5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (April 24 - Results & Review)

Tony Khan crosses the final frontier on the same night he books a baffling, divisive show.

25 4 Willow Nightingale
AEW

The line-up looked strong, the vibes in Daily's Place are always lush. The ugly LED barricades threatened to diminish the iconic aesthetic, but there's something about the unique architecture of AEW's spiritual home and the open air environment that captures the freedom of expression and unique creative vision at the heart of the promotion.

Jon Moxley was set to defend his IWGP World Heavyweight title against Powerhouse Hobbs. A fondly-remembered and wickedly brutal giant-slaying was promoted in the very same venue in 2020. That was the template.

New AEW World champion Swerve Strickland, meanwhile, was set to wrestle Kyle Fletcher in an Eliminator. This was basic, yes - a predictable reminder that AEW is "Where The Best Wrestle" - but on week one, well before the next pay-per-view cycle, a bit of acclaim wasn't going to do him any harm. Did the match generate it?

Chris Jericho was scheduled to appear in a live segment. The best he could hope for was a callous rejection loud enough for it to be perversely entertaining. How sad.

The best episodes of US cable TV deliver a trifecta of matches, angles and promos. As daft as it seemed, a segment in which Chuck Taylor had to pick his best friend between Orange Cassidy and Trent did promise some affecting drama. The Best Friends stable often deliver memorable moments at the checkpoints of their big programmes.

AEW almost always produces seminal pay-per-views. The TV has felt lacking in recent weeks.

Did last night reverse the trend...?


Downs...

4. Chris Jericho Continues To Be Unwanted

25 4 Chris Jericho
AEW

Chris Jericho did his faux-sincere heel gimmick in a promo segment. Few people cared. The loud irony of the Dynasty hijack appears to be an aberration; ultimately, this hack stuff is too dull to give too much of a toss about either way.

Jericho had one genuinely great idea in his promo, you can't not give him that. His insistence that he's carrying on the legacy of Terry Funk - when the meta heat is that Jericho has never felt less relevant, beloved, or helpful - was really well measured. That was all ruined when Big Bill, former AEW World Tag Team champion - with robotic delivery that indicated he didn't fully buy into the pitch - asked Jericho to mentor him. Does being a former World champion mean nothing?

Bill felt like a green geek fresh out of developmental, a beggar difficult to take seriously. Jericho only entertained the idea of taking him under his wing, too. How low on the totem pole do you have to be for Jericho to hesitate?!

He was aligned with Jake Hager for three years! Bill is three times the hoss Hager is, and even if that's subjective, Bill is more successful in AEW's storyline canon.

He might as well have been consigned to Rampage throughout his entire run for how he was framed last night.


3. Bad First Night For The New AEW World Champion

25 4 Swerve Strickland
AEW

The presentation of Swerve Strickland was baffling and counterproductive. His first night as the supposed new Ace was indistinguishable to that of a babyface TNT champion.

As you'll read later, AEW's booking is inspired at its detail-oriented best. Tony Khan can add a very thoughtful layer to a character arc, like Will Ospreay's later in the show. He's also prone to scoring the daftest own goals and failing to adhere to the basics. It's infuriating: like watching a flair player with no end product. Swerve didn't open the show with a statement of intent nor enjoy a celebration.

Instead, he simply entered Daily's Place and wrestled a 50/50 match in which he, like virtually every pushed star on TV, gave his opponent too much. Even if the match were excellent, it would have scanned as a midcard presentation. It wasn't. For a lot of the run-time, it was a late 2010s super-indie movez match.

Swerve really did look like he'd damaged his ankle when driving Kyle Fletcher to the ring apron with the Swerve stomp. It looked like a spot gone awry until Fletcher rushed into an ankle lock. Beyond this one moment of impressive craft, this was a dull start to Swerve's reign - and Swerve really didn't need to allow Fletcher to kick out of the Stomp at this stage.

The fighting champion who wins hard-fought matches, already a bit one-dimensional, won't work when there's a hundred titles and most Dynamite matches strive for great.


2. A Big Disappointment

25 4 Swerve Strickland
AEW

Jon Moxley Vs. Powerhouse Hobbs was flat.

It told a logical enough story, but there was zero tension, suspense, or ultra-violent energy. Mox should have wrestled from underneath as a bloody mess struggling to survive against a bad and mean monster. The sense of peril should have felt alarming. And then, much like he did against Mr. Brodie Lee, Mox should have unleashed a frantic, relentless ass-kicking at the finish, putting across the idea that he had to burn through 100% of his stamina in one burst, otherwise he was doomed.

