6 Ups And 7 Downs From WWE Elimination Chamber 2019

Some nice moments and solid main event, but lackluster PPV overall.

Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Don’t let the number of ups and downs confuse you: Elimination Chamber was not a good show Sunday night.

The second-to-last PPV before WrestleMania 35 watched like an episode of Raw with a quality PPV main event riveted onto it, with a couple title changes thrown in to liven/shake things up. Match quality was well below average, and nearly a half-hour of PPV time was dedicated to introductions during the two chamber matches.

We crowned new WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions in a match where no one had to tag in or out of the match. We saw a title change hands where the winner didn’t pin the champ. We saw another title change where the full-time wrestler took the pinfall loss instead of the 49-year-old commissioner.

And on top of that, we were treated to a PPV match featuring the offensive (emphasis on “offensive”) stylings of Baron Corbin, fresh off his latest Olive Garden shift. We got to see Corbin and company drag things to a halt with their slot.

But, Elimination Chamber did feature two title changes that put the titles on wrestlers who deserved the straps. We saw a quality main event that gave a veteran a spotlight to shine. And we saw inaugural champs crowned in a real, emotional moment.

Oh, and The Man came around.

With that said, let’s get to it…


Downs...

7. Maybe Graves Should Muzzle It

mandy rose bayley
WWE.com

Look, we all know that wrestlers and announcers are playing characters on TV and during PPVs, but when real life intervenes, maybe discretion is the better case of valor.

In this case, Corey Graves is well known for his lecherous drooling over Mandy Rose. It’s beyond creepy at this point, and he continued his tongue-wagging Sunday night. The wrinkle to this was the revelation from Graves’ wife in a since-deleted social media post about the announcer having an affair with Carmella.

This isn’t a commentary on someone’s potential personal shortcomings – Lord knows that no one is perfect – but given that, maybe he could have toned it down for a night.

Worse, Michael Cole and Renee Young appeared to be hip to the room and called him out. Cole paid an actual compliment to Rose by starting off, “Despite the way Graves talks about Mandy Rose…” and Young flat-out told him that his drooling makes people uncomfortable.

Again, these are all characters, but it was a bit uncomfortable. Find a new gear to this shtick.


6. A Lot Of Nothing

Elimination Chamber Woman's
WWE.com

We’ll pay tribute to the women’s tag team Elimination Chamber match later, but one thing should be noted as a negative: a whole lot of nothing.

The beginning of the match was actually pretty forgettable, with no team scoring an elimination until just before the final team entered. The action was fairly dull, with a lot of nondescript brawling and laying around. The IIconics’ tired shtick certainly didn’t help as everyone lied around the ring. There was one nice moment with everyone hitting finishers on each other, but it was a bit ridiculous with 10 women in the ring at the time.

Even after Nia Jax and Tamina entered the match, it took a couple minutes to really ramp up. It’s as if they were booking the match backward and ran out of time halfway through and had to improvise/stall the first half of the bout.

Not a huge negative, but after sitting through 15 minutes of intros and a 35-minute chamber match, having 15-20 minutes be forgettable is not gonna get a positive here.


5. Lacey Adds Nothing

Lacey Evans
WWE.com

Remember when WWE boasted about how they were going to shake things up by debuting new superstars so we’d have new matchups and new faces? Yeah, WWE sure as hell doesn’t.

Two months since that announcement and none of those wrestlers competed on Sunday’s PPV. In fact, none of them have been assigned to a brand yet. Lars Sullivan hasn’t even debuted (though it’s for the best until he’s ready), EC3 is trading wins with the departing Dean Ambrose, Heavy Machinery is digging out of an embarrassing debut, and Nikki Cross recently teamed with Alicia Fox.

Lacey Evans, meanwhile, actually appeared on the Elimination Chamber PPV, walking down the ramp… and then walking back. Seriously, were we short a couple minutes and needed to puff the PPV out to four hours? What was the point of having someone who hasn’t had a Raw or SmackDown match since Royal Rumble show up to do a twirl?

Absolute waste of time.


4. Intros Galore

Jeff Hardy Elimination Chamber 2019
WWE.com

If you didn’t make it to the TV in time for the start of the Elimination Chamber PPV, don’t worry, you didn’t miss anything, even if you were 15 minutes late. And if you got stuck in the bathroom or putting the kids to bed before the main event, you had another 10-12 minutes of time to kill.

