5 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (2 Jan - Results & Review)
Randy Orton returns; SmackDown signs fresh talent; Ambulance Match underwhelms.
The first SmackDown of 2026 was a 3 hour tour around the best and worst of Triple H-led booking. 'The Game' and his WWE creative squad penned title changes, comebacks, new additions to the blue brand roster and more on Friday night in Buffalo, but it wasn't all sunshine and rainbows amidst the new year celebrations.
Drew McIntyre announcing the stipulations for his upcoming '3 Stages Of Hell' whopper vs. Cody Rhodes could've gone better, and it was completely overshadowed by some personal business involving the memory of Cody's dad Dusty. WWE will always try to push those buttons when it comes to the Rhodes family, and perhaps rightly so, but the '3 Stages' thing? Yeah, could look a little tastier than it does after the reveal.
Elsewhere, the main event between Damian Priest and Aleister Black felt like a bit of a slog. Both borrowed from Hunter's old 'more is more' playbook in terms of the amount of time they had to work with, and that meant the first half was totally inconsequential. Being fair, that 'Ambulance Match' gimmick is tough sledding, but it might surprise a few to see it in the 'Downs' section regardless.
Back on more positive footing, both Trick Williams and Jordynne Grace look like they'll be impact players on SmackDown, and there's definitely something to Trick's simmering issues with Sami Zayn. Meanwhile, Grace could well save Jade Cargill from the purgatory imposed on her since winning the Women's Title.
WWE still have some ironing out to do with the 3 hour length too. Here's all the good and bad from Friday's effort!
Downs...
5. WWE Pick Lame ‘Stages Of Hell’
Aw man, it honestly hurts to put this in the 'Downs' section, but that's due to WWE's decision making more than anything Drew McIntyre or Cody Rhodes did. Here, Drew was delicious as a dirtbag heel daring to be punched in the face so Cody would forfeit his WWE Title without the pair even reaching Berlin for their '3 Stages Of Hell' match next week.
It is a bit strange that Cody was so cut up about a printed photo he could surely redo and reframe, but it was the symbolism and insult to his family that he was so mad about. That part made sense. What doesn't make sense is the formatting for '3 Stages'. Could it be anymore obvious? The company really could've been a lot more creative with these choices.
Cody and Drew will contest a straight up wrestling match (which lacks intensity as a pick), a 'Falls Count Anywhere' clash and then a steel cage bout "if necessary". It will be necessary, and everyone knows it. Again, McIntyre's promo and his smashing then burning of the Dusty picture was top heel work, but WWE are letting the duo down with the '3 Stages Of Hell' trio they've chosen.
This is one of those occasions when Hell In A Cell would be perfect. We all know what Drew is capable of when he's mixing it with a hated rival inside the Cell - just look at his epic vs. CM Punk for proof of that. There's still a chance they'll get away with this lacklustre formatting, but it could've been so much better on paper.
Oh well.
4. Ambulance Match Underwhelms
Many had high hopes for the blow off between Damian Priest and Aleister Black, but this was underwhelming. Admittedly (and being fair about it), the ‘Ambulance Match’ gimmick is a tough nut to crack, because it’s effectively ‘put dude in vehicle and shut doors’, so there isn’t that much drama. They also really tried here, but nothing other than the final few minutes was worth seeing.
Even the fireball revenge spot felt tame and inconsequential. That same blast put Priest on the shelf and gave him visible injuries. On this occasion, it did nothing but stop Black for 30 seconds. So, what was the point? You've also got to question the wisdom of the result - Priest has felt ice cold for a while, and this was Aleister’s chance to properly ascend to main event status. He’ll seemingly be stuck in the midcard glut for life, and has become a new version of Bray Wyatt in terms of making grandiose promises without coming through on them in the end.
Yes, this guy wishes he could be more positive and gush about the main event, but it just didn’t hit personally. Maybe some fans reading this piece will feel different, and that’s totally cool. This is just one person's opinion, after all. It doesn't make yours truly right. Everybody sees things their own way.
Throughout, there was a sense that everyone was killing time until Rhea Ripley emerged from the ambulance and they could sprint to the finish. That left the opening 20 minutes or so rather flat. This might be viewed as one that got away for WWE come the end of 2026.
3. Wasn’t Feeling Matt Cardona’s Comeback
File this under the same bracket as the moans above.
It isn't nearly as high profile as mucking up a WWE Title match announcement with lame stips or seeing an 'Ambulance Match' main event sag, but there was still something missing from Matt Cardona's full time company return. He'd previously shown face as Zack Ryder on the 14 November SmackDown as part of the John Cena tournament when he lost to LA Knight.
Fast forward to today and the Zack attack is back...albeit not as Ryder. He'll be known as Cardona going forwards, which must feel like a personal success for the guy. This is everything he's ever wanted since being cut loose in 2020. However, his comeback match vs. Kit Wilson was a little off. It should've been a squash more than anything so Kit could whine about "toxic masculinity" in promos afterwards.
