5 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Dec 3)

Brock Lesnar shines; WWE are obsessed with pies; SmackDown books a big return.

Brock Lesnar Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Thanks for coming, Sami Zayn.

Everyone's favourite delusional heel won a Battle Royal last week to earn himself a crack at Roman Reigns and the Universal Title. Anyone who thought Sami would get that shot at Day 1 was wrong though - WWE decided to give him the match on SmackDown. Well, sort of.

Brock Lesnar's return was the biggest selling point for Friday's show. The 'Beast' had a say in how Zayn's sudden opportunity played out, and it's now Lesnar himself who will challenge Reigns come 1 January. Most probably saw that coming, to be fair, but WWE did a neat job of shoving Sami out the way on FOX.

That was one of few booking high points, sadly. Warring ex-tag partners weren't given nearly enough time to work with, another duo were made to look like total simpletons, and the Drew McIntyre and Jeff Hardy pairing ended up looking like extras from Michael Jackson's 'Smooth Criminal' video shoot.

Then, there was the pie bullsh*t. This latest obsession is as unfunny as it is ineffective. There's no way it'll help the next SmackDown Women's Title feud along either, but WWE just can't help themselves.

Here are all the 'Ups' and the 'Downs'...


Downs...

5. Too Short, Fellas!

Sheamus Cesaro
WWE.com

Less than four minutes.

That's all Sheamus vs. Cesaro got handed on SmackDown. Man, you'd think these two were some wet-behind-the-ears, inexperienced newbies who didn't really know how to put a match together. They're not - they're some of the most reliable workers WWE has on Friday nights, and they deserved more.

This battle of former Bar members should've been a hard-hitting classic. Instead, Sheamus won without too much of a struggle after shouting at his old partner and letting him know he's nowhere near as good as Ridge Holland. Gee, that'll make Cesaro look good, won't it?!

It should be criminal to have lads like this under contract when you're only booking them to go three-four mins. Cesaro was literally challenging for the Universal Title earlier this year. All that momentum he carried post-WrestleMania season has been lost.


4. The Power Of Rock Compels You

The Viking Raiders Shinsuke Nakamura Rick Boogs Pat McAfee
WWE.com

So, Shinsuke Nakamura and Rick Boogs effectively cost The Viking Raiders a match with Los Lotharios. Instead of being upset, Erick and Ivar were calmed by Boogs playing their entrance theme on guitar. This is why nobody cares about the one-time War Machine anymore.

They come across as total goofs.

Someone backstage in WWE will call this "sports entertainment", but there still needs to be some protection for certain characters. The Vikings are meant to be destructive brutes who strike fear into the hearts of men everywhere. That's how WWE portrays them occasionally. Then, guff like this happens.

The Raiders should've been seething that Naka and Boogs even got involved at all. Nah, why do that when you can have them dance like Fandango. Big, scary dudes dancing is a proven winner, eh? It worked for Lord Tensai, after all...


3. What Is The Point Of This?

Drew McIntyre Jeff Hardy
WWE.com

Life is full of mysteries; what is the meaning of life, for example? Who was 'Jack The Ripper'? Why are Drew McIntyre and Jeff Hardy still feuding with Happy Corbin and Madcap Moss when this is so blatantly going absolutely nowhere in a hurry?

That might be the biggest.

Happy Talk was painful, and the heel pair's jokes were so poor that they couldn't even be called funny 'in a bad way'. Then, the visual of McIntyre and Hardy posing in Corbin and Moss' hats after coming out to beat them down was...certainly a decision.

Right, get this: Drew is ticked off that he was omitted from last week's Battle Royal. He went from complaining about that and demanding answers to mucking around with Jeff Hardy. Has anyone on the creative team stopped to ask why? Do any of them care, or are they just trying to fill minutes?


2. “2 Pie Toni"

Toni Storm
WWE

Eek.

Remember when Becky Lynch referred to herself as "Becky 2 Belts"? That was fine, because Lynch was legitimately the dual Raw and SmackDown Women's Champ at the time. Fast forward to 2021 and Toni Storm is "2 Pie Toni". Not quite the same.

Toni literally called herself that during a backstage promo with Kayla Braxton on this week's show. The would-be SmackDown Women's Title challenger noted that everybody is calling her such a name after Charlotte Flair slapped a few pies in her face recently. That's doubtful, and WWE's wording here was horrible.

Watching Storm refer to herself as "2 Pie Toni" is hard to stomach. Her potential is being thrown to the dogs with the pie business, but few will be 100% bowled over to read that. WWE are dropping the ball big time with another promising young star though.


1. More Pie-Related “Hilarity”

Charlotte Flair Pie
WWE.com

Toni getting some measure of revenge on Charlotte for pie-gate wasn't the worst idea, but did they need to use more bloody pies? What's the obsession here? It's so juvenile to see someone take that food to the face every week. Lord only knows how this is supposed to gear fans up for a title match.

