5 Ups & 5 Downs From Last Night's WWE NXT (Dec 11)
Great bookends, boring shelf.
NXT has developed something of a bad - and ominous - habit in recent weeks.
There's a creeping feeling that it's becoming the main roster in a more ironic way than the Survivor Series hype had intended. Just last week, in the course of about five minutes, NXT borrowed two rotten tropes: Cameron Grimes, because he apparently can, blindsided Raul Mendoza and forced himself into a match with KUSHIDA. But KUSHIDA exacted vengeance by stealing one! with a roll-up. On the same show, the advertised Rhea Ripley Vs. Dakota Kai match didn't happen, and it's all well and good to say that it shouldn't have, that it was too early. You, I, we are in the bubble. We're not going anywhere. The more casual fans tuning in just might. Impromptu, very convenient main event match set-ups, opening promos...NXT is significantly less "BS" than the main roster, but it's no alternative to it.
NXT also has a huge show coming up next week.
Shayna Baszler is set to defend the Women's Championship against Rhea Ripley in what is surely an event not merely worthy of a TakeOver; TakeOver is worthy of a match of that magnitude.
This episode mostly served as a go-home show for NXT TakeOver: Don't Watch AEW After The Christmas Break, Lads, Here's Where The Action Is.
Was it effectively promoted?
Yes.
And bear in mind, not all Ups and Downs were created equal...
Downs...
5. So NXT Is The Main Roster, Then
KUSHIDA Vs. Cameron Grimes is every other 2019 NXT feud you've ever seen, and it's so boring, but it won't be pointless, because KUSHIDA will probably get over a bit more by winning a damn good match. That's the purpose of all this, ultimately, but it's all so functional and unambitious.
Last week, KUSHIDA stole one over Grimes in an impromptu match. This week, Raul Mendoza was allowed an opportunity for revenge in a pretty OK 50/50 match that KUSHIDA interrupted. In the second main roster finish in as many weeks, Grimes, positively aghast at this development - shouldn't they teach this in the Performance Center, since it happens on the main roster all the bastard time? - succumbed to a roll-up. What next? Is Grimes going to avenge this by making KUSHIDA eat dog food? Is he going to blame each and every one of you for this recent loss of form? Are he and KUSHIDA going to thrash out their differences on Miz TV? Will they become a tag team because they are feuding, leading to wacky miscommunications and an NXT Tag Team Title reign?
Will he get his hat back?!
This is sh*t, Grimes is a geek, and NXT is far more like the main roster than anybody cares to admit.
4. The Worst Act In The Wednesday Night War Make An Appearance
Ironically, the groan that accompanies the Forgotten Sons sounds like the sudden realisation that you'd forgotten they exist, and just remembered that they exist. This act is awful. Irredeemably awful.
The Forgotten Sons are a literal punchline, only punchlines are amusing, and the Forgotten Sons are not a source of any discernible entertainment. The tone of the act, never mind the f*cking premise, is also garbage: they are shredded and colossal, but they are also jobbers. Jobbers are meant to look skinny and pitiful to enhance the stars in visual contrast. They're not meant to look like they can kick the sh*t out of you. NXT badly needs sentimental, plucky, maybe older hands for this function. Get Eric Bugenhagen or whatever they renamed on TV to get acts with potential over by having them beat the piss out of him. It's an NWA Powerrr act on NXT, it's not working, and it never will.
Anyway, here, the Forgotten Sons' Jaxson Ryker wrestled Travis Banks in a Worlds Collide preview, Banks' stuff looked like it barely connected, he stole one, it lasted about two minutes, and it was still offensive.
3. False Advertising
In a pre-match promo cut earlier in the night (a solid enough promo, incidentally), Mia Yim promised to send Dakota Kai home in an ambulance.
She sought to achieve this by...throwing a few suplexes at a slightly more risky angle, and Dakota Kai responded by shrieking a bit more when she threw her kicks. That's reductive, and probably a little harsh, but the tone of this match betrayed both premise and promise. It was a solid-to-good pro wrestling match that, ultimately, felt like a slightly intense wrestling match, and when it did meet the remit, Yim hit more steps than opponent in one of the big spots.