Bonus points if he worked the same 'unsafe working conditions' pitch Shawn Michaels did following a backstage fight with Bret Hart in the 90s. That'd be some laugh.
Look, it is nice to see Cardona back in the thick of it, and he will be a credit to the SmackDown roster. Sadly, this comeback bout just didn't feel all that dazzling. Further, it's hard to see Kit thriving as a singles star away from Pretty Deadly. Stranger things have happened around these parts, in fairness.
Overall, this was a little low on the energy front for a grand return showing designed to get everyone pumped for the artist formerly known as Zack Ryder.
2. Take 2 For Giulia, But…
...she still isn’t over on the main roster, and it’s unlikely that winning the Women’s United States Title for a second time will change that.
WWE are just repeating the same thing here, and they better have something in mind for Giulia or she’ll have another dull reign for a few months before dropping the belt all over again. Chelsea Green might be this division’s ‘in emergency, break glass’ button, come to think of it. That’s because she’s entertaining no matter what she’s doing. Unfortunately, the same can’t be said for Giulia right now.
Their match wasn’t terrible by any means, but it’s hard to get excited about this title or the new champ. Giulia came into WWE with a lot of hype and was better on NXT, but her matches are nothing special, promos aren’t her strong suit, and nobody cares about the Women’s US Title. All of that collides to make it a proper struggle for her in WWE.
Kiana James hasn't been talking a lot lately either, which begs the question: What is her purpose if not to cut promos aplenty for Giulia and take that pressure off the new champ's shoulders? Yep, every aspect of this package needs a rethink from top to bottom. The Women's US Title comes across as a sticking plaster from Triple H then.
It might be for the best if Giulia works an 'Open Challenge' gimmick weekly like the guys have been doing with their United States strap. If nothing else, at least that'd let her concentrate on actually wrestling, because it's clear that WWE have zero clue how to flesh out some personality for the international star.
1. This Tag-Team Feud Sucks
Please stop this.
SmackDown featured a pre-tape video from Bo Dallas/Uncle Howdy droning on and on and on about “the meaning of family” and taking shots at Solo Sikoa’s past. It was the usual nonsense from The Wyatt Sicks. Personally? So over them. Here’s hoping they don’t dominate the tag conversation on SmackDown in 2026 like they did for much of 2025.
It perhaps says everything that Shinsuke Nakamura and Tama Tonga starting a little side story is more interesting than the tag title feud. They appeared in a brief exchange backstage, and the pair spoke Japanese to one another. Solo wasn't so sure he liked that, but Tonga ensured him that it was nothing to worry about. Then, he glanced back over his shoulder before walking away with Sikoa.
Talking about something Howdy and gang weren't even involved in speaks volumes about how boring they are as a group these days. They've got a stranglehold on the tag belts whilst top teams like The Street Profits, Fraxiom, The Motor City Machine Guns and more continue to sit in catering doing next to nothing. Hmm. That doesn't sit well, especially when The Sicks have been so crap.
This feud between The Wyatts and Solo's MFT group has no juice to it whatsoever. Dark days are ahead if WWE believe this constitutes thrilling TV for these 3 hour long SmackDowns. Repeat: Get those belts off The Sicks as soon as humanly possible so the blue brand can recover from their nightmare-inducing reign.
Not to put too fine a point on it, but...they suck.
Ups...
5. Now This Is More Like It For Jade Cargill
Jade Cargill's scheduled match with Michin didn’t happen due to an injury. It's obviously not nice that Mia Yim was struck down with a shoulder blow, but the match being cancelled was hardly a bad thing for this episode of SmackDown. Let's be real, it would’ve sucked wind on the 3 hour edition and represented yet more treading water for Jade.
Instead, Jordynne Grace approached Cargill during a backstage promo and got the ball rolling on a possible rivalry between them. Now that’s more like it! This is more in line with what Cargill needs as champion. Bianca Belair is surely still the end goal here, but Grace challenging would be magic and could (in theory) be a blistering headliner for a coming episode of TV.
Jade towered over Jordynne during this segment, yes, but Grace has believable power and strength. Fans will respond to that when she takes the fight to the bullying Women's Champ, and this sort of credible threat is precisely what Cargill has needed since beating Tiffany Stratton for the belt in early-November.
It's taken Hunter and pals a hot minute, but they're finally moving Jade in the right direction.
Best wishes to Michin as she recuperates from an injury suffered towards the end of 2025, but the silver lining to her misfortunate is that Grace vs. Jade is on the agenda. Once that's done, Cargill can mow through Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss en route to resuming her issues with old tag-team partner Belair. That has to happen in 2026, doesn't it?!
4. An All-Action 8-Woman Tag
IYO SKY, Rhea Ripley, Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss beat Asuka, Kairi Sane, Nia Jax and Lash Legend in a fun 8-woman tag effort that kept the energy high and was actually way better than the women's WarGames match at Survivor Series. Nah, yours truly will never miss a chance to rake WWE over hot coals for that lame duck double ring cage match.
