5 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (23 Jan - Results & Review)
WWE sets up things to come at Saturday Night's Main Event; Jacob Fatu tells Cody Rhodes how it is.
Friday's episode of SmackDown had a clear goal in mind: Hype this weekend's edition of Saturday Night's Main Event, and paint the show as a possible game-changer for Royal Rumble. Did it achieve that? On one hand, absolutely. On the other, things look a little meh. A few of the matches at SNME could prove tricky, but at least we'll get a new WWE Title contender out of it.
As the equal share suggests, this was a middle of the road SmackDown. WWE content is rarely outright awful these days, but the writing team never threatened to reach the heights they did with last week's blue brand offering. That 16 January edition had a lot to brag about. The 23 Jan one...not so much. A trio of inspired matches and a fabulous face to face did serve up bags of entertainment though.
The 'Downs' may seem a tad nitpicky to some. Fair enough, but they're just one guy's opinion and come from a good place. This fan wants everybody on the WWE roster to look good, and it's just a pity that some of the material they're asked to work with is paper thin or (worse) falls apart quickly. Hopefully, that'll change due to the hyper-charged interest the Rumble-WrestleMania season typically creates.
On the plus side, it was a star-enhancing episode for Jacob Fatu, Jordynne Grace, Kiana James and (at times) Trick Williams. Triple H might need to think twice before booking that main event again, right enough! Here's all the good and bad.
Downs...
5. WWE Hung Drew Out To Dry Here
Attention, WWE creative: Simply scribbling down 'Drew McIntyre talks about the Fatal-4-Way at SNME for 10 minutes before leaving' and calling it a day isn't compelling. You'd think the team would've learned that lesson last summer with Cody Rhodes. Back then, Cody was tasked with going out to the ring with a microphone to say nothing of note. Sometimes, he managed to salvage it. Other times, he didn't.
Why take the risk?
Here, McIntyre appeared to talk about that Fatal-4-Way and bragged about being WWE Champ. There wasn’t much to his promo, being brutally honest, and it really did smack of those one man promos the company had Cody do. Drew didn’t do anything wrong here, that’s worth saying - the big Scot just didn’t have much material to work with, and so he had nothing to say that hadn’t already been said.
Thankfully, the live crowd in Montreal came along for the ride and injected the skit with some much-needed energy, but McIntyre's going nowhere speech took place during a sorry lull for the episode. It badly ran out of steam around midway through, and things never really picked up again. A little more thought and care needed to be taken on those format sheets.
Something else of note: Drew is getting heavy babyface reactions from audiences no matter what he does. They were invested in his 'nearly man' gimmick before winning the WWE Title, and most fans appear legit happy that he seized the belt from Rhodes. That's something to keep an eye on.
4. Boring Main Event Drags
Some combinations just don't mesh well. For example, even legends like Steve Austin and The Undertaker toiled when trying to put on satisfying pay-per-view main events for years. Similarly, Scott Steiner and the English language has rarely been a great match. OK, couldn't resist that little joke. Scotty did cut some tasty promos in his time, and at least everyone remembers the bad ones.
Trick Williams vs. Damian Priest looks set to become the next match up WWE should avoid. It didn't work in the main event slot on this week's SmackDown. The whole match was a struggle, they didn't gel, and it was obvious from the first minute that Sami Zayn was going to cause the DQ. Then, the night ended with a pair of Randy Orton RKO’s to Trick and Sami, but it wasn’t enough to save the day.
Williams has clear star potential after coming up from NXT, but one thing needs repeating: Never, ever put him in the ring with Priest again. It wasn’t the right blend. Neither guy could lean on their power game, it looked like they were moving through treacle for around 99% of the thing, and those fans in Montreal (who normally go nuts for anything) were quiet as mice.
This shouldn't be taken as some massive warning sign for Trick on the main roster, but Triple H will have to be careful with him going forwards. No, this didn't work. No lasting damage done. Creative will say they had to try it. Onto the next.
3. AJ Styles Gets A Pointless Match
Fair warning! Some will disagree with this 'Down' and start looking out the pitchforks due to the criticism, but it felt pretty disappointing that Nick Aldis invited AJ Styles to SmackDown to line up a SNME match vs. Shinsuke Nakamura. Like, that was it? That's why he brought AJ to Friday nights. Did he even consult with Raw GM Adam Pearce about any of this?!
Styles is winding down his WWE career and there’s still talks he’ll be done after the match with Gunther at Royal Rumble, so they’re clearly squeezing one last bout vs. Nakamura in. It feels unnecessary. Yes, giving AJ some olive branches and making him happy during this retirement sprint is important, but this match has come completely out of left field and lacks spice.
It isn't like Shin has been doing much of note on his own, and now he's crammed awkwardly in as a tune up match for Styles before the 'Phenomenal One' wrestles Gunther. Why? Just why? The whole deal is terribly rushed, and it's not like there was any clamouring from the fanbase for a rematch. Michael Cole called it years in the making, which is a stretch.
Pointless would sum it up.
