6 Ups & 2 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Jan 16)

Simply Glorious.

Jinder Mahal Bobby Roode
WWE.com

One week after delivering what will likely go down as one of the year's blandest events, SmackDown fired back with two extremely solid hours of television last night, delivering fun, easy-to-watch show that pushed the United States Title to the forefront.

Bobby Roode, Xavier Woods, Jinder Mahal, and Mojo Rawley were gunning for tournament glory, but while their semi-finals took place as planned, Daniel Bryan had a huge surprise in store for the victors. This wasn't the only time WWE flipped the script throughout the night, though. The writers eschewed over-the-top dramatics for pure competition, and thankfully, the previous week's drudgery was nowhere to be found.

WWE Champion AJ Styles was in the house, but restricted to one short segment, while Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn were nowhere to be found. Elsewhere, The Usos' issues with Chad Gable and Shelton Benjamin escalated, the absent Randy Orton literally phoned it in, and The Riott Squad clashed with Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair, and Naomi.

There was nothing groundbreaking on the show, but last night's SmackDown was extremely watchable, with the wrestling-centric format a welcome change of pace.

Let's break it down...


Downs...

2. Slave To The Grind

Jinder Mahal Xavier Woods
WWE.com

While it'd have been foolish to expect a high workrate classic from Xavier Woods and Jinder Mahal, it should have at least been a smart, well-worked TV match. Woods was one of WWE's most improved wrestlers last year, and arguably The New Day's biggest standout, while Jinder, for all his flaws, at least understands his role. Their bout wasn't good, though, and made for a stodgy start to the night.

There were several problems. While technically sound for the most part, Mahal's complete inability to generate crowd heat through his grinding ring work remains a massive problem, particularly in contests as long as this. His control sequence was characteristically laborious. The crowd were so quiet, it was as if they were watching the bout in a library, and this killed all interest in Xavier's comebacks.

'The Maharaja' controlled the vast majority of the match's 18 minutes, generating no real drama throughout. Cut the runtime in half, focus more in Woods' fire than Mahal's dominance, and this contest may have succeeded. Instead, it went down like a turd in a punchbowl.


1. Fat Jokes

His number one contenders weren't in the building last night, but WWE Champion AJ Styles was. He conducted a brief interview with Renee Young after the Mahal vs. Woods contest, and while relatively routine, it finds itself on the 'Downs' list for one simple reason: fat-shaming.

'The Phenomenal One' stated that his upcoming bout with Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens wasn't a 2-on-1 handicap match, but a 3-on-1. Why? Because "KO counts as two guys," apparently.

Perhaps this is nitpicking, but bulls*** like this should have no place in modern WWE programming. Yes, Owens is a husky guy, but focusing in on it isn't just reaching for the low-hanging fruit, but emasculating a guy who's supposed to be one of the company's top heels. Styles came off as a bully in the process, and while AJ was only reading from somebody else's script, the quip does his character no favours whatsoever.

WWE love poking fun at Kevin Owens' weight, and while their stubbornness is legendary, we must call them out every single time they resort to this gross tactic. Otherwise, nothing's ever going to change.


Ups...

6. Function Over Form

Mojo Rawley Bobby Roode
WWE.com

The primary function of a weekly television match isn't to pop a high star rating, but to further a narrative. Sometimes we lose sight of this. As long as the action is technically sound, generates heat, and achieves its storytelling function, it should be considered a success.

That's why this relatively innocuous clash between two of SmackDown's most ordinary wrestlers is an 'Up.' Bobby Roode vs. Mojo Rawley was fine. It's not something you'll ever return to, but they worked an effective back-and-forth format that allowed both to shine, with Mojo once again coming off well as an aggressive heel.

'The Glorious One' picked up the victory in just over 13 minutes, which was the right choice. He was the biggest star in the tournament, and a dead lock to make it to the finals, though it's somewhat surprising that Rawley wasn't protected in defeat. Regardless, it'll be interesting to see how the former Hype Bro handles this adversity, and we won't be complaining if he channels this frustration into one final, feud-ending bout with Zack Ryder.


5. Restarting The Riott

Riott Squad
WWE.com

The Riott Squad haven't had a good run.

They've suffered through repetition, as their angles often resemble carbon copies of those already performed by Absolution on Raw, but their lack of protection is just as complicit in their failings. The writers have done an excellent job of completely diminishing the trio's threat level. It's tough to treat them like serious heels as a result, but the good news is that The Squad are back on the right track, and their upward trajectory commenced this week.

Ruby Riott, Liv Morgan, and Sarah Logan clashed with Charlotte Flair, Naomi, and Becky Lynch - the brand's three biggest faces. Much like Roode vs. Mojo, the bout was solid but unspectacular, but succeeded in its goal of giving each participant some shine.

