One week removed from NXT Takeover, and the wrestling world is still abuzz about the WWE's developmental talents. Not only was the show a great one, with high drama and quality in-ring action, it's arguable that the NXT Special was a better show top to bottom than WWE Payback, which featured the likes of Triple H, The Shield, Randy Orton, John Cena, and company as opposed to lesser known entities like Sami Zayn, Tyler Breeze, and Charlotte who were featured on NXT Takeover. The fact is that the show one week ago proved two things: 1) The Divas Division in the WWE is a joke compared to what the women have going on in NXT, and 2) the WWE has some bright performers on its horizon. The question is, will these talents translate to the main roster? They all have the ability, but as we've seen, the WWE can bungle the transition from NXT to main roster. It's easy to imagine that some of the guys that we love on NXT will have a hard time carving out a spot for themselves on the crowded, more critically scrutinized main roster. In fact there are at least 6 names that are beloved amongst the NXT faithful, that might have some trouble were they to be called up to the main roster tomorrow. For some its their character that won't translate, for some it'll be their size that makes it hard for them to find their footing, and for other it might simply be impossible to match the success they had on NXT in the WWE's crowded main roster landscape. Let's take a look at these performers who will struggle to find their niche in the WWE narrative based on their gimmicks, their abilities, or possibly simply due to overcrowding. Of course you can chime in with your thoughts, which are always appreciated, in the comment section below. Let's generate a little discussion, and prognosticate about the stars of tomorrow!
6. Bayley
Bayley is without question one of the most beloved characters on NXT, and if you take one look at her work, it's easy to see why. As a character she's enthusiastic, affectionate, a wrestling historian, she's painfully shy at times, and she is in every sense of the term an underdog in the NXT's Women's Division. Furthermore, she is absolutely adorable and a pretty good wrestler to boot, and that along with her other great qualities endears her to the fans. Every week she comes out to the ring and she's so happy to be there. Any fan can relate to that on at least some level and while most of us will never don a pair of trunks and wrestle in front of the WWE Universe, fans know how they would feel if they got the chance to. Bayley is NXT's embodiment of that, and that along with her status as an underdog and the fact that she might be the cutest thing in a WWE ring, is why the crowd at Full Sail loves her. All that being said, it's hard to believe that her shtick will translate well to Raw and Smackdown. There's always a chance obviously, but the character that she projects is not one that is long for the main roster. While she may be a breath of fresh air on NXT, it wouldn't take long before the fans turned on her on the grander stage. The WWE Universe at large doesn't appreciate cute, or adorable, or naivety, or general enthusiasm. The WWE Universe at large loves a bad ass, somebody with some edge to them, and edge is simply something that Bayley doesn't have. Were she to be called up to the main roster, she would flame out in a matter of weeks. Fans would tire of her fangirl, goody goody attitude and she would be jobbing to top Diva heels in no time.
5. Mojo Rawley
Mojo Rawley is a relentless ball of energy whose mere presence in the NXT Arena gets fans excited. Say what you will about his actual wrestling ability (which is limited) or the believability of his maneuvers (which aren't all that believable), Mojo brings energy that gets the people going in Full Sail. He doesn't get hyped, he stays hyped, and chances are that if you are present in that arena during a Mojo Rawley match, you will be at least a little bit energized by the hype machine that is Mojo Rawley. Conventional wisdom would suggest that Rawley is then a pretty good fit for the main roster, specifically for those long 3 hour Raw shows, where some segments can drag on and eventually suck any energy the crowd may have had out of them. Mojo could be the answer for that; simply insert him into what you anticipate could be an emotional lull for the program and boom, he's an instant energizer that will bring the crowd back up. If you think that, you'd be wrong. While it's true that Raw can tend to drag because of it's length, it is also true that the WWE Universe at large are a rather unforgiving lot as opposed to their more forgiving Full Sail sub-section. They are unforgiving of stupidity, they are unforgiving of guys that they don't think deserve a push getting one, and they are certainly unforgiving of empty energy. At the end of the day Mojo is empty energy. He has no substance to his character, and without being an impressive in-ring talent he will peter out in no time on the main roster, especially under the current incarnation of the character.
4. Aiden English
Even though he is portrayed as a heel on NXT, Aiden English is without question one of the superstars that Full Sail University can't get enough of. They either love him, or love to hate him, but they want him in the ring or on their television screens, serenading and entertaining them. Aiden has certainly earned his spot on the NXT roster, being one of the most charismatic performers they have. He is a quality singer, cleverer than anyone could have expected when it comes to his lines (some of the cleverest word play in a WWE ring by a guy not named The Rock), he has a magnetism that draws you to his performance, and on top of all that, the guy is more than serviceable in the ring. Whether you root against him because he's the villain or not, nobody can say that the guy doesn't bring something unique to the table. Aiden English has pretty much everything that somebody would need to carve out a spot for themselves on the main roster, but still you can't help but be doubtful that he has much of a chance. Firstly his body type doesn't do him any favours. He is skinny and lanky, and while that may fit in with his character being a drama geek on NXT, amongst some of the trees that they have on the main roster, it will be hard to believe that he poses any real threat. Secondly his name is forgettable, not quite on the level of a Michael McGillicutty, but pretty pedestrian in its own right. Finally, his biggest hindrance on the main roster would be the character itself. There is a ceiling on how successful this kind of character can be, and the best he could hope for is to be Fandango. There are plenty of those kinds of characters on the main roster, which will mean he'll likely never stand out, and will just be another forgettable face in the crowd.
