6 Ups And 7 Downs From WWE No Mercy 2017
WWE promised WrestleMania-worthy bouts. Did it deliver as promised or fall short?
Going into Sunday’s WWE PPV, you had to believe that if the two major matches delivered and at least one bout on the undercard was above-average, No Mercy could be the best “B-show” of the year.
And while we certainly got an outstanding match in the Raw Tag Team Championship contest, the two main events, while technically fine, left something to be desired. You would think that the two first-ever matches would be epic confrontations, and instead they fell a little short. The matches themselves were good, but they certainly weren’t WrestleMania main event worthy.
Overall, the PPV was decent enough, if only somewhat a letdown from lofty expectations going in. The tag title match exceeded projections, while others were solid. All five women in the Raw Women’s Championship worked hard in a compressed bout, conveying the total dominance of Nia Jax without her losing the match.
But really, should we be faulting WWE for promising two WrestleMania main-event-caliber bouts, and then delivering two matches we’ve basically seen before? If either of those bouts closed Mania, fans would be understandably frustrated. Even so, if you wanted to watch the PPV after the fact, it’s worth it for the spectacle, just remember to fast-forward the cruiserweight match.
With that said, what powerslammed the competition, and what got speared out of their boots? Let’s get to it…
Downs...
7. Demon = Alter Ego?
Sometimes it’s tough to understand WWE logic or reasoning (or the lack there of). The case of Finn Balor and the bodypainted Demon is one of those things.
In NXT, Balor often would break out the bodypaint for a big match, typically at a TakeOver event, which meant 4-5 times a year. The announcers sold it as Finn tapping into a darker side of himself and channeling that energy… but it was still Finn Balor.
But Sunday, the announcers and storyline made it seem like Balor and Demon were two different characters, referring to the Demon as Finn’s alter ego. That’s more reminiscent of Mankind turning into Dude Love or Cactus Jack, a completely different character. This was even part of the billing of the match, “Man vs. Man,” meaning no demons allowed. (But gods were OK, apparently.)
It’s not a huge deal in the grand scheme of things, but it still felt odd. Does this mean that Balor is now seguing into that paranormal realm where a wrestler channels powers from strange places? Or is this just WWE gobbledy-gook? Again, not a big deal, but it felt unnecessary.
6. Division-Killer
This must have been what it was like when Hornswoggle won the Cruiserweight Championship.
When Enzo Amore moved over to 205 Live, the reviews were mixed. He wouldn’t be able to keep up with the more skilled wrestlers, but he would potentially add a little main roster star power and might help up the profile of the division.
Instead, we got a godawful Cruiserweight Championship match Sunday night, with Neville slooooowly dominating Amore, practically wrestling himself as he went along. He had to stall for a half-hour before missing a Phoenix splash, and even then, he only lost when Enzo kicked him low with the ref’s back turned, winning the title.
If ever there was a “throw your beer at the TV moment,” that was it. Unless Enzo is turning full heel, this was about the dumbest thing WWE could do with the division.
5. Know Your Audience
Booking Miz to be the heel in his adopted hometown against a guy who fans have been at best lukewarm to is not the best climate to make a new star. You’re just begging for “Bizarro World.”
And that’s exactly what happened Sunday when Miz faced Jason Jordan for the Intercontinental Championship. Billed as residing in Hollywood, Miz had the Los Angeles crowd behind him while Jordan struggled to get fans to react positively when he wasn’t performing an impressive move (such as a deadlift delayed suplex or twin Northern Lights suplexes).
At one point, fans chanted, “Let’s go Miz!/Who’s your daddy?” which pretty much summed things up. Corey Graves (most likely with Vince McMahon in his headset) tried to spin it as the fans being disrespectful to Miz by chanting about his father, which was so ludicrous that he should have been embarrassed for even saying it.
Jordan is extremely talented, but it’s becoming increasingly obvious that something is going to have to give at some point. His in-ring talent isn’t going to completely overshadow this poor soap opera storyline.
