6 Ups & 4 Downs From Last Night's NXT (Jan 15)

DI-Why Though?

Kieth Lee
NXT

If somebody had told you a few weeks ago that NXT would feel like unmissable viewing because we were desperate to see the fallout from a UK TakeOver show, you... well, you wouldn't have laughed in their face but you'd probably have started a group chat purely to tell your friends the rubbish they were coming out with.

While that sentiment is probably still only about 85% true this week, that's still as close to it as we're ever likely to get. Worlds Collide has quietly built an excellent card, and the British imports on it feel like an essential cog in the machine. None of this really makes sense, but judging by the noise that greeted Undisputed Era sticking one on Imperium this weekend, you'd never have guessed.

And lo did we move forward to this week's episode of NXT. Add to the WC build some tantalising clashes in the much-maligned Dusty Rhodes Classic and a hotly two hours of television was in store. Having the absurd depth of the women's division all go at it in the main-event was simply the icing on Wednesday night's most wrestling-y cake, but would the show live up to its understandable hype.


Downs...

4. No Nigel McGuiness

Nigel McGuinness
WWE.com

It's maybe a little harsh this one but such is Nigel McGuiness's importance to this broadcast that his absence is, whatever the reason, always going to be a problem. We were told during the show that, following his resounding work calling NXT UK TakeOver Blackpool II, he'd been given some "well deserved R 'n' R". Nobody's going to argue that he doesn't deserve that, but nonetheless it makes for a weaker NXT.

That McGuinness has carved out such an important role for himself since the inaugural United Kingdom Championship tournament is one of WWE's genuine and uncynical success stories. The man never wrestled a match for the company (despite signing for them), is not a particularly big name to casual fans in North America (despite his amazing run in Ring of Honor) and is... well... British. WWE's best colour commentator is, probably quite predictably, the least WWE-style guy they have.


3. Spoiling The Surprise

Tegan Nox NXT
WWE

Surprise returns and shocking moments are what make wrestling what it is. Done correctly they can elevate a match from passable to memorable, and on certain levels, they can turn an otherwise solid show into unmissable, once-in-a-lifetime viewing. If you've got them up your sleeve, and you don't need them to sell tickets in advance, you drop them out of nowhere.

NXT clearly understand this, as the reception that greeted Shayna Baszler was that of someone who'd been away years, not a mere few weeks, but by telegraphing the returning Tegan Nox (and her long-awaited showdown with Dakota Kai) they robbed the audience of a moment they've been looking forward to since WarGames.

Given the quality of the match this feels like an incredibly petty gripe, but if NXT were worried that a debuting Martinez and returning Nox would have depleted the crowd too much to care about Baszler's appearance they are comically wrong. Sometimes more really is more.


2. DI-Why?

Ciampa Gargano
NXT

I'm going to get into what an improbable success story the build to Worlds Collide has been later on but, while the ends might justify the means, said means are starting cause their own problems. Case in point, hastily cobbling together a promo segment and half-baked reformation of DIY, purely for a one-off match.

Both men are currently balls deep in the build to some of the biggest matches of their careers so far. Ciampa will take on Adam Cole for both the NXT Championship and, in all probability, a place on the WrestleMania card itself, while Johnny Gargano finally, finally, gets his match with Finn Bálor. TakeOver Portland feels like a monumental night for them... but this basically puts it all on hold.

While that's forgivable given the show is a month away, reforming DIY after everything that's gone on feels a little cheap. Yes, they're pals now and yes they've teamed together before, but if this was ever going to happen for a big show then it should really have had a big show narrative informing it. As with everything NXT though the match with Moustache Mountain will make it all worth it, but in the moment it underwhelmed in the extreme.


1. Directionless Stars

Tyler Breeze Lio Rush
NXT

The NXT formula, for years, was incredibly simple. Sign the best stars in the world, allow them to hone a more WWE-friendly style through a weekly show with a modest audience, build to critically-lauded blow-off events every few months, before finally moving them up to either Raw or SmackDown.

The brand still has the same intake and acquisition of stars (as well as adding Finn Balor, incorporating the entire Cruiserweight division, and occasionally featuring NXT UK) but suddenly they can't afford to lose anybody. This is slowly but surely leading to a log-jam at the top, and those stuck behind seemingly have nothing substantial to do.

Kushida, who's now on an improbable losing run to Cameron Grimes and a team from NXT UK, looks a million miles away from the megastar he seemed when he signed. Tyler Bate has comprehensively outgrown his native brand, but still can't seem to score a win over here. Isaiah 'Swerve' Scott advances to Worlds Collide following a win this week, but has hardly featured since he debuted. Dominic Dijakovic has had his gimmick reduced to little more than "man who fights Keith Lee sometimes". Dunne and Riddle look fantastic in the Dusty Classic, but neither has had a feud of genuine substance since the move to TV.

That's all without even mentioning Velveteen Dream as well. There's simply not enough TV time for the number of performers who deserve it.


Ups...

6. Short And Sweet

Kieth Lee Undisputed Era
NXT

On the one hand, if you've got an evening of professional wrestling bangers in store for everyone then it's probably an idea not to open the show with a momentum-sapping promo. On the other though, if you really feel like you have to give someone a mic to open the broadcast, you might as well make it your most over star, keep it all under two minutes, then spark a massive brawl.

While there's a growing criticism that NXT only has one speed setting since its move to the USA Network (AND IT'S AAAAH EXCITEMENT, ADRENALINE AAAAAH), it's not really a problem if it's being used correctly. The lack of genuinely captivating talkers on the brand should be something they look to remedy in 2020 but, until they do, letting everyone do the talking with their fists is probably the safest option.

