5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Collision (11 May - Results & Review)

Dynamite Kid lands in AEW; Adam Copeland gets evil; Swerve Strickland gets revenge.

Bryan Danielson
AEW

Did you know: Bryan Danielson loves AEW?

The BCC man cut an impassioned promo after delivering the goods on Collision. Covered in welts and standing alone mid-ring after Claudio Castagnoli weirdly scarpered, Bryan put over Tony Khan's company like Adam Copeland before him. Bog standard PR? Maybe, but Danielson was also there to sell the upcoming 'Anarchy In The Arena' bout at Double Or Nothing.

AEW says their programming is where the best wrestle. Fans will debate that endlessly, but it's definitely hard to argue with some of the quality on display during Collision. Following up on that has always been problematic for Khan, but he can proud of performances from folks like Bryan, Claudio, Top Flight, Dax Harwood, the debuting Dynamite Kid, Adam Copeland and Kyle O'Reilly.

Saturday was a special evening for O'Reilly, and he shone in a gruelling main event opposite the former Edge. Not everything was perfect though - some usual ad break formatting wrecked parts of the broadcast, and there was a painful lull here or there which threatened to kill the otherwise rowdy live crowd in Vancouver.

Here's all the good and bad from the latest episode of AEW's 'B' show.


Downs...

4. “Claudio Certainly Has A Reason For Revenge”

AEW Collision
AEW

AEW dug up footage from December 2022 to explain why Bryan Danielson and Claudio Castagnoli vs. Top Flight was booked for this week's Collision. Fair enough, and fair play to those in-house for remembering a random Rampage Battle Royal even happened, but...was it actually necessary? As in, did the tag need context this flimsy?

Look, trying to justify matches and make them seem less random/one-off is fine, but the idea that Claudio waited approx a year and a half to "get revenge" is a bit much. Behave! Tony Khan really wants people to believe that Castagnoli sat on a Rampage loss everyone forgot 10 minutes after it happened?!

Yikes.

Here's the problem: That isn't actually proper storytelling at all. No, it highlights a flaw in AEW booking that has turned some away. Basically, an awful lot of their content happens for the sake of it and never leads to much. Choosing to draw attention to that here was a puzzling choice.


3. Really Poor Time To Go Pic-In-Pic

AEW Collision Picture-In-Picture
AEW

The timing on these ad breaks is legit rubbish.

All Elite went to picture-in-picture right after Will Ospreay hit a dive on Lee Moriarty and pointed at Roderick Strong behind the commentary desk. Of course, going to ads meant fans watching missed the entire verbal exchange between two guys who are wrestling on the next pay-per-view. Awkward.

It would've been lovely to hear what Ospreay and Strong were bickering about, but the tiny box on the right hand side of the screen was muted whilst Jon Moxley yakked on about being tough. This is another issue with AEW's presentation - they spend lots of time telling you what's next instead of focusing on what's in front of you in the moment.

That makes it harder for segments to feel important, which is a damn shame when Ospreay is one of the biggest new-hires in the company and somebody who will probs be headlining PPVs sooner rather than later. Tony needs to sort out this crappy timing, and quickly.


2. More Rampage Than They’d Care To Admit

Thunder Rosa Robyn Renegade
AEW

Thunder Rosa vs. Robyn Renegade was perhaps the most brutal lull on Collision. It wasn't needed, and came out looking like something that'd be more at home on Rampage most weeks. When the 'C' show is in its usual Friday night slot, that is. It was part of a three-hour block next to Collision on Saturday.

The live crowd, who had been hot all night for literally everything else, died a death early on during the match and never really came back. Thunder is a live wire for sure, but even AEW's most hardcore fans struggle to care about bouts against workers (Renegade) who have never been portrayed as a true threat or all that important.

Again, this match didn't need to be on the card.

It was around seven minutes of wrestling for the sake of it. Sure, one could say that about a lot of the other matches on this show, but at least they were entertaining and/or had some sort of follow-on promo to help make them watchable. Not so for Rosa vs. Robyn, sadly.


1. The Squash Nobody Needed

Daniel Garcia
AEW

Why was this booked?

Genuinely baffled as to what Daniel Garcia beating KM in around two minutes was supposed to achieve. Seeing Danny tear down a much bigger opponent this way doesn't even work for an underdog character like him. Also, the clash was part of a back-to-back squash match double act, which was downright poor.

Whilst true there was a crucial angle sandwiched in between them, yeah...AEW booked two squash bouts in a row on Collision, and that was bad planning. Matt Menard gamely tried to explain that Garcia was finally showing a selfish streak by being ruthless, but he was fighting a losing battle on guest commentary there.

Finally, screw that moron who ran into the ring before being tackled by security. All Elite's cameras caught a glimpse of that, but swiftly cut away to Garcia talking some smack at the foot of the entrance ramp. Sorry, but any wrestling "fan" who rushes the ring mid-show is an idiot and deserves zero sympathy.


Ups...