That’s because the introductions of all the competitors just went on and on and on for what seemed like forever. Nearly every wrestler walked slowly to the ring, stared at the chamber to sell how daunting of a structure it was, and then took their sweet time getting into the pod. The women tag teams in particular made sure to walk around the entire ring, visiting each occupied pod before settling into theirs. And the men weren't much better.

It was maddening to look at the clock and realize 15 minutes had passed since the PPV started and nothing had happened. It’s understandable that six separate intros are going to take some time, but it’s just crazy to realize that that much time has elapsed.


3. SmackDown Gripes

The lconics
WWE.com

Since this writer doesn’t review SmackDown, this is a rare opportunity to vent about a couple things.

First up, the IIconics, who only seem to exist to make viewers hit the mute button. During their brief time in the Elimination Chamber match, they added nothing… except screeching at decibels that has pets raising their heads. They aren’t anything special in the ring and their act is just to scream and screech. It was aggravating after a couple minutes and their quick departure was welcomed. That isn’t a great way to get heel heat; it’s a great way to get “mute” heat.

Secondly, where the hell is Asuka? Everyone is (rightly) focused on Becky Lynch and her quest for a WrestleMania match against Ronda Rousey, but everyone is ignoring the person who defeated her and injured her knee in the first place, Asuka.

Since winning the SmackDown Women’s Championship match against Lynch at the Royal Rumble, Asuka has not been seen live on the blue brand (a video did air two weeks ago). She still doesn’t have an opponent for WrestleMania – although there still are seven weeks to go – and two of SmackDown’s top women have fled to Raw to challenge Rousey.

Seriously, what gives? Talk about being an afterthought. At least give her a squash match on the kickoff show against Lana or Zelina Vega or someone to remind fans that Asuka is a dominant wrestler.


2. Raw With PPV Main Event

ronda rousey ruby riott
WWE.com

That’s about the best way to describe Elimination Chamber: an episode of Raw with a PPV main event tacked on at the end.

Seriously, look at everything between the two chamber matches: a Raw Women’s Championship squash that served as a setup for an angle advancement (and a really good one at that); a paint-by-numbers Intercontinental Championship handicap match; a lackluster SmackDown Tag Team Championship match; and a godawful Baron Corbin snoozefest against Braun Strowman, who lost after massive interference.

None of that screams “PPV-quality material,” but that’s what we got. The women’s chamber match was fine, and the men’s chamber match was really, really good. But everything else could have been moved to Monday and no one would have blinked.

We get that on the Road to WrestleMania, the two PPVs after Royal Rumble are afterthoughts to some extent, but holy crap that was bad. Match quality aside, we’ll note some positives about the outcomes of these bouts where appropriate.


1. An Overbooked Mess

Braun Strowman Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

WWE sure has its finger on the pulse, because clearly what everyone really wanted Sunday night was a long, drawn-out, plodding, overbooked-within-an-inch-of-its-life match with Baron Corbin defeating Braun Strowman.

The no-DQ match featured Corbin on slow-motion offense, but it livened up as Strowman picked up the pace and nailed a powerslam through a table. However, any enjoyment was short-lived when Drew McIntyre came out to distract him so Bobby Lashley could wallop him with a steel chair.

From there, all three men slowly pummeled Strowman and cut off every comeback, culminating in a triple powerbomb through a table stack. And then Baron pinned Braun to end this abomination.

It’s just all-around stupid. This could have been a Raw match, or a Strowman squash followed by post-match beatdown, but instead we got that. Uggh.


Ups...

6. Mr. Kickoff Show

buddy murphy akira tozawa
WWE.com

As frustrating as it might be to see the cruiserweights seemingly permanently banished to the kickoff shows of PPVs, we might as well accept it and enjoy the matches we get.

Buddy Murphy’s Cruiserweight Championship matches have consistently been entertaining as he’s continued to just win, and Sunday’s bout against Akira Tozawa was no different. Tozawa took Murphy to the limit and had him on the ropes several times, notably a flurry at the end with an inverted hurricanrana, two suicide dives and a draping senton for a close 2 count.

But Murphy did what he’s always done and pulled out a Murphy’s Law finisher to retain the title. You’ve got to wonder if he’s turning any heads backstage and could earn a promotion to the main roster, ala Mustafa Ali.