It'll all get repetitive in the long-run, but a weak, awkward promo does more damage to a feud's build than the sight of wrestlers doing what wrestlers are paid to do. Let Adam Cole have as much time as he wants with the stick, but definitely have him interrupt anybody who wants a right of reply.


5. The Broserweights

Dunne Riddle
NXT

When NXT announced the return of the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic two huge problems immediately jumped out about it. 1) The inclusion of NXT UK, a brand they've done precisely nothing to make people care about for over a year and 2) NXT doesn't actually have any tag teams. How long ago those problems feel today.

If we should have learned anything from Bálor / Joe, and Ricochet / Black, it's that the hastily thrown together single-star tag teams are usually the best thing about this tournament. In Matt Riddle and Pete Dunne (who should really have been called Joint Manipulation, ey lads) they've perfected the formula. Two men with seemingly no connection, but undeniably natural chemistry in both their in-ring work and their gimmicks.

Their first-round match against the hugely impressive Mark Andrews and Flash Morgan Webster stole the show last night, and regardless what the plans originally might have been they must surely now head all the way to the final. There's honestly years in this partnership, both as a team and then eventually as rivals, and whoever's idea this was should be bought their own private island.


4. Worlds Collide > TakeOver

Velveteen Dream Worlds Collide
WWE

When NXT announced they were replacing the usual pre-Rumble TakeOver with Worlds Collide two huge problems immediately jumped out about it. 1) The inclusion of NXT UK, a brand they've done precisely nothing to make people care about for over a year and 2), well, actually no that's it.

The previous iteration of the event saw a load of barely broadcast, essentially non-canon pairings, that became considerably more famous for the series of tweets Harper posted after his match with Dominik Dijakovic, rather than any of the actual matches themselves. There can not have been a single person who thought this was a good idea at the time and yet, here we are, two weeks out, and it looks like being the most stacked card they've put together in years.

The integration of the NXT UK element is arguably the most surprising of all, with a (mostly) stellar showing at TakeOver Blackpool doing wonders to put over the brand's stars ahead of their clash with their trans-Atlantic colleagues. Walter, Toni Storm, Kay Lee Ray and the rest of Imperium all feel like important parts of both brands at the moment, and the work done tonight by both teams involved in the Dusty Classic should hopefully tempt some of the audience over.

It's nice to be wrong, sometimes.


3. Grizzled Young Veterans

Grizzled Young Veterans
NXT

Zack Gibson is WWE's most underutilized star. No @s please.

The man currently plies his trade on the company's least-watched brand and, when he does, he's forced to share the ring with at least 3 other men. His partner James Drake is wonderful, and the tag-teams he goes up against are a lot better than they're given credit for, but the man is peerless when put alone in the spotlight, and given a live microphone. Lo and behold, he cut the shows best promos in months.

Until he's finally afforded a singles run on NXT UK (or, sh*t, I don't know, NXT itself) we can only hope that he's at least allowed to excel as a team. Giving the Grizzled Young Veterans the huge scalp of knocking off Kushida and Alex Shelley is long-overdue recognition for good they actually are. Given the wave of excitement that greeted the reformation of the Time Splitters, this was a huge win.

The match itself was a million miles removed from the opening contest between Dunne, Riddle, Webster and Andrews, but it nonetheless had enough to keep a searing-hot crowd engaged as it built to one of NXT's biggest upsets since... well... Kushida's last match on the show. Getting beaten by Cameron Grimes in December last month.


2. Beth Phoenix

Beth Phoenix
F4WOnline.com/WWE

It should be said though that, in the absence of Nigel McGuinness, Beth Phoenix massively stepped up this week. For the duration of NXT's run on the USA Network she's very much been the third element in the three-person booth; struggling to add anything not covered by McGuiness, and sometimes even a word in with Ranallo. Tonight she felt important and insightful, and long may it continue.

I've personally been critical of her occasionally feeling like a spare part on the show, so I'm delighted to report that this now feels more like a product of her simply being crowded out as opposed to not having anything insightful to offer. Hopefully going forward producers will take steps to ensure he's getting a fair crack of the whip.


1. An Embarrassment Of Riches

NXT Women
WWE

While this exact point can easily be made about the earlier triple threat match between Lio Rush, Tyler Breeze and Isaiah "Swerve" Scott, watching the women's division make their entrances for the main event battle royale, it really does hit home just how absurdly strong that element of the show currently is. Candice, Yim, Belair, Martinez, Shirai, Nox, Li, even Catanzaro would all have made legitimate challengers for Ripley.

Shotzi Blackheart, Kayden Carter, Deonna Purrazzo and Dakota Kai, who would make her presence felt later, also feel like stars in the making. There wasn't even room for Taynara and the recently debuted Chelsea Green.

That they saw fit to include Shayna Baszler in this was just showing off. Arguably the most dominant women in the entire company in 2019 (sorry, Becky) thrown in here to really help get the eventual winner feel that much more impressive. For the purposes of her own personal story, you'd hope this doesn't take any shine off a potential Royal Rumble moment.

In the end the win, and the title shot went to Bianca Belair. Right now, the obvious candidate is Io Shirai, but either her popularity with the Full Sail crowd is counting against her, they're saving her WrestleMania weekend, or the speculation that she's hoping to leave the brand is sadly true. In its own right her missing out here should be a down, but Belair's so good in her own right that nobody can have any complaints.


Managing Editor
Managing Editor

WhatCulture's Managing Editor and Chief Reporter | Previously seen in Vice, Esquire, FourFourTwo, Sabotage Times, Loaded, The Set Pieces, and Mundial Magazine