title scene though. Those who were worried about Tiffany Stratton vs. Charlotte Flair before might want to avert their eyes from this week's show. It's OK to get even more concerned about the way things are headed on that front.
Here's all the good and bad from a hastily-reassembled Smackers before next week's Elimination Chamber.
Downs...
3. The Rock’s Rambling “I Want Your Soul” Promo
Up first: The Rock's appearance.
Look, hopefully WWE has a plan to make this work and everything comes up smelling of roses in the end, but SmackDown's segment felt a little awkward and almost clumsy. Honestly, it still feels a bit sudden within the context of TV that Cody Rhodes and The Rock are great friends now, especially after everything that happened during the build up to WrestleMania 40. Rock saying he wants to make Cody “his” corporate style champion has potential though, but this maybe wasn’t the blistering first chapter of that story arc WWE wanted it to be.
Rock being heavily involved in the final month before ‘Mania could muddy the waters if someone like CM Punk or John Cena is challenging. Being fair, let’s wait and see how it plays out, but it'd be hard to give this segment anything other than a ‘Down’ in isolation. That was a lot of rearranged time dedicated to bare bones.
There are glimmers of hope in Rocky going Mr. McMahon vs. Steve Austin style with Rhodes. He's pretty much asking Cody to become a 'Corporate Champion' without saying those words. There shouldn't be any issues with Cody being dumbfounded and lost for words either. That was the intention of this skit.
It just didn't quite land the way Rock, Hunter, Cody and WWE as a whole would've wanted it to. If this was planned out all along, then everyone really needed to do a better job with The Rock's actual wording here. He meandered a bit too much for this to feel impactful.
2. Honestly? A Little Dull!
Triple H has work to do on Tiffany Stratton's alignment. It's all over the place. One minute, she's a champion babyface rife with fighting spirit who fans love. The next, she's playing the old bitchy brat character like it's NXT all over again and she's a definitive heel. Sort that out pronto, please. This 50/50 stuff is doing Tiffy no favours.
Her match vs. Candice LeRae on this week's show never really got going. Yours truly has to admit he's now split on the upcoming Elimination Chamber tag with Trish Stratus as well. It's definitely cool to see Trish, but it doesn't feel like Stratton should be focusing on anything other than Charlotte Flair right now. This is either the most important match of her career or it isn't.
Beating Nia Jax and Candice one more time alongside the legendary Stratus won't help that fight.
Finally, what was up with Nia’s move on Trish and Tiffy? She just…sat down rather than hitting the Annihilator as usual. Something clearly went wrong there. Perhaps Jax saw that Stratus (who was laying on top of Stratton) was slightly out of position and didn't want to risk injuring her. Fair play, but the move did look horrible regardless.
Overall, Stratton vs. LeRae was a dull affair that didn't do much to make the division look like one primed for WrestleMania season. Maybe that's a tad harsh, because this is one match and that's all, but there are genuine concerns about where WWE could take things in coming months.
Speaking of which...
1. Charlotte Flair’s Guest Commentary
Time to repeat something.
Charlotte Flair is the more experienced wrestler in the upcoming 'Mania bout with Tiffany, and the onus is therefore firmly on her shoulders to sell it as must see. You would've thought Charlotte and Stratton were fighting on Main Event with the lack of energy to Flair's comments when sitting in on guest commentary for SmackDown. Seriously, did she need a nap or something?
This is WrestleMania season, for crying out loud. You just returned to win the women's Royal Rumble, and you've been pointing at the big neon sign like that's commission based. Charlotte, where was your fire and passion here?! She was a non-event when sitting next to Wade Barrett and Joe Tessitore. Flair said absolutely nothing of value, and outright failed to sell her title challenge with any kind of vigour.
People are kinda concerned for this match, and with good reason. If Charlotte is going to continue acting like a bored elitist who can't be bothered to hype things up, then fans will sit on their hands come Las Vegas. Right now, the only saving grace this 'Mania bout has is that Triple H might stick by the new star and give Stratton a career-boosting victory. It's up to Flair to sell the opposite - nobody else.
She was almost caught off guard by some of Wade's softball questions too, which was strange. Literally all Charlotte has to do is put Tiffany over as a new star worth beating, then do her usual 'I'm the measuring stick' stuff. Apparently, that's too much effort.
Ups...
5. 'Melo Don’t Miz' Becomes A Thing
OK, so it looks like Carmelo Hayes and The Miz will become a tag-team after all. Personally, zero issues with that, because Melo needed something to do and was struggling on his own anyway. The cheesy wordplay works, and both men had some decent chemistry as a team vs. R-Truth and LA Knight on Friday night. This was a two for one storytelling push too.
Shinsuke Nakamura got involved to cost Knight before they tangle over the United States Title once more. Again, nobody should be offended by that. Truth took the fall (as he should), LA had an out (necessary considering he was the biggest star in the match), and a brand new ego-driven tag-team unit shared smiles after getting their first win together.
No, this wasn't the kind of match anyone needs to go out of their way to see, but it was functional whilst pushing two separate stories forwards. Sometimes, that's perfectly fine for TV. Not every single match needs to be a five star classic. It's more important to tell tales and fit into the framework of the broadcast overall. Truth and Knight vs. Melo Don't Miz did exactly that.
It was way better than Tiffany Stratton vs. Candice LeRae, which should've strived for similar. Truth is handy to have around on Fridays for situations precisely like this one, and there could be something in Melo Don't Miz if WWE plays their cards right. Fingers and toes crossed this is a turning point for Hayes on the main roster.
