6 Ups & 4 Downs From NXT 401

Triumphs & tribulations on the road to Takeover: Brooklyn III.

Aleistar Black Bobby Fish
WWE.com

Coming off a couple of good episodes with outstanding main events, NXT 401 had to deliver to keep up the momentum going into the brand's pre-Summerslam Takeover event. Current storylines include Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano's tag team breakup, SAnitY beating up everyone in sight, the return of Drew McIntyre and the recent debuts of the Velveteen Dream and Aleister Black. NXT Takeover: Brooklyn III is on the horizon and by now it has to cope with the assumption that it will deliver higher in-ring quality than the accompanying Summerslam.

The brand is still in the process of building the card for Takeover as well as develop new stars after so many of its alumni have left for the main roster. The impending Mae Young Classic also gives the women's division a much-needed focus away from the seemingly impervious champion Asuka, with new female performers featuring in qualifying matches.

One major issue is who is going to feature in the singles title matches. Bobby Roode dispatched a game Roderick Strong in an outstandingly worked match last week, and the question of who is next to be offered up to women's champion Asuka is still unresolved. Did NXT 401 settle these questions, and did the action itself meet the standards set over the last few weeks?

Downs...

6. Another Tag Team Breakup Story

NXT 401 Cassius Ohno Hideo Itami
WWE.com

Hideo Itami and Cassius Ohno had a quality match with SAnitY last week which ended when Itami failed to tag in his partner and the inevitable loss ensued via enormous Killain Dain death flop. The two teased a feud when they accused each other for the loss in a fairly tired story turn that illustrates how frustrated NXT creative seems to be with finding something compelling for Hideo Itami to do.

Itami is an excellent wrestler but an aimless soul who hasn't been able to show why he was such a big deal as KENTA in Japan. Building a story for him is laudable but there's already one more interesting tag team breakup story going on with Gargano and Ciampa and NXT isn't big enough for four of them.

No one's going to complain too much if Itami faces Ohno at Takeover, but a lot more could be made of it that a simple former-friends-falling-out placeholder feud that looks like a third-generation photocopy of a better story.


5. Vanessa Borne Vs Jayme HacheyNXT 401 Vanessa Borne Jayme Hachey

This was a qualifying match for the Mae Young Classic, a tournament positioned as the equivalent of the Cruiserweight Classic and United Kingdom Championship tournament. It pitched the legitimately powerful-looking Jayme Hachey against a more generic bad girl Borne.

The match was presumably an advertisement for the for the Mae Young Classic but it didn't function as a particularly enthralling teaser. It wasn't shambolic but both competitors seemed stilted and moves lacked impact. They very much looked like they were going through a routine rather than having a fight, and in the absence of any context there was no reason to root for either competitor.

The Mae Young Classic has every chance of showing the world what women's wrestling can really be, but this match was a bit of a dud. Far from the worst, just uninspiring and way too easily forgettable.


4. Johnny Gargano's Directionless Return
NXT 401 Johnny Gargano
WWE.com

Johnny Gargano's in-ring promo was intended to build hype for his return after being dramatically merked by his tag team partner Tommaso Ciampa. The crowd reacted well to him, especially when he said he was 'still Johnny Wrestling' for a major pop.

Unfortunately that was about all he said. He wants to be at Takeover: Brooklyn, but there was no indication of who he intends to face or why. The obvious answer is Ciampa and NXT would be pretty crazy not to cash in this feud on the big stage, but Gargano made barely any mention of his nemesis, or of any other opponent for that matter.

Presumably NXT is going to give Gargano a run at a couple of other opponents before building directly to Ciampa, but Gargano's promo didn't line up anyone for him to face before then. It would have been the perfect time to set him up against somebody but that didn't happen, and while the crowd appreciated seeing him the segment didn't advance anything and served only to remind us that Gargano is a nice guy who exists.


3. The Velveteen Dream Looks Like A Car Wreck

NXT 401 Velveteen Dream
WWE.com

It's uncertain how much is riding on the Velveteen Dream becoming a star, but with luck it won't be too much because he's shaping up to be a disaster. A combination of Prince, Goldust and RuPaul with better abs, he lacks the charisma and natural performing ability to carry off his pouty diva schtick.

His matches so far have been squashes so there's still a chance he's a good wrestler. His character, however, is neither original or particularly compelling. This episode's predictable heel promo didn't do anything to suggest he's destined for greatness, either. His lines could have come from an early 2010s Diva and the character is in danger of straying into caricature and stereotype territory.

A catty heel played without conviction or humour isn't what NXT needs right now. It's not quite time to write off the Dream yet as it's such early days, but it's going to have to get a whole lot better, if not change completely, if the character is to bring admiring eyes to NXT.


2. Who Are The Authors Of Pain?
NXT401 Authors Of Pain

There will always be a place in professional wrestling for a couple of enormous, scary-looking guys, which is why the Authors of Pain exist. From their awful name to their pairing with an underused Paul Ellering, the AoP are as generic as monster heels come.

They've been around a while now and as holders of the NXT tag titles you'd think there would be something more done with them, but they're the exact same bowling-ball shaped behemoths they were when they debuted.

The Authors of Pain are still very much learning their craft, so it's not surprising they haven't been given too much creative weight to bear, but Ellering's presence hasn't done anything to give them a personality or motivation beyond battering whatever's in front of them. To move beyond the old-school Big Evil Guy gimmick they need to either undergo a change or deepen the audience's understanding of who they are - they need to turn on Ellering, gain some distinctive mannerisms or just explain why they do what they do.

