6 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (November 1 - Results & Review)
6 'Ups' is generous for a Dynamite that continues to settle into a new, divisive era...
Does anybody else except MJF care that Jay White has stolen MJF's World title? It's not as if he isn't still the champion.
AEW, the promotion, should care. To put over the stakes and magnitude of MJF Vs. Kenny Omega on the last episode of Collision - the match held to determine the best AEW World champion ever - the physical belt should have been present, held aloft by the referee, and kissed by the champion. Tony Khan in his capacity as AEW's President and General Manager should have (offscreen) ordered Jay White to surrender the belt or be withdrawn from the Full Gear main event.
The storyline has not worked - the stakes are low, and it has been diluted by multiple other subplots. Those subplots aren't uninteresting in and of themselves, but MJF Vs. Jay White is mils below MJF Vs. Cody Rhodes, or MJF Vs. CM Punk.
Did AEW course-correct on Dynamite...?
Downs...
3. Important Announcement Descends Further Into Parody
The important announcement was important, technically, but it hardly warranted the hyped graphic treatment ahead of time.
Khan announced that tickets for All In 2 will go on sale before this year's holiday season really kicks in. It's an inspired idea; a not inconsiderable number of people will purchase tickets as gifts or ask for tickets as gifts, saving them money. It did not warrant the announcement treatment, but then again, does anybody give a damn at this point? Does anybody even discuss what the announcements are going to be now with pipe dreams in their hearts?
The announcement graphic is a meme, it's been a meme for years, so why not pop a rating with it? Well...
It makes Tony Khan appear, if not quite a laughing stock, then incredibly desperate. It's a bad look. It does nothing to put AEW over as a hot, premium product. Just announce it on the show with no fanfare and save yourself the stigma.
The marketing in AEW, as with so much else, could do with significant improvement.
2. Another Diluted Storyline
There wasn't a great deal to the Golden Jets Vs. Daddy Magic and Cool Hand Ang tag, though Kenny Omega looked remarkably sharp given his exploits on Collision. Also, Chris Jericho can map out a good tag team match even when it means absolutely nothing, and he sprinkled in a halfway convincing false finish when he ate a baseball bat shot counter to a Lionsault attempt. This otherwise just existed to set up a post-match verbal showdown.
Nice as it was to see Omega finally feel like he wants to get at Don Callis, this whole scene embodied the booking philosophy that is nuking the sense of emotion in AEW's storytelling.
Why does so much of AEW's output feel like Joey Janela's wacky, ironic Spring Break meets WWF Survivor Series?
Callis challenged Jericho and Omega to an eight-man street fight in a fortnight's time. Omega accepted, revealing that Kota Ibushi will partner his team. When Don Callis pointed out that he has four men (Powerhouse Hobbs, Konosuke Takeshita, Kyle Fletcher and Will Ospreay), Jericho revealed that they have three men, and, to combat the strength of Powerhouse Hobbs, one giant: Paul Wight.
What?
Wight - in addition to being the latest geezer in the retirement home that is AEW - was fished by MJF and Adam Cole the last time he was seen on television. He was mucking about as Captain Insano before that. And now fans are expected to take him seriously. Even it's for a Dynamite eight-man tag and nothing more, it's still lightweight knockabout fun. It's still diluting, ultimately, the Callis Vs. Omega programme, which feels less and less like a believable conflict but rather an excuse to get more out of an overcrowded roster.
MJF and the Acclaimed.
Omega, Jericho, Kota Ibushi and Paul Wight.
Copeland, Sting and Darby.
FTR and LFI.
Orange Cassidy and his endless cast of acquaintances.
Unexpected babyface supergroups are the latest thing AEW has become intensely obsessed with, to diminishing returns, and supergroups are never as good as proper bands.
1. Fun Main Event Needs Higher Stakes
Is the MJF Vs. Jay White programme up there with the very best of AEW?
No.
Is it a World title programme that aims to sell a pay-per-view?
Yes, and there exists a curve against which to measure its quality. Standards are high, stratospheric even, and this whole business falls short.
MJF and the Acclaimed Vs. Bullet Club Gold was a fun main event, but it didn't help inject any real drama or importance to MJF/White. The Acclaimed's act is crowd-pleaser stuff that is overexposed and hasn't felt driven by any true emotion since they defended their World Tag Team titles against FTR. The act is broader now.
Also, BGC are flailing bratty midcard heels masquerading as a main event unit. They're fun, in an over-the-top way, but they're hardly the Four Horsemen. Combine all of that with MJF's crowd-conditioning gimmick, and there was no real heft to any of the Dynamite main, much as the fans in the arena wanted to see the faces get on the same page.
Jay White scored the pin on MJF, which in theory strengthens his title challenge (but also signposts that he's not going to do it twice). The Blade Runner should if nothing else create an incredible near-fall at Full Gear. This might be generous, but MJF took the pin and still thanked the Acclaimed for their efforts by scissoring them. If you're into this character arc, MJF made a friend that didn't do anything for him. Adam Cole has attempted to impart this lesson for a while now. That's progress!
It's not seminal main event material, but it's decent character work for an arc that, while divisive, is well thought-out on its own terms.
Ups...
6. Willow Nightingale Could Be So Much More, And Yet...
Willow Nightingale and Hikaru Shida displayed thrilling glimpses of the great and significant match they could one day have.
The work looked fiery, snug, tight, accomplished. They balanced a precarious dynamic fairly well, working an all-babyface match and drawing duelling chants - chants louder than the staggeringly questionable matchmaking warranted.