This shouldn't have resembled an outright copy of the Double Or Nothing 2020 semi-main, but the energy of that much really should have been harnessed here. None of that happened and really, very little did.

This was a slow and frankly dull dissection of match, one that Mox won, in an anticlimactic finish with no drama, after trapping Powerhouse in the Bulldog choke. Hobbs looked to have suffered a real injury - and best wishes to him if so - but the match wasn't trending in a strong direction regardless.

A real disappointment.


1. What?

25 4 Jack Perry
AEW

Where to start with one of the most unhinged and unexpected angles in AEW history?

If you somehow missed it: The Elite entered the building at the very beginning of the broadcast, and in a show-long storyline, attempted to negotiate the return of Jack Perry with Tony Khan. An in-ring meeting was set for the main event segment. In it, after Perry and Khan reconciled with a hug, Perry struck Khan in the chest. Khan's bump was too funny and the very idea was too crazed for it to feel like a proper transgression. After feigning to help Tony up, the Young Bucks - as Kazuchika Okada did a very funny point - blasted him with, and this was a very cute easter egg in retrospect, the Tony Khan Driver.

Ultimately, this was too silly. Khan was bad here, only remembering to clutch at his stomach after an amateurish pause. The execution of an idea that will take some explanation to work was so-bad-it's-good.

CM Punk was terminated with cause for - as it appeared during the screening of the Wembley footage a few weeks back - motioning aggressively in Khan's direction. Will Perry and the Bucks get fired for actually striking Khan and actively attempting to damage his neck?

This is the problem: the angle collided drastically with real-life precedent, and AEW is a promotion that seeks to exist in the real world. Say, in the follow-up, that it is written in Matthew and Nicholas Jackson's contracts that they must succeed Khan on a temporary basis in the event that he is unable to fulfil his duties. Khan is on record confirming that Bryan Danielson would succeed him.

This feels for now like yet another mistake in a long series of them. Between the introduction of too many titles, a fourth and fifth hour of TV that has lessened AEW's premium appeal, and an expanded PPV schedule, Khan has made the same errors that every 21st century promoter has made en route to the downfall. Now, the big story in AEW is a heel authority figure gimmick.

Ultimately, this just reeked of a Fake Wrestling Angle, no matter how fascinating it undeniably was.


Ups...

5. Weird Timing, Decent Development

25 4 Best Friends
AEW

Last night's Dynamite was a baffling experience. The sequencing of the show and the content on it was just off in several different ways.

It began in earnest when Orange Cassidy was filmed limping onto the stage, the victim of a Trent sneak attack backstage. A Dynamite that doesn't start with a strong match is still strange enough, five years in, but launching the show with a midcard angle - and subsequently presenting the new World champion as a midcard act - was so weird and distracting.

This would have played far better had it all unfolded around the 40 minute mark. The gist is that Trent demanded Chuck Taylor emerge from the back and make a decision: who is his best friend?

In a good line, Trent said that Orange, a "narcissist pr*ck", was brought into be Trent's mascot, but he became Cassidy's lackey. In a fun and unexpected twist that built towards a Trent Vs. Chuck Taylor Parking Lot Fight - a really cool potential sequel, and one of those ideas so good you can't believe you didn't think of it sooner - Chuck called Taylor a "piece of sh*t".

Really odd way to start the show, but a neat way of advancing the programme.


4. A Problem Is Addressed...Sort Of

25 4 Will Ospeay
AEW

Will Ospreay's entry into the International title picture is difficult to unpack.

He is the most over wrestler in the company. He is the World champion-elect; the only question is when. The International title is beneath the wrestler and indeed the character: it makes little sense for him to defeat Bryan Danielson in a match framed as a meeting between the two best wrestlers alive - at a minimum! - if it doesn't double as a match fought to determine the #1 contender. Ospreay winning the Casino Gauntlet match was an inelegant solution to a problem that has been articulated in these Dynamite reviews since Revolution: Swerve can't be the guy as long as Ospreay is hunting him. This move - again, inelegant, open to scrutiny - is inspired.

The chase is the greatest thrill in pro wrestling. AEW just elongated Will Ospreay's inevitable coronation as the man. It feels less like Tony Khan's trademark dallying - he can't be accused of withholding matches after Ospreay's last two PPV outings - and more like a concerted effort to extract the maximum value from a long-term investment. Ospreay is still only 30 and is All Elite for several years. Moreover, if it's even this simple, Ospreay's detour should allow Swerve to map out a title reign without Ospreay's inevitable shadow looming. Swerve's run can now be appraised on its own merits. There's no Wembley end date - right now - to wait for.