As it is, the Authors of Pain aren't much more than a pair of props for faces to clamber over or get crushed beneath.


1. Authors Of Pain Vs Heavy Machinery
NXT 401 Authors Of Pain Heavy Machinery
WWE.com

This match for the tag team belts was between two teams with almost the same gimmick of enormous men who are impossible to knock down. The Authors of Pain in particular looked limited in their repertoire without opponents they could throw around at will, and even Nigel McGuinness on commentary had to acknowledge that Heavy Machinery were way too new a pairing to justify a title match.

The spectacle was impressive, especially with Otis Dozovic who resembles a small beige planet and whose hot tag was the centrepiece of the match, and neither team took time out for a rest. Where the match suffered severely was in comparison to NXT's two previous main events, the wrestling clinic that was Bobby Roode vs Roderick Strong and the heartstopping Last Woman Standing Match between Asuka and Nikki Cross.

This would have been a fine regular match to demonstrate the Authors of Pain's dominance and give Heavy Machinery a run-out, but as a main event it was lacking and demonstrated the paucity of creative juice in the Authors of Pain concept.


Ups...

4. Aleister Black Is Awesome

NXT 401 Aleister Black
WWE.com

Former indie darling Black has one of the most impressive and characterful entrances in the WWE, along with some particularly appropriate entrance music and a heavy but not too cheesy dark occultist schtick.

He looks amazing, wrestles with the right aggressive, vicious style and has so far kept a real aura of creepiness and ruthlessness about him.

Black hasn't been heard from yet, which works fine for someone whose mystique needs to be maintained but does raise the issue of how the character can develop or deepen. If Black is to become a major player in NXT and beyond, he needs a way for his character to express himself without necessarily grabbing a mic at every opportunity.

He's talked up a lot by the commentators and sold as a man who talks only in the universal language of kicking people in the face, which is a good basis to build on for now. Whether Black is the real deal or another Solomon Crowe has yet to be seen, but it's a great start.


3. The Best Commentary Team In WWE
NXT 401 Commentary Team
WWE.com

Mauro Ranallo's return to NXT last week was a godsend for anyone who values quality commentary with their wrestling. Accidentally referring to Bobby Fish as 'Roderick Strong' during the first match only served to emphasise how rare it is that he messes up. Perhaps most refreshingly Ranallo isn't afraid to call moves as if - whisper it - he was commentating on a legitimate combat sport.

Nigel McGuinness has grown in confidence as well since his introduction around the United Kingdom Championship tournament. His form of colour commentary is to flesh out the backgrounds of the performers, including their histories (part of the new WWE policy of accepting other promotions exist), training and fighting styles. The two work together to make the performers sound like dangerous and storied competitors. Above all the NXT team show respect for the wrestlers and make it easy to buy into the impact of what is happening in the ring.

Percy Watson is still there but he rarely pipes up, and as uninteresting as his observations are at least they aren't offensive and he doesn't do much to detract from the pairing of Ranallo and McGuinness.


2. Aleister Black Vs Bobby Fish

NXT 401 Aleister Black Bobby Fish

Fish was introduced to a considerable pop, including from the commentators, although it's not clear if he's going to be a fixture on the roster or an occasional foil as Rich Swann was prior to his cruiserweight breakout. Fish certainly has personality, with his grand hipster facial hair and plenty of bustle, and made a great contrast with the taciturn Black.

The two immediately showed what NXT's mark-friendly indy style is all about with swift counters and some lightning-quick martial arts cut and thrust suggesting these two have done this plenty of times before.

The match was a more competitive outing for Black who has been squashing opponents so far and he didn't get everything his own way, especially with Fish's knee-to-the-temple counter out of a suplex and a sweet 'senton atomica' as called by Mauro Ranallo. Fish also broke out the kind of turnbuckle exploder suplex that looks like it will kill the man taking it if he under-rotates. Black's later kicks met Fish's legs and chest with the kind of meaty thwack that can only be the result of genuine and painful impact.

Both men got to show off their technical game and authentically nasty-looking strikes in the kind of rock-solid match NXT is looking to make its stick in trade.


1. Killian Dain & Drew McIntyre In The Title Picture

NXT 401 Bobby Roode William Regal
WWE.com

Champion Bobby Roode showed up for a short segment with Chilly Willy Regal, which pitched the idea of hulking Northern Irishman Dain and the scowling Scotsman McIntyre as potential challengers for the NXT title. A number one contender's match was duly booked for next week's show, with the winner going on to face Roode at Takeover: Brooklyn.

It wasn't a compelling segment and there isn't much plot going into the match between the two Celtic grapplers, barring a parking lot scuffle between SAnitY and McIntyre that felt bolted to give things some heat and remind everyone SAnitY are jerks. The match itself, however, has the potential to be very good and it at least means that there will be some build-up to a new championship challenger for Takeover.

It also confirms that the WWE has plans for Killian Dain beyond serving as SAnitY's attack dog, and that it has enough faith in McIntyre to make him part of a major angle for the brand. The likelihood is that SAnitY's shenanigans will get Killian Dain the ticket to Brooklyn. before that, Dain should get the chance to show off some of his intimidating presence and raw impact, and McIntyre might even remind everybody why he was once the Chosen One.


Contributor

Ben Counter is a fantasy and science fiction writer, gaming enthusiast, wrestling fan and miniature painting guru. He was raised on Warhammer, Star Wars and 1980s cartoons that, in retrospect, were't that good. Whoever you are, he is nerdier than you.