6 Ups And 2 Downs From WWE NXT (May 25)
NXT Title match delivers; new champ's inspirational speech falls flat; women's division soars.
You know what you're getting from NXT, and that's a good thing.
WWE's black and gold offering is guaranteed to highlight in-ring action above everything else, but that doesn't mean there's no time for shenanigans - indeed, this week's show had promos aplenty, and a hidden gem segment you need to see soared around halfway through the night.
It's actually a credit to the writing team that NXT's only niggles came from repeat booking and trying to force a naturally-likeable character into some crummy Nia Jax circa 2018 role. They need to stop that immediately, because it feels out of place and could chip away at a new champ's credibility if WWE's over-reliance on bully-boy heel jokes continues.
Obviously, as the 'Ups' and 'Downs' counter reveals, there was more good than bad. That's another hallmark of the brand, and it's pretty clear that WWE creative breathed a sigh of relief when their paymasters moved the show to Tuesday nights. Now, they don't have to try and compete segment-to-segment against AEW Dynamite, which is another plus.
Here's all the good and the bad from NXT's latest...
Downs...
2. Back-To-Back Attacks
Oney Lorcan's attack on Bobby Fish was fine, but it happened too soon after Raquel Gonzalez and Dakota Kai had done the same to Ember Moon and Shotzi Blackheart. The result was that Lorcan's vicious kicking felt like a repeated trick by the writers on a show that didn't have many.
They should've spread this out a little.
Fish's match with Pete Dunne was typically watchable, and it is cool to report that the latter is seemingly being groomed for a main event run. However, this is the kind of thing some fans would roast Raw or SmackDown for, so it's only fair that NXT is held to the same standards.
Lorcan ambushed Bobby like he had been whipped into a frenzy by the women's attack earlier on. The commentary team didn't have much unique to say about it either, presumably because they'd blown their load during the opening tag beatdown.
1. A Little Too Generic
Hmm.
Bronson Reed's steel cage match win over Johnny Gargano bagged him the North American Title last week. It also raised the stock of the big bruiser and suggested that WWE has full faith in him. Why did they script this unremarkable and boring 'follow your dreams' speech then?
Reed's inspirational chatter fell a bit flat, and it wasn't the best first step for a new champion. Worse, Santos Escobar's unnecessary weight jibe hints that WWE think focusing on Bronson's belly is the way to go. It isn't, obviously. If anything, it's stupid and lazy writing.
The whole segment, from Reed's promo and Santos' bold claims, was just a little bit too bland. Bronson was put in the 2018 Nia Jax mould here, and it was slightly awkward. He's too good a worker to be settling for this kind of generic sh*te.
Ups...
6. A Hot Start
Tag-team wrestling is ideal for opening the show, and this was proof of that. Plus, both squads (Raquel Gonzales and Dakota Kai especially) have stunning individual chemistry that only heightens when they're in the ring together. Shotzi Blackheart and Ember Moon know how to sell for Raquel, put it that way.
One of them will make a fine challenger for the NXT Women's Champ.
That seems to be the plan, and it could be Moon who gets the nod. No NXT fan should have any issues with that, although there is a creeping sense that TakeOver: In Your House is a bit of an afterthought when it comes to title matches. That worrying thought aside, this opening tag was blistering stuff.
It kicked the broadcast off nicely, furthered the notion that Kai is becoming a bit of a weak point for Raquel and helped establish the Shotzi/Ember combo as the female tag-team in this company. Just great work all-round.
5. Getting Their Heat Back
Thank God this attack came before Oney Lorcan's.
Gonzalez and Kai deserved to take the spotlight and look like a right pair of menacing bad asses by ambushing Blackheart and Moon post-loss. Some might not like this 'get your heat back, brother' formula, but it'll pan out long-term when one of the faces is slotted in as Raquel's next challenger.
