6 Interesting Observations From WWE's Mae Young Classic
Memorable matches, new stars made, bolstered ranks and forgettable announcing.
After a critically acclaimed tournament last year featuring some of the best cruiserweight wrestlers in the world, WWE decided to go all-in on its ongoing effort to brand itself as championing a women’s evolution in wrestling.
The inaugural Mae Young Classic, which concluded with a live finale Tuesday after SmackDown, should be termed by all accounts as a success, introducing several female wrestlers to a larger audience and showing that what we’ve been seeing out of several of the current and former NXT standouts is not limited to WWE. There are talented female competitors all over the globe who can more than hold their own in the ring.
That’s not to say that the tournament was without some hiccups. But let’s give WWE credit for putting together an all-female tournament that delivered several memorable matches and brought some new faces into the casual fans’ conscience. That alone is worth something.
Whether WWE decides to hold another such tournament, it’s fair to say this was a worthwhile venture for the company, as well as a learning opportunity to not repeat a couple mistakes. Regardless, the entire tournament is available on the WWE Network and definitely worth a watch. We’ll undoubtedly see several of these women on WWE TV again soon, so best to familiarize yourself with them.
While we could go back and review individual matches and offer critiques, let’s take a look at some overall observations from the Mae Young Classic. Let’s get to it…
6. Stretched Out Too Far
When you look at the field of 32 wrestlers, there was a noticeable drop-off of talent, with several women clearly not belonging in such an event. Marti Belle’s dismal performance, which reportedly resulted in the booking being changed on the fly, is a standout example.
The result was a handful of first-round matches that were pedestrian at best, boring at worst. While not every match can be a home run, it’s not great when trying out a new idea – an all-female tournament – to throw a handful of dud matches out there right out of the gate.
The good news is that there were enough skilled competitors and solid matches to more than make up for the bad ones, and the tournament really picked up in the second round. And that begs the question: Would it have been better to do a smaller tournament?
Of course, 16 women most likely would have meant four fewer episodes and several talented women being left out. But going with 32 resulted in some inexperienced wrestlers getting slots. Maybe they could have had a round robin tournament with eight pools of three wrestlers (24 total), and then the winners of each have a single-elimination tourney (last three rounds of Mae Young). Just an idea.
5. Several Hidden Gems
While there were a handful of wrestlers who might not have belonged in the tournament, there were plenty of memorable matches that are well worth checking out.
Without going into detailed explanations about each, viewers should make it a point to watch Kairi Sane versus Tessa Blanchard, Jazzy Gabert versus Abbey Laith, Laith/Rachel Evers, Sane/Bianca Belair, Piper Niven versus Santana Garrett, Niven/Toni Storm and Shayna Baszler versus Mercedes Martinez. Those matches all exceeded expectations and were great representations of what the competitors were capable of.
When a tournament can produce several matches that have fans buzzing afterward, you’ve done something right.
4. Subpar Announcing
One warranted criticism that popped up a lot on social media
bears mentioning here because it was completely within WWE’s control.
One of the strongest parts of last year’s Cruiserweight Classic was the pairing of Mauro Ranallo and Daniel Bryan calling the action. Both men were extremely knowledgeable and very into the entire tournament, and it showed in how they called matches.
On the other hand, we had what felt like a disinterested Jim Ross and Lita, who slogged their way through the tournament, reciting pre-prepared facts about the competitors and trying to muster excitement during some of the slower bouts. It was just obvious that they weren’t adding a lot to many of the matches, and in some cases were actually detracting from what was going on in the ring.
While having a WWE Hall of Fame announcer in JR and a HOF female wrestler in Lita call the action sounded great on paper, it was clear that they didn’t work as well as hoped. The company needs to pay attention to that going forward.
3. Baszler Protected, But Solid
Shayna Baszler has only been wrestling for two years, but her decade of experience in MMA certainly has helped her with her development in the squared circle.
While Baszler finished runner-up in the Mae Young Classic, she certainly can’t be categorized as the second-best competitor in the tournament. She was somewhat protected in having mainly experienced opponents (Mia Yim, Candice LaRae and Mercedes Martinez) fighting her and making sure she looked like a million bucks. They also kept her matches relatively short while sticking to her strong suit: striking and submissions.
However, it’s also fair to say that Baszler held her own throughout the tournament. Just because you aren’t the best in-ring performer and have veterans providing the opposition, you still have to get the job done yourself. And the Queen of Spades certainly did that. She also played the badass heel role really well.
It’s unclear whether she’ll actually come to WWE as a full-time wrestler or participate in a “Battle of the Four Horsewomen,” but Baszler definitely accredited herself.
2. Kairi Is The Real Deal
When someone has a buzz surrounding them as one of the best
wrestlers in the world, that can be both a blessing and a curse. It’s a lot to
live up to those expectations.
But Kairi Sane did just that during the Mae Young Classic, winning five matches en route to becoming the inaugural MYC winner. Along the way, Kairi captivated fans with her Insane Elbow diving elbow drop that rivals “Macho Man” Randy Savage’s famed elbow drop. She had standout matches against Tessa Blanchard and Bianca Belair, and her semi-final match against Toni Storm was also a good one.
Sane and Shayna Baszler had a solid, entertaining finals match on Tuesday, with Kairi showing as she has during the entire tournament that she plays underdog better than almost any wrestler out there. If she can stay healthy, Kairi could be a huge asset to the women’s division on Raw or SmackDown.
1. Reinforcements Are Coming
If you take a look at the ranks of the women’s divisions on
Raw and SmackDown, you’ll see a lot of wrestlers who came up through NXT in the
past couple years. In fact, the vast majority of active wrestlers cut their
teeth in NXT.
With Asuka leaving NXT to head to Raw, it’s clear there was a talent gap forming due to all the departures. But the Mae Young Classic might help replenish NXT’s ranks in a big way. Some women already were under contract (such as Abbey Laith, Lacey Evans, Sara Logan and Bianca Belair), but it looks like several others have been added to the developmental territory, such as Dakota Kai, Rhea Ripley and Taynara Conti.
If anything, the women already under contract got an opportunity to shine, while others used the tournament to introduce themselves to WWE and launch a new phase of their careers. If even half of the women who signed with WWE make it to the main roster, it will help fill out the ranks up there, so we can avoid repetitive bouts on Raw and SmackDown.
That might be one of the biggest legacies of the Mae Young Classic: bringing in new talent, introducing them to WWE fans and then bringing them into the fold to create deep divisions of skilled women’s wrestlers.