6 Worst Handled Characters In WWE