5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (26 Dec - Results & Review)

WWE announced '3 Stages Of Hell' and changed the US Title on the final SmackDown of 2025.

Carmelo Hayes WWE United States Title
WWE.com

The final SmackDown of 2025 is in the bag, and now Triple H/WWE's creative team will be looking to make a splash with 3 hour-long shows early in the new year. Anyone who has tuned into Smackers since summer will know things need to change a little around here. Far too many blue brand episodes have come and gone without much to shout about. They're rarely outright terrible, but there's a reason why many are side-eying friends at the prospect of an extra hour from January onwards.

At least 2025 went out with a bang.

Drew McIntyre lined up a lesser-spotted stipulation bout for his apparent blow off with Cody Rhodes, and that'll take place in Berlin, Germany a few weeks from now. WWE also switched the United States Title, gave the floor to Joe Hendry so the charismatic Scot could show off his singing and brawling skills, and there was even room for another NXT star to lay down a marker for things to come in 2026.

SmackDown's biggest problems are on the women's division side. Honestly, Trips has to sit down and have a proper think about what he's doing with names like Jade Cargill, Giulia, Chelsea Green and others. They're all too talented to be mixing it in uninspiring (and that's being kind!) storylines/feuds.

Here's all the good and bad from Friday's pre-taped episode. Big announcements, title changes, a quasi-'Superstar Shakeup' and more - SmackDown did have a lot to offer, but some parts sagged badly.


Downs...

3. Why Were They Here?

Charlotte Flair Alexa Bliss Rhea Ripley IYO SKY
WWE.com

Scrap the brand split.

WWE had to stop, think for a second and realise that their own booking threatened to lessen the impact of a "free agent" segment later in the show. So, Rhea Ripley and IYO SKY just happened to attend SmackDown for no real reason despite being tied to Raw? They approached Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss, which led to Nick Aldis setting up an 8-woman tag-team match for next week 3 hour episode.

This is literally the most uninspiring and clumsy way they could’ve gone about things, but OK. Look, the match will probably be fine in execution, but WWE needs to scrap the roster pretence. They never honour it anyway, but then announcers occasionally talk about the Draft/brand split like it’s some super-important set of rules that GMs have to adhere to. It's total nonsense, and everyone knows it.

Ripley and SKY had no business being on this week's SmackDown. The aforementioned 8-woman tag could've been set without them in the house, and that would've made some Trick Williams-related business later in the episode feel a little stronger. The NXT star deserved that spotlight. No, this skit didn't murder his spot on the show by any means, but it did feel unnecessary.

In future, if WWE wants to book cross-pollination, then give workers from one show a reason to be hanging around backstage for the other. What? Did Rhea and IYO just hear that SmackDown had better catering than Raw, or something like that? Flimsy stuff like this must be called out until Hunter sorts it.


2. A Nothing Women’s Tag

Giulia Chelsea Green
WWE.com

Chelsea Green and Alba Fyre beat Giulia and Kiana James in around 3 minutes on Friday night. These women are really trying, but WWE needs to help them out a bit more than they have been. Giulia just isn’t over either, and that’s holding things back. Fans clearly prefer Green, but she’s still doing the arrogant, borderline delusional heel gimmick. It’s a weird mix; yes, it's cool that these workers have something to do, but Trips badly needs to refocus on the women’s side of SmackDown in the new year.

The boss pushed some of these characters into the background a little too much in 2025, and that’s caught up with them. Put it this way: Why should anyone care about Giulia hunting down Chelsea at this point, or that she beat Green in a nothing tag bout? There doesn't seem to be any punishment for failure anyway. Cast your gaze over to the mainline Women's Title scene and you'll see Michin (who regularly fails) going after reigning champ Jade Cargill.

More on that in a bit.

There's nothing to like about the Women's United States Title picture other than the fact that Chelsea is a far more entertaining champ than Giulia by default. It's concerning that the belt, whilst retaining some hope on Green, has been stuffed so far down the pecking order than it'd need to break its neck pecking to rise back up it. That's on the writers, and they don't get a pass for it.

Sort this out. Also, whilst you're at it...


