5 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE WrestleMania XII

60 Minute Men.

WWE.com

Broadly speaking, things were on the up for WWE as they entered WrestleMania season following a challenging prior year.

The September 1995 birth of Monday Nitro had reframed the conversation about mainstream professional wrestling in North America, but WWE's pay-per-view and live attendance numbers were gently creeping up by the turn of the year. With selective evidence, Vince McMahon was permitted to believe he was on to a very good thing with the "Boyhood Dream" push of the best all-rounder in his company (and arguably the world), not least when he had the second best to put him over at the 'Show Of Shows'.

Unfortunately, he was showing weakness elsewhere. Like leaning on legends to pad out the Survivor Series in 1993 and the "fastest Royal Rumble in history" in 1995, a 60-minute match between the two top stars was a sound masking agent for the lack of star quality available for the 'Grandest Stage' in 1996. The pressure was on Shawn and Bret to deliver there, because McMahon himself was struggling elsewhere...

(Want more WrestleMania Ups & Downs? We got 'em: I, 2, III, IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, IX, X, XI)


Downs...

5. Total Hucksters

WWE Network

It spoke to the illogical nature of these silly b*llocks parodies that the "Geriatric Match" was dumped on the pre-show - though that's not to suggest that The Huckster and The Nacho Man belonged anywhere else.

The company cribbed Mystery Science Theater's setup to reduce the pre-taped 'comedy' scuffle further, but it highlighted just how wasted all the television time was that had been donated to it. The petty insults lobbed across the bow by Vince McMahon were a blight on WWE's fragile grasp on the market leader's spot, hypocritical in the extreme, and missed the point entirely about how WCW were using the former stars.

McMahon couldn't even bring himself to fake some hilarity at the payoff - the first point during this entire ordeal in which he was simpatico with his audience.


4. Freebies

WWE

Though the pensioner parodies of Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage didn't belong anywhere near the main card, fellow kickoff residents Skip, Zip and Sunny should have been a far bigger part of the night's proceedings rather than merely occupying the closing moments of the 'Free-For-All'.

The Bodydonnas scored victory over The Godwinns to claim the vacant Tag Team Championships in decent clash whilst Sunny again highlighted how she was a cut above almost every other talker on the roster, but - due predominantly to its positioning on the show - none of it helped pull the division out of its months-long slump.

'The Golden Haired Fox' was the story here - as she would be with the belts for most of the year - distracting Phineas Godwinn gifter her side the win shortly before she sidled up to the pig farmers en route to a longer stint with The Smoking Gunns.


3. Stone Deaf

WWE.com

The silence soundtracking Stone Cold Steve Austin's violence spoke volumes about how meaningless the future 'Rattlesnake' was in WWE at the time, despite matches against Savio Vega often over-delivering, and Austin himself speaking on how the energetic feud got him into the sort of physical condition the company needed from their eventual top star.

Vega - perhaps like a New Generation Randy Orton - was obviously just a wrestler's wrestler. None of the effort expended in the ring travelled out into the stands or through the screen. Austin cheated relentlessly to win but nobody in the audience gave a tiny toss about any of it.

Pay-per-view customers weren't really even asked to. The contest saw cuts to the OJ Simpson's infamous 1994 car chase footage masquerading as a continuation of the Goldust/Roddy Piper Backlot Brawl (more on that later). Vega and Austin were warm bodies for the live crowd, even if the product was ice cold.


2. Vader's Time?

WWE

This failed attempt at a midcard blockbuster saw Vince McMahon attempt to save his big banter battle between Yokozuna and Vader for a follow-up Monday Night Raw without having to remove them from the 'Show Of Shows' altogether. The decision to book the battle (with a babyface stipulation, no less) in favour of the heels was thus baffling in the extreme.

The six-match main card offered ample time for all the outings even with a one hour main event, but 13 minutes still felt like a lifetime waiting for the former WWE Champion to claim five more alone in the ring with Jim Cornette as per the pre-match agreement. Especially when he failed!

The match sort of helped Vader's ascension, though not as much as his original Rumble debut. A disappointing maiden 'Mania regrettably foreshadowed the bulk of his run.


1. Iron Blunts Iron

WWE.com

Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels rightly defend this match as one of the best of their incomparable careers. The two go an hour in a worthy pro wrestling main event that - at the absolute least - can objectively be considered a hugely impressive athletic pursuit.

Subjectively, it was a bit of a bore.