Mia Yim did, admittedly, backdrop Kai through a table in the post-match, but this spot was doubly undermined. Firstly, it was a dreaded get-the-heat-back moment after Kai's win, and secondly, it didn't resonate as a moment of hatred-fuelled violence. The blocking and staging felt rather contrived, and the landing felt both gentle and botched, where it was meant to look brutal and be safe.
Ultimately, NXT promised a chapter in a blood feud between two women who hate one another, and delivered something co-operative and underwhelming.
2. Tonal Mishmash Reveals Stark Reality
This was very strange, and very damning.
Breezango's hot doctors entrance was amusing, but the audience hasn't yet learned to expect it, so it didn't receive much of a pop. It's nice to hear Beth Phoenix become a real human being with her charming innuendos, and charm should have marked the tone here; Breezango are a comedy act, as are the Singhs, but this was a bizarrely brutal match that came off like main event cosplay of (albeit quite impressive) high spots and crunching apron bumps. It was an on-brand NXT match wrestled by two acts that should be used to vary the tone of the show. It wasn't bad, but rather misjudged. NXT is serious, intense business. At it's best, it an awesome rush of a show, but it's rarely fun. This should have been fun.
Perhaps it wasn't fun because the wafer-thin ranks of the tag team division necessitate an artificial push for depth, which is precisely what this was. Undisputed ERA Vs. Breezango has immense, lowkey potential as a story match, but the dynamic requires that on-paper contrast to soar.
How much more amazing would it have been, had Breeze and Fandango started ripping them apart in the 15th minute of a TakeOver match without first wasting it on TV?
1. Bianca Belair Vs. Kayden Carter: Just A Match*
*When the show needed something more than just a match.
This was solid, and Kayden Carter impressed in spells with her ingenuity and timing - particularly from a springboard reversal kick to the mush - but the entire show was dragging badly at this point, ranging from tedious to aggressively fine for about 45 forgettable minutes. Something felt off in respect of Bianca Belair's performance. The confidence/obnoxiousness balance was misjudged; at various points, it felt like she'd turned heel and nobody told us.
Has she turned heel? Survivor Series was as confusing as sh*t.
That NXT ran with this Just A Match highlighted problems elsewhere. Too many top or emerging acts are without direction. Matt Riddle is awesome, and very popular in the elusive, key demographic, and he has lost far too often and is not embroiled in a programme of note - and any plans, it feels like, as a worrying byproduct. Isiah 'Swerve' Scott is an outstanding talent. NXT has neglected the North American and Tag Team Title divisions to the cost of the product. Stakes are missing.
This erodes confidence in the future.
Ups...
5. A Great Cold Open
In a neat contradiction of the intro, NXT devised a very creative cold open for this week's show; a hybrid video package incorporating the usual open and a recap of last week was interrupted by Adam Cole with a "Wait, wait, stop..." as Slipknot chugged out and was replaced in the mix by the Undisputed Era's theme - an audible cue that illustrated the extent to which Cole et al. dominate the whole show with their gold prophesy.
The camera cut to Cole at the helm of the production truck in a unique means of cutting a promo in the classic chickensh*t mould. He claimed that no man in the Triple Threat main event had earned the right to face him, even though both Keith Lee and Tommaso Ciampa have scored recent pins at his expense, and Finn Bálor defeated Matt Riddle to establish his credentials at the precipice of the main event. As a heel, he expressed his wish to see all three men destroy one another, and in a very cute line, declared himself the greatest NXT Champion that ever lived.
This foreshadowed but did not give away the finish of the main event - who else calls himself the greatest ever NXT Champion? - in a way that, very subtly, drove the narrative heft of next week's super-show.
4. Lio Rush Vs. Angel Garza BANGS
Watched closely enough, there was a certain 'hissy' aspect to that opening brawl, but it didn't matter at all to a rapt Full Sail.