4. Nia Comes Up Short Again
It’s about time for WWE to crap or get off the pot with Nia Jax.
Nia once again came up short in a Raw Women’s Championship match on Sunday, though it wasn’t for lack of a dominant performance. WWE has been good at making Jax look like a division-beater, but she inevitably slips on a proverbial banana peel and fails to win a big match. In this case, she got powerbombed off the apron by all four women, then came back, only to post herself and be knocked out of the ring when Alexa Bliss picked up the pinfall.
If WWE wants Nia to be a dominant force in the women’s division, then she needs to win the big match, not constantly come up short. Sure, there might be a perfectly legit reason for her to not win the title here (more on that later), but it’s something the company has to be aware of.
3. Cena Needed A Howitzer
We all expected the John Cena/Roman Reigns match to include numerous kickouts of finishing moves. But Roman kicking out of four Attitude Adjustments.
Come on.
There’s a fine line between a wrestler looking superhuman by kicking out of finishers, and making your finishers look like a joke, or worse, making fans not buy into the finishing moves.
Cena hit Roman with an AA, then a Super AA, and later two consecutive AAs, only for Reigns to kick out of both of them. And then, Roman popped up, hit a Superman Punch and spear and pinned Cena clean.
Seriously, what the actual hell? Roman kicks out of four AAs, but Cena can’t kick out of one spear? (The spear through the table outside doesn’t count since there was a full minute between move and pinfall attempt.)
2. Plan 9 From WWE
“OK everyone, this time Roman Reigns will be ‘over’ with the fans.”
Can you imagine someone pitching the John Cena/Reigns feud and saying that? Roman defeated and potentially retired the Undertaker at WrestleMania, which was the latest failed attempt to turn him into a made man, so having him beat Cena in their first one-on-one encounter would work, right? Right?
The announcers sure sold it as a changing of the guard. It was more than saying that the ring was now Roman’s yard. They called it the biggest win of his career, a defining victory. Cena even gave his endorsement by raising Roman’s hand afterward.
The match itself was good, but not the epic encounter you would have expected or thought they would deliver. And billing it as a changing of the guard didn’t help matters, as Roman basically punched and punched and punched while absorbing Cena’s offense. Again, a good match, but it certainly didn’t feel like Roman had ascended the mountain to become The Guy in WWE.
But hey, maybe this time, fans will respect Reigns’ achievements and position in WWE!
1. Marquee Bouts Don’t Live Up To Hype
The positives of the two big matches will be extolled later, but when a PPV is hyped on the basis that there are two WrestleMania-caliber main events, then both or at least one better deliver an epic bout.
Instead, both matches were good, but not great. John Cena versus Roman Reigns was a pretty good contest, but if it closed Mania, it would have been a huge letdown, not just because Reigns would be anointed that future of WWE. And Brock Lesnar versus Braun Strowman wasn’t surprising for Brock winning, but because he took the monster out with only six German suplexes and one F-5.
It’s one thing to hype a PPV on two first-ever encounters, but it’s another to call the matches worthy of the Mania main event slot. WWE set the bar very high, and it simply didn’t clear the hurdle.
Ups...
6. Cesaro’s Not Human
If you weren’t a strong supporter of Cesaro before Sunday’s tag title match, you have to be afterward… and that goes for Vince McMahon as well.
The Swiss Cyborg has always been solid in the ring and is known for being pound-for-pound one of the strongest wrestlers in WWE. But it took a different kind of strength for Cesaro to persevere through an incident where he took a catapult to the ringpost and knocked his front teeth out… and then kept going in the match for another 10 minutes.
Think about how you’d react to getting your teeth knocked out, and then imagine continuing to wrestle at a high level. It’s almost impossible. But Cesaro made it look easy.
Well, as easy as wrestling with a bloody mouth can look.
5. Balor/Wyatt Feud Has Appropriate Ending
You don’t often get to say that a storyline has a definitive ending, but we can hope that the Finn Balor/Bray Wyatt feud has indeed reached a climax after Sunday’s match.
