5 Ups And 9 Downs From WWE Hell In A Cell 2016

Women finally close out a PPV, but it's not enough to save lackluster event.

Charlotte Sasha Banks
WWE.com

That thud you just heard was the Raw brand hitting the ground floor. No doubt, some will declare that Hell in a Cell was a great PPV filled with brutal spots, historic firsts and wild hyperbole.

But make no mistake. Hell in a Cell was WWE continuing its trend of cluelessness, from matches with minimal storylines, to unworthy PPV matches, to bad finishes, to booking the hometown girl in the historic main event and then having her lose. We saw a Cruiserweight Champion who won a 32-man tournament this summer, only to lose his title because he fell for a fake injury from a guy who sucker-headbutted him a few weeks ago. We saw a United States champ overcome the kitchen sink being thrown at him to win yet again, drawing boos for the 11 millionth time with no new results.

And we saw women crack the glass ceiling by headlining a PPV (despite the announcers repeating over and over that they had three main events) and holding their own. That alone gives HIAC some additional positive vibes, but it’s hard to look at this PPV and not be disappointed overall. There was some potential here though, which makes it even worse.

So what rose to the occasion and what fell flat on its face? Let’s get to it…


Downs...

9. Cheapest Of Cheap Pops

enzo amore big cass
WWE.com

Fans responded strongly to Enzo Amore & Big Cass Sunday, especially during their promo, which name-dropped a couple Boston sports legends.

Enzo & Cass will sometimes use local references to rally the fans to their side, and Sunday, they mentioned Celtics great Larry Bird and Red Sox star David “Big Papi” Ortiz, drawing big cheers. However, there’s one small thing that should count against the duo: They’re from New York. Even casual sports fans know of the intense rivalry between the Yankees and Red Sox (and Enzo has worn pinstripes gear on occasion), so two New York guys playing to a Boston crowd for a cheap pop was, well, cheap.

And before the onslaught of negative comments fly, keep in mind this is a somewhat tongue-in-cheek “down.” Enzo & Cass are a fun act, and this isn’t some conspiracy against them. But as a longtime baseball fan, this writer can’t let that transgression pass by unnoticed. Tsk tsk.


8. Gold Fever

kevin owens seth rollins
WWE.com

There was a somewhat scary statistic thrown out before the WWE Universal Championship cell match: Seth Rollins has now competed in a title match on 16 straight PPVs (when he’s been healthy).

That is just a crazy number of matches, spanning back to WrestleMania XXXI last year, when Rollins won the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. He defended it at eight PPVs before getting injured. Rollins then returned to win the world title and immediately lost it. He’s been competing for the Universal Championship since SummerSlam.

This is not to say that Rollins shouldn’t be a top guy fighting for a championship (his face turn seems to be catching on more day by day). But it wouldn’t hurt to have someone else step in and battle for the top prize and let Rollins fight someone else in a feud that doesn’t involve a title for a change. Maybe Chris Jericho’s Codebreaker after the cell match will lead to just that.

Let’s face it: If this was Roman Reigns we were talking about, fans would be apoplectic about it, so let’s be fair about it.


7. Cruiserweights Don’t Click

brian kendrick tj perkins
WWE.com

After playing up the fact that Brian Kendrick and TJ Perkins have a friendship going back many years, you would have thought that they would have had a lot more chemistry in the ring, but they just didn’t click.

You would expect a Cruiserweight Championship match on PPV to involve both men pulling out all the stops and hitting some high-impact, dazzling moves to help put the division over. Instead, the early part of the match focused on Kendrick wondering why TJP wouldn’t lay down for him. But even once they moved past that, you could tell (and the crowd did as well) that they weren’t on the same page.

You have to hope that there are better matches on the horizon for the fledgling division. We’ve seen great cruiserweight matches this summer in the Cruiserweight Classic, and hopefully we’ll see some in WWE.


6. A Gullible Ex-Champ

Brian Kendrick T.J Perkins
WWE.com

If you’ve been paying attention, you knew that Brian Kendrick was a desperate man. He constantly said so during promos, headbutted Cruiserweight Champion TJ Perkins after a match, and asked TJP to lay down for him.

So how in the blue hell was Perkins so gullible that he fell for Kendrick faking a knee injury during their title match? WWE seems to love having its babyfaces be gullible goofs. Perkins is not even two months into his WWE tenure, and the only two things fans could tell you about him right now is that he loves video games and he got played with a ruse a 10-year-old saw coming.