Through Garza's sh*t-eating grin, Lio Rush's aggrieved body language, and the intensity of the melee, the two men engineered a triumph: an exciting Cruiserweight match, laced with authentic, totally absorbing animosity, that didn't rely on chemistry and technicality to get itself over. It was far more ambitious - and better - than that. It was rough on purpose early to convey the fight atmosphere, a neat, immersive touch that saw Rush and Garza tumble almost head-first out of the ring under a blur of strikes.
The crowd went apesh*t for this, hooked by the work and the story that informed it: Garza continued to burrow underneath Rush's skin, in a manner germane to the storyline, by stealing Rush's signature spots and outwitting him throughout several scintillating rope-run deception sequences. This enforced Rush to take a risk - he needed to arrest the flow of the match, and he was pissed off enough to do it - which Garza punished by getting the knees up to counter Rush's crazed frog splash to the outside. Every near-fall felt earned - the animosity and undying refusal of humiliation fuelled them - and Garza in the end put Rush away with a submission, after Rush had kicked out of the Wing Clipper. This was the final phase of a psychological plan, and it looked gruesome.
A believable, proper full-on banger of an opener - one of the best matches in the short history of the Wednesday Night Wars.
3. A Great Video Package
The video package produced to further get Rhea Ripley over was pitched very well in tone, and proved a very welcome departure from a contract signing or a pull-apart brawl.
NXT advanced storylines in the immediate and short-terms using the medium all night, which was appreciated; it created hype and anticipation without exposition nor disruption. Ripley's was most effective; it showed footage of her early life as a wrestling fan, to humanise her, but balanced the sentiment by making it clear that she is a wunderkind who has accelerated through her development because she is exceptional at this.
Brief but effective, in just minutes, NXT portrayed Ripley as a wrestler worthy of your support with the ability to repay it.
2. A Thrilling Main Event
A very good main event structured intelligently, Keith Lee Vs. Finn Bálor Vs. Tommaso Ciampa was as understated a match you'll see that also incorporated a nasty, rafter-height Tower of Doom spot.
Bálor impressed here, just as the conversation had turned somewhat following two merely good outings against Matt Riddle and Ciampa. His strength and velocity generated the biggest pop of the match, when he cradled a Lee suplex, and catalysed a quality, barricade-shaking breakdown sequence that led to a stunning aerial assault and drove the energy of the fabulous finishing sequence. This wasn't the most pronounced Ciampa performance, but he was protected adequately by displaying a power (his air raid on Lee looked awesome, and he sold the struggle of the build excellently) and resilience that drained him at the finish. Lee continued to impress with the impossible human schtick that manifested here with a squelcher of a moonsault that, realistically, should have been broken up by Bálor and not kicked out of.
The ending, however, was pure poetry.
Bálor, since his return, has claimed that he doesn't watch the business; the business watches him. But he certainly had Ciampa's kill-shot scouted well enough to take advantage of it to secure his shot at Adam Cole.
This was very neat heel character work that tacitly put Ciampa over in defeat, where Lee was protected by the big move/flash pin double-barrel shot.
1. The Right Man Wins
Tommaso Ciampa's quest to reclaim Goldie is a TakeOver main event. His winning here would have lived down to the criticisms of NXT on USA as reactionary and desperate at the detriment of a gripping, long-term picture.
A Keith Lee win and flash-forward to an interference-driven loss wasn't a terrible idea, at all, but it had an air of cop-out about it, and his taking the loss was reassurance that he is perceived by brass as a long-term prospect. Keith Lee's momentum isn't the concern here; Finn Bálor's lack of it was. His history as a main roster World Champion and NXT legend demands an immediate push into the main event picture. His character is of a man who transcends the current main event because, without him, it would not exist.
Adam Cole Vs. Finn Bálor is a very interesting, different, and completely unpredictable match. The all-heel dynamic is fascinating, and if handled correctly - which is all but guaranteed - should manifest as the sort of match that is very rarely witnessed on North American TV. It really puts over the suspension of disbelief element, because why do two heels never wrestle?
A weird, refreshing and thoroughly captivating atmosphere is set to descend over Full Sail next week.