5 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Jan 1)
The first SmackDown of 2021 had returns, big bumps and the worst concert in WWE history.

The first SmackDown of 2021 had some solid wrestling, superb promo work, a possibly major return, awful comedy and one hell of a set piece bump.
WWE's build towards Royal Rumble continued, but the company didn't announce any other names for either upcoming 30-person brawl. Instead, they spent Friday's two-hour broadcast hyping up potential rematches for the Universal, Tag-Team and Women's Titles. That's fine, though the show could've done without Angelo Dawkins playing drums.
One glaring problem with SmackDown right now is that there's a huge disparity between the main event feud and everything else. Most of the midcard pack (like Dawkins and Street Profits pal Montez Ford) come across as an afterthought to the show's creative team, and that's hard to overlook when watching - Bruce Prichard must also be glad he doesn't have Monday's third hour on Friday nights too.
So, SmackDown's latest was ye olde mixed bag. At least there was room for some touching tributes from the roster and the kind of big time conclusion that WWE used to do weekly.
Here are all the 'Ups' and 'Downs'...
Downs...
5. Where Is This Going?

Billie Kay's current gimmick seems totally aimless.
She's gone from trying to get hired by The Street Profits (to do what was never made clear) to teaming with a number of partners in the women's tag division. Now, it appears, Kay has turned into a manager for thrown-together tandems like Natalya and Tamina.
None of this will get her over. It's not even doing much for The Riott Squad either - Ruby and Liv Morgan were previously gunning for the Women's Tag belts. Michael Cole said as much on TV for a few weeks. Has that been dropped? If not, then how will beating one-off duos like Nattie and Tamina help them?
It's all so...directionless and random. Billie's headshot-obsessed character sucks, and The Riott's title tilt is paper thin. Would it have been too much to ask that Kay and Peyton Royce were kept together as The IIconics so two actual tag-teams could feud?
4. Cheer The Heels, Boo The Faces

Things aren't much better on the men's side of the tag scene.
The Street Profits come across as naturally arrogant and unlikeable. Sure, New Day had loads of heel-ish swagger at one point and things worked out for them, but they were at least endearing. Ford and Dawkins just grate, and they got too much screen time to talk about nothing on SmackDown.
Their 2021 predictions skit was rotten from the start. The jokes didn't land, it felt like it was going too long three minutes in, and it almost felt like a relief when Dolph Ziggler and Robert Roode attacked them. This is the kind of "heel" attack on "babyfaces" that might've been cheered by a live crowd.
That's not good. Dolph and Roode showed the kind of aggression that The Profits lack, and that needs to change pronto. Dawkins and Ford are actually really annoying at times. They could do with a heel turn themselves.
3. Babyface Exhibition

Big E's Intercontinental Title win on the Christmas Day edition of SmackDown was a landmark moment in his resurgent singles career. Beating a delusional (and excellent) heel like Sami Zayn was the proverbial icing on top of the cake, but what came next was always going to be more important.
It's Apollo Crews.
Crews has done sod all since being drafted from Raw to SmackDown. Suddenly, despite never winning a match to earn it, he's allowed to put himself forward for E's "open challenge" and bag a title shot next week. Again, this isn't inspiring or likeable behaviour, especially when the crux of Sami's frustrations is that he's overlooked.
E vs. Crews is the kind of babyface vs. babyface bout that just seems skippable too. There's almost nothing about it that screams "must see"; WWE may have been better-served putting 'King' Corbin in this spot. Big E needs strong/obvious heel challengers.
2. Should’ve Been Better?

Some folks aren't going to agree with this 'Down'.
That's fine, but yours truly was expecting a bit more when he saw that Otis and Daniel Bryan would be teaming up against Cesaro and Shinsuke Nakamura. All four guys are good workers. Two of them (Bryan and Bryan) especially could also be considered world class, so it wasn't a stretch to think this would be sensational.
Instead, it was a passable TV match and little more. Now, nobody is suggesting that anyone phoned it in here, but it surely had the potential to be better than it was. In the end, this viewer came away with a feeling of disappointment - things never really got going to the level one expected.
In fairness, they got the finish right. The fact Daniel tapped out Naka is also interesting, because Shin has done something that Bryan hopes to do in a few weeks. Namely, win the Royal Rumble. Fingers crossed he's in with a shout.
1. A Limp Return