After this finish, one can see a title change coming a mile off on Monday’s Raw. Rhea and IYO will surely topple The Kabuki Warriors, then Ripley and SKY will probably have Nia and Lash waiting for them afterwards. Charlotte and Alexa too. Michael Cole and Corey Graves hyped up Legend loads during this bout for a reason though, and it's interesting that Flair and Bliss were handed the jobber entrance treatment despite their star power.
Maybe their union won't last too much longer then.
The match was a great watch anyway, and it feels like the babyfaces winning was the correct call. SmackDown's live crowd went positively banana (trademark: Pat Patterson) for the finish. There's no denying that Ripley has cooled off as a must see character since this time last year, but her team with IYO is popular enough to work.
Again, this is the bout that should've happened at Survivors. WWE need to start learning lessons about what happens when they shoehorn combos into major gimmick scenarios just for the sake of it. These women didn't need all of the extra bells and whistles. Their story didn't merit it, and they were perfectly fine simply wrestling a straight up 4v4 tag.
3. Melo Keeps The US Goodness Going
Carmelo Hayes beat Johnny Gargano in a tidy United States Title match. No, fans didn’t (for a second) believe that Melo’s newly won belt was under threat, but he’s building something decent as a babyface and has people in his corner. That sympathetic babyface role worked for Sami Zayn and Ilja Dragunov as United States Champions, and it’ll work for Hayes.
Of course, it would be lovely if Carmelo actually got a full blown feud rather than doing the ‘Open Challenge’ thing weekly forever, but it’s hard to argue against matches of this quality. Looking forwards, Tama Tonga is still due a United States Title shot. It's a real shame we didn’t see Tama vs. Ilja, but Tonga vs. Hayes would be class if it happened too. Perhaps Shinsuke Nakamura could poke his nose in on that fun to keep...whatever's bubbling there between he and Tama going?
Cue Solo getting steaming mad at the thought of his troops making alliances without his say so.
The men's United States Title scene did keep SmackDown purring during the final few months of last year, and there's no sign that's set to stop in 2026. The timing couldn't be better for Melo either - management will need him to step up and work lengthy matches to pad out these 3 hour episodes, and he's ready for that challenge.
Here's hoping creative don't forget all about Dragunov too. Maybe a heel turn will be in the works for him as he targets the belt he just lost to Hayes. That'd ease concerns that US Champs won't get proper rivalries as well.
2. “Happy New Year, Miz!”
Credit where it's due: It was a fabulous decision to kick off the first 3 hour edition of SmackDown in 2026 with a moany Miz eating some RKO goodness. Randy Orton returning for the first time since October to hit his finish injected the show with much-needed energy from the off. That's something WWE will probably lean on throughout this latest 3 hour run, and rightly so.
Miz was ranting about his miserable 2025, including last week’s loss to Joe Hendry, then he pitched a tag-team with Orton like that was ever going to happen. Sensing what was coming, fans were delighted to see Randy blast the heel then repeat the trick when they chanted "one more time" over and over again. Better yet, Orton's evening wasn't over there.
Later, he approached Cody Rhodes and told his ex-stablemate he’s coming for the WWE Title once his old Legacy cohort is finished with Drew McIntyre and this '3 Stages Of Hell' business in Berlin. Arguably, that suggests that McIntyre has no chance of leaving Germany as the new WWE Champion, which might irk some, but nothing is guaranteed at time of writing.
It'd be a seismic shock if Drew walked out of the steel cage following all 3 falls next week, then dropped the belt back to Cody in time for Rhodes clashing with Randy at WrestleMania 42. SmackDown's top title scene does need that kind of shift heading through the most important quarter of the year, y'know.
It's fantastic to see Randy back doing his thing anyway.
1. Trick Williams Throws His Name In The Hat
Segment of the night goes to a war of words between Sami Zayn and Trick Williams. It was to the point and excellently handled from beginning to end. Sami was in the middle of a story about explaining to his son why he’s never been World Champion when Trick interrupted and dripped star power. Williams said that, unlike Sami, it wouldn’t take him 20 years to get to the top.
He plans to be World Champ sooner rather than later.
Zayn didn't like that and said that Trick needed to be humbled pronto. This is a sweet first step for Williams on the main roster, to be honest. The story of Sami humbling him so he can feed his own title dreams works, and the matches these guys could have should be stunning. First up, Trick has Rey Fenix one on one; Fenix has been lost in the shuffle for a while now, but he can be trusted to put on a show and look competitive against the former 2-time NXT Champion.
Williams must be thrilled with his performance on Friday night. He looked every bit the top star as soon as he walked through the curtain. The fans in Buffalo knew exactly who was coming out (which isn't guaranteed due to the standard of some entrance music these days!), and they were buzzed to see him confront somebody as respected as Sami.
This is only the start for someone who could, all going well, be the breakout main roster of 2026. "Whoop That Trick" indeed.
What did you think of WWE's first SmackDown in 2026? For more wrestling, check out 12 WWE Nightmares That Could Come True In 2026 and 10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE Raw From 2008!