5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Raw (Oct 24)
Uneven episode doesn't click well with distraction finishes, bland stories.
It’s tough to put a finger on it, but even though this week’s episode of WWE Raw scored some decent positives, this was not a very good program.
If your name was Johnny Gargano, it was a particularly disappointing episode. Raw just could not get out of the blocks Monday night, with a program that lacked compelling storytelling, good in-ring action and true star power. It felt like the show just limped along to the finish with a few peaks to the valleys.
The difficulty here is that Raw under the new regime is better at masking the negatives, so whereas before you could easily point to hugely disappointing moments, it’s a vibe thing now, a feeling you get after watching an hour and trying to recap what you experienced. You can pick a few things, but specifics are tough.
The wrestling isn’t bad, but it’s not memorable from week to week, plus they’ve gotten lazy with the finishes almost all involving distractions or interference. The stories aren’t ludicrously bad, but you aren’t seeing a late contender for feud of the year either.
Of course, there’s always next week for all of this, but this is definitely a “watch the YouTube videos and read a recap” week.
Let’s get to it…
Downs…
4. Johnny Wrestling Forgets His Name
Just in case you thought everyone who was an NXT darling in the Triple H era was going to shine as brightly as they did then now, we bring you Exhibit A, Johnny Gargano.
We’ll have more to say about Gargano in a bit, but let’s focus on one specific issue from Monday. A guy who goes by the moniker Johnny Wrestling decided mid-match to stop, climb on top of the announce desk, put on JBL’s Stetson and do a mocking dance like a cowboy. Worse, when it worked out ok for him, he elected to keep it on and try to hit another move on Baron Corbin, when Bradshaw interfered and tripped him up, directly leading to a loss.
Gargano went completely out of character to goof around with JBL and looked like a geek. It didn’t help that the outcome seemed obvious with a newly recast Corbin in the beginning of another renewed push, so it wasn’t like you thought it was going to work out well for Johnny.
That was a true groan-inducing moment if there ever was one.
3. Riddle’s An Idiot Again
When the new regime took over, one of the immediate beneficiaries was Matt Riddle, who regained his first name and almost immediately started to be treated like a serious competitor instead of a goofy stoner.
Things went so well during August and September that you started to think that maybe Riddle was being positioned as a top-level face, someone who could contend for a top title.
Then the last two weeks happened, and Riddle is once again making bad stoner jokes (“bongos” sounds like “bong,” so let’s have him confuse the two!) and annoying people backstage, with Elias being the current target.
It’s not as big of a panic moment because the new regime has proved they can book Riddle properly, so maybe this is a temporary diversion to establish the Elias/Riddle dynamic. But do you really need to treat the Original Bro like an idiot to do that? It’s like a bad habit coming back and needing to be pushed down again.
2. Gargano Clowning Around
Whatever WWE is aiming for with Johnny Gargano in this main roster run, it ain’t working.
Since coming back to the company, Gargano has been involved with former protégé Austin Theory and now Miz (and his ongoing feud with Dexter Lumis). These are both carryovers from his NXT days, which is a nice bit of continuity.
But Johnny Wrestling has been spending more time doing bad comedy bits with Miz recently. It’s not funny, and it’s making him look more like a jerk than a taunting babyface. He spent Monday joking with R-Truth, threatening to “blow the whistle” on Miz’s secret and then just disappearing, only to return and serve as a distraction in Miz’s match against Truth.
Then later during his match with Baron Corbin, Gargano inexplicably stopped to put on JBL’s Stetson and dance on the announce table like a goof rather than focus on the match.
Why? How is this making Gargano a likeable babyface? He was the heart and soul of NXT. Now he’s the mean-spirited “babyface” court jester of Raw and a mouthpiece for Lumis.
1. Distractions R Us
Another week, another plethora of distraction finishes littering Raw. It’s becoming an epidemic.
Raw featured seven matches Monday night. One was an Omos squash. Of the remaining six, five matches had a distraction or interference as part of the finish. That’s absolutely maddening. Only Elias versus Chad Gable ended cleanly, and even then, Otis interfered on the outside.
You can’t keep doing this and expect it not to backfire with fans. They’re just going to count on a distraction in every match because it already happens way more than half the time. Yes, there are times it’s more than warranted, but other times, it’s just lazy, unimaginative booking.
And that’s the indictment here. For all the praise being heaped on this new regime for being some revelation, they still are booking sh*tty finishes on Raw every week.
Ups…
5. At Least She Ditched The Mask
When we last saw Nikki ASH, she was sitting in the corner of the ring after yet another loss, sobbing and ripping off her mask.