The outcome is what really matters, though. The Squad triumphed over their rivals, with Morgan cheap-shotting her way to a pinfall on former Women's Champion Naomi, which puts her side back in the W column. An important result, but the follow-up is key. It'll be for nought if WWE have the trio fall back into their losing habit next week, but let's be optimistic and hope they succeed in strengthening the Squad ahead of the women's Royal Rumble.


4. Flipping The Format

The New Day
WWE.com

Last week's SmackDown was a bland, formulaic snoozer that conformed to the brand's every tiresome trope, and offered few major developments throughout its two-hour runtime. Fortunately, this wasn't the case last night. If we're going to rip on the bookers whenever they get lazy (and we do, frequently), it's only fair to praise them when they finally break the format, as was the case here.

Okay, the show kicked off with an in-ring promo, but it was brief, to the point, and featured wrestlers who don't often get the chance to feature in the opener. It quickly bled into the first bout, and that brings us to the next format deviation: the wrestling-centric focus.

This show was all about the matches. WWE gave us almost a full hour of in-action, and while none were truly excellent, most hit the right notes. Whatever the case, focusing on a more competition-driven show was extremely refreshing for a company so prone to polluting their TV product with tedious segments. They'll likely revert to type next week, of course, but we'd like to hope that they'll deem last night a success, and decide to switch things up more often.


3. Staying Out Of The Way

Daniel Bryan Shane McMahon
WWE.com

The lack of Daniel Bryan and Shane McMahon was part of what made last night's show such an easy watch.

The authority figures were present, but nowhere near as invasive as usual, with Daniel Bryan's United States Title tournament swerve their biggest contribution. They were ringside for the main event, too, but didn't interfere. Instead, the duo sat in their chairs, let the wrestlers get on with it, and only got involved at the end, when they presented Bobby Roode with his prize.

As obnoxious as their ongoing storyline has been lately, it was great to see WWE present Shane and Daniel like supplemental figures again. This is how babyface staffers are supposed to be booked. They shouldn't be hogging the spotlight, but enhancing it for full-time performers, which is exactly what happened on SmackDown.

It helped that Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn weren't in the building. Their presence would've almost certainly resulted in the f***ery that has killed the blue brand in recent weeks, with Shane once again coming off like a meddling egomaniac. A smart booking choice all-round, particularly for those who watch WWE for wrestlers, not their bumbling bosses.


2. Bryan's Big Swerve

Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Big swerves are part of what make wrestling such a compelling storytelling medium. A promotion should be judged by their ability to keep the audience guessing, and while there's always a danger of going too far with it (see: Russo, Vince), WWE, in particular, could definitely do with inserting more surprises into their programming. The product is often cripplingly predictable. You know exactly what you're going to get from an episode of Raw or SmackDown, and that's why every swerve, no matter how small, always feels like a big deal.

This was the case last night, when Daniel Bryan announced that the United States Title tournament wouldn't be concluded at the Royal Rumble, but later in the show. It was Bobby Roode's suggestion, though. 'The Glorious One' was jumped by The Singh Brothers after defeating Mojo Rawley, and while Jinder Mahal tried to back out of his challenge, the General Manager flexed his managerial muscle.

Full credit to the writers for delivering this show-making surprise. Mahal vs. Roode wasn't exactly a hotly-anticipated clash, and would've likely had a detrimental effect on the Rumble card, but hot-shotting the booking made it feel fresh and exciting. A complete success, and a great decision.


1. Glorious Victory

Bobby Roode Unites States Champion
WWE.com

Bobby Roode vs. Jinder Mahal was always going to be our tournament final, but while many predicted that 'The Maharaja' would walk away with the United States Championship, this wasn't the case.

WWE delivered a minor surprise in SmackDown's main event. Bobby Roode, the most popular man in the tourney, defeated the former WWE Champion cleanly. With the Singhs banned from ringside (a huge help in ensuring the bout's success), 'The Glorious One' battled his foe for over 15 minutes, fighting through his resthold-centric offence before finally putting him away with his signature DDT, securing the biggest win of his main roster career.

This was a big improvement on Mahal's earlier bout. His work wasn't dynamic, but Roode sold his plodding offence well, making his control spots infinitely more bearable. Jinder isn't an objectively good wrestler, but he is capable of having a competent match with the right opponent. This bout, coupled with his two against AJ Styles, prove it.

On top of this, Roode was the right man to win the tournament. The United States Title hasn't had much shine lately, but Bobby is a guy the fans actually want to invest in. If the WWE give him a chance, and keep his presentation strong, there's no reason they can't use him to restore its glory.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.