Remember, that's the point here - Storm will challenge Flair for the SmackDown Women's Title eventually. This week, Charlotte knocked back Toni's pitch (for the millionth time) before getting thumped with Vince McMahon's favourite gag. This is not good.

Not good at all.

Now, this writer isn't opposed to some comedy on a wrestling show. Laughs have their place, but that's the problem with this: WWE crowds aren't giggling along. Instead, most are wondering aloud how this is supposed to get Storm over as a red hot babyface challenger.


Ups...

5. Maybe The Start Of Something?

Shayna Baszler Sasha Banks
WWE.com

OK, so Shayna Baszler lost to Sasha Banks here, but that won't be a problem if WWE gets the ball rolling on a long-awaited lone wolf character for the 'Queen Of Spades'. She's been stuck with crummy tag partners for far too long. It's time to let Shayna fly solo and show her skills again.

The match was decent too, and Banks is a big enough star that her win didn't feel like a waste of Baszler. Also, WWE's pre-match vignette was akin to pressing the reset button on Shayna - they better follow this up with something meaningful next week. It's vital that the next babyface champion has some solid contenders.

Baszler would be phenomenal as a straight-up heel challenger.

Yours truly is choosing to look on the bright side of this defeat. He liked the hype video and the fact that Shayna locked on a submission early. Plus, it was fun to see Baszler without someone like Nia Jax, Sonya Deville or Natalya for once.


4. Back To What Works

Kofi Kingston Jey Uso
WWE.com

SmackDown's current tag division is a little thin on the ground.

The Viking Raiders are a joke, Los Lotharios are just getting started, Shinsuke Nakamura and Rick Boogs aren't even a full-time team (Shin is Intercontinental Champion) and the Sheamus/Ridge Holland combo is in its infancy too. That left Xavier Woods and Kofi Kingston as the only real challengers for The Usos.

It's hardly ideal that these two squads are at loggerheads again, especially when Woods just won King Of The Ring, but Kofi Kingston's comeback worked well on this week's show. He got a decent pop from the live crowd, and then New Day got to stand tall over the reigning champs.

That, rather conveniently, helped sell the idea that Roman Reigns' empire is crumbling around him. Hopefully, that's only temporary - Woods/Kofi don't need the tag straps again any time soon, and The Usos are fine champions anyway. Now, if only WWE could prep another babyface team to challenge during WrestleMania season.


3. Cold Killer Brock Lesnar

Sami Zayn Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

Brock Lesnar is at his best when he's intimidating the living f*ck out of everyone. He and Sami Zayn, who proved to be great foil for the comeback man, kicked off SmackDown with a fine face-to-face bit. It was a nice change of pace to have their dominant anti-hero meets cowardly heel dynamic at the top of the broadcast.

Very few wrestlers have the ability to look foolish without losing all of their credibility with the audience, but Sami nails that role. He's a real credit to SmackDown every single week, regardless of what he's doing, and this was yet more evidence of his importance.

Even Lesnar seemed to be having a good time out there.

The way Brock goes from laughing and joking to super-serious at the flick of a switch is sensational. Like Zayn with the delusional/cowardly traits, nobody does menace better in WWE than Lesnar. This was a fine way to open the night.


2. Sami’s Reasoning

Sami Zayn Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

The unlikely Brock/Sami double act got to close it too.

Later, Zayn implored Lesnar to help him beat Reigns. In a genius moment (one that was also a rare show of self-awareness from the scriptwriters), Sami then reasoned that he'd be an easier opponent for the 'Beast' at Day 1 than Roman. That was an unexpected line, but it made sense.

For a character who often basks in his own delusions, this was pretty logical. It's hard to argue with Zayn's point - he would've been an easier road to the Universal Title for Brock. Sami also fancied bagging a cheap run as Universal Champion himself, which is exactly what an opportunist like him should be interested in.

Then, things turned. Zayn accidentally insulted Brock and took a pasting for his cheek. That set up the main event. Anyone wondering how WWE would handle a heel vs. heel showdown between Sami and Roman got their answer before the show went dark.


1. Squashed. Flat.

Sami Zayn The Usos
WWE.com

Lesnar murdering Zayn was always going to happen eventually, and that allowed Roman to take advantage of the situation. He scored an easy win just because he could, and now moves on to face Brock at Day 1 early next year. In other words, everyone was a winner.

Well, except poor Sam Zayn.

There was an almost-sympathetic vibe to Sami's performance post-Brock beatdown. He ate a spear from Roman and then got choked out before he'd even really readied himself for that Universal Title bout he earned last week. This is something WWE can come back to if they wish.

Would Zayn work as a babyface? Maybe/maybe not. He'd definitely give it a try though, and the dude excels at almost everything put in front of him these days. This squash, whilst rendering the Battle Royal result pointless, was exactly what it needed to be.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out WWE NXT WarGames 2021: 10 Last-Minute Predictions and 4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Nov 26)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.