Miz playing his goofy, totally uncool partner works.
4. SmackDown’s Tag Division Is Clicking
DIY and Pretty Deadly could've gone out there and wrestled an acceptable 15-20 minute TV match that ended with Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa picking up a routine win. Sure, they could've done that, but WWE decided to do something much, much, much more interesting. There's just so much to like about where the blue brand's tag-team ranks are right now generally.
The Street Profits are coming across as almost APA-esque brutes who have everyone's number and know it. Meanwhile, DIY are running for their lives from the chasing pack, Motor City Machine Guns feel they're due another shot due to what Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins did at the Rumble, and then there's Pretty Deadly's bizarre potential as a spitfire babyface duo.
Did anybody see that coming when calendars turned to 2025? Anyone?!
PD have been showing some much needed aggression during recent matches and segments. That continued here vs. Gargano and Ciampa before all of the run-ins. On commentary, Barrett and Joe Tess wondered aloud whether or not Deadly might've beaten DIY had Ford and Dawkins not cut them off at the knees. That, dear readers, is simple storytelling done well.
It's pretty obvious there's a multi-team match coming at WrestleMania 41. Good, 'cause there should be. There, it'd be lovely to see either The Profits go full-blown heel and reign supreme as champs (it looked like they were heading for a heartbreaking WWE split at one stage!) or Pretty Deadly get some flowers for their hard work as punching bags for the division previously.
At least these teams all have some purpose behind showing up for SmackDown every week. That's progress.
3. “You Asked For This!”
One of the best things about villainous Kevin Owens is that he's the kind of heel who believes he's 100% in the right about everyone else. They're all dirtbags, not him, and he'll use whatever warped logic he needs to when convincing himself of that. This simplicity isn't a negative - it makes following KO's antics more fun, because fans know he'll always find a way to spin despicable behaviour.
On Friday, Owens went super creepy by hanging about outside Sami Zayn's house and filming his family through the window. No, this won't turn him into some DDP-style stalker gimmick, but it proves the point of KO's delusion. He can't see that this is going too far, because he thinks Sami is the one to blame. In his promo, Kev said he couldn't believe Zayn didn't just take his deserved punishment and move on without trying to get revenge.
Now, KO has to brutalise him and cause pain for Sami's family by doing so. "You asked for this. It's all your fault", he said. That psychopathic chat is really working for Owens as a character. Like the intro says, he didn't need 25 minutes to put his point across. So, maybe The Rock should've been taking notes. Ouch! That's pretty harsh, granted.
It's valid though. Kevin managed to put across everything he needed to put across in just a few short minutes. The location, his panicked bubbling that almost threatened to turn into full on tears, and the coming brutality of their "Unsanctioned" match at Elimination Chamber helped make KO vs. Sami one of SmackDown's finest segments.
2. 'Big Jim' Gets A Big Win
One can just see the complaints now. 'Why is Jimmy Uso beating Drew McIntyre right before Drew walks into Elimination Chamber?'. Anyone pointing that out is only concerned about the credibility of an important PLE match, but their fears are misplaced on this occasion. Look at the evidence. Uso rolled McIntyre up in surprise fashion, and the finish was presented as more of an opportunistic fluke.
However, it’s a clean win over an established top guy for ‘Big Jim’. He’s really coming on leaps and bounds as a singles star in his own right, which is great to see after it looked like he’d be left in the dust by his Royal Rumble winning brother a while ago. Some might not like McIntyre losing before Chamber one bit, but Drew got his heat back post-match by battering Uso. They had a tidy match too, one that ended with McIntyre’s lust for violence costing him.
In short, he’ll survive this.
It's crucial to remember that Jimmy is trying to build momentum on his side. Triple H knows that Uso will be a valuable upper midcard player for the rest of the year, so sacrificing McIntyre for one night was the right thing to do. Drew yelling at a downed Uso after flattening him, and saying that he's the one going to WrestleMania anyway, will come back to haunt him post-Chamber.
Jimmy vs. Drew was the right choice as an opener for SmackDown. Hopefully, this isn't the last time these two go at it. They've got chemistry, man.
1. Hoss Fight Main Event Delivers
The main event was packed with chemistry itself.
Something just feels right about seeing Braun Strowman and Jacob Fatu in the same ring together. They showed what they're capable of back on a recent Saturday Night's Main Event, and the duo served up more good times here. Braun and Damian Priest are a good power team in the short-term too. That needs to be said. They won't be going after the tag belts, or anything, but they work in this kind of setting.
There was an interesting wrinkle on the heel side; tension between Jacob Fatu and Solo Sikoa punctuated the match. That peaked when Jacob accidentally superkicked Solo right in the jaw, then stared down at him with a serious lack of empathy. Yep, loads to enjoy here. It was four bulls hitting power moves aplenty, but the action had a nice pace to it throughout.
Tama Tonga, who was at ringside for the ex-New Bloodline pairing, even took one hell of a bump for Strowman's old steam train spot over by the announce table. Thankfully, that was one of the only times he got involved. Full focus needed to go on issues between Jacob and Solo, as well as the main event push Priest is getting on Fridays.
That's being endorsed by Braun, at least for now. Credit to all four of these dudes for bringing the energy levels back up after everyone was left confused by The Rock's segment with Cody Rhodes. They had a job on their hands, 'cause people's interest could've dropped post-Rock, but the quartet delivered.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 20 Wrestling Gimmicks That Got WEIRD Rip-Offs and 50 Fascinating Facts About WWE in The 1980s!