5 Ups & 5 Downs From Last Night's WWE Backstage (Jan 14)
It's a New Day for WWE Backstage, yes it is!
No CM Punk this week.
And with the clickbait accusations out of the way, on to another relatively pleasing edition of a show that has quietly become the best thing about WWE's billion dollar deal with Fox since it debuted last year.
The company make more money from this arrangement than any in their history, yet SmackDown plays out with familiarity that borders on the frustrating. Roman Reigns grafts atop the card, Bray Wyatt gets stop-start pushed, Daniel Bryan works harder for the art than it does for him and the women are marginalised into fighting over the belt or men. Was any of this any different before Vince McMahon had a Scrooge McDuckian room of cash to dive into?
Of course not - even Backstage is a glossy reimagining of the beloved and much-missed Talking Smack. But it works each week at returning to those lofty heights, even if it isn't quite perfect...
Downs...
5. Punk In Public
Or not, as the strange schedule agreed upon between the 'Voice Of The Voiceless' and Fox resulted in Punk being absent yet again, having not appeared on the show since December 10th. Based on his own confirmation, it'll be January 21st when he next sits down with the panel.
Though not technically a Down this episode deserves, it's one for the deal in general.
As a fan of the show, a fan of WWE or a fan of CM Punk, there exists modicum of hype but a vacuum of unwarranted frustrations. There's no bait and switch nor false advertising, but can anybody really "change the culture" if they're hardly ever there to do it?
4. Wrestling With Your Feelings
A lame duck that petered out early due to the three performers popping at their own patter rather the paltry material, the second Rachel Bonnetta segment had all the charmlessness of the first and did even less for Fire & Desire than it did for inaugural patient Bayley.
Crossover bullsh*t like this works in extremely small doses, and there'll likely not be another Bonnetta segment for another several weeks, but just because the vignettes are spaced out like CM Punk appearances it doesn't mean they're remotely as welcome.
The fluff was in high supply on this episode too, with special guest Freddie Prinze Jr ready to walk into the weakest semi-regular segment...
3. Promo School
WWE Backstage, regardless of the company's monied deal with Fox and whatever marketing budget they afford it, is not must-see TV.
There's yet to be an angle or a scoop or a moment beyond CM Punk's surprising return that made it appointment viewing, and though it benefits from the light and shade across the hour, this is too wooly for its own good.
Freddie Prinze Jr was the best of the bunch to so far try this by an absolute mile, and The New Day were enjoyable pre-recorded extras to aid Xavier Woods in his battle. But
2. The Satin Sh*t
Was Ryan Satin only brought in to advertise that WWE are finally compensating their talents a little more in line with what they probably deserve?
Every week, his scoops are limited to updating audiences on which Superstar just brought home the bacon, with Elias as this week's minted benefactor. All well and good and all nice news, but the longer the "stories" relate to this, the more obvious the facade is going to look.
Satin was affable as usual, and his confirmation of Mercedes Martinez' Performance Center signing brought some genuinely interesting news to the segment, but there'll need to be something a little juicier soon before the whole thing feels a little bit of a waste.
1. Headbangers
No performative position should ever expose a pro wrestler, not least the warm and welcoming environment of something like a WWE Backstage time-filler, but Ember Moon's freezing up during a game night show-closer was oddly uncomfortable.
Following some twin magic from The Usos as they romped to victory with a selection of quickfire impressions and logical guesses, Moon and Xavier Woods were stumped by the former NXT Champion's struggles to think of ways to impersonate Farooq, Dude Love and, shamefully, Stone Cold Steve Austin.
Moon's been excellent in an analytical role on this show, but struggles when put on the spot in quickfire situations such as these. On a show that normally only makes good on main roster creative mistakes and minutes don't feel like hours, this was some time-standing-still awkwardness she shouldn't be subjected to again.
Ups...
5. Into The Woods
Guest panellist Xavier Woods, predictably, was a constant delight from the second he opened his mouth.
Plugging the sh*t out of his...everything during his introduction, he then went on to hype news of his return before bantering it off as still being ages away.
It'd be unfair to credit Woods with the entire success of The New Day, but his ingenuity and enthusiasm helped propel it from a Sports Entertainment dead rubber to pro wrestling phenomenon, and this particular environment was a reason of precisely how and why he made it so. The longer he's out, the more he should be placed here - he's a gift to the entire organisation.
4. A Prinze Among Men
Freddie Prinze Jr was too good for WWE.
Well, too good and too rich. Discounting the aforementioned performance in Promo School later on in the show, Prinze Jr he offered several fascinating notes about the spell that saw him in and out of WWE's creative process between 2008 and 2009.
He joked that Stephanie McMahon being a teenager during his teen idol years helped his cause, and that the schedule was "more man" than he was. Amidst knowing glances from the panel, it was genuinely sweet to hear the others share Titan Tower tidbits with the Hollywood star.
3. Turning Point
Your writer hasn't been the kindest to Booker T for some of the nonsense spewed on such a massive platform so far, but he earned the guiltiest of pops this week when he completely exposed the daft side of the otherwise-excellent Becky Lynch/Asuka segment on Monday Night Raw.
Referring to the dreaded green mist as "water-based" for how quickly Lynch managed to recover and cut her promo, his "I like it...but..." response was quite refreshingly honest and earnest in place of his typical insanity.
He peppered it throughout the rest of the show because the mad f*cker absolutely cannot help himself, but the conversation flowed so well that the pops became part of what made this week's edition so enjoyable.
2. Keeping It Real
Having recently returned to SmackDown, The Usos could have easily kept kayfabe for the most part, particularly in relation to their absence across much of 2019.
Alongside Xavier Woods, the brothers were only too happy to discuss the legendary 2017 tag team programme with The New Day, as well as their days training with Booker T alongside fellow panellist Ember Moon. Backstage, surprisingly, was willing to address the elephant in the room.
Renee Young brought up their break as well as talking to their children about their legal issues, with both Jimmy and Jey speaking frankly about how they used that experience to set themselves straight - particularly as they made their return to television. The segment was short but satisfying, adding gravitas to what was already a thoroughly enjoyable catch-up.
1. Trailblazers
Short but sweet, this return from commercial loaded with highlights of the four women that entered the men's Royal Rumble long before such a thing existed for their own division - or in Nia Jax' case in 2019, because she f*cking wanted to.
Ahead of a couple of clunker segments on a show that otherwise raced by, this was a palette cleansing use of WWE's vast archive, not least with Rumble fever starting to gradually permeate throughout the entire organisation. The celebration of Chyna, Beth Phoenix, Kharma and Jax was nice for the sake of being nice, and how often can that be levied at WWE?
As a bonus by-product, Kong was more over by virtue of the clip played of her 2012 Rumble cameo than she's been since sidling up to Brandi Rhodes as part of The Nightmare Collective in AEW - even Backstage can book a better women's division.