50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE Royal Rumble
20. CM Punk Was A Kid At Christmas In 2008
It's always a treat when you've watched so much wrestling you forget some sneakily brilliant moments that rekindle the magic of childhood wonder.
That happened to your writer when watching the 2008 Rumble. Quick bit of context: This was the third Rumble in a row (it was a quiet Sunday), so imagine the pop when Roddy Piper's music hit and he came face to face with old rival Jimmy Snuka as Madison Square Garden lost it.
They weren't the only ones - CM Punk was loving life too. He grinned from ear to ear as he rested and watched two old heroes do battle in the middle of a WWE ring for the first time in decades. Obviously, this couldn't top John Cena's epic return to win the whole match, but it was a killer nostalgia blast.
WWE would lean on that nostalgia in the Rumble heavily as the years rolled on; especially during mid-portion lulls.
Punk's reaction to what he was seeing contrasted with The Undertaker's. That particular icon had entered the bout as #1, so he was dead on his feet by the time Roddy and Snuka came to blows. If anything, 'Taker likely appreciated a breather in the corner.
Over on the other side, it's fairly obvious both Punk and John Morrison were having a mini mark out session over all of this. It isn't hard to understand why.
The Garden meant so much to WWE lore, and so did legends like Piper and Snuka. Their feud had been a banner moment in the 1980s, and now here they were coming full circle in 2008. Punk was absolutely ecstatic to witness it up close and personal.
19. 2009 Clutched At Straws
Match-defining threads locking everything together were nothing new for the Rumble by the time 2009’s scrap rolled into view, but Triple H battling with Legacy just didn’t feel that thrilling when watching for a second time 15 years later. One thing becomes clear whilst the match is in progress: WWE were going against fan wishes by booking Triple H vs. Randy Orton the way they did.
It was all so forced, but that's easier to see now than it was back then.
People in Detroit for January's pay-per-view were into Hunter as a baby and Randy as a heel, but they’d been there done that with the combo time and time again. A young Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase were heaped on as extras to try and make things feel different. It didn't click as well as everyone thought it would.
It certainly didn't click anywhere near as well as Cody's title reign has in the modern era. Orton won despite Hunter eliminating both Rhodes and DiBiase before losing out. WWE were going for a heroic babyface gimmick here, but some of the other elements next to Trips were skewed.
For example, neither Vince nor Stephanie McMahon came across as likeable enough characters for sadistic heel Randy to toy with. There were good moments on TV, but they would've been better with stronger faces.
The McMahons had natural heel energy.
It's pretty interesting to see how many of the tropes WWE used for Trips as babyface became go to ones for Roman Reigns almost a decade later. A lot of it was the same old stuff.
18. Nobody Has Matched HBK’s 2010 Desperation
The desperation of Shawn Michaels was a waaaaaay hotter plot point than Triple H's anti-Legacy quest. In 2010, HBK entered an Oscar-worthy performance in the Rumble after entering as #18. He started off on top of his game by eliminating everyone from old buddy Trips, Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase to Drew McIntyre, Carlito and John Morrison.
That's when things fell apart and ended in heartbreak, kid.
Go back and watch the way Shawn reached out for the rope like he was a dying man clinging to life after being thrown over the top by Batista. Phenomenal. Nobody has ever put across their anguish the way Michaels did back then.
He needed to win the Rumble and headline WrestleMania one last time before retiring. Of course, WWE kinda ruined the story by having Shawn main event in a non-title bout vs. The Undertaker anyway, but that shouldn't detract from his emotions during the 30-man match.
Michaels is regarded as one of the best ever for a reason. This is just example 3,472, or therein thereabouts. He couldn't have done a better job of hiking up the drama in 2010 right before Edge went on to win instead.
The shattered and heartbroken look on Shawn's face when he realised everything was slipping away? Priceless, and it elevated the 2010 Rumble to become one of the best ever.
The current NXT overseer put across more feeling and passion in 23 minutes than most wrestlers do in a lifetime. His entire second run between 2002-2010 is well worth reliving all over again, but the 2010 Rumble has to be right up there as one of the top highlights from it.
17. R-Truth Had A Moment Nobody Remembers
R-Truth is one of those unsung heroes who's still purring in WWE, so anytime there's an excuse to give him his flowers? Take it. Sure, his 24/7 Title stuff grated hard after a while, but Truth is one of the few to get comedy right under Vince's watch, and that should earn the guy a Hall Of Fame ring alone.
He was swimming upstream against a toilet humour tide there!