If anything, Styles shouldn't be wrestling again until he goes at it with Gunther. Accepting this makes him look foolish. Some may argue brave instead, but it's senseless. WWE are padding SNME and nothing more. The least they could've done was have Gunther promise Naka a pay off if he injures AJ. The least.
2. Glad The Titles Changed, But…
...you know where this moan is headed.
Solo Sikoa and Tama Tonga beat Dexter Lumis and Joe Gacy to win the tag titles. Anyone who reads these pieces regularly will know how much that’ll please this guy, but the match was fairly nondescript from start to finish. The Wyatt Sicks getting a stranglehold on SmackDown’s tag ranks last year wrecked it, and it’ll take more than one match to sort everything. That's just the truth.
The Sicks vs. MFTs rivalry has had some brief highlights here or there, but hopefully it’s over. There are far too many talented teams sitting around doing nothing whilst this is going on. Honestly, no clue what to do with any of the members involved afterwards, but this Sicks stuff has to stop. It's been a painful exercise once the initial heartfelt sentiment (due to the fact it's a tribute to Bray Wyatt) faded.
Paying respects to a fallen favourite is one thing. Destroying an entire division and stinking up the place in some of the most boring title matches ever is another. Fingers crossed we can draw a line under all of this without getting to the seemingly inevitable Solo vs. Uncle Howdy match; it's actually a slight shocker that WWE didn't plonk that on the lineup for Saturday Night's Main Event this time.
Yep, it's a positive that the tag titles are off Lumis and Gacy, but let's not get ahead of ourselves. Nobody is out of the woods yet. At least not until someone breaks into WWE creative meetings and tears 'Wyatt Sicks vs. MFTs rematch' off the script printouts.
1. Pesky Mask Business Holds Everyone Back
The upside to this is that most will appreciate WWE’s writers trying to give everyone something to fight about, but that doesn’t mean it’s automatically interesting. Nathan Frazer beat Johnny Gargano to theoretically win Axiom’s mask back from Gargano. As aforementioned last week, his tag partner likely has loads of these things in storage, so why is this particular mask so special? Also, Fraxiom looked like total goofs when Gargano and Candice LeRae grabbed the mask back and ran away.
The saga rolls on.
Unfortunately, Triple H's crack team of writers (looking at you, Road Dogg) managed to fudge the hot SmackDown tag-team division and make everyone in it less interesting. Also, Johnny might need a new pal now Tommaso Ciampa is gone or he’s cooked. Put it this way: It would be a colossal shock if he broke out into a successful singles run without a partner there to back him up.
Fraxiom's lot in life at the minute seems to be 'well-meaning idiots'. They could easily grab that mask back from Gargano and LeRae or tell the couple they simply don't care about it. That's how flimsy the story is. This is verging on fighting over a Japanese shampoo commercial like Booker T and Edge did back in 2002.
If nothing else, that iconic pair could point to money as motivation. Axiom and Frazer can't do the same in 2026. They should be banging on the creative team's door and suggesting ways to make things better, because they're in trouble if this is all WWE has for them.
Ups...
5. More Strong Women’s Division Work
Every 'Down' was slapped about by an 'Up' this week.
For example, it's really nice to report that Jade Cargill finally has something fun going on as Women’s Champion. Jordynne Grace was at ringside for her win over Chelsea Green. Montreal’s faithful were firmly behind Chelsea (they're not the only ones - she's one of the most endearing workers on the roster), but everyone knew she was never winning the match. It was a good watch regardless.
Green was given just enough to bring this above squash level, and the interplay between Cargill and Grace is working for both. Jade doesn't feel the need to get physical with Grace for one of two reasons. A) She's biding her time and convincing herself that Jordynne isn't a threat. B) Jade is secretly intimidated by the ex-TNA star and fancies bullying lower tier workers instead. We're about to find out which one is true.
Again, it raised an eyebrow that WWE didn't pop this on Saturday Night's Main Event, 'cause Cargill vs. Grace seemed perfect for that. It would've been a fine fifth match option for the card if management fancied it, and it's heartening that Trips is starting to realise what he has in Cargill as champ.
Tiffany Stratton's own reign fizzled out last year, so it'd be a nightmare if the same thing happened again with Jade. Lining up challengers as credible as Grace is one way to avoid that. The fact that Chelsea got to look awesome is a bonus ball in the scenario.
4. Whoop That Trick (Literally)
There were grumbles aplenty with Friday's main event, but yours truly has no problems with the opening promo train segment. Trick Williams had to eat some humble pie after the way he’s been throwing his weight around since arriving on SmackDown, and this did a fine enough job of setting the scene for his match vs. Damian Priest and the Fatal-4-Way at SNME.
Also, nice transition by WWE from that trio into a fired up promo from Randy Orton. This sort of thing is exactly what TV is for, and it was never boring. Unlike the headliner. Seriously though, there's a lot to like about Sami Zayn's heartfelt quest to become World/WWE Champion, Trick is coming across as an arrogant git who believes his own hype, and Priest is living proof of learning to walk before you can run on the main roster.
