5 Ups & 6 Downs From AEW Dark (Sep 22)
Another show, another must-see Ben Carter match. This is becoming a habit.
AEW Dark was thrust into the unfortunate position of being the second most interesting show on a night that saw the promotion release the one-hour Late Night Dynamite special just after midnight. This was a pre-emptive measure to combat an NBA playoff series between the Houston Rockets and Los Angeles Lakers potentially going to a seventh game, and yielded a fun, breezy hour of wrestling on TNT, highlighted by Ben Carter further establishing himself as a can't-miss prospect.
Mr. Carter was on fire again here, albeit on an entirely different show.
This was a sluggish episode of Dark. One could probably glean this from looking at the 11-match card and 90-minute runtime alone, though this one was extra stodgy, with little to differentiate most of the squashes. Cherrypicking is therefore essential on a show designed to highlight Ricky Starks, Eddie Kingston (and his entire stable), two Dark Order tag teams, Serena Deeb, and more.
A reminder of the usual Dark Ups and Downs system: an Up is worth watching regardless of investment levels, while a Down should only be checked out if you're into the spotlighted performer. Let's light the fuse...
Downs...
6. Ricky Starks vs. Christopher Daniels
Given that Ricky Starks is a regular Dark highlight and his opponent isn't an enhancement talent, but a respected veteran and full-time AEW roster member, this should have been one of the night's biggest highlights. Sadly, it wasn't.
Starks vs. Daniels never got out of first gear. It was too one-paced to hold the attention for long, with the wrestlers working beneath even a house show clip. More than anything, it felt like an extended opening sequence and even Ricky's splashes of personality weren't enough to save it from being entirely skippable, with Starks winning via Spear.
5. Evil Uno and Stu Grayson vs. Fuego del Sol and Rembrandt Lewis
This was the Dark squash format to a tee, with jobbers Fuego del Sol and Rembrandt Lewis granted a few splashes of offense against The Dark Order before inevitably falling in a meek effort.
Grayson and Uno's Fatality finished Fuego off. The bout's turning point was Stu deciding he'd had enough of the jobbers' sh*t early on and completely cutting Lewis off, effectively ending the opposition's comebacks. He and Uno are a great team but you need only check this out if you can't get enough of their work.
4. 5 and 10 vs. Ryzin and Xander Gold
This bout suffered from the same problems as the other Dark Order match. 5 and 10 can both be fun to watch but these pseudo squash layouts are beyond tedious, serving only to pad records and allow less experienced wrestlers to get their reps in.
Really, there isn't much point in checking these things out.
Ryzin looks like he should be playing bass in Coal Chamber, though, so respect to him for rocking the nu-metal look in 2020.
3. Will Hobbs vs. Serpentico
A potentially fun match between two good wrestlers undone by overbooking.
Serpentico has looked good in recent outings and Will Hobbs is usually great, having seemingly won his AEW contract on the back of impressive showings on Dark, against Darby Allin on Dynamite, and in All Out's Casino Battle Royale. There was no real need for this bout to be so interference-heavy, particularly as the heel lost. It was, though, and Luther's ringside presence dragged this down.
'The Original Death Dealer' got involved several times, whether he was helping Serpentico while the referee's back was turned or catching Hobbs' attention. Will got to show off some of his eye-catching work but the match's momentum swings came almost exclusively from Luther. A weird choice, though at least Will took the W.
2. Lucha Brothers vs. Dontae Smiley and Maxx Stardom
Though largely fit for purpose, this was entirely too long for what it needed to be.
Maxx Stardom surprising Rey Fenix with a Gedo Clutch should have been the end of him and Dontae Smiley. Instead, they were controlled for a long, uninteresting period early on, with the Lucha Brothers utilising a variation on the worst move in professional wrestling, the Paradise Lock, to stifle Maxx. Time passed at a glacial pace before Smiley tagged in, ran through a few spots, then got out of there, leaving Stardom to take the fall via a double-team Package Piledriver.
The Lucha Brothers are perfectly capable of being nasty, over-the-top pricks in situations like this. Here, it felt like they didn't want to break a sweat.
1. Gunn Club vs. Cruz and M'Badu
A nothing match from start to finish, and the easiest skip on the show.