Get ready for an insane realisation whilst watching the 2010 Rumble: Truth entered at #25 and immediately dumped both Mark Henry and Big Show out of the match. Typically, it takes multiple workers to eliminate even one of those guys, and WWE makes a big song and dance about the spot to kill a few minutes. Not on this occasion.
Truth made it look easy, and it happened so quickly most have forgotten all about his giant double elimination in years since it happened.
Next question: Where was R-Truth to stop the pain of Show and Kane wrecking momentum in the 2015 Rumble, eh? Eh?! WWE should have a Batman-style searchlight for times like that. You're needed, Truth. Go do your thing and save the fans from boredom.
That's what he did back in 2010 amidst all the Shawn Michaels-led drama and Edge's victory celebrations.
Less than 5 mins later, Truth was eliminated by Kofi Kingston, but he'd done his bit for the cause. Perhaps this observation is going in 2-footed on Henry and Show, but it was just so unexpected to see them thrown out of the Rumble this way. Most others have surely forgotten about it too.
16. 2011’s 40-Man Experiment Flopped
The mid-80s "sports entertainment" boom cemented the WWF as an organisation that stood for production excellence, mass excitement and a boatload of hype/exaggerated claims. Bigger was always better.
Liked WrestleMania I? Well, have 'Mania 2 beamed from 3 different cities. Enjoyed the first televised Rumble in 1988? Here it is in '89, albeit with 30 superstars instead of 20. Going big was always the aim.
What worked mid-Hulkamania didn't fly decades later. Come 2011, WWE tried to pitch that year's Royal Rumble as the biggest and best ever. The famous match would have 40 entrants instead of the now-standard 30, but something didn't sit right with fans.
Sure, WWE went bigger, but they defo didn't go better. It turns out that 30 is the ideal number for any Rumble, and there's no getting away from the fact that some innovations just flat out suck.
Beefing up the count by 10 did nothing for the match at all, and 2011 is actually one of the flattest Rumbles to revisit today. No wonder bosses shrugged their shoulders after seeing it in execution and quietly ditched the idea until 2018's Greatest Royal Rumble came along to make things worse by exacerbating everything that was wrong with 2011.
That took some doing, but they did it.
Nostalgic comebacks from the likes of Diesel and Booker T mattered more to fans after the event than Alberto Del Rio's win too. The same goes for John Cena eliminating CM Punk before Del Rio had his moment in the sun. Those were all bigger talking points post-PPV than the 40-man tryout or who remained standing at the end.
15. Comedy Strangled 2012
WWE could've slapped a funny theme song on the branding for 2012's Rumble and referred to it as 'the comedic one', because there were laughter tracks scattered all over the thing. In the end, it was a stumble more than a Rumble. Mick Foley returned to have a mirth-filled battle between 'Mr. Socko' and the 'Cobra' with Santino Marella, and announcers like Michael Cole, Jerry Lawler and Booker T all had short stays in the match themselves.
It's a bit jarring to experience all over again without the week by week context of WWE's TV product. Far too many of the entrants were inconsequential, and Sheamus winning 100% comes out looking forced whether fans liked it or not. He was Vinnie Mac's chosen new babyface, so everyone would just have to put up with it until the boss moved on to a shiny new toy.
Sheamus wasn't bad, just miscast. In fairness, he wasn't given much backup with all that Foley vs. Santino stuff and so many commentators drifting in and out of the match in the blink of an eye. Star power hadn't been this thin in the Rumble for a while, put it that way.
This is one to skip if you're on a Rumble binge session before the next event and need to save some time here or there.
Give it a miss unless you absolutely must consume everything Foley, or liked that period when Cole in-ring tortured countless other fans. MC lasting longer in the match than surprise entrant Kharma and future WWE Champ Jinder Mahal should've been a crime. Less so for the latter, but you get the point.
14. Poor Rey Mysterio Didn’t See 2014 Coming!
The build up to this sorry state of affairs begins as soon as anyone fires on the 2014 Rumble and CM Punk makes his entrance as #1. You know what's about to happen. The live crowd in Pittsburgh wanted Daniel Bryan more than anything in the whole wide world, but WWE wouldn't budge.
Batista was the comeback king ready to punch his WrestleMania ticket, and people were far from happy about it.
A toxic mood created by the booking and Boo-tista's return trickled down onto other legends too. Things would be rectified by the #30 slot though, eh? Surely Bryan, who had lost to Bray Wyatt on the undercard, would rush out and put everything right.
No - Rey Mysterio was the final entrant, and he was booed out of the building. Well, WWE's decision to put anyone but Bryan in that spot was jeered heavily, at least.
Batista won the match and did some sign pointing (such was becoming the norm), and the live crowd rebelled. Spare a thought for poor Rey though. He was also booed hard, which is so, so odd to witness considering his legendary status.
