5 Ups And 3 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Dec 3)

WWE really need to stop with those manufactured cheers...

There's a real sense that WWE are killing time until the end of the year, or at least until TLC is over and done with. The injury to Seth Rollins during a UK Tour date in November did cause problems, but it seems like the company haven't quite recovered from that setback yet. The decision was made to put the WWE World Heavyweight Title on Sheamus, and have Roman Reigns chase him for the belt instead of Rollins. Thus far, this has broken down to a war between 2 distinct groups. On one side, The Authority and The League Of Nations. On the other, Reigns apparently heads up 'The Family', a stable which also includes Dean Ambrose and The Usos. This week's episode of Smackdown continued the rivalry between both those factions.

Downs...

3. Opening Segment Misses The Mark Due To Piped In Crowd Noise

Pretty much since the program was debuted by the company, WWE have piped in post-production crowd cheers and jeers during Smackdown. Generally speaking, the cheers are supposed to give viewers the impression that the live audience are going nuts for a top babyface. The problem is that the noise feels completely fake, and sounds ridiculous. On this week's episode of Smackdown, the show opened with Roman Reigns talking about The Usos and Dean Ambrose in glowing terms. Referring to the men as 'The Family', Reigns tried to gain empathy from the fans by talking about how important family is. People didn't appear to be digging it, at least not visually. That didn't stop the production team from inserting awkward cheering during the promo. Things worsened when Sheamus and the rest of the League Of Nations converged on the stage. Even though adding cheers to broadcasts isn't a new thing for WWE, it seemed like some of the boos levied at Sheamus were piped in too. That's worrying. Looking at things from a stand point of aesthetics, the fake crowd noise doesn't even sound realistic. It actually ruined the opening segment.

2. Rusev And Ryback Feud Is Uninspiring

On Monday Night Raw, Rusev and Ryback engaged in a short match which ended in count out. The 'Bulgarian Brute' decided to check on Lana instead of finish the match. The blonde beauty had been hit during a brawl between the wrestlers on the outside of the ring. The idea of a rivalry between both men was furthered on Smackdown. Cutting a promo backstage, both Rusev and Lana called out Ryback for "deliberately" hitting the 'Ravishing Russian' during the melee. It's obvious that this is a feud which will push the reset button on the relationship between Rusev and Lana. It's likely to be a short one, because WWE simply want things to go back to the way they were before with the real-life couple. The problem is that fans are probably more into Lana than they are Ryback, who will be expected to be the babyface in the feud. There's something lazy feeling about the situation, and it's pretty uninspiring. Rusev has been struggling for a while now to gain traction, but the same can be said of Ryback's good guy act. Simply shunting them together doesn't seem like an ideal solution to either man's woes.

1. Roman Reigns Wins Handicap Match By Count Out

The main event of the show was a confusing one. WWE desperately want fans to embrace Roman Reigns as a genuine babyface, but they have booked themselves into a corner with the finish to Smackdown. The question must remain, why does Roman need Dean Ambrose or The Usos when he can outsmart all the heels on his own? This was not good booking. It's fine to book Reigns in impossible handicap situations, because it makes the villains look like exactly that. The problem comes when the babyface is written to undermine their villainy and come out on top anyway. There was no consequence for Roman foolishly agreeing to face all the bad guys at once, he won by count out regardless of being at a gross disadvantage. This is an issue many fans previously had with John Cena, the 'Super Human' aspect of his character. It seems that persona has now been shifted onto Roman Reigns, and it's difficult to like. Babyfaces require vulnerability if they are going to be effective, but that isn't how WWE want to do things. Reigns made Sheamus, 'King' Barrett, Rusev and Alberto Del Rio look like clowns here. If he can outlast them all in a 4-on-1 situation, why can't he beat Sheamus in a singles match at TLC?

Ups...

5. R-Truth Comedy Is Quirky But Works

Traditionally, WWE comedy can cause fans to roll their eyes more than laugh. Vince McMahon's idea for giggles is to be as hammy as possible. More often than not, it fails to hit its intended target. That hasn't been the case with R-Truth recently. Before Survivor Series, Truth was hilarious as he told everyone he would become WWE Champion at the Pay-Per-View. The Miz then reminded the man that he wasn't even in contention, and laughs were had at Truth's reaction. Something similar happened on Smackdown. The Dudley Boyz and Tommy Dreamer were in the ring, waiting for D-Von's singles bout against Bray Wyatt. The familiar Wyatt Family insert played, signalling their arrival. When the cameras cut to the stage, R-Truth was standing there instead, and he looked utterly bemused as to how he had even got there in the first place. Flashing and a smile and a wave to the live crowd, R-Truth was gone in rapid fashion. This was an unexpected moment, but it played to the dimness of Truth's character. It also came out of nowhere, which can usually be considered a plus. This was an inoffensive little segment, one which didn't take much TV time and raised a chuckle.