Randy looking on from behind the scenes but refusing to get involved until he could pick the right moment fit his status too - Cathy Kelley even brought that up when approaching 'The Viper' for a few comments. Then, Orton called it a dumb question likely because he knew he'd been rumbled. Cathy = investigative journalist.
Seeing veterans like Zayn and Priest double up on Williams but still have their own aggro going on is realistic and in-fitting with the Fatal-4-Way come Saturday. Honestly, WWE could've left it here without what happened later on at the end of the show. That opening segment gave SNME's match enough build.
They didn't actually need the Priest vs. Trick match to put a bow on things.
3. Triple Threat Tag Brings The Energy
Kiana James and Giulia vs. Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss vs. Nia Jax and Lash Legend was all action and kept the tempo up without ever dropping. Together, all 6 women brought the energy of the show right back up after a serious lull. Plus, this proved to be another coming out party for James. WWE better be keeping an eye on her work, because she’s outshining her partner right now.
All going well, Kiana will shine up nicely again vs. Rhea Ripley and IYO SKY at some point too. First. RHIYO have to contend with Liv Morgan and Roxanne Perez this Saturday. Realistically, they'll blast clean through James and Giulia whenever that match happens (hopefully on an episode of SmackDown 'cause the champs can go anywhere), but that shouldn't dishearten the challengers.
Friday's win was opportunistic for Kiana. Is it outlandish to suggest that she'll be the breakout star of the duo, not Giulia? No-one could've even predicted that as a question when the pair were put together, but it's a valid point. James has been seriously impressive whether she's working singles or tags so far this year. She's become one to watch.
So, energetic matches with purpose that don’t outstay their welcome. That's a big yes! This number one contendership situation was fast-moving, never sloppy, and it had unexpected winners. Going in, some thought for sure that Jax and Legend would get the nod. Nope. WWE went with Kiana and Giulia instead, possibly as a reward for the former's hard graft since becoming Giulia's mouthpiece.
Good match and good segment all round.
2. They Needed This
Michael Cole was conducting a love-in style sit down interview with Cody Rhodes when Jacob Fatu walked in to confront him. Smartly, Cole got the hell out of dodge and Fatu took his place. It was intense, it was upfront and it was…helpful to the issues these guys have. Praise the wrestling overlords for ensuring that Jacob mentioned how he was locked in on Drew McIntyre before Cody put his hands on him inside the steel cage.
That needed to be addressed, because it didn’t make much sense at the time when Rhodes went after someone he has no beef with. Score another for the star making performance from Jacob here - it added some last minute gloss to their match at SNME too. That’s really all you can ask from a skit like this. Well played, everyone.
Cody continued flirting with heel mannerisms and statements by bringing up Fatu's time in prison (which was a verbal low blow), and that was welcome as well. It upped the intensity between both guys further, and it made Jacob point out that he hasn't even started being truly violent with Rhodes just yet. After remarks like the one Cody shot off, that's coming.
Credit to WWE's camera crew for getting up close and personal on their faces, by the way. Directors also told the crew to shoot Jacob and Cody from underneath, so that gave the promo a claustrophobic air that really worked for it. Simple as this: Rhodes vs. Fatu at SNME needed something this fraught and enjoyable.
Jacob was at his menacing best, and Cody gave as good as he was getting by almost threatening to heel it up.
1. Great Match, Great Finish!
The year is 2046. WWE boss Aurora Levesque has just booked a United States Title rematch between Carmelo Hayes and Ilja Dragunov. Together, the aging duo tear it up and leave fans breathless. Life is good. AI wrote the script for their promo exchange before the match. Sorry, couldn't resist that last gentle jibe.
Hayes ran it back vs. Dragunov on Friday's SmackDown. The bell to bell content of the match was excellent. There was a springboard DDT from Melo that grabbed a near fall and looked amazing, and the pair even spliced in some comedy on the ring apron; Ilja smiled through the pain and said he was having fun. Hayes: “What’s wrong with you?!”.
Some reading this may hate The Miz getting involved, but it fits his general involvement in the story (he has history with Carmelo, don't forget) and his bid to force respect back out of Hayes. The fact that Melo didn’t see his old partner's interference until watching a replay worked too. He was hot about Miz poking his nose in, as he should be.
Almost hilariously, Dragunov bled hardway yet again for the zillionth time. It seems that dude can't get through a match without dinging his eyebrow/nose/lip/ear/any other body part. Thankfully, the blood never takes away from his bouts or gets in the way. In fact, it adds to his own brand of pain theatre.
It looks like WWE plans to move away from the 'Open Challenge' thing and start a tri-pronged feud between Hayes, Ilja and Miz. Eventually, Dragunov should exit stage left and leave 'Melo Don't Miz' to thrash out their differences. Top match though.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 15 MORE Incredible WWE Attitude Era Moments Nobody Ever Talks About and 15 MORE Incredible WWE Ruthless Aggression Era Moments Nobody Ever Talks About!