Here's the deal with these Gunn Club squashes: Billy is old and rigid and largely sticks to his signature spots, while Austin is enthusiastic but extremely underseasoned. This doesn't make for a compelling blend when they're in there with a couple of enhancement talents like Cruz and M'Badu.
Billy hit the Fame Asser for the win. That's literally all you need to know.
Ups...
5. Joey Janela and Sonny Kiss vs. Kevin Blackwood and Daniel Garcia
Kevin Blackwood and Daniel Garcia are a cut above the usual Dark enhancement team and have plenty of chemistry from their time working together on the independent scene, so their work is always going to be worth checking out. throw them in there with a tag team as fun as Sonny Kiss and Joey Janela and you're left with an easy Up.
Garcia and Blackwood booth looked good in their fleeting control periods. Kiss and Janela looked as good as they always do, lighting the Buffalo boys up with trademark popping offense, building to Sonny scoring the fall with his split leg drop.
It'd be great to see Garcia and Blackwood score a regular gig here, particularly with the indies in stasis. They have a lot to offer.
4. The Butcher and The Blade vs. Puf and Calvin Stewart
This is technically Puf's second AEW appearance, as he featured as a red herring during Kip Sabian's 'Best Man' reveal a couple of weeks ago. He's a fun wrestler and exactly the kind of jovial personality The Butcher and The Blade were born to run through. Man has a dancing donut in his entrance video, for crying out loud.
Butcher and Blade had no time for Puf's good vibes, clobbering him and Calvin Stewart at the bell. Stewart was pulled apart here. Beaten down relentlessly after Puf was lobbed out of the ring, his time in the ring was a complete, one-sided pounding until a dropkick won him enough time to tag Puf in.
Dancing his way out of an attempted German suplex, getting some of his sh*t in, and tagging out, Puf unwittingly doomed his partner, who was hauled in the ring and hit with an immediate Full Death for the fall. Butcher and Blade were great here.
3. Serena Deeb vs. KiLynn King
Signed on the back of an impressive showing against Thunder Rosa on Dynamite, Serena Deeb is a very good professional wrestler and still only 34 years old, with this bout proving why she'll be one of AEW's smartest signings this year.
KiLynn King is green. Her Dark performances have varied greatly, usually depending on her opponent. Here, she was placed opposite a savvy opponent who knows how to guide a lesser experienced performer through a bout, and while this wasn't anything blow-away, it showed how useful a player Deeb is going to be in getting the most out of the AEW women's division. A very encourage performance, with Serena leading the way.
Deeb's finisher - a single-leg crab with an arm trap - scored the victory.
2. Eddie Kingston vs. Brian Pillman Jr.
A complete change of pace from the Ben Carter vs. Lee Johnson match, this.
Kingston and Pillman Jr. closed the night after Carter and Johnson had highlighted it, with Eddie's slower, more domineering style taking over. Watching him wear dudes down is always a treat. Kingston has genuine ring general vibes about him and while matches like this aren't going to give you a sugar high, they aren't designed to. Eddie has a perfect understanding of his strengths as a performer and wisely keeps things simple.
Pillman Jr. ate his latest AEW loss with spinning backfist, giving Kingston his second win in the company.
1. Ben Carter vs. Lee Johnson
Another Ben Carter match, another banger.
Late Night Dynamite saw the up-and-comer work an awesome bout with Scorpio Sky. It was all about establishing the hyper-athletic Carter as someone who could hang with a veteran opponent, as he foiled Sky with a surprising level of fight time and time again, before the experience gap came into play and Scorp took the victory. Here, he faced a wrestler far closer to him on the hierarchy in Lee Johnson.
This was nuts. Carter and Johnson worked at a level far beyond the usual Dark offering, yielding one of the finest matches in the YouTube series' history as a result. That's a low bar, admittedly, but they fought out of their skins, and while Carter will understandably get the headlines, it was great to see Lee being given the opportunity to show what he can do as well.
A match that built towards a thrilling series of nearfalls finished with Carter's Frog Splash. Running through the bout's better moments would spoil the fun of watching it, so just check it out. A must-see for anyone who likes their wrestling fast, fluid, and energetic.