Monday night, Nikki Cross returned, playing a variation of the Tasmanian Devil character longtime fans likely remember from NXT’s Sanity. Cross attacked everyone ringside during and after the main event pitting Bianca Belair against Bayley. Nikki took out all of Damage CTRL, Belair and Bayley in her whirlwind.
While it was very reminiscent of the Nikki of old, it’s hard to ignore just how futile she was before she left just a few short weeks ago. It’s not like she left on top with an injury. Nikki hasn’t won a match on Raw or a PLE since October 2021.
However, we’ll give this a very tepid “up” because Nikki finally has ditched the superhero gimmick to something that suits her better.
4. Nice Character Work
Give Elias some credit for showing some subtlety in his actions Monday night, giving fans some shades to play with.
Elias returned last week and clearly was playing a face, but he gave a couple of bits where you could see him getting frustrated (mainly with Matt Riddle) and turning heel. That came and went last week, but Monday night, we got another dose of that subtlety.
Backstage, Elias warned Riddle to never interrupt him again, giving him a pass for last week but promising to drop him next time. Then Riddle started playing the bongos, much to everyone’s annoyance, and Elias stepped back, grimaced, grabbed his guitar and wound up as if to swing it at the Original Bro. That little hint showed that there’s still the old Elias there, just beneath the surface.
And now that he’s seemingly paired with the resurgent grating personality of Riddle, it’s probably a matter of time before Elias turns on Matt and goes full heel again. While it isn’t on the level of Randy Orton turning on Rittle, it’ll be fun to see if we get more little hints along the way.
3. Rollins’ Heel Work Elevates Ali
Give Seth Rollins a fair amount of credit for his work in putting Mustafa Ali down while still respecting him Monday night.
Ali is Rollins’ next likely challenger for the United States Championship, and he chased Seth off at the end of Raw last week. Rollins repaid the favor by doing commentary during Mustafa’s match against Austin Theory. Throughout the bout, he was cheerleading for Theory, even noting that he was “a former disciple of mine.” He got upset when Ali went on offense, not wanting him to pick up a big win, and basically acknowledging that Ali was resilient every time he came back.
Rollins kept leaping out of his seat toward the end, and he finally acted on his inclinations and provided a big distraction to allow Theory to get the win. Afterwards, his attack and trash-talk furthered the budding feud with Ali, punctuated by Mustafa’s retaliation on the ramp, showing that he couldn’t be held down and was indeed a threat to Seth.
2. A True Heel Act
It’s time to admit this writer was wrong. For months, this column has pilloried The Judgment Day for just about everything, right down to its “The” in its name.
But during the past couple months, the group has found its stride and achieved success as a true heel stable. There is no “cool” vibe to Judgment Day. They don’t have a bunch of catchphrases and hand signals that fans can imitate and play along with. They don’t even get one up on the babyfaces by being better – they just are massive cheaters with Rhea Ripley often providing a distraction or attacking a wrestler. The group is winning more than it’s losing. They’ve finally moved on from Rey Mysterio.
Perhaps the biggest boost (aside from Ripley’s ascension) for the group has been Dominik Mysterio. Despite his genetics, Dom is not a prodigy in the ring. He’s more David Flair than Charlotte Flair (gonna keep using that one until it catches on).
And The Judgment Day (and WWE) are leaning into that. They are pumping the younger Mysterio up, with Damian Priest calling him the greatest luchador of all time. Dom himself said he was this generation’s Eddie Guerrero… or better yet, Eddie was his generation’s Dominik Mysterio.
It’s all being done with a wink at the camera, which is what makes it work so well. They know in reality they’re full of it, but that’s what makes it so great. It’s fun stuff and makes it easy to “hate” them.
1. The Legend Of Rhea Ripley Grows
What can you say about Rhea Ripley that hasn’t been said already? From being mired in go-nowhere tag teams to languishing as Edge’s lackey, Ripley seemed to be way off-course for the longest time.
But Rhea has found herself in the new iteration of The Judgment Day as the group’s enforcer, much like Chyna was D-Generation X’s x-factor in its early days. Ripley has played off of and played up Dominik Mysterio during his heel turn, and she’s been a difference-maker during Judgment Day matches.
Monday, however, she hit the trifecta. Ripley pumped up Dominik in the promo and would deliver a low blow to Karl Anderson so Finn Balor could win his match.
But mid-match, she posted the massive Luke Gallows and then bodyslammed him, which was a pretty damn impressive feat. She even then made a point to mock LG with a “too sweet” in his face.
If you weren’t impressed by Ripley before Monday, you should be by now.