Wyatt and Balor split their first two matches, with Finn (spray-painted as the Demon) defeating Bray at SummerSlam. Sunday’s match was dubbed as a “man versus man” match with Balor forbidden to channel his inner Demon. (Although Bray was apparently allowed to channel his “godlike” delusions.)
Bray jumped Finn before the match and injured him, then kept on the pressure throughout, while Balor gritted through it all. He gutted it out and overcame Wyatt, finally delivering a Coup de Grace for the win. It actually tied things up nicely, with Balor keeping the Demon under wraps and overcoming a sneak attack to win.
Of course, we’ll probably get more “mindgames” from Bray on Raw, because the feud must continue. Let’s just hope that this represented an ending, not another stop on the ride.
4. Goddess Versus Empress Next Month?
During No Mercy, we received a teaser that could explain why Alexa Bliss retained her Raw Women’s Championship Sunday.
Vignettes have been teasing the arrival of undefeated former NXT Women’s Champion Asuka, but Sunday announced her due date: the TLC PPV on October 22. With the Empress of Tomorrow showing up in four weeks, it can’t be long before she has her sights set on the Raw women’s title. And for that reason alone, hotshotting the title to another wrestler now would have been a bad move.
Beyond that, announcing Asuka’s debut now was a smart move. Presumably, you had a bunch of fans watching No Mercy for the two big matches, and you might as well use that opportunity to plug the next Raw PPV, and announcing a big debut is one way to try to hook viewers.
3. Soooo, That Match Happened
It’s tough to determine whether Brock Lesnar versus Braun Strowman was a good match or a bad one, or if it was just something that happened.
No one was expecting a technical clinic from these two, but we’ve seen both men involved in other matches where they clearly held their own and put on a great show. So they certainly had the potential to turn this much-anticipated bout into a must-see.
And the result? It’s tough to say. On the one hand, Brock being overmatched in the early-going was a pretty near storyline, but he survived the onslaught and countered with a Kimura and five consecutive German suplexes. Even then, he still had to weather two running powerslams before hitting an F-5 for the win.
If you thought the finish was anticlimactic, you’re not alone. But the match was still a good power battle while it lasted. Much like Goldberg/Lesnar at WrestleMania XXXIII, Sunday’s title match was more about the spectacle than the wrestling.
It is surprising though that Strowman lost cleanly to one F-5, rather than kicking out of one or two before being slain.
2. One Way To Get Cheered
WWE finally figured out a way to get an entire arena to cheer for John Cena: Pit him against Roman Reigns.
Cena was the clear fan favorite in the match, despite soaking in some jeers himself. But it was readily apparent that Roman was the villain in this bout. When Cena hit a Super-AA on Roman, the fans chanted, “One more time!” They cheered Cena during the typical “Boo!/Yay!” spot where the wrestlers trade bombs.
Overall though, it was the reaction after the match that deserves the biggest nod. As Cena slowly brought himself back to his feet after Reigns left, the fans gave him a warm reception, even chanting, “Thank you Cena!” in appreciation.
It’s nice to know that even though he gets booed a lot of times, the fans overall respect his performance.
1. Tag Title Demolition Derby
Between Cesaro’s missing front teeth and the sheer carnage of the match itself, the Raw Tag Team Championship match was clearly the spectacle of the undercard.
All four men worked hard to deliver a knockout match, with hard-hitting moves that had fans – and some writers – jumping out of their seats. The White Noise-Powerbomb combo was an especially electric moment, with Cesaro powerbombing Seth Rollins off the middle turnbuckle onto a prone Dean Ambrose.
Cesaro’s injury slowed things down momentarily in the middle of the match, but they picked it right back up once it was determined he could continue. The ending, with Sheamus accidentally Brogue Kicking Cesaro before falling to a Kings Landing and Dirty Deeds, was a nice ending that made both teams look strong – it took a miscue for the champs to retain.
A lot of times, you might say that enough is enough and move on to a new feud, but let’s hope that if that’s the case, we see them meet up again.