Swerve might still be outclassed, but he's no longer on a countdown, and feels less like AEW's second consecutive transitional champion.


3. A Really Good Women's Segment

25 4 Willow Nightingale
AEW

Willow Nightingale is great, deserves a celebration more than most, and was great even when she technically wasn't throughout her big moment.

She was as inordinately endearing as ever when talking herself up as the new face of TBS. Then, she was again interrupted by Mercedes Moné. The commentary team once more laboured over the idea that she is displaying poor form by refusing to let Willow have her moment. Willow responded to Moné by talking to the ringside camera operator half the time. That was the technically not great bit - this really needed an intense, focused face-to-face - but Willow being a bit awkward is part of the charm. She never feels remotely synthetic.

The problem, all along, was that the dynamic is too blurred. Moné is a star that you want to see make a difference and win, but Willow is too likeable. Here, for the first time, with dialogue and delivery that didn't feel robotic, Moné and Willow explored the emotional ramifications of their fateful meeting in NJPW. Moné couldn't look past the searing pain she felt for months and the real terror that her career might have ended as a result of the ankle injury; Willow said that she hasn't felt like a good person since even if wasn't her intention.

It could still be cleaner, all this - and is this continuity really more important than a less divisive and pure fictional story? - but for once, it was at least emotionally affecting.


2. A Second Really Good Women's Segment

Mina Shirakawa
AEW

Anna Jay, much too young for the spot but there aren't too many others, did an effective, commendable job of showcasing Mina Shirakawa, who has vast potential as a star. Sultry and stiff, she exudes a domineering arrogance that should prove to be a great contrast when Toni Storm completes her "You love me, you really love me" babyface turn.

Shirakawa smacked Jay in the face after the longest-feeling ad break of the night - again! - and impressed a mostly subdued Daily's Place with her creative strikes. Jay floated over a Glamour driver attempt to lock in the Queenslayer in a lively strategic sequence - one thartdeserved a more protracted submission tease - but ultimately succumbed to it. Solid, lean, nothing great - but the match achieved its objective of elevating Mira and establishing her as somebody the obsessive May can idolise and Strom can fret over.

Through the lens of what the long-term storyline is striving to achieve - the break-up of Storm and May after May's torrid affair - this was especially impressive. It couldn't have been a dud, otherwise Storm looks threatened by nobody.

In the post-match, after Storm saved May from Anna Jay's post-match attack, Serena Deeb emerged to challenge for the Women's title. Now that Storm has dropped the strange, unnecessary idea to wrestle as a pure gimmick, that is set to be an outstanding encounter.

This was a really good night for the AEW women's division.


1. Will Ospreay Highlights Best Match Of The Show

25 4 Will Ospreay II
AEW

The Casino Gauntlet match was the in-ring highlight of the show despite the usual contrivance. What if somebody simply...won within five minutes before each scheduled wrestler filtered to the ring?

The Casino ladder match is dumber than this, because at least in the Gauntlet, nobody was announced. It was much easier to buy the false finishes. Jay White was fantastic here. He initiated it with Penta El Zero Miedo, and, knowing that a horde was set to fill the ring and take the shot, that first sequence was urgent and thrilling, worked like sudden death. The match took on a Royal Rumble-style layout as more wrestlers entered and worked a sequence with whomever held the advantage at that given moment. Not to seem like a bad faith and idiotic concern troll, but the rules and the gist could have been better explained. Even the commentary team seemed nonplussed by how this new, unadvertised type of match was meant to function.

In terms of action and nothing else, this actually smoked anything from January, with the exception of the incredibly suspenseful final show-down between CM Punk and Cody Rhodes. Jay White was the ideal choice to enter first and thread the match. His demeanour and ring IQ positioned him as the ideal scavenger. Lance Archer was fun as the ass-kicking difference-maker - Will Ospreay took a terrifying header to the outside when taking an awesome variation of the Blackout - and Komander crafted a Holy Shit moment by unexpectedly taking Archer out with a hurricanrana through a ringside table. The idea to use the surgically-repaired Kyle O'Reilly as the wrestler on whom Ospreay was reluctant to use the Tiger Driver '91 was the sort of clever extra detail that epitomises peak AEW.

Ospreay won by pinning Komander following a fantastic white-knuckle sequence. Ospreay was a supernaturally great base. When he took a hurricanrana, he basically headbutted the canvas at 90mph and flipped over faster than a click of the fingers. That is barely hyperbole. The man is not human. This match, as thoughtful as it was exciting, highlighted a show that nobody will ever agree on.

That's just what AEW needs after almost two years of constant debate.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!