3. CJ Parker
CJ Parker started off on NXT as a babyface that everyone hated, and how could you not? His entrance was stupid, his dancing was dumb, and his nickname "Moonchild" was lifted straight from the 1970s. Everything about the gimmick was ham-handed, hokey and dated. Add to all that that CJ Parker wasn't that great of a wrestler and his name was taken from a Baywatch character, and it wasn't surprising that people couldn't bring themselves to get behind it. Now that they've turned him heel, and are having him play an annoying, overly judgmental environmentalist, he seems to be in a role better suited for such a hokey character. What he's saying about the world is right, but he's so obnoxious and preachy that you can't wait for him to get his head kicked in. Without Bo Dallas on NXT, CJ Parker might be the brand's most unlikable heel, which is a good thing. The character can only work on NXT unfortunately. Not that the WWE isn't in need of uncool heels (there's an epidemic of heels trying to be cool all over the main roster right now), it's just hard to say that the WWE Universe would react to this CJ Parker character one way or the other. Having him play the part of dickish Lorax, coming to the arena each week and protesting on behalf of the trees works in a smaller environment like NXT, and as we've established, the NXT subsection of the WWE audience is slightly more forgiving of the outside the box ideas than the WWE Universe at large would be. Were he to be called up to the main roster, it is doubtful that he'd receive much of a reaction at all, and would be sent back to NXT to get repackaged.
2. Tyler Breeze
Let's get this out of the way, Tyler Breeze is a gem. His character, his performance, his ability in the ring, his brand new theme song (sung by himself) are all outstanding. His understanding of who his character is, down to his mannerisms and the fact that never at any point during a match or promo (by himself of somebody else) does he break character for even a millisecond is proof that he has completely encompassed this character. When he's in the ring or on an NXT screen, he is not a performer portraying Tyler Breeze, he is Tyler Breeze. It seems like a silly distinction to make but it's the difference between the great performers in the WWE, and the ones that aren't quite up to snuff. Couple this with the fact that Tyler Breeze is a phenomenal athlete and terrific wrestler (trained by one of the best technical wrestlers ever, Lance Storm) and its hard to imagine that this guy doesn't have everything you need to be successful in the WWE. That said, you can't help but worry about what would happen to Prince Pretty if he were called up to the main roster. The fact is that he is a smaller guy, and on the main roster we've seen just that fact derail several promising superstars. You also have to account for the fact that his character, the self-centred model is more in the same vein as Adam Rose and Fandango, both characters I don't expect to be stars on Raw or Smackdown in the years to come. Both those guys would be lucky to have a solid Intercontinental or U.S. Title run. If you were to poll people who watch Breeze on NXT, you'd find that most of them believe that he is a great performer and is absolutely entertaining in and out of the ring. He has all the tools to at the very least rule the mid-card of the WWE, and possibly be a guy you could throw out there against top guys and put on a great show. The question isn't what we think, it's what Vince and the higher ups think. With that in mind, it's just hard to imagine that they'd attach more value to him than they would another niche character like Fandango or Adam Rose.
1. Adrian Neville
Adrian Neville is inarguably the flagship performer on NXT as it is presently constituted. You could maybe make a case for Sami Zayn, but Neville is the champ, and Neville is the guy racking up wins. He's been half of the NXT Tag Team Champions, he is the current NXT Champion, and the fans absolutely love to watch him wrestle. He does things in a wrestling ring that many WWE fans would believe impossible. He is an aerial show for the ages. You couple that with his status as an underdog because of his size, and you have a viable replacement for Rey Mysterio. he has all the same skills, brings the same brand of excitement, and only lacks the appeal to the latino market. With all that said, why is Adrian Neville on this list? He's amazing, he packs so much punch in such a small package, he can do things that the world has never seen before! This is a guy the WWE should showcase! This is all true, and allowing him to perform death-defying leaps and flips to draw eyes to their product is likely what they will do with this guy, but while he is at the pinnacle of NXT, the cornerstone of that brand, the best he could hope for on the main roster is to be a multiple time Intercontinental Champion. Why? Because he lacks charisma. The guy is a brutal promo, and to make matters worse he doesn't have any engaging phrases, celebrations or traits that the fans can latch onto. RVD may not be the best promo guy, but he does have charisma, he does have his signature taunt, and we all know that he's an arrogant guy, which we like. Neville is RVD without any personality, Rey Mysterio without the branding or brand potential. He leaves a lot to be desired when it comes to these important aspects of being a WWE superstar, which is why his place on NXT right now, seems to be the peak of his career,
Matthew J. Douglas is an emerging screenwriter born in Toronto. A lifelong fascination with what makes a compelling story and the Toni Morrison quote "If there's a book that you want to read, but it hasn't been written yet, then you must write it." led the often opinionated Matthew to the life of writer. Matthew is also a lifelong WWE fan, and a self diagnosed Reality TV Junkie.