Maybe they’re setting Perkins up for a title rematch, but they sure made him look foolish in the process. Let’s hope there’s a sharp detour coming.


5. Not Ready For PPV

dana brooke bayley
WWE.com

Can someone explain why Bayley/Dana Brooke needed to be settled at a PPV? Aside from a fluke win where Dana clearly was supposed to use the ropes to cheat, Bayley has owned this feud, even planting Brooke last week after she was jumped during an arm-wrestling match.

The match itself was pedestrian at best, with Dana controlling Bayley by attacking her injured right arm. (At least she remembered to attack the correct arm the whole time.) But Bayley recovered and used the same arm for clotheslines and a corkscrew elbow. Even after Brooke broke out of a Bayley-to-Belly by attacking the injured arm, Bayley simply reapplied the finisher for the win.

Overall, it was an awkward, clunky match. Even as a cooldown match, it didn’t below on PPV. It might have worked better on Raw. Just please let this be the end of this little feud.


4. Super Reigns

Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Hell in a Cell is a brutal match that puts wrestlers through a lot of physical anguish. Overcoming it to win takes a superhuman effort. But there are times when it gets a little forced, especially when the fans aren’t into the hero’s comeback.

Rusev beat Roman Reigns from pillar to post during their match, with Reigns playing defense for most of the second half of the match. Still, Rusev could not put him away, despite using a chain, steel steps and the Accolade twice. Reigns powered out of Rusev’s finishing hold twice (the second time with Rusev using a chain across Roman’s face), hitting a Samoan drop on the steps and then spearing the Bulgarian Brute off of it for the victory.

But the crowd wasn’t exactly rallying to Reigns’ support throughout the match – they chanted “Let’s go Rusev!/Rusev sucks!” at one point – lessening the impact of Roman’s triumph. It was a decent match, but Reigns’ superhuman victory after being beaten down for so long felt anticlimactic and just ridiculous. It might have been better for Reigns to demolish Rusev to retain.


3. The Feud Must Continue!

Cesaro Sheamus
WWE.com

Whose idea was it to have Cesaro & Sheamus win by DQ to prolong their Odd Couple routine as they challenge for the WWE Tag Team Championships? Uggh.

The at-odds challengers managed to function well enough against champs New Day, but ultimately, a trombone and Kofi Kingston’s interference was enough to render a PPV title match moot. The match itself wasn’t anything better than what we got on Raw, but unlike Monday night, the PPV bout didn’t have a real conclusion. Lame.

Of course, this is being done because New Day is about six weeks away from breaking Demolition’s record tag title reign. And probably because Vince McMahon thinks the bickering between Cesaro and Sheamus is hilarious. (Spoiler alert: It isn’t.)


2. Overdone

Charlotte Sasha Banks
WWE.com

The Hell in a Cell match between Charlotte and Sasha Banks could have stood out a little more and might have been even better received had it not been the third HIAC match of the night. That’s a lot.

Three out of seven matches took place inside Hell in a Cell, putting it on par with TNA’s Lethal Lockdown, where every match takes place inside a steel cage. By the time we got the Women’s Championship HIAC match, we had seen broken tables, bent steel chairs and wrestlers flying into the steel cage. That’s not to say that it wasn’t still impressive, but it definitely lost its luster by having three cell matches in one night.

This should be a lesson for WWE in the future to limit these to one or two at a PPV. Better yet, do away with the HIAC PPV theme and save the gimmick for a match that demands the cell to end a feud.


1. Deflating The Hometown Crowd

Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

WWE’s obsession with having wrestlers lose in their hometowns is a ridiculous ploy that is going to backfire someday really bad.

Sunday’s decision to have Sasha Banks lose the first women’s PPV main event in her hometown was just a horrible decision that pissed off the crowd and let to a pretty deflated group of fans. Many were counting on Sasha overcoming and finally getting a decent reign with the title, but it looks like they’d rather have around Charlotte’s waist.

Beating the hometown girl in a title match is one way to tick off fans and lead some to not show up the next time you’re in town. That might sound extreme, but why should fans shell out their money, if they’re local heroes are going to get toppled like that?

