5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Raw (30 Dec - Results & Review)

Women's IC tourney closes strong, Rollins and Punk go full insider, New Day booed mercilessly.

CM Punk Seth Rollins
WWE

And that’s a wrap for WWE Raw on cable television.

Next week’s program undoubtedly will look different, whether that’s simply new visuals or a new format. But for this week, WWE went out with a hot audience that elevated an above-average December episode.

Raw Monday night was powered by the strength of its two Women’s Intercontinental Championship tournament semifinal matches and a main event promo battle between CM Punk and Seth Rollins ahead of their much-anticipated match next week. There were plenty of things to enjoy about Monday’s program, which zipped by, but it also had a few things dragging it down.

Punk and Rollins had a heated exchange that kept the temperature up on their rivalry, but it also was chock-full of insider references that can be a turnoff to a lot of fans. While once upon a time that sort of thing was fun and shocking, in 2024 it feels like a try-hard. Still, their feud is ripe for a hot one-on-one bout next week.

The two women’s matches pitting Dakota Kai against Zoey Stark and Iyo Sky versus Lyra Valkyria were the high points of the night in the ring, with Iyo and Lyra being a fantastic exchange that deserves a rewatch. If WWE is doing New Year’s resolutions, they should commit to more women’s matches like that in 2025.

Less Finn Balor/Damian Priest, R-Truth/Pete Dunne, and American Made/Alpha Academy. Leave all of them in 2024.

Let’s get to it…


DOWNS…

4. Quick Doesn’t Mean Painless

Pete Dunne R Truth
WWE

“Let’s light this Butch up!”

With that, R-Truth continued one of the dumbest, unfunniest feuds in WWE today, as he once again referred to Pete Dunne by his former moniker, which triggered the Bruiserweight to rush from the back and jump Truth in the aisle, mercifully cancelling their match.

This heatless rivalry has been going on for what seems like forever but likely has only been two months (Truth beat Dunne in less than two minutes four weeks ago), and it centers on Truth – whose entire gimmick these days seems to be the living embodiment of CTE – being unable to stop messing up and calling Dunne “Butch” despite Pete repeatedly threatening the hapless superstar.

The idea is that Dunne is so enraged by Truth’s mix-ups that he can’t control himself, but he’s also so flustered that he’s unable to actually stop Truth. And that’s about it. There’s no story beyond that, no endgame hinted, and no reason why Dunne hasn’t just wiped Truth off the face of the roster. It’s comedy without the humor, and the fact it was even booked as a match Monday night was ridiculous.

If WWE insists on putting this in the ring again, have Dunne end it, or let Truth win and send Pete packing to SmackDown to start over. But can this not carry over into 2025?


3. Another Week, Another Priest/Finn Confrontation

Damian Priest
WWE

Sometimes, there are heated rivalries that are so electric that they can carry on week after week with no end in sight, and fans will never tire of them.

And then there’s Damian Priest and Finn Balor.

Priest has settled into a solid role as an upper-mid-card babyface, but we’re now five months into this ongoing feud between him and former stablemate Balor, with no end in sight. They’ve fought and Damian has decisively won, but Finn and his Judgment Day cohorts continue to attack the former world champion on an almost weekly basis.

Monday, Priest grabbed backup in the form of the new World Tag Team Champions the War Raiders to take on Judgment Day, and the six men delivered a solid, if unspectacular, match. After Priest picked up the victory, he immediately was jumped by Balor until Erik and Ivar could make the save.

So once again, the feud must continue. Can we please get a blowoff match and move on?


2. They’re Going To Do It, Aren’t They?

New Day Rey Mysterio
WWE

Rey Mysterio’s burgeoning feud with the New Day has a lot of potential. As newly minted heels, New Day needs a universally loved babyface to play off to ensure maximum negativity, and who better than the Hall-of-Famer?

Monday, Rey tangled with Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods backstage, with Mysterio saying that as a locker room leader, he needs to step up and put big egos in their place. He challenged New Day to a tag match next week.

And that’s where things veered into icky territory.

Woods asked which of the other “Rey Mysterio cosplaying cronies” in the LWO would team with Rey, but no confirmation was given. That leaves the door wide open to have Penta debut next week as a mystery partner. If that’s the case, this “down” is justified, even if his debut is overall successful in fans’ eyes.

First, bringing Penta in and immediately sticking him with the LWO is lazy booking at its finest. “Hey, we’re bringing in a masked luchador, let’s stick him with the stable full of luchadores!” Secondly, the LWO has three other, able-bodied members who could team with Rey, all of whom would make solid partners. Even in storyline, why sideline them for a new guy? If you’re Dragon Lee, wouldn’t you be resentful of Mysterio bringing in someone new for a high-profile match rather than enlisting your help?

If WWE doesn’t pull the trigger during the match and goes with Dragon Lee (and perhaps Penta is backup afterward), then this is less of a negative. But it still would be a bit of typecasting to bring Penta in and immediately insert him into the LWO, a stable that seemingly can’t find screentime for its existing members.


1. Insider References Galore

Seth Rollins and CM Punk
WWE

There are always two minds when it comes to a wrestling promo that relies on a ton of insider references to generate heat.

On one hand, it rarely fails to elicit huge reactions from fans in the know and spark a lot of online discourse. However, it also is a navel-gazing crutch that requires fans to break out a character bible to understand everything. If you’re using these references sparingly, that’s one thing, but if it’s a firehose of comments, you’ve gone too far.

Monday’s show-closing confrontation between Seth Rollins and CM Punk was a nonstop barrage of callbacks and veiled comments, with Punk obliquely referring to Vince McMahon as he called out Rollins’ use of “took his ball and went home” and remarked that he loved WWE but hated the guy running the company when he left 10 years ago. Seth dropped references to Colt Cabana and AEW in trashing Punk, while Punk used arrows as an analogy throughout his verbal comeback.

