5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (14 Feb)

Hulka-moan-ia.

Carmella Bayley
WWE.com

Nothing says Valentine's Day like another throwaway episode of SmackDown, right?

That's not strictly fair. There was a lot to love on this week's show, and it was a hell of a lot better than last week's dire edition. Going in, fans were expecting Hulk Hogan's first appearance for a few months, some more soft build towards Super ShowDown in (quiet now) Saudi Arabia and maybe a little inkling towards what's in store at WrestleMania.

It's totally odd that WWE seems devoid of that 'Mania magic since the Royal Rumble though. That lack of spark owes a lot to the fun blockades known as Super ShowDown and Elimination Chamber on the horizon, but there's also something more that's stopping the company from really kicking into high gear before rocking up on Tampa.

Friday's SmackDown was evidence of that, but there are some beams of light flashing through the cracks. Basically, if you love SmackDown's women's division, adore when nostalgic acts are used the right way and like generous helpings of WWE sports entertainment, then this was a solid show.

Here are all the 'Ups' and 'Downs' from it...


Downs...

4. Bliss-less Banter

Alexa Bliss A Moment Of Bliss
WWE.com

Ugh, those painful show-opening promos need to sod off.

SmackDown has usually been good for kicking off with actual action since moving to FOX (some 'King' Corbin stuff aside), and the writers have done a solid job of getting to some actual wrestling quickly. Even when they haven't, the banter has been improvised well enough to offset any annoyance from 'Stock Opening Promo #20,562'.

That wasn't the case on this week's episode. The jokey prattle between Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross felt about as authentic as most of the female division's hair, and their interview with title challenger Carmella was horribly stilted too. This whole segment was just a poor, poor, poor opening to the program.

WWE need to realise that talent can miss episodes when there's nothing worthwhile for them to do. Bliss and Cross were stuck out there with sh*t material and couldn't rescue it. Nothing about this was likeable, and the Carmella vs. Bayley match could've happened without it.


3. Hulk Hogan Wasn't There In Person

Hulk Hogan SmackDown
WWE.com

Brother, dude, brother, brother, dude, dude, dude, brother.

That was the kind of chat fans expected from Hulk Hogan's first WWE appearance in months, but the old stager wasn't even there in person on this week's SmackDown to run through his dialogue. Instead, much like Goldberg last week, Mr. Hulkamania appeared via satellite from his Beach Shop in Florida.

Fans in Vancouver were audibly disappointed when Hulk showed up on the big screen rather than inside the ring; he might not be the most popular legend in wrestling circles these days, but Hogan is still a pop to see live. WWE didn't give the BC fans that kind of thrill on Friday night. They were robbed of some in-person fun here.

On one hand, it makes sense that WWE wouldn't fly in guys like Goldberg and Hulk for short promo segments each week. On the other, it makes a mockery of their own hype when they don't. The company never make it clear enough that stars are appearing via video link.


2. The Miz & John Morrison Lose Out

Roman Reigns John Morrison The Miz
WWE.com

Well, what the flying Miz & Mrs was this?

The Miz and John Morrison are the number one contenders for New Day's SmackDown Tag-Team Titles, and they're slated to face Kofi Kingston and Big E at Super ShowDown for those belts. Why then did WWE's writers see fit to have the guys they want fans to take seriously as a title threat lose to some makeshift duo?

This was unacceptably naff booking, and it took one almighty whizz all over SmackDown's tag ranks for no reason whatsoever. If anything, Daniel Bryan could've taken a fall here and then continued his bad-tempered ways by kicking the living crap out of Roman Reigns afterwards like he did to Heath Slater last week.

WWE chose the wrong outcome for the sake of some forced house show-style happy ending. This main event was neither built strongly enough nor important enough for Miz and Morrison to take a loss. Remember this when Michael Cole is putting over the team as dangerous in Saudi Arabia.


1. That Ending

King Corbin
WWE.com

The announcers told fans several times that 'King' Corbin had been fined and banned from competing for "unprofessional conduct" last week (he beat up some production staffers and poured a drink over some planted fan's head). Corbin then had to wave his front row ticket around as an excuse to enter for the main event.

That was where logic ended, assuming one doesn't mind WWE dumping all over the demand for tix by writing Corbin to buy one last minute. After the main event tag match, the 'King' ran in, thumped Roman Reigns in the head with his sceptre and then posed on the stage.

Erm...what?

Why was Corbin's throne on the stage to begin with, and why did WWE have his entrance music queued up if he wasn't supposed to be there? He'd supposedly been barred from competing on SmackDown, so this didn't make any sense at all. Why is logic so hard?


Ups...

5. Bayley Remembers

Bayley Alexa Bliss Nikki Cross Carmella
WWE.com

Regular readers of this article might be surprised by this one, but thank God for Bayley.