For now though, Murphy will continue to put on solid matches before the PPV proper begins.


5. Pure Elation

Bayley Sasha Banks
WWE.com

There’s no faking the emotion that Bayley and Sasha Banks displayed after becoming the inaugural WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions.

The two wrestlers are both former Raw Women’s Champions and NXT Women’s Champions. They’ve been a big part of the resurgence of women’s wrestling in WWE, so it’s only fitting that they hold the new tag titles first. They did so in an Elimination Chamber match that underperformed in the first half but ramped up as things wore on.

Banks, who was barely able to wrestle the past several weeks, ended up saving her team with a unique application of the Banks Statement to tap out Sonya Deville. It was a great reversal from recent weeks where Bayley carried the duo.

Afterward, both women were basically speechless in a live in-ring interview, which was genuine as they soaked in the cheers.


4. Balor Club Is Golden

Finn Balor Bobby Lashley
WWE.com

If you needed a reminder, it has been two-and-a-half years since Finn Balor last held gold in WWE, and that was only for one day.

That drought ended Sunday when Balor overcame the odds and defeated Intercontinental Champion Bobby Lashley and hype man Lio Rush by pinning Rush. It was a classic 2-on-1 handicap match, with Lashley doing 98% of the work and keeping manager Rush out of the ring.

But it was Lio’s ego that spelled doom, as he tagged himself in, lost the advantage and got hit with a Coup de Grace for the loss. Afterward, Lashley took out his frustration on Rush with a massive spinebuster.

For Finn, this is a big deal, as he is the type of wrestler who could benefit from holding the title. If he’s allowed to defeat other challengers and have a decent reign, it could help establish him as more than an undersized underdog into more of a player on the roster.


3. Real Tag Team Wins Tag Titles

The Usos Tag Titles
WWE.com

The entire Cinderella story of Miz and Shane McMahon had to end sometime, and it looks like WWE pulled the plug on it Sunday night.

The Usos won the SmackDown Tag Team Championship when Jimmy reversed a pin attempt by Miz to score a 3 count. The match itself was fine, aside from Shane being the dominant force with his trademark highspots. And naturally, it was Miz (who had just announced he’s about to become a father again) who ate the pinfall because you’ve got to keep McMahon strong for future bouts.

That aside, it’s good to see the tag titles on an established team and not prolonging the very strange, very odd story of Miz and Shane.

Of course, it’s very possible this could lead to a rematch, or a falling-out between the former champs, because we’re going to have to have a Shane McMahon match at WrestleMania, right?


2. The Man Comes Around

WWE elimination Chamber 2019
WWE.com

You just had to figure that Becky Lynch wasn’t going to take that suspension lying down.

Robbed of her WrestleMania main event title match and injured the night before, Lynch showed up during a staredown between Ronda Rousey and Charlotte Flair, limping to the ring with crutches and facing off against her two adversaries.

Lynch tossed her crutch at Flair and then proceeded to pummel her with the other, wearing it out with repeated shots. Becky then offered her other crutch to Rousey and seemingly allowed her to get retribution on Charlotte, only to wallop Ronda and beat her to a pulp, busting her open in the process.

The attack was perfectly done, with fans unloading on Charlotte during her pre-match promo and then cheering wildly for Lynch as she unloaded on Rousey and Flair. Becky left with security to her name being chanted as Charlotte and Ronda licked their wounds. Awesome.


1. Kofi’s Time To Shine

daniel bryan kofi kingston
WWE.com

Yes, he came up short in the Elimination Chamber, but Sunday’s PPV main event was all about Kofi Kingston.

The 11-year WWE veteran battled to the end of the chamber match, squaring off against Daniel Bryan in a drawn-out one-on-one segment at the end of the bout. Kingston came close on numerous occasions to defeating Bryan for his first WWE Championship, but he ultimately fell to a D-Bry knee.

It certainly was frustrating to see the entire arena rallying behind Kofi and trying to will him to victory, only for Bryan to pull off the clean win. But at the same time, Daniel has been on fire as the eco-friendly champion, so you could easily argue against changing horses, crowd be damned.

However, WWE would be wise to listen to their fans for a change (crazy concept, we know) and see if there’s actual energy behind Kingston. After all, we were promised “fresh matchups,” so another AJ Styles/Daniel Bryan confrontation or John Cena world title match at WrestleMania wouldn’t quite meet that test, right?


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.