1. An Automatic Weekly Down

Jade Cargill
WWE

It’s beyond rubbish that feuding with Michin and B-FAB is all WWE has for Jade Cargill now she’s Women’s Champ. The promotion knew they'd be taking SmackDown from 2-3 hours starting with the 2 January 2026 episode, and yet this tripe is all they had in mind for Jade?! She should be kicking in office doors and dishing out clotheslines for that formatting blunder.

This week, a couple of quick backstage promos went over old ground. Nobody said anything new, and the whole thing is just so boring. It’ll take one hell of a match to turn the nose up on this story, let's be real. Triple H also better have something major in store for Jade once SmackDown settles into that 3 hour groove again, because the show could honestly use a proper female feud to reflect her star power.

Besides, they’ve been brushing the title off since Tiffany Stratton was champion, and that needs to stop. It's nonsensical, counterproductive and unenjoyable to watch strong acts like Stratton or Cargill flounder the way they have been with the gold around their waists. They've both tried to make the best of scraps handed to them, but something has to change for the better in 2026.

It's too late for Tiffy's reign, but Jade is different. She's begging for a Bianca Belair comeback, or just something that people care to see. Going back and forth with Michin and B-FAB isn't cutting it, and it never will. The punishment continued on this week's show though, because of course it did.

SOMEBODY STICK UP A HAND DURING CREATIVE MEETINGS AND OFFER SOMETHING ELSE.


Ups...

5. Trick Williams Sows Some Seeds

Cody Rhodes Trick Williams Nick Aldis
WWE.com

Trick Williams is about to slide into the cocksure heel role Carmelo Hayes was playing before he split from The Miz and went babyface a while back. During a pre-tape, Trick could be seen waiting for Nick Aldis in his office. Initially, Williams deferred to the WWE Champion when Cody Rhodes came in and asked him to leave, but then Trick came back to say Cody needed to hold onto the title “real tight” if Aldis throws cash his way and signs him.

He called himself “the hottest free agent”, so let a bidding war between Raw and SmackDown commence. Trick is just one of several knocking around the place (Je'Von Evans is in that bracket too). Again, this segment would've been far more pressing if WWE ever honoured the brand split properly, because what's really stopping Williams from showing up wherever and whenever he likes?

On the plus side, Cody vs. Trick should be something special that WWE builds to long term. It’d be one hell of a match, and it's about time that wrestlers started ruffling some feathers immediately as soon as they're called up from developmental. Not everybody needs the slow burn treatment. Williams has been killing it on NXT for years now, so he's ready.

He's Oba Femi ready.

Sowing some seeds for Trick vs. Cody was smart. NXT call ups shooting their shot at the poster boy makes sense rather than...say...having them target R-Truth or somebody like that. It's a huge compliment to Williams that he looked every bit the star in such a short promo skit.


4. A Great Way To Help Joe Hendry Bed In

Joe Hendry The Miz Otis
WWE.com

Say his name and he appears etc etc.

Reports say that Joe Hendry will be on SmackDown permanently going forwards. Beating The Miz in this ‘Miracle On 34th Street Fight’ deal was a fine way to get the ball rolling on that. Not the tiny balls rolling though. Leave that to Miz, apparently. You know what you’re going to get with these festive brawls. They’re purely played for laughs, but don’t always work. The good news is that this one did, and Miz did everything in his power to make Hendry look like a rising star on the main roster.

Akira Tozawa, Otis and R-Truth were involved in this too - Tozawa was an elf, Otis was Santa, and Truth was disguised as the bunny. There could be an odd couple tag-team thing in Hendry and Truth; this isn't the first time they've shown some chemistry onscreen together. All in, the match represented a fun and goofy way to kick off the final SmackDown of 2025.

Miz can take this sort of humiliation in stride, by the way, because he’s unflappable as a character. Dude could lose 500 matches in a row, then come out and talk about the time he beat John Cena at WrestleMania to get some heat back on himself. That's when you know someone's part of the furniture (which is meant as a compliment).

Hendry got strong crowd reactions for his singing and his power moves during the 'Street Fight'. His poise is top notch, his skills on the mic better than most, and now he can either go solo or work a comedy duo with Truth. Things are looking good for the hot Scot.


3. Lash Legend Shows Real Promise

Lash Legend Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

WWE want Lash Legend to have a biiiiiiiiig 2026, and matches like this one vs. Charlotte Flair show she’s capable of great things if she keeps working hard. Even somebody with the sun in their eyes could see that there's a solid shell for Lash to build on. She has talent, doesn't appear to think she's the finished article, and is obviously popular enough with the roster that veterans are willing to give her a leg up the ladder.

