5 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE NXT: Roadblock (Results & Review - 5 Mar)
Trick whoops Melo; Roxanne snaps; Regal, Spears and Ruca return; The Family celebrates.

Welcome to NXT Roadblock, where it most decidedly doesn’t say “wrestling” on the marquee.
Tuesday’s developmental television special delivered some average to solid wrestling and a plethora of backstage segments that varied from cringe to entertaining. In short, a typical NXT program.
Roadblock set the table for several matches for Stand and Deliver next month, making the NXT Championship match official while dropping strong hints for a few more contests at the WrestleMania weekend show.
The show also welcomed back a superstar who has been out of action for nearly a year in Sol Ruca, and offered the first match for a returning wrestler in his first WWE/NXT match in more than five years, Shawn Spears.
But far and away, the biggest developments came in the closing match, with Tony D’Angelo earning his first NXT Championship match and a returning Trick Williams battering Carmelo Hayes to ignite their feud just in time to culminate at Stand and Deliver.
Being a two-hour program where things move at a sometimes breakneck pace, even when NXT is trash in several spots, it flies by and doesn’t take itself too seriously. That’s why it’s easier to recommend an average or subpar show over a solid three-hour Raw.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
5. Bad Match, Botched Return

Sometimes, matches exist solely for the purpose of an angle development, and that’s fine… when it’s executed well.
Tuesday’s contest between Fallon Henley and Blair Davenport was short and subpar, but it took place only so Sol Ruca could make her return after being out of action for nearly a year. The two brawled outside, with Davenport running into the steel steps and propping herself up on the barricade, only for Ruca to hit a cartwheel DDT off the wall.
At least, that’s what was supposed to happen. Sol more or less whiffed, with a camera angle partly covering for it. Blair was shoved back into the ring and quickly pinned for the loss, and Ruca celebrated with Henley.
You can’t give a pass to a botched spot when it was the entire point of the backstage segment setting up this match, which existed only for said spot. It’s a shame too: Ruca is talented, and her whiff made this an underwhelming moment.
4. Get Thea A Tranquillizer

Thea Hail has been a great character since her debut as a recent high school graduate who decided to attend Chase University to continue her studies. Her cheerleader-meets-Scrappy-Doo persona has been infectious, and even her twist under Jacy Jayne’s tutelage has been nicely done in spots.
With Chase U saved via Jacy’s calendar, things should have returned to normal, but suddenly, Jacy has become the mean girl everyone thought she would have been right out of the chute, finding a new bestie in Jazmyn Nyx.
None of that on its own is bad, but the “acting” was horrible during Roadblock. Jacy and Jazmyn’s facial expressions throughout the tag match was anything but subtle, all but screaming, “We’re bored of you and couldn’t care less if you lose horribly!” Jayne’s backstage diatribe later wasn’t much better, nor was Hail reacting to Jacy’s giving her the “loser” gesture and then running off to pick a fight with Kiana James and Izzi Dame.
Maybe there’s a missing component here or we should give it more time to play out, but this felt like badly acted stuff that didn’t land how intended.
3. Bad Line Reading

Some failed TV writer clearly thinks they’ve struck gold with Tatum Paxley’s obsessed, ranting single white female persona, force-feeding bad dialogue into her and having her spew it out at maximum speed.
While prepping for their tag title match later in the night, Lyra Valkyria and Paxley were chatting about their chances when Tatum maniacally declared that they had to win, that she’d do anything to win, and when she was champion, she would “journey into the farthest darkness,” conjure some evil, torture opponents and “take out their souls until they’re crying in complete agony.”
Terrifying stuff. No, really. It’s actually scary that this made television, that no one heard it during rehearsals and killed the segment for being insanely bad and laughable. Worse, it just makes your NXT Women’s Champion look silly by association as she tries to keep a (worried) straight face reacting to this screed as if Tatum shouldn’t be wearing Joe Gacy’s straight jacket.
There’s over-the-top obsessive behavior, and then there’s “kicked out of the William Shatner Drama School for overacting.”
2. Exposition Junction, What’s Your Malfunction?

Shawn Spears’ return to NXT last week was certainly a shock, as he waffled Ridge Holland with a steel chair. It left questions about why he came back and why he was targeting Ridge.
But if there’s an opening to talk, that just means it’s a chance for the writers to crack open their thesaurus and go to town.
After squashing a jobber, Spears spoke about how it “takes a certain kind of man to hold a mirror up to humanity” because most won’t like what they see. He called people hypocrites and then mocked Ridge for saying he fights for his family, saying he was “lying to yourself.”
When Holland came out though, Spears dropped his chair and allowed Ridge to pummel him, even sliding the chair to him and daring him to prove Shawn right by battering him. However, the referees saved him.
So… what’s the story here? Ridge is supposed to be a dangerous person who hurts those he’s in the ring with, which is literally the job of a professional wrestler. And Spears is targeting him because… he’s a liar? Is the strategy to get Holland to admit he’s really a villain? And then what? He and Spears team up? Shawn goes on to get more confessions out of other superstars?
It’s a very strange vibe, and not the kind where you are curious enough to breathlessly wait to see the next development.
1. No Quarter, No Excitement