It is very easy to split and lose the crowd in a match like this, but Shida and Nightingale assembled an entertaining shoot-out that developed a powerful level of drama and didn't allow either woman to appear weak or callous. As well put-together as it was, it was almost annoying, if you're of a pessimistic disposition. Imagine how over Willow Nightingale would be if her booking wasn't abject, thoughtless rubbish. She could be a veritable sensation.
She has lost a title match and the opportunity to be in a title match across the last three weeks. Fans should almost be resentful of the character at this point, and they love her. Imagine if AEW put in a tenth of the effort into her arc as they did Hangman Page's.
Something very special would have unfolded by now.
5. Elegant Plotting
Throughout the night, MJF wandered the backstage area in an attempt to resolve his dilemma. He sought partners ahead of his eight-man tag main event against Bullet Club Gold, and his rivals sought him, in a decent enough show-long storyline that was hardly Jerry Jarrett-tier. More of this is welcome without straying too far away from the sporting, fixtures-based framework. Or what's left of it, anyway.
Roderick Strong continued his descent into caricature by offering his services to MJF. The Acclaimed continued to court him. In an intriguing glimpse into a continuing story, MJF knocked on Kenny Omega's locker room door but was rebuffed by Chris Jericho. MJF muttering "as*hole" was a neat nod to their very long past. Wardlow then terrorised MJF by threatening to attack him when he least expected it. Later in the night, MJF picked the Acclaimed following a half-decent sight gag in which, faced with Jeff Jarrett and his cronies luring him back to the dark side, he felt he had no choice.
Good, organic-feeling world-building and continuity, even if the mystery itself wasn't greatly compelling.
4. The Elite Saga Begins Again (Again)
Hung Bucks Vs. Brian Cage and the Gates of Agony was trending towards good enough before an awesome finishing sequence - and some long, long overdue character development.
After some good if familiar genre action, Swerve Strickland appeared on the stage and gloated over invading Hangman Page's house last week. Page, fired up, left the Bucks to die via fabulous, OTT overkill. After a series of brutal-looking Fatality moments, Matt could no longer stand, much less raise his shoulder, and the Hung Bucks are no longer ROH Trios champions. This was an echo of the best Elite saga booking. Each character was right in their own mind.
Page, who realistically should have hunted Swerve down the second he stepped foot in the arena, had to defend his family. Matt Jackson threw a tantrum because he lost a title (if only that title actually meant something) before later asking Kenny Omega where on earth he was.
For the Bucks, and their recent track record of not appearing to care much at all, it's a start - but do fans want to see the end of the Elite saga?
Is yet another chapter in which they fall out with another, as a result of Paul Wight of all people, the best possible use of an act that peaked in 2021?
3. Jon Moxley Is Back
After Orange Cassidy squeaked by Claudio Castagnoli in the opener, he was attacked by Jon Moxley. The beat-down looked good enough, and it was allowed to go on as long as it did through HOOK's ejection from the arena. There was nobody there to save him. Nobody else had his back.
It's probably best to ignore that Cassidy is in a stable called Best Friends and has tagged this year with Keith Lee, El Hijo del Vikingo, Eddie Kingston, Penta El Zero Miedo, Darby Allin, Bandido, Sting, Katsuyori Shibata...
In a show obsessed with friendship throughout, watching a badass in a bad mood threaten ungodly violence in a class backstage staring-down-the-lens promo was so much more refreshing than it should have been.
2. Full Gear Match Made
Already, the folly of the expanded pay-per-view schedule is beginning to realise itself. Jon Moxley Vs. Orange Cassidy 2 and Hangman Page Vs. Swerve Strickland 2 are both set for Full Gear, which is good in a fairly uninspiring way. This is what happens when you're down on the content farm.
On a happier note, a fun attraction was set in Adam Copeland, Sting & Darby Allin Vs. Christian Cage, Luchasaurus and Nick Wayne. Even though almost literally everything in AEW feels like an early WWF Survivor Series show these days, in a cack-handed and lazy attempt to get everybody on the roster involved, this specific prospect is exciting.
As ever, this was all elevated by Christian Cage and his intoxicating heel work. He's just a remorseless, nasty individual, and he furthered this arc by interrupting Copeland's promo and threatening to break his neck. The image Cage conjured of a helpless, decimated Copeland was grotesque.
Cage really is in the form of his life.
1. A Very, Very, Very Good Opener
Orange Cassidy did more to make Claudio Castagnoli look like a monster in 10 minutes than Vince McMahon managed in 10 years.
For much of a gripping opening match, Claudio essentially played the role of a powerful freak capable of throwing Orange Cassidy around and up by his ears at his mercy. It was not unlike watching a child who was probably too old for that sort of thing practise wrestling moves on a stuffed animal.
Claudio reversed a tornado DDT attempt seamlessly into a tilt-a-whirl backbreaker and then a tilt-a-whirl gutbuster early to set the tone. While it was impossible to watch this version of Claudio Castagnoli and not immediately fan-cast him into the role of top heel - he was a mutant in this goddamn match - this could have benefited from a touch more back-and-forth. Orange Cassidy was uncharacteristically shaky on the comeback, which didn't help, but he mounted it so late in the match that the finish scanned as something of an anticlimax.
The finish itself was incredible - Orange popped back down onto Claudio's shoulders, thwarting the uppercut attempt with a shock hurricanrana - but they have an even better match in them. The chemistry was wonderful, the match very good, the crowd was into it but their minds were still intact. Run it back again.
There is much left to achieve.