5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Jan 6)

Roman Reigns snaps at Sami Zayn; Charlotte Flair struggles; WWE sets up Royal Rumble.

Charlotte Flair 2023
WWE.com

Attention, Triple H: You're making the same mistakes the soon-to-return Vince McMahon once did with Charlotte Flair. She is not a good babyface, has made it clear she doesn't want to be one and is horribly miscast during her own WWE comeback.

Sort it out.

The good news is that there was a lot to like about this week's SmackDown elsewhere. No, it wasn't quite the show last week's John Cena-boosted broadcast was, but it was still a fun two hours and Smackers continues to trump Raw in terms of being easy to digest.

WWE's main goal on Friday night was to announce some names for both Royal Rumble matches and setup the big title bout for Roman Reigns on that pay-per-view. Creative achieved that, and they're still managing to squeeze more juice from the Sami Zayn story too. That remains pro wrestling's absolute best narrative, which won't change unless Vinnie Mac's comeback deems Sami expendable.

It's unrealistic to expect any show to be flawless from beginning to end, but SmackDown often comes close. Sadly, there are often just a few little things that let it down. Here's all the good and bad from the blue brand's latest!


Downs...

3. Let The Moment Breathe!

Hit Row Ricochet
WWE.com

Ricochet qualifying for the Rumble is fine. Hell, even the two-minute length for his match vs. Top Dolla is forgivable. However, did Braun Strowman need to get involved here? Yes, he was returning the favour to Ricochet, but Hit Row's heelish antics needed some breathing space they didn't get.

Braun squashed their moment.

Top Dolla, Ashante Adonis and B-FAB battered then berated Rico post-match, then cowered when Strowman came out for the save. Being honest, it might've been better had they at least tried to take the fight to him and come out worse. By running away, they lost the lustre they'd just built.

This is really last chance saloon for Hit Row. They haven't been great since returning to the company last year, and it'll be agony for the trio if they flop just as much as heels as they did playing babyface. Hopefully, things pan out for them.


2. Babyface Charlotte Flair Just Doesn’t Click

Charlotte Flair 2023
WWE.com

WWE noticeably piped-in some cheers for Charlotte Flair's promo here.

Last week, people were surprised by her return so responded in kind by cheering. She is a big star making a comeback after a significant absence, after all, so that's no shocker. This week, people just seemed confused because...there's nothing to particularly likeable about Flair's presentation.

She's a condescending heel who wears a painted-on smile, and nothing can change that. Post-cringeworthy promo, Charlotte was then tasked with getting a solid six minutes out of Sonya Deville. The match struggled to get going then ended suddenly, which didn't help it fly with the audience.

If the writers wanted to double dip on fan goodwill for Charlotte's comeback, then this was a swing and a miss. The Memphis crowd never seemed sure how they were supposed to react when Flair was saying she doesn't care what people think about her, for example.


1. “Sure, Whatever!”

Kevin Owens
WWE.com

That nonchalant reply sucked.

Roman Reigns heard Kevin Owens' challenge for a title bout at Royal Rumble, then said: "Yeah, sure. Whatever!". This one line did nothing to sell the match as important; everyone knows it's background noise to the bubbling tension between Roman and Sami Zayn, but at least try to make it seem like KO is some sort of threat.

Reigns palmed him off here like he was Triple H giving The Brooklyn Brawler an exhibition-esque title shot back during the 'Attitude Era', and that is not a favourable comparison. This writer also isn't sure what went on with Roman yelling that he wants Owens gone "forever".

This sort of suggested a 'Title vs. Career' stip at the Rumble, but that clearly isn't WWE's plan. So, Kev had to add in a remark about not going away for good before questioning Zayn's balls and leaving. The first half of this skit was great (more on that to come), but the second? Meh.


Ups...

5. Kofi Kingston = Bulletproof

Kofi Kingston Santos Escobar
WWE.com

Some pro wrestlers could lose pretty much every match from now until the end of their careers and still remain over. Kofi Kingston is one of those workers - he's built up enough cred with fans to last a lifetime, and so nobody should take umbrage with his loss to Santos Escobar on SmackDown.