Sorry to any fans of British wrestling, but hearing the No Quarter Catch Crew drone on about the significance of a trophy that mid-carders fight over in matches with strange rules is not winning support.
Tuesday’s in-ring promo wasn’t helped by four bland dudes just repeating themselves and talking about “heritage” but not naming any heroes or being able to point to classic moments. At least when WWE talks about the Intercontnential Championship, there are plenty of memorable champions and title matches to cite. Has there ever been a Heritage Cup Championship match that could be defined as “classic”?
Sadly for the crew, William Regal’s appearance – and the tongue-in-cheek acknowledgement that Charlie Dempsey is in fact his son – didn’t elevate the segment. Regal simply repeated everything Drew Gulak, Damon Kemp and Dempsey said, before saying he’d be watching.
Sure, for devotees sopping up every bit of what NXT offers, Regal being back on camera might have been a welcome sight. But it was about as flat and drab as humanly possible.
UPS…
5. Wolf Dogs Roll Over Chase U

Bron Breakker and Baron Corbin are not going to have snowflake-laden matches, but they’re a tag team you can’t stop watching.
The NXT Tag Team Champions ran over Andre Chase and Duke Hudson in a match where the outcome was never really in doubt. Chase took a lot of punishment from the meathead jocks before Duke made a bit of a comeback, but it was all for naught. The Wolf Dogs weren’t losing their tag titles this early in their run.
It’s pretty obvious Corbin and Breakker aren’t going to be here for a long time, but a good time, so NXT would be wise to put them out there whenever possible to run over the competition.
4. Kabuki Warriors Retain, Perez Stakes Claim

The Kabuki Warriors thwarted the challenge of Lyra Valkyria and Tatum Paxley Tuesday, retaining their WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship. The outcome was obvious given that WWE had already shown a graphic on Raw the previous night with Asuka and Kairi Sane defending their titles against Shayna Baszler and Zoey Stark on next week’s Raw.
That didn’t stop Lyra and Tatum from trying to unseat the champs. Valkyria in particular looked good against the accomplished veterans, giving her another strong showing against main roster superstars. The match itself was fine, though Kairi looked like she got rocked at some point and was sluggish on the back half of the contest.
An interesting tidbit that came out during the match was the reminder that Asuka has never lost in NXT, a span of more than 200 matches, including a lengthy reign as NXT Women’s Champion.
Face miscommunication – Lyra inadvertently hit Paxley with a spinkick – led to the challengers’ downfall. Whether that feeds into Tatum becoming jaded toward Lyra remains an open question.
Afterward, Roxanne Perez jumped Valkyria and targeted her arm, snapping it in the turnbuckle in a different kind of spot and pretty clearly turning full heel. That should make for a great one-on-one match at Stand and Deliver, which seems like the obvious direction here.
3. Tony D Adds To The Family, Lands Opportunity

Tony D’Angelo had a pretty big night at Roadblock, welcoming a new family member and earning his first NXT Championship match.
The Don of NXT extended an offer to Luca Crusifino to serve as his consigliere, a move that felt inevitable the moment an Italian attorney appeared on NXT several months back. That expanded The Family and gave them some added heft after a lengthy run as just a duo of Tony D and Stacks.
Later, D’Angelo beat back Carmelo Hayes to punch his ticket to Stand and Deliver, where he’ll challenge Ilja Dragunov for the NXT title. The match itself was pretty decent, with Hayes flying around the ring and Tony D using his power game to ground the former champion. In the end, D’Angelo showed he wasn’t above playing into Melo’s fears, blaring Trick Williams’ entrance music to distract Hayes and allow the Don to put him away.
D'Angelo will make an intriguing challenger for Dragunov, as he’s shown growth in the ring but remains a goofy caricature – albeit it in a good, harmless way. Still, there’s an opportunity here for the character to evolve, a process that isn’t unprecedented. We’ll have to see what develops during the next month.
2. Bad Build, Good Execution

There is no gentle way to say this: Joe Gacy and Dijak are just ridiculously bad, cartoonish characters. If they were any more of a couple of scene-chewing, over-the-top caricatures, they would be winking at the camera to let the audience in on the joke.
However, Gacy and Dijak in the ring, more specifically in an asylum match, were actually really entertaining… if you knew what you were getting. Given the manic, bizarre Gacy and the 80s-era vigilante Dijak, there was no way to take their blowoff match as a serious blood feud.
Their plunder brawl worked well though because both men are very good workers who know how to actually work a match. They employed everything at their disposal – a chair, a door, a table, a fire extinguisher, duct tape and a straight jacket – to try to incapacitate the other. There was the obvious bad comedy spot with a box marked “Do not open” that Dijak slid open, only to have a boxing glove spring up and hit him in the groin. Hilarity ensued.
It also featured Dijak hitting a moonsault off the cage and Gacy nailing a senton while wearing a straight jacket. While nothing resembling what critics would call a “good” match, it was never dull, and it looked to have blown off the feud, so that’s enough to merit an “up” here.
1. Trick Whoops That Melo

Just because a “surprise” return is all but telegraphed doesn't mean it’s an unwelcome moment.
Case in point, Trick Williams finally made his way back to NXT Tuesday night at Roadblock, running in to attack Carmelo Hayes after Melo lost his match against Tony D’Angelo for an NXT Championship title shot. Trick Willie took the fight to Hayes and his personal security, sending his one-time best friend scampering.
Williams showed the manic fire of a man obsessed with revenge, which is exactly how he should have appeared after Carmelo turned on him at Vengeance Day and put him on the shelf for a month.
A match between the two former friends at Stand and Deliver is basically etched in stone and could easily be Trick’s best, a launching point for his career. The guy radiates an aura that can’t be taught, so it was great seeing the biggest angle of his young career taking off well Tuesday night.