4. Charlotte Continues Hinting At Heel Turn

It's a good thing that Becky Lynch is back in the WWE Divas Title picture. The feud between Paige and Charlotte was fine, but Lynch was ominous by her disappearance. All of a sudden, Becky went from being by Charlotte's side all the time to never being around. There really needed to be some explanation for that, and it seems like the creative team are trying to bridge the gap. On Monday Night Raw, Charlotte feigned injury to beat her friend. Then, on Smackdown, she ended up costing Becky a match against Brie Bella. After being hit by an accidental elbow by the Bella Twin, Charlotte entered the ring and caused Lynch to lose by disqualification. Afterwards, Charlotte tried to get Becky to link hands, but the Irish Diva was conflicted. There are several ways WWE could go with that, which is a good thing. The obvious answer right now appears to be turning Charlotte heel. She's not really over in a huge way as a babyface, and is overshadowed by Ric Flair regularly. Turning her heel could be just the ticket. Alternatively, Becky Lynch could be the one to go heel, aligning herself with Paige down the line. The fact there are multiple paths open to creative is a very notable positive.

3. The New Day Come Across As True Villains

Legendary announcer Jim Ross recently stated his belief that The New Day can't be considered out and out heels. JR's point revolved around the fact that Kofi Kingston, Xavier Woods and Big E have great interaction with the audience, and do make people laugh. In the podcaster's eyes, that's not what heels do. Smackdown aided that problem a little, and it was well done. Even though the opening segment was hindered by piped in crowd noise, The New Day did create one interesting scenario. Facing Dean Ambrose and The Usos, they ascertained that the babyfaces would not be able to help Roman Reigns later in the show if they lost. This would mean that Reigns would have to face the League Of Nations all on his own. The New Day did defeat Ambrose and The Usos, meaning they were barred from the main event. In the process, they looked like heels, because they were taunting and teasing the good guys. Simple little things like this can go a long way to gaining heat for New Day, who are more likeable and entertaining than half of the babyface roster.

2. Tyler Breeze And Neville Show Their Skills

Since being called up from NXT recently, Tyler Breeze has lost some steam. Fans were excited to see what 'Prince Pretty' could do on the main roster, but a feud opposite Dolph Ziggler hasn't really caught fire yet. Similarly, Neville has stalled as of late, and isn't really involved in any rivalries. A backstage segment does hint that he may enter a short feud against The Miz however. In the opening match on Smackdown, Breeze and Neville put on a fine display. It's unfortunate that the match likely won't mean much in the long run, but it's heartening to those currently down in NXT to see their peers positioned against one another on a main show. Ziggler was at ringside providing commentary, meaning his feud with Breeze seems likely to continue. The action during the bout was excellent, and hopefully management were keeping a keen eye on things backstage. Breeze and Neville are great talents to have around, but they need something to really sink their teeth into if they're going to get over fully. It was good to see Summer Rae get involved in the finish here, because it gives her a reason for being around ringside, helping her man pick up victories.

1. The Wyatt Family Dominate The ECW Originals

After Survivor Series, The Wyatt Family needed something to help them regain some lustre in the eyes of the core fan base. There should be no issue with them losing to The Undertaker and Kane on the big Pay-Per-View, but Bray Wyatt and clan do deserve to be taken seriously. A program against The Dudley Boyz was a bit one-sided, before Bubba Ray and D-Von brought in Tommy Dreamer to help. There's a chance that other former ECW alumni will become involved over the next few weeks, possibly leading to a match at the TLC PPV. If that doesn't happen, and the feud doesn't make it to Pay-Per-View, at least The Wyatts are being booked to be dominant. That was the way things played out on Smackdown, the end scene of the segment being Bray and his men standing proud over their opponents. Bray Wyatt faced D-Von Dudley in a short singles match. It felt genuinely unique to see one of The Dudley Boyz in a one-on-one affair, which somehow made the situation more interesting. The Wyatts put Dreamer through a table and battered The Dudleyz into the bargain. This opens up the possibility for the ECW team to enlist more help. What others 'ups' and 'downs' can you think of from WWE Smackdown? What do you make of the points raised on this list? Let us know what you think down in the comments section below!

Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.