6 Match Star Ratings From WWE WrestleMania 40 Night 2

The story is finished, Cody is the Man, and Bayley is rejuvenated.

Cody Rhodes five stars
WWE

Extending WrestleMania across two nights was a badly needed and well overdue development - when WWE was actually afraid of the growing wider wrestling world, in the mid-to-late 2010s, and set about warehousing as much talent as possible. 

It's still probably the best way to go about it, even if the scope of the roster is the same size as it was when WWE promoted four-hour one-night stadium shows years earlier. That approach yielded its own issues, in that WWE sometimes struggled to sequence the card properly - more than one match died when it shouldn't have - and, moreover, a lot of emerging midcard acts never got (sorry) their 'Moment'. The two night split is the best compromise.  

Still, a trend has emerged: Night 1 was invariably better and hotter than Night 2.

The line-ups last year were probably ill-advised. The razzmatazz on Night 1 - Logan Paul and KSI, that phenomenal Dominick Mysterio entrance - might have made Night 2 slightly less than the slog it was in the middle phase. By Night 2, you've already seen the stage, You've already seen that awesome vista of fans. You've already felt the WrestleMania magic, and the magic is that it used to feel that bit more elusive. 

LA Knight working a singles match on Night 2 threatened to bring about that three-year pattern. 

Then again, Night 2 was only about one thing. really. 

WWE didn't do it again, did they?!

6. Seth Rollins Vs. Drew McIntyre - World Heavyweight Championship

WM Drew McIntyre Seth Rollins
WWE

Seth Rollins Vs. Drew McIntyre was great, the post-match angle was superb, and both set the tone for a mostly brilliant night two of WrestleMania. Seth and Drew got it here, to their credit. 

Over the last however many years, the art of the opener has died off. Very often, a match that is long simply happens to open a big US wrestling show. The old idea - of a lean, action-packed match that does not piss about and gets the crowd immediately on-side - resurfaced here. Drew echoed WrestleMania XXVIII by immediately jumping Seth Rollins with the Claymore kick. That was inspired. The fans weren't asked to squint and concentrate on a distant blur of limb work. Moreover, that 2012 precedent remains so unforgettable that the resulting near-fall was entirely believable. Drew was cocky as Seth recovered, losing focus, taunting CM Punk and taking selfies with his wife. From there, for 10 blistering minutes in an exhilarating match that felt like it could end at any time, Seth fought back but couldn't withstand the pain coursing through his knee to mount a consistent advantage. 

The near-falls were great, the momentum shifted like a vibrating bell, and McIntyre won with a Claymore after Rollins couldn't capitalise after stomping Drew's head on the commentary table. 10 punchy, very loud, super dramatic minutes. 

This ruled, and after the big title win, a sensational angle followed. Drew and Seth shared a quiet, respectful exchange of words. Drew kissed his wife. He wore the opposite of job face; this felt like a genuine title celebration. It wasn't. After Drew stood on the table and crotch-chopped Punk swept his legs, removed from the brace from his arm, and beat Drew silly with it. Damian Priest then cashed in to a mega-pop after an unbelievably high South of Heaven. 

Outrageously good stuff.

Star Rating: ★★★★


5. Bobby Lashley & The Street Profits Vs. The Final Testament - Philadelphia Street Fight

WM Final Testament
WWE

The Final Testsment Vs. Bobby Lashley and the Street Profits was a mess of a match. 

Firstly, around half of the stadium couldn't see it. A beaming light blotted their eyes and, despite many very vocal requests, the production unit only dimmed it near the finish. Don't confuse the crowd reaction with heat generated by Karrion Kross or a pop that met his comeuppance. None of that happened. Fans didn't actually like the match, but they'd have preferred to have been able to see it than not. Watching the stream back, they didn't miss much - unless they get schadenfreude from messy, bad wrestling. After a generic heat sequence with kendo sticks set the tone of a bog-standard WWE plunder match, things unravelled. It was clunky more than it was botched to high heaven. 

Very little was registered to dramatic effect. Even chaos has to breathe a little, and this didn't: it was a rushed, clunky and hardly violent match. Scarlett Bourdeaux barely got the time to draw heat before B-Fab neutralised her interference. Bubba Ray Dudley turned midway through the match and helped Lashey and the Street Profits through a table. The first one broke; it could only happen to Karrion Kross. Not good at all. 

The ECW tribute is mandatory in Philadelphia, apparently, but you'd be better off venturing to the nearest shindie that can afford to pay the Sandman to do his entrance.

Star Rating: ★¼


4. LA Knight Vs. AJ Styles

WM AJ Styles LA Knight
WWE

LA Knight Vs. AJ Styles continued the least impressive streak in WrestleMania history: AJ's match quality on the grandest stage is so poor that it's often hard to recall that he's a legitimate great of the 21st century. 

This wasn't actively bad or anything, but it was mediocre short of the odd, elusive exciting moment. They didn't do the appalling old WWE thing and begin a grudge match with a collar-and-elbow tie-up - God, remember the Dean Ambrose Vs. Seth Rollins programme? - but after the hysterical personal violence of the build, it was a bit daft to start hot with punches only for Knight to very quickly turn in his usual offence. This needed a stip and didn't get one. The match was good when attempts were made to convey the hatred that apparently existed between the two men. Knight taking a back body drop onto exposed boards by ringside was one such moment, but elsewhere, this was a shoot-out between a man who has lost his fastball and a man who may never have had one. 