Oh, also - that spot with her holding opponents in a fall away slam position but bouncing them between the top and middle ropes should stick. It’s bullying behaviour, and it fits Legend as a heel. Aesthetically, Lash has the visible power to be considered a threat to anybody. Charlotte was giving here as well. She laid out and let Legend kick lumps out of her for 80/90% of the match, then Legend’s inexperience showed.

The relative rookie got distracted by Alexa Bliss and Nia Jax scuffling, so Flair capitalised and rolled her up. Michael Cole did well to explain that it was actually Flair who was distracted at first, but her experience edge meant she could refocus on the task at hand. Meanwhile, poor Lash couldn't. Yep, really solid work from both these women.

One can see this being a bumper PLE title bout somewhere down the road if Legend keeps improving the way she is. Seeing her drop Nia Jax as a partner longer term will be satisfying, then Lash will only go from strength to strength. Surely Triple H saw enough from this performance to keep her in mind for higher profile spots in the new year.


2. '3 Stages Of Hell' Incoming

Drew McIntyre Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Drew McIntyre was a delight as a horrible git trying to get under Cody’s skin. First, he feigned an apology to referee Dan Engler for laying hands on him before his suspension, then McIntyre laid out a tasty ‘3 Stages Of Hell’ stipulation to Rhodes for SmackDown in a few weeks. Drew didn’t detail what each stage will be though, so we’ll have to wait for that announcement.

Personally, this guy isn't so sure they needed to go with the ‘Dusty’s in hell’ line, but it is what it is and Cody was clearly cool with it or it wouldn't have happened. Even so, this will conjure up images in select fan minds of Randy Orton bashing Eddie Guerrero to Rey Mysterio back in 2006. The circumstances are different (Guerrero had only passed a few months before that line), but still.

Bold statement incoming: Drew has to win the WWE Title when this '3 Stages' encounter happens. That’d rock the road to Royal Rumble/WrestleMania and give him some much-needed credibility in title matches to boot. Cody’s a big boy, so he can take the loss and move forwards. Plus, Rhodes could always reclaim the belt before 'Mania if the creative team begins to panic.

This will be the first ‘3 Stages’ on the main roster since John Cena vs. Ryback in 2013. It's the first one in WWE generally since Johnny Gargano vs. Adam Cole on NXT in August 2019 (which feels like a bloody lifetime ago!), so there's merit to Drew busting out the announcement in 2025. Fans don't see these epics too often, so this one should land.

'No DQ', 'Steel Cage' and then 'Last Man Standing' could be a fun combo. Just saying.


1. US Title Match Goes Hard

Carmelo Hayes WWE United States Title
WWE.com

Fighting champion and honourable son-a-ma-gun (credit: Santino Marella) Ilja Dragunov gave Carmelo Hayes another crack at the United States Title due to Tommaso Ciampa’s interference on the 5 December episode. That proved to be one battle too many for Ilja. Hayes won the belt following a fab 20 minute match that went back and forth. The action really was top tier, especially towards the finish.

This is a pivotal moment in Melo’s main roster career, so here’s hoping he gets a title reign to be proud of. Continuing the ‘Open Challenge’ gimmick wouldn’t be a bad idea. That’d fill a hole on the coming 3 hour long SmackDowns and give Hayes something meaningful to do. Saying that, maybe a standalone feud would be best, because Carmelo really needs a story he can point to as a turning point for him since moving up from NXT.

His bout with Dragunov was fantastic regardless.

Ilja’s title reign was littered with this kind of goodness, so hopefully Triple H doesn’t just forget all about him now he’s no longer champ. WWE can be guilty of that. It's like a child having seemingly endless fun with a shiny new toy. Then, once they get a new one, that old boy suddenly seems irrelevant. Has 'The Game' never shed tears over Toy Story?! What a monster. He was defo Sid growing up.

Back to the match. It was a slick showing, one typical for Ilja and more in tune with what Hayes was doing on NXT before moving up to SmackDown in the 2024 Draft.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE SmackDown From 2008 and 8 AEW Nightmares That Could Come True In 2026!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.