WWE also kind of played Dakota's part in the beating as an apology to Gonzalez. This was Kai's way of saying sorry for eating the pinfall loss in the prior tag match and showing her championship teammate that she's still a powerful ally. That's a plot point that needs fleshed out properly soon, but there's time for that.
It's hard to dislike a beatdown spot this intense too. Add in the fact that (again) it was the first on the show and it stood out more than Oney's. The way Gonzalez targeted Shotzi in front of her mate Ember, like she was saying 'you're next', was a hoot.
4. The First Hour’s In-Ring Quality
There was a lot to like about NXT's first hour.
It followed on from Raw's rather...unexpected focus on pure wrestling by delivering back-to-back corkers that you should go out of your way to see. The aforementioned women's tag bout was scorching and dramatic, and the technical wizardry of Pete Dunne vs. Bobby Fish harkened back to some of the latter's old ROH battles.
Dunne now moves on to face Kyle O’Reilly and Johnny Gargano in a Triple Threat next week. Win that and he'll earn an NXT Title shot against Karrion Kross at In Your House. Does that work? In-ring, absolutely, but WWE might have to do more to present Pete as a likeable challenger for the definitely-villainous Kross.
This week's show was a good start, and it was packed with great matches. Things got a little squash match heavy in the second hour (before the lengthy main), but the first? Man, that was a nice tag-into-singles flow they had going on there.
3. Franky Monet’s In-Ring Debut
That's not to say that occasional squashes can't work out.
They can, and Franky Monet proved it by slaying Cora Jade in approx three minutes. This match was exactly what it needed to be - Franky looked like a real star, her offensive flurries were on point and that finish she's rocking is a winner. Also, credit to Beth Phoenix for yelling out, "That looks familiar".
Yes, Monet's finisher is the old 'Glam Slam', but that's fine. Borrowing a few other things from the Phoenix playbook wouldn't be a bad idea either. Yours truly has always wondered what an in-her-prime Beth would've looked like in today's female ranks. Maybe Franky can fill that void by becoming an alpha female herself.
There's always a worry that vignette-heavy wrestlers will fail when they eventually step foot inside the ring (Eva Marie, for example). Nothing to worry about with this one though! Franky looked ready to establish herself as a star in this division.
2. The Million Dollar Face-Off
Cameron Grimes is getting a lot from his rags-to-riches story. Here, he somehow went from unlikable braggart to sympathetic figure in just one segment, and the guy made it look easy. Of course, backup in the form of 'Million Dollar Man' Ted DiBiase helped big time.
Ol' Teddy still has it.
He turned back the clock with some mic magic during this face-to-face, and even left with LA Knight. It'll be interesting to see if DiBiase becomes Knight's new manager or if this was just a one-off designed to push LA's simmering issues with Grimes. Regardless, it was solid.
Everybody involved played their roles to the hilt. Cameron sorta' came out as the babyface of the piece, DiBiase showed he still has some gas in the tank, and Knight is an insufferable jock jerk who'd believably look down on someone like Grimes.
1. The Champ Retains
Being honest, few fans truly believed that Finn Bálor was dethroning Karrion Kross.
This TakeOver: Stand & Deliver rematch was functional at best going in, but both lads did a sweet job of adding doubt to proceedings during the final few minutes. That's when Finn did his best work - he was really up for a proper match here. To his credit, Karrion met the workhorse halfway.
Keeping the belt on Kross was the right call. Injuries cut his legs off last summer, so this year's sunnier months should belong exclusively to him. Meanwhile, there are some questions about what the future holds for Finn. He's been on fire since rejoining NXT, but appears to have done everything there is to do on the brand.
Still, it'd suck to see him move back to Raw or SmackDown and become a bit-part player again. Maybe some time off would be best for all concerned. Then, eventually, Bálor can come back and resume his NXT Title charge. This match was living proof that he belongs on Tuesday nights long-term.
What did you think of this week's WWE NXT? For more wrestling, check out 18 Things You Probably Missed From WWE SmackDown (May 21) and 18 Things You Probably Missed From WWE Raw (May 24)!