You’d think WWE might have learned a lesson from Raw, when they clearly were counting on the Minnesota crowd to boo hometown hero Brock Lesnar, and it tanked so badly that Vince McMahon pulled the plug on the segment. But it sure doesn’t look like it.

And click "next" below for the Ups..


Ups...

5. Cruiserweight Carwreck

cruiserweight classic
WWE.com

Admittedly, these multi-man cruiserweight matches are doing exactly what you’d expect – pumping up the crowd and reintroducing the lucha style that had taken a backseat in recent years – but they won’t remain in the “ups” column forever.

Creating a cruiserweight division on Raw has opened the door to a lot of talented wrestlers getting the opportunity to perform on a bigger stage, and it’s provided a different kind of match and a diversion from the angle-heavy stuff we sometimes get. Guys like TJ Perkins, Tony Nese, Rich Swann and Cedric Alexander have made a nice impression, and matches like the six-man from the Hell in a Cell pre-show certainly help with that. The match alone – complete with Alexander scoring the win – was a nice positive to start the night.

But – and this comes with a caveat – if WWE continues to run six-man cruiserweight tag matches that appear to just be random bouts with no rhyme or reason, it will become a negative for the division. We’re not talking about needing a half-hour segment to set up every match, but simply establishing friendships and rivalries and setting things up a little go a long way to giving the wrestlers a little depth.

The caveat here is that the cruiserweight division is less than two months old, so the previous paragraph is more of a preemptive warning than anything.


4. Telling Stories

luke gallows enzo amore
WWE.com

Let’s give the announcers credit when credit is due: in this case, during the Enzo Amore & Big Cass versus Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson match.

The announcers noted that Gallows & Anderson dominated the tag team scene in Japan before coming to WWE, but then added that the duo hasn’t been successful in WWE yet and the two men acknowledge it and are working to remedy that. It wasn’t an earth-shattering revelation, but hearing the announcers talk about it prominently during their match – which they won – helped drive home the message about them.

We can all lament how the Club was handled initially – including a horrid “comedy” feud with New Day – but repeating that the duo is getting serious about kicking a** and winning – and following up on that – makes for some nice consistency and helps rebuild the team.


3. Big Cass Runs Wild

big cass karl anderson
WWE.com

Even though Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson emerged victorious Sunday night, it wasn’t total domination for the Club.

WWE officials clearly are high on Big Cass, an agile seven-footer, and it seems obvious (especially after his brief singles run when Enzo Amore was out injured) that he is destined for a singles push at some point. So it made for a nice touch when Cass got the hot tag and ran through both Gallows and Anderson with big boots and elbows. He got knocked out of the ring, and the Club quickly took out Enzo for the victory.

Despite the loss, Cass looked like a beast, which was a smart call. You have to wonder how much longer WWE will allow Enzo & Cass to be a team and resist the temptation to break Cass out on his own. For now though, enjoy the tandem’s antics.


2. Brutality In The Cell

Kevin Owens Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Kevin Owens and Seth Rollins (and Chris Jericho) delivered exactly what you’d expect from a Hell in a Cell championship match: physicality, brutality and some crowd-cringing moments.

KO and Rollins went right at each other immediately, and the match remained at a steady pace. There were a few moments we haven’t seen in a cell match before (which is rare when there’s already been 34 other HIAC matches), such as Owens’ cannonball into the cell and Rollins’ powerbomb of KO from the ring, through an angled table resting above another table on the floor.

The sequence in the middle of the match, with both men trading finisher attempts, superkicks and finally a clothesline, brought the crowd to its feet. Even with the interference from Jericho, it was a really good match between the two. This was an occasion where the fans chanting, “This is awesome!” was deserved.


1. Breaking The Glass Ceiling

Charlotte Sasha Banks
WWE.com

Let’s put aside the conclusion of the match, and let’s just look at the history aspect of the Charlotte/Sasha Banks bout.

The women put on the first female Hell in a Cell match. It also was the first WWE PPV to be main-evented by the women, which is a huge accomplishment. The women made the bout feel like a big deal, and they certainly didn’t rest on their laurels. They could have just enjoyed the fact they were in the main event inside a cell and had an average match. But they pulled out all the stops and tried to win over the fans.

They did have a pretty good match, and fans were plenty into it. But alas, WWE seems to love shooting itself in the foot. Still, at least the ceiling was broken Sunday.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.