The build-up infamously focused on Bret's grizzled experience going up against Shawn's exceptionalism, though both themes played far better against their Canada/America divide a year later than here. Technically excellent but dramatically hollow, the moment Bret looked at the clock late on to see the exact time he expected spoke to the mechanical nature of the match they'd assembled.

Elements are worthy of rewatch - Shawn's petulant post-match insistence that Bret and Jose Lothario get out of the ring especially - but the scant moments are better condensed rather than fully consumed.


Ups...

5. Mat Classic

WWE

One for the fans of wrestling's odd aesthetics this, but WrestleMania XII remains the only WWE pay-per-view in company history to have branding or an event's logo on the canvas. More's the pity too, because it looked absolutely fantastic.

Allegedly just another fascinating Vince McMahon foible, the print on the mat was something he felt sullied the stage built for his Superstars - in spite of the advertising dollars WCW took in for splashing sponsors all over theirs.

Even during his organisation's financial nadir, it was a cash-grab too far for the Chairman, and an artistic choice he didn't believe best for his business. To some, it remains one of the most eye-catching aspects of this entire WrestleMania.


4. WrestleMania Goes Hollywood

WWE.com

Long before WWE used the silver screen as their 'Show Of Shows' setting (and actually had a feud that drew interest at the box office), Goldust mined the game for promo patter that masked the psycho-sexual androgyny Vince McMahon was impressively trying to master with the gimmick.

Former actual film star Roddy Piper had no truck for this sort of attention ordinarily, but he did have a Ford Bronco. Because of course he did.

Built as a set piece for the aforementioned OJ gag, Piper and Goldust's parking lot scuffle was legitimately horrifying. Pre-taped but feeling as live as it needed to, the 'Hot Scot' obliterated the 'Bizarre One' with a baseball bat before dodging a hit and run attack ahead of giving chase to the Intercontinental Champion's gold Cadillac.

With the violence and car chase checked off, only the sex remained to assemble 1996's hottest action thriller. Game-for-anything Dustin Runnels again delivered, sporting negligee under his golden ensemble for reasons never otherwise-explored. With a live crowd baying for Goldust's demise, the blood-drenched Piper duly obliged.


3. Orange Squash

WWE.com

A super-tanned Ultimate Warrior brought the 'good' old days back for Vince McMahon for one night at least, popping the sh*t out of the Anaheim crowd for his return crushing of future company overlord Hunter Hearst Helmsley.

The story's been retold over and over again by 'The Game' himself, but Helmsley doing the honours here wouldn't have looked half as damaging had he won King Of The Ring as originally planned. As it was, he was the designated jobber for one of the prior era's biggest stars to have a penultimate WrestleMania moment.

There's a bizarre enjoyment to be had about the man-out-of-time 1996 Ultimate Warrior run, not least because he now had pyro in the shape of his iconic symbol. It's fun to fantasy book Warrior going head-to-head with new headliners Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart, but the difference in their shifts on this very show highlight why it was such a fantasy. 'HBK' and 'The Hitman's 60 minutes were for the discerning, Warrior's 1:39 strictly for the disenfranchised.


2. Wild Men

Marc Mero had a bad run at life in WWE after word spread of the guaranteed contract he'd gained from Vince McMahon as the company began playing catch-up with Eric Bischoff' and Ted Turner's big spending.

It wasn't his fault that he'd pocketed the deal of course, nor was it quite as apparent why McMahon really saw value in the 'Wildman' - at least until Sable sided with him in the weeks following this backstage scuffle with a disgruntled Triple H.

The pair Rumbled following Triple H's squash as the blueblood blamed the then-nameless valet for his loss. Mero's promo was cheesy and his shoving match with Helmsley wasn't a great deal better, but the fight over Sable here and on subsequent editions of Raw did much to establish all three acts as staples of a revamped and revitalised midcard.


1. Tall Order

WWE.com

Diesel and The Undertaker's blockbuster semi-main event succeeded where their friends and colleagues elsewhere on the card failed as much because of the tempered expectations of both at the time.

'Big Daddy Cool' was always serviceable in there with the right opponent at his peak, but - like The Undertaker that same year - he'd failed to inspire much excitement in a February clash with Bret Hart. Neither were form, despite the gripping grief between the two dating back to the prior December. As is so often the case with this particular pay-per-view, they were saving it for the 'Grandest Stage'.

Comfortably stealing the show, the two giants wrestled with the energy and effort of men half their size, with Undertaker extending his unbeaten streak to five at Diesel's expense. Performing perhaps for his perspective new employers, Kevin Nash gave Vince McMahon a ringside seat for what he was about to lose out on when the seven-footer went south.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.