Kofi went out of his way to make Santos look great, and he even managed to work in a tease for what's to come at the Rumble by tossing Escobar over the top rope. That was appreciated, especially because Michael Cole and Wade Barrett could then weave in their own hard sell for the pay-per-view.

Good stuff.

Nothing life-changing here, or anything, but Kofi vs. Santos was a tidy little 10-minute TV match that secured the heel a much-needed singles win over a former WWE Champ. That should be celebrated, and it won't hurt the New Day legend one bit either.


4. Solid Build For Scarlett & Karrion Kross

Karrion Kross Scarlett Madcap Moss Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

Scarlett and Karrion Kross squashed Emma and Madcap Moss flat before sticking a Rey Mysterio mask on Madcap and making it clear who's next. It was nice to see Scarlett out there in-ring (even for a squash), and Kross is showing some nice intensity since wrapping up his feud with Drew McIntyre.

There's more to come from this lad. Way more.

One possible downside to this equation is that Moss has tumbled hard over the past six months or so. Still, he played his role well here, and somebody has to be sacrificial lamb so heels like Karrion can continue their march towards eventual main events. This was fine for what it was.

The mask business post-match also gave everyone something to hang their hats on creatively. Rey can return, apologise to Madcap for having to go through that and put him over as a young up-and-comer. Then, Kross can blindside him and things can move on from there.


3. Predictably Awesome

The Usos Sheamus
WWE.com

Everyone knew that The Usos vs. Drew McIntyre and Sheamus would hit the heights, and it did. Was there any real threat of Jimmy and Jey losing their belts? Hmm, kinda'. More so than usual, anyway. Sheamus surviving the 1D was a mega-moment, and the faces are big-enough stars that it was always in the back of fan minds.

The Bloodline has started to show serious cracks, don't forget.

It wouldn't have been inconceivable for WWE to heap further misery on the group following last week's egg-on-face loss for Roman and Sami to John Cena and KO. Everything about this tag soared in front of a hot live crowd, but that's no surprise given the sheer depth of star quality on hand to work it.

The Usos keep on delivering whenever they're involved, and this could easily have taken place on pay-per-view. Christ, it was so good that yours truly wouldn't be against a rematch at Royal Rumble. Why not? Opening the show with something this tasty sounds like a hoot.


2. Roman Reigns Barks At Sami Zayn

Roman Reigns Sami Zayn Bloodline
WWE.com

This was a standout moment for sure.

Roman eventually lost his cool and roared at Zayn during the opening segment. He wanted to know why Sami had lost to Cena and Owens last week (refusing to take any of the blame himself for what happened), and then asked why Zayn is running around trying to be him when he should be focusing on Bloodline business.

Special mention must go to Paul Heyman's facial expressions in the background - they were masterful, and the way WWE's cameras faded in and out of focus on the manager when it mattered was sensational production. Also, the entire Bloodline subtly moved away from Sami when Roman was shouting at him, which was awesome.

We're into 2023 now and this group is still wrestling's greatest gift. If WWE can keep this ticking over the next few weeks and find a way to convince people that Zayn could cost Reigns come the Rumble, then they'll take things up yet another notch.


1. The Remorseful ‘Tribal Chief’

Roman Reigns Sami Zayn Paul Heyman Popcorn
WWE

Manipulation has been one of the strongest qualities to Roman's character since he started this unmatched 'Tribal Chief' run. The way he snapped at Sami Zayn publicly then apologised for losing his cool privately doesn't show weakness. It shows off that manipulative streak nicely.

By forcing the visibly uncomfortable Zayn to sit and watch SmackDown's main event with him when Sami would literally be anywhere else, Reigns exhibited the most dominant aspects of his gimmick. By the end, he'd lowered Zayn's guard (keep that in mind when the inevitable Bloodline beating comes) enough that ol' Sam Zayn was throwing popcorn around the room.

There's so much depth to this story.

No-one should be this entertaining just sitting backstage watching a match, but that speaks to the realism of Roman, Sami and Paul Heyman as human beings. They aren't just pro wrestling characters - they're relatable people just turned all the way up to 11.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE Raw From 2003 and 10 Things Everybody Hates About AMAZING Wrestling Matches!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.