Fans who love this sort of thing were clearly enjoying it, but it also wasn’t necessary to sell the match. The feud already was red-hot heading into next week – all they needed to do was land the plane Monday night. They succeeded, but this was an excessive amount of insider crap for the sake of it.


UPS…

5. Exorcising The Demons

Otis Chad Gable
WWE

The truth is that the American Made/Alpha Academy feud should have ended months ago, serving as the launching pad for Chad Gable’s new heel stable.

Instead, the hope at this late stage in 2024 is that Monday’s match between Gable and Otis served as a soft reboot for American Made, finally putting the rivalry between the jocks and the comedy troupe to rest and allowing the Star-Spangled group to begin 2025 with a clean slate.

Gable continuously attacked his larger opponent’s leg, targeting it with a Dragon Screw and locking in an anklelock a few times to soften up the limb. Naturally, Otis made the comeback and overcame interference from the Creed Brothers a few times before finally succumbing to an anklelock and tapping out.

If this truly marks the end of this and a fresh start for American Made, then this “up” is warranted. But if the feud must continue, then this was wishful thinking, and it’s just back to wasted potential.


4. A Compact Battle

Dakota Kai Zoey Stark
WWE

Had the Women’s Intercontinental Championship tournament been full of short, tight, competitive matches like Monday night’s bout between Zoey Stark and Dakota Kai, it might have been better received overall.

Stark and Kai had a no-filler match on Raw, eschewing chinlocks and breathers to focus on constant action. Dakota hit a pump kick at the bell and they traded corner whips before Kai hit a monkey flip on Stark – only for Zoey to land on her feet. They fought on the apron, traded bombs and went for their knockout blows, with Kai hitting a flipping backcracker and Stark nailing a suplex and powerdrive knee.

The finish saw Dakota counter a powerbomb with a Code Red, and then Stark hit a rolling Death Valley Driver, leading to Zoey going for a springboard dropkick… and getting cut off with a superkick. Kai hit the Go-To-Kick for the win, advancing to the finals.

The match wasn’t a technical masterpiece or even something that will make a “best of” list, but it was all action, had the crowd reacting to flurry of offense, and it produced a nice moment for Kai, who has suffered through a series of injuries and struggled to actually create a bit of momentum for herself.


3. The Other Side Of Punk, Rollins

CM Punk Seth Rollins 2
WWE

Insider references aside, CM Punk and Seth Rollins closed out the last Raw on cable television with a fiery promo battle where they did their level best to sell their hatred as a long-simmering stew that boiled over when Punk returned to WWE last year.

Whether unwittingly or not, Rollins gave credence to Punk’s contention that Seth is a corporate bootlicker: Rollins kept talking about how Punk abandoned WWE (and wanted the place to die), but Seth stayed out of loyalty to fight in the trenches to improve the company. However, Rollins did get a good dig in as he bluntly called Punk a cancer to the company and the industry itself, and he vowed to cut it out next week.

Punk used arrows as a stand-in for the attacks he sustained during his waning days with WWE in 2014, talking about how he had to get far away from the company so he could pull them out, and now he was coming back with the arrows in tow to shove them down Rollins’ throat.

While the wild, all-over-the-arena brawl was a hotter selling point for the feud, Monday’s promo was fine at maintaining the heat and adding a final wrinkle or two to the mix.


2. ‘Boo! Yeet!’

The New Day Jey Uso
WWE

WWE’s carefully curated attempts to get the New Day maximum heel heat continued Monday night with a bit of sweetener and a pretty cagey pairing.

Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods opened Raw with deafening boos, some originating from the crowd, some piped in through the speakers. However, it was clear that no one was cheering on the longtime fan favorites, and the jeers got louder as Kofi and Xavier kept trying to speak. (In another nice touch, Kingston yelled for the production truck to turn off the New Day’s old entrance music, signaling that the duo is heading for an image makeover.)

Then the brilliance kicked in. If you’re going to try to train the audience to boo the New Day mercilessly, why not bring out the guy who gets the biggest babyface reaction on the roster? Jey Uso came out to yeet with the crowd, providing a clear contrast between himself and the odious New Day. It didn’t hurt that Jey quickly turned on his former friends and informed them – and the fans – that New Day sucks.

With that, Kofi and Xavier left. It was a simple, yet effective measure to continue the audience training and further establish New Day as a heel act without revealing new theme music or gear, or even having Kingston and Woods do much else beyond show up and try to speak.

The training wheels are going to need to come off really soon though, as they’re treading water and there’s going to be diminishing returns on this shtick before too long.


1. Blowing The Doors Off The Arena

Iyo Sky Lyra Valkyria
WWE

Iyo Sky versus Lyra Valkyria should serve as a template for what WWE women’s wrestling in 2025 can be if the powers that be invest and fully commit to it.

The two wrestlers delivered a fantastic Women’s Intercontinental Championship semifinal match Monday night, with Sky fighting from underneath after tweaking her knee early on and Lyra targeting it constantly throughout. The two continuously countered each other with liquid wrestling and pounded the other with high-octane offense.

At one point, Valkyria backflipped out of the corner and massacred Iyo with a shotgun dropkick back into the corner, then spiked her with a tornado DDT and held on to hit a suplex for a two count. Not to be outdone, Sky hit a victory roll variant off the top rope, followed by a moonsault to the floor, and a Bullet Train before missing the Over-the-Moonsault, which allowed Lyra to pick up the win after a series of rollup reversals.

Honestly, that’s not doing this match justice. It was a great match and a perfect way to wind down this IC title tournament. Fans should make a point to watch this bout back.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.