5. Hell Of A Surprise Package

Will Ospreay Lee Moriarty Roderick Strong
AEW

OK, so Ospreay vs. Moriarty was waaaaaaay better than this guy was expecting going in. Truthfully, there was some eye rolling in this household when the match was announced, because it seemed like Will would gobble Lee up in 3-4 minutes. Honestly, yours truly should've known better, because Ospreay isn't that kind of worker.

He prefers to work, work, work and try to make the best of every scenario.

So, the actual match was a surprise package, but that's only half the story. Roderick Strong joined commentary and pointed out Will's hesitation to hit the Tiger Driver '91. Hesitate like that at Double Or Nothing, Roddy said, and Ospreay would be in trouble during their International Title showdown.

Some wrestlers are obnoxious to the extreme on guest comms but offer no insight or story context. Strong nailed it, and Ospreay won using a Stormbreaker instead of the Tiger Driver to prove a point pre-PPV. Stunning attention to detail from everyone involved.


4. Fun Tag-Team Opener

Claudio Castagnoli Top Flight
AEW

Every wrestling promotion worth paying attention to knows the value of a hot tag-team opener. That works whether you're some local fed running shows in front of 50 fans or a worldwide powerhouse like WWE. People respond to zippy, well-worked tag wrestling. They always have and they always will.

Claudio and Bryan vs. Top Flight was a good time then.

Everyone tuning in knew the BCC lads would give Darius and Dante Martin plenty, and they did (including a few delicious near falls). Castagnoli and Danielson are comfy in their own skins, so they never get insecure or precious about giving opponents a lot during matches. That generous mentality makes their matches superior every time.

Top Flight have always shown potential, but it'd be sweet if they had actual characters to develop beyond the 'we're happy-go-lucky high flyers' thing. Still, they must've enjoyed tangling with world class grapplers like Claudio and Bryan here. The match was certainly a cracking watch!


3. Dynamite First Impression

Dynamite Kid Tommy Billington AEW
AEW

Speaking of cracking little matches.

What a debut showing that was from 'Dynamite Kid' Tommy Billington. Young Tommy has paid tribute to his legendary uncle by carrying on the Dynamite name, and the original would've been well proud of his nephew's efforts on AEW TV this week. Billington looked like he'd been part of All Elite's roster for years.

The dude writing this piece was lucky enough to commentate some of Tommy's formative matches on the indy scene, and it was clear he always had something about him even as a teenager. Of course, his great performance on Saturday will only count if AEW follows up on it - they rarely do, which is a pity.

Dynamite got a nice reception from fans and showed up well against Dax Harwood. Tony Khan would be doing himself a favour by following up on these good first impressions more than he does. Should he sign Billington then sit him in catering? No. Should he sign him then develop him on ROH or on shows like Rampage? Yes, but there has to be a game plan and career trajectory.


2. A Canadian Battle Doesn’t Disappoint

Adam Copeland Kyle O'Reilly
AEW

The first half of Adam Copeland vs. Kyle O'Reilly arguably sagged a bit, but the match maybe needed that opening "feeling out process" to make the second act even better. Vancouver's wrestling masses were firmly behind hometown boy O'Reilly from the off, and that raised a wry smile from Copeland once he realised he'd have to be a bit more villainous than usual.

Typically, the ex-Edge met that challenge head on.

Fans bit on O'Reilly reversing a spear attempt into his guillotine choke, but then Copeland retained the TNT Title after finally landing his go-to finish. Adam socking Kyle in the gut several times and O'Reilly's distressed selling post-match could lead to something story-wise. Keep an eye on that.

Stellar in-ring work from start to finish here. If they did have a slightly different layout planned going in before Vancouver rallied behind Kyle, then credit to both men for pivoting and working the match that live crowd wanted to see. Such adaptability is welcome in an era of rushed spots and cramming everything in.


1. Swerve Gets Some Revenge

Swerve Strickland
AEW

Brian Cage will never win 'Promo Of The Year', but he did well with his speech justifying The Mogul Embassy's attack on old leader Swerve Strickland during Dynamite midweek. On Collision, Cage said that Swerve ditched the group until he suddenly needed them to even the odds against Christian Cage and pals.

That was logical, and so was Strickland rushing out to ambush Cage and The Gates Of Agony as revenge. The bloodlust of Swerve is something that's never gone away even mid-babyface turn, and that's worth mentioning; he might be baby rather than heel, but Strickland hasn't magically turned over a new leaf. He's still vicious.

Now, a match vs. Cage should keep the champ busy heading into his bout with Cage at DoN. Collision presumably won't be the last time anyone sees Swerve kick the ever living sh*t out of his old Embassy during the road to that pay-per-view. More cinder block action incoming.

For now, it was fab to see the champion in an intense angle on Saturday.

What did you think of this week's AEW Collision? For more wrestling, check out 10 Secret Wrestling Retcons You DEFINITELY Don't Remember and 10 Things That’d RUIN WWE’s 2024!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.