5 Ways WWE Use Money In The Bank Terribly
Money In The Bank has so much potential, but it's so often completely wasted.
Chris Jericho conceived the Money In The Bank Ladder Match before WrestleMania 21, with the idea that the winner of the bout would receive an opportunity to cash-in for a championship match whenever they desired.
First introduced at WrestleMania in 2005 and competed for every year since, a separate Money in the Bank PPV was established in 2010.
Money In The Bank offers the same potential of a championship as a win at the Royal Rumble. A briefcase win used to be a guarantee of a new champion when cashed in, until the 13th winner John Cena was the first superstar to fail in his cash-in.
In the first number of years, this platform was used to establish new stars and create first-time champions. A number of superstars won their first championship through this avenue. For example, it was the route towards gold for Edge, as he earned the nickname ‘The Ultimate Opportunist’.
The shock factor of never quite knowing when or where the briefcase is going to be cashed-in can still be incredibly exciting, and so long as WWE stop making these mistakes, it could yet be for a little while yet.
5. Helping John Cena Look Strong
Over the years, WWE have come up against criticism countless times for putting over ‘Super Cena’.
This is no different when it comes to Money In The Bank.
It has been used to protect Cena when he loses, make him look strong with failed cash-ins and protect him as the ultimate good guy when cashing-in.
‘The Leader of Cenation’ has been involved in five cash-ins. The very first cash-in Edge took advantage and won the title from 'The Champ', sheltering him from losing clean.
Number two was Rob Van Dam; ‘The Prototype’ lost but through interference from Edge who speared the ‘Babe Ruth of WWE’.
Cena then won MITB in 2012, announcing he was going to cash-in on Raw 1000 against CM Punk. Once again, interference cost John his chance at claiming the title. Big Show had attacked and the match was thrown out.
The next year we saw Damien Sandow lose his cash-in to a one-armed champ. This is the one that hurt the most, completely ruining all momentum ‘The Intellectual Saviour Of The Masses’ ever had.
The 15-time WWE World Champion was lastly involved in Baron Corbin’s cash-in on Jinder Mahal, which ‘The Lone Wolf’ failed to capitalise on. Corbin interrupted Cena vs. Mahal to cash-in, and John responded in kind. This helped 'The Chain Gang Soldier' lose his title opportunity, without actually losing.
Every single one of these maintained the Superman-like aura for the ‘Doctor of Thuganomics’.
Now with John busy in Hollywood, has someone else taken over the Reigns? Maybe ask Braun Strowman...
4. Placing Money In The Bank On Established Stars
The first few years of Money in the Bank was used to help establish stars. Edge, Daniel Bryan and CM Punk rose through the ranks of WWE. A large reason for the rise of these wrestlers was capturing Money In The Bank. The likes of Jack Swagger and Alberto Del Rio benefited from wins here too.
However, like with the Royal Rumble, they also gave it stars that didn’t need the rub.
Let’s start with Cena, shall we?
Placing the Money In The Bank on Cena feels like a complete waste of time on reflection. There would have been some other way for CM Punk to turn heel, and the opportunity to create a new star was wasted.
We also had Randy Orton win in the match dubbed ‘Money in the Bank All-Stars’. This felt like a forced way to shove The Authority down our throats - since it was.
Then we had Sheamus win in 2015, who was an established fella (pun intended) already. Placing this on the former King Of The Ring winner was done for two reasons. Firstly, to make a babyface out of Roman Reigns during the eventual cash-in (it didn't work). Secondly, to help reposition the Irishman back in the main event scene.
The Celtic Warrior was a declining attraction, and the briefcase was used as a means to both save him and create a positive crowd reaction for 'The Big Dog'. It did neither.
These successes could have been placed on superstars that would have benefited significantly from winning the briefcase.
3. Not Going All In On Establishing Up-And-Coming Stars
When WWE do give this opportunity to up-and-coming stars, they have a habit of not going all in with them.
Instead of strapping a rocket on to the briefcase holder, WWE books the superstars in 50/50 feuds, or even losing streaks.
CM Punk's first reign when he cashed-in is a good example of this. Between winning and cashing-in the briefcase, CM Punk either didn’t appear or lost on every pay-per-view.
WWE had a huge chance to make Dolph Ziggler a main event star on many occasions, none so much than when he cashed-in his money in the bank the night after WrestleMania. They had done so well with Ziggler in the build-up, who defended his MITB numerous times.
When ‘The Show-Off’ finally won the WWE World Heavyweight Championship, he was unfortunately hindered by an injury. A face-turn upon his return should have saved Dolph, but this was to no avail when he spent very little time chasing back the title he had recently vacated. He failed to win the belt back, then swiftly moved back down to the mid-card.
Baron Corbin fell victim to this as well. He only held the briefcase for 57-days, then failed to cash in, seemingly as a punishment for speaking out of turn backstage. Even though he has became a perennial main event presence on TV since, he has been defined as a total joke.
If WWE had gone all in with these superstars, they may be legitimate main eventers today rather failed pushes.
2. Having Money In The Bank Winners Constantly Lose
Apparently, the reason Damien Sandow failed his cash-in on Cena is because Vince McMahon didn’t see him as a star. He saw that he had lost too much, and nobody would take him seriously because of it.
Just try to get your head around that. The Chairman who booked Sandow to lose most matches, then didn’t see him as much of a winner. Go figure.
Carmella and The Miz experienced a similar process, and this ended up hurting their titles reigns. Both were booked to lose matches and look weak. Subsequently, when their stints with the belt began, they were not considered main event worthy.
Baron Corbin also fell victim to weak booking before, during and after his Money In The Bank win. ‘The Lone Wolf’ had not won a PPV match since TLC 2016 when he claimed the briefcase in June 2017. He then didn’t win on PPV until October 2017 at Hell In A Cell.
This is not the stats of a star in the making.
The problem with the MITB briefcase is that the superstar is taking advantage of a situation, and in turn, potentially doesn’t need to look overly strong.
The backwards view from WWE's perspective is that it doesn't matter if the MITB winner loses a few matches here and there. The briefcase is seen to protect them from these loses, and still be viewed as World Championship material.
Then they wonder why nobody, including WWE themselves, takes them seriously after losing so many matches? It's almost as bad as when WWE job-out their mid-card champions to superstars in the main event.
1. Drawing Heat, In The Wrong Way
Carmella’s original Money In The Bank win was a complete mess. There is no doubt about it.
It’s a wonder that she managed to recover from such a horrible mess.
In an historic match in the first ever Women’s Money In The Bank Ladder Match, a man grabbed the contract. This was at a time when WWE was trying to project the women as equals to men after years of being presented as second-rate.
The backlash from the WWE Universe was unprecedented. This was a reaction of disgust and shame for the sport that they love. The result has since been wiped from history, a smart move given the widespread censure - not to mention scandal surrounding Ellsworth's personal life.
Any image you see coming from WWE will not show you James Ellsworth grabbing the briefcase. The image you do see is that of ‘The Princess Of Staten Island’ retrieving it nine days later on SmackDown. Wise choice.
After spending the previous two years building the Women’s Division up, this set the roster back quite some way.
It’s a wonder she went on to defeat Charlotte Flair and Asuka retaining her title until SummerSlam 2018.
This was clearly done to draw heat on Carmella, but was it worth sacrificing Money in the Bank - and such a significant one, no less - to achieve that aim? Absolutely not.