The SmackDown Women's Champ almost saved that lifeless 'A Moment Of Bliss' interview segment with one tiny morsel of information. As the heel champion ran down the chances of Carmella ever beating her for the title, she added that Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross could cram it too because she'd already beaten them in a handicap match.

Everyone, including this guy, had forgotten about that match at Extreme Rules 2019. There, live on pay-per-view no less, Bayley offed Bliss and Cross in a two-on-one effort to retain her belt. That happened on 14 July last year. Look it up if you don't believe it.

This was a rare example of someone in WWE remembering matches older than a few weeks and using them to cut down opponents in promos. It added credibility to Bayley's claim that she's the best Women's Champion the brand has ever seen, and gave Bliss and Cross a reason to be out there in the first place.


4. That SmackDown Women's Title Match

Bayley Carmella
WWE.com

Bayley shines when Sasha Banks isn't there to steal her spotlight. If that sounds harsh, then think back to recent times on SmackDown when the actual champion seemed to be Sasha's sidekick, not the other way around. Running about with Banks was doing nothing for Bayley's aura.

Without someone there to nab some of her spotlight, she's starting to come into her own on the mic and have some cracking matches to boot. For a bout that seemed so uninteresting before it started, Bayley vs. Carmella was one hell of a title corker that every self-respective wrestling fan should go out of their way to see.

Some spots, like 'Mella's top-rope Hurricanrana, her kick out from that 'Bayley-To-Belly', the champ countering 'Code Of Silence' by chopping Carmella's arm away and Bayley resorting to cheap tactics to "survive" (as Cole put it), were awesome. This was a much better match than anyone probably believed it would be.

It should've opened the show cold without that unnecessary talk show tag-along.


3. The Protest Concert

Sami Zayn Cesaro Elias
WWE.com

Whether you have time for WWE's reliance on angles or not, that 'Protest Concert' skit involving Sami Zayn, Cesaro, Elias and Braun Strowman was light-hearted and popular with the Vancouver crowd. They were audibly into it, and only cheered louder for Elias the more Sami and Cesaro pretended they could play instruments.

"Less cowbell" was a stroke of genius.

OK, so nobody thought SmackDown on FOX was going to be riddled with these silly sports entertainment fluff pieces, but this was a good laugh and everyone played their roles brilliantly. Sami was an obnoxious d*ck, Cesaro his over-enthusiastic heavy, Elias got big pops and Braun looked like a no-nonsense monster again.

If WWE's writers are going to book this sort of stuff, then they should make sure to do it using guys and gals who can carry segments. Congratulations, Zayn, you're finally forgiven for all that Bobby Lashley trash a few years ago. This was funny.


2. Dolph Muscles In On Mandy

Otis Dolph Ziggler Mandy Rose
WWE

If your heart didn't break along with Otis' when he spotted Dolph Ziggler getting cosy with his Valentine's Day date Mandy Rose, then you've got ice running through those veins. As much as this was yet more soap opera fare on an episode rammed with it, it did develop some characters and reveal that there's way more to this story.

You didn't think they were gonna' live happily ever after, did you?

Look on the bright side. First, Mandy didn't seem too happy to see Dolph crash her date when he showed up. Second, Ziggler and Otis will have some damn good matches together in the run-up to WrestleMania, and that's exactly what the Heavy Machinery man needs. Dolph can bump around for him and ease Otis into a singles run.

Everyone came out of this looking good, and that's been the case throughout this entire unlikely love story. Otis got his feelings hurt, Rose didn't exactly out herself as a frosty-hearted bitch and Ziggler looked like a total jerk by stealing someone else's seat at the table.


1. Bray Wyatt's Hulkster Hint

Bray Wyatt Hulk Hogan
WWE

One thing WWE definitely shouldn't do is bow to Hulk Hogan's wishes and book him in "one more" lengthy match at WrestleMania 36. That'd be a huge mistake, both for the company and for Hulk. He's not physically able to work a classic, and could actually embarrass himself if he tried to go 10 minutes or longer.

Taking a Mandible Claw from Bray Wyatt though? That's a different story.

Wyatt dropped a heavy hint on this week's SmackDown that Hogan might be next in line for his 'Fiend' after Goldberg. There are two options here: Hulk vs. 'Fiend' could happen at 'Mania (in more of a prolonged angle kind of way than a proper match) if Wyatt drops the Universal Title to Goldberg at Super ShowDown. Or, they could collide at the next Saudi Arabian special after WrestleMania.

It wouldn't be popular amongst Hogan haters, but would it really be so bad to see Bray squash another legend? That'd be the best use of Hulk in 2020, and it'd scratch that itch for anyone who does want to see him on WWE pay-per-view one more time.

What other takeaways did you have from this week's SmackDown? For more, check out 10 Wrestlers Who Were Right To Walk Out On WWE and 10 Wrestlers Who Are Wasted In WWE!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.