Sonya Deville hasn't really been seen on WWE television since losing to Mandy Rose at SummerSlam last August. Before that defeat, she was coming into her own as a heel promo machine, and could've been considered a weekly highlight on SmackDown.
Real-life drama interrupted Sonya's flow, and it's great to see her back, but...how lame was this return? Deville, who has a genuine chance of becoming the top female in the company someday, was shown walking backstage. OK then. Thanks for that!
That was it - she walked.
Imagine Roman Reigns had been shown walking around like he was getting some daily exercise before coming back as the 'Tribal Chief'. That would've killed any surprise element. Deville didn't even do anything later in the show to justify her leisurely stroll.
Ups...
5. The Opening Exchange

Now for some sweet positivity.
Most who have read recent SmackDown articles will know that Roman Reigns and Kevin Owens have been smashing it. They've got chemistry together, and they're clearly enjoying the chance to work a serious program that's head and shoulders above anything else on Friday nights.
Here, they produced another belter of a verbal exchange. KO targeting Jey Uso for his constant interference at TLC and in last week's Steel Cage effort made sense, as did watching Roman paint himself as some standalone legend who should attend shareholder meetings in Vince McMahon's stead.
As usual, everybody played their roles to perfection at the top of the show. Even better, Reigns' malevolent glare hinted at the violence that would come a bit later on. Bonus points for Jey constantly looking over at his cousin so he could react accordingly too.
4. All Those Brodie Lee Tributes

WWE were never going to top the emotional tribute show AEW produced on Wednesday's Dynamite, but they didn't have to. Instead of dedicating the entire broadcast to Brodie Lee, the company showed his memorial graphic first and then let the roster express their love and respect to a fallen friend.
SmackDown was stacked with Brodie tributes.
Big E, Daniel Bryan, Cesaro and Sasha Banks all wore black armbands with his name splashed across them, and their matches had some sneaky homages too. E used Brodie's gator roll and shouted, "Yeah! Yeah! Yeah!", Cesaro hit a sidewalk slam, Otis nailed a spinning lariat and more.
Backstage, Adam Pearce borrowed from Lee's Twitter handbook by saying, "You know what that means". E also topped things off by namedropping Brodie's wife Amanda and son Nolan. He even found time to drop in some love for Lee's beloved Toronto Maple Leafs.
Lovely.
3. The Women’s Tag

Last week, WWE had random teams formed by Bayley, Carmella, Sasha Banks and Bianca Belair challenge Charlotte Flair and Asuka for the Women's Tag-Team Titles. It didn't sit right, because nobody had earned that shot. This week, things were a bit more relaxed and realistic.
Sasha teamed with Belair again, and there's a clear attempt to turn Bayley and Carmella into a full-time duo; that might be short-lived. This could be Bayley's way of trying to get the SmackDown Women's Title off Banks and onto someone she believes she can beat. If so, that's smart.
However it shakes out, one thing was obvious: These women have gelled.
Their tag match had a tremendous second half that's well-worth going out of your way to see. 'Mella vs. Banks also has one more pay-per-view showing in it before WWE move on to other things. If they play it right, then they can pivot back to Bayley rather easily.
2. Heels Are Real People Too

As mentioned earlier, it does kinda' suck that Big E's first challenge as IC Champ is against another smiling babyface. At least it's true that he has some decent heels to work with post-Apollo Crews, and those heels might even launch a mini-feud of their own to establish the next number one contender.
Why not? Heels can disagree occasionally.
During one of SmackDown's tag matches, Sami Zayn and 'King' Corbin failed to see eye-to-eye. They argued extensively, and Zayn also had problems with Corbin's henchmen Steve Cutler and Wesley Blake. Being honest, this bout would've been useless without that dissension.
Also, it was cool to see Sami loop back to his time calling the shots as a faction leader. He tried to get Cutler and Blake to do his bidding like Cesaro and Shinsuke Nakamura would've done at the start of last year. Corbin ensured they wouldn't, which only furthered the friction.
1. Big Bumps Rule

Man, KO and Roman Reigns have covered a lot of ground in a relatively short space of time.
Their rivalry over the Universal Title has had TLC matches, Steel Cage wars and now spectacular big bumps on SmackDown. Everything they're doing is working, and this was no exception. Seeing Owens get chucked off the staging through those tables was an awesome way to end the show on Friday.
The set piece put forward his brave attempt to battle against the odds, and it also displayed how far Reigns is willing to go to remain on top. Add to that Jey's own willingness to do Roman's bidding and you have a cracking story.
Side note: Owens will have to get the upper hand on Roman's squad at some point. He did beat Jey Uso here, but then got his ass kicked again. If WWE want to squeeze another bout from these guys at Royal Rumble, then they're gonna' have to let Reigns show some actual weakness. Otherwise, KO's title threat won't be believable in the slightest.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more, check out 5 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Dec 25) and 10 New Year’s Resolutions WWE Must Make For 2021!