Knight won with the BFT. Elements of the match were good, but nothing was really sewn together in a way that kept the fans locked in. When they weren't complaining about the blinding light above the big screen that towered over the ring, they chanted "YEAH" mostly because it's fun to chant. On that light: it removed focus from two matches and seems to be a recurring issue every year at WrestleMania. 

It's not good enough for a promotion that brags so much about its production values.

Star Rating: ★★¾


3. Logan Paul Vs. Randy Orton Vs. Kevin Owens - United States Championship

WM Randy Orton Logan Paul II
WWE

The main event was an unforgettable spectacle for what it was, and everybody in the stadium took leave of their senses entirely, but - subjectively - the Triple Threat United States title match was the most impressive thing on the card. 

In a superb entrance, Kevin Owens entered the ring on an ATV and then backed up the ring to pick up Randy Orton on their journey to kick Logan Paul's ass together. They did precisely that for several minutes before Orton sneakily attempted an RKO. Everything about this was fantastic: Orton's sheepish expression, Kevin's look of "What gives?", the mutual decision to say "Screw it" and have a hockey fight, the hockey fight dynamic. When Paul took them out with a double Buckshot lariat, his smug grin was radioactive. He'd just taken out two major stars at once, and he let the crowd know it. They let him have it and how with a booming chorus of jeers in return. It was fantastic. 

WWE technically broke the "rules" by stacking the odds against the heel early, but did so in a way that was consistent with the characters. Orton and Owens have that devil in them. This really was utterly perfect storytelling given who precisely was involved. The match evolved into something constantly exciting, a swarm of activity, with various RKO teases, reversals and several lively sequences in which each wrestler could never quite hit or score the pin from their attempts to take both opponents out with consecutive big moves. 'Speed', a streamer (?), revealed himself as the Prime mascot and for those too old to know who he is, it didn't matter. 

It was easy to infer that he is intensely annoying and he did a cracking job of communicating that and bumping for an RKO on a table. Paul retained by splashing Owens after Orton, who he'd thrown out, did the hard work. 

This match was class: a perfect delivery of a fun but equally tricky dynamic.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


2. IYO SKY Vs, Bayley - WWE Women's Championship

WM Bayley IYO Sky II
WWE

IYO Sky Vs. Bayley followed a similar path to the other Women's title match: it started slowly and generated minimal heat as you'd probably have expected, given that the storyline while a traditional hit didn't feel hot throughout the build. 

Sky targeted Bayley's leg early, which made sense but didn't help matters: limb work doesn't play all that well in a stadium setting. Happily, the fans didn't just come up for the finish; Bayley knows how to control an audience and is almost a stealthily great bomb dropper. When Sky ate a gruesome sunset flip bomb into the bottom turnbuckle, the old Bayley crowd reaction materialised. She was serenaded with the "Hey Bayley!" chants as she paced her comeback masterfully. 

Both women built on the atmosphere with a sequence of excellent, sudden momentum shifts: the spot in which Bayley bravely fought through the pain in her knee to attempt a flying elbow drop, only for IYO to trap her with a crossface, completely unglued an enthralled crowd. Even better was the series of moonsaults that Bayley evaded at the third attempt, only for Sky to front-flip out of a Rose Plant. That was superb, heart-stopping pro wrestling excitement. Bayley won, to a stirring reaction, with the flying elbow and Rose Plant combo. 

Watching Bayley finally get her big babyface moment on the main roster was just lovely.

Star Rating: ★★★★


1. Roman Reigns Vs. Cody Rhodes - Undisputed WWE Universal Championship

WM Roman Reigns Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes finished the story, but the story finished in a way that was popular if unnecessary - if you happen to be a bit of a misery.

Before the bizarre cameo-stuffed schmozz, Cody and Roman replicated their exquisite in-ring chemistry. The best way of describing is to picture the sort of match WWE mandates as an institution - slow-burn pacing, make 'em come up, make the spaces between the big moves count - only really, really, really good. They're just so assured. What they do in there is everything Triple H and Randy Orton thought they were doing a decade and a half ago. In a great early moment, Cody withdrew a table from under the ring. In the ultimate heel move one can pull in 2024, Roman shoved it back. With the fans in a total chokehold, as loud as the stadium was across the 24 hours, Roman, toying with his opponent, executed a Cross Rhodes.   

While the finisher theft trope has been done for years and indeed to death, it meant something here. Roman tried to big league Cody, saying that his moves were trash. This was Roman's company.

Cody gave Roman a receipt by dropping him with a spear. Cody then initiated his closing match-winning play before Jimmy Uso interfered. In a spot 1000x times better than anything in their diabolical match on Saturday, Jey speared him off the ramp and through a table. Solo Sikoa then interfered, but the resulting spike/spear double team didn't land as a near-fall because fans sensed the Marvel "cinema" incoming. John Cena fought Solo off. This brought out the Rock, who hit Cena with the Rock Bottom. In a sequence no other top star would dream of agreeing to, Seth Rollins entered the scene in Shield garb and got nothing in before he was immediately laid out and took a chair to the back when he made it up. Cute callback, but he looked so much like a geek - after so much build with a mid-match special entrance - that it scanned as a cruel, well-timed joke. And what does the Undertaker have to do with anything?! 

He turned up, gave the Rock a chokeslam, and after Seth became a two-time bitch, Cody hit the Cross Rhodes three times and that was that. The stadium loved it. Daft as it was, those three mega-pops elicited the epic feeling WWE sought. Was it necessary? Is it miserable to state that Cody and Roman are so great that they hardly needed the help of this fun but deeply contrived scene? 

Either way, Cody celebrating with Mama Rhodes was beautiful, and the scene was unforgettable.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!