Christ, he was even a legend back then! You'd never get this sort of reaction to his entrances in any Rumble now.
Mysterio was perceptive enough to feel the heat and shift to the ring pronto. His 2-minute showing wasn't satisfying enough to quell the discontented masses who believed they'd been shafted by a company that didn't view Bryan the same way they did. If only big Dave had thought to grab the mic and yell, 'Are you not entertained?!'.
That would've been some heel turn, but that wasn't WWE's plan.
13. Rock’s 2015 Confusion Is Still Funny
Looking back, was there a real risk of the Royal Rumble losing all good graces with the core fanbase permanently?! That thought seems a tad extreme, but WWE annoyed the fans with back to back results in both 2014 and 2015. It certainly wouldn't do to have so-called babyface Rumble winners pointing at the big WrestleMania sign as everyone either booed, rolled their eyes or flooded for the exits.
That's what makes the final few minutes of 2015's pay-per-view so fascinating in a twisted way.
The Rock raised the hand of winner and new WWE poster boy Roman Reigns as jeers rained down hard from the stands. This was becoming an unwanted trend for the McMahons, and this guy would be willing to bet that they didn't like it one bit. Watch 2015's event again and you might well get some sick enjoyment out of seeing Rocky's most confused eyebrow ever right at the end of the show though.
Philly was his least favourite city for a few minutes there.
Roman was still a fresh-faced hopeful at the time, so he stuck to his guns and gamely brave-faced the whole ordeal. Rock was aghast at what was happening; he visibly went slack-jawed and flashed the same mix of disbelief and anger he had when being booed vs. Brock Lesnar at SummerSlam 2002 or Hulk Hogan earlier that same year during WrestleMania X8.
It's kinda funny in a sensationalistic way. It's also OK to laugh knowing that everything worked out for Reigns eventually. When he won his next Rumble, the cheers were loud, but more on that soon.
12. 2016 Showed The Best & Worst Of WWE
His trigger finger wasn't anywhere near as itchy as it'd become a few years later, but Kevin Dunn needed a cuff on the ear for skipping AJ Styles' first ever company entrance so he could focus on Roman Reigns doing his best, 'Who the hell is that?!' face in 2016. That was the worst of WWE at the time.
The best came when AJ got a strong half hour in the Rumble before being thrown out by Kevin Owens.
There was no shame in that, but there was shame in Dunn's production style favouring Vince's pet projects over somebody who was literally appearing in front of WWE fans for the first time. Surely that was more important than zooming in on Roman? Reigns was already a main-eventer, and he didn't need the extra cheese on his whopper.
AJ did. He needed that attention and the rewards that come with it.
If one's being kind, he'd suggest that Dunn was harking back to Steve Austin's horrified facials when Bret Hart came out to face him in the '97 Rumble. That'd be stretching it. In reality, WWE likely prioritised Roman over AJ's debut.
At least Styles' bow was one of the best Rumble debuts ever, and his in-ring performance allayed any fears about what post-TNA AJ in WWE would look like. One year later, AJ was working John Cena for the WWE Title at the 2017 pay-per-view.
Things panned out for him nicely, but good lord - would it have killed Dunn to let everyone bask in the atmosphere of a Style-ish arrival?
11. The First Female Rumble Remains The Best
When binging 2-3 Rumble events every other night in preparation for this epic, it was easy to get some Rumble blur. In other words, things started to stick together in the ol' brain box, because there are only so many surprise spots, teased eliminations or final four stand offs someone can take without the benefit of 12 months between them.
That's why the 2018 show felt so refreshing to reach.
WWE introduced another first for the women's division by running an all-female Royal Rumble match. This was the next logical step in the "women's revolution" that had been touted since 2015-ish. 2018's match remains the best one yet.
Maybe that speaks to the freshness of it, or perhaps it's down to Asuka being a high-quality, inspired choice as winner. Let's go for both.
The entire women's locker room was raring to go, and well done to WWE for giving them the main event slot on the night. The historical significance of this first would've been dampened had they been stuffed on the undercard somewhere. Opening the pay-per-view would've been slightly less bothersome, but that headline slot was well deserved.
A post-match debut for one Ronda Rousey shocked the world too. This was long before 'Rowdy' Ronda had a meltdown at wrestling fans or decided she didn't really enjoy the WWE process after all. She was excited to be there, and the mainstream media couldn't get enough of querying what this meant for her MMA career over on the news channels.
Subsequent female Rumbles have had serious highs, of course, but nothing comes close to the first. Or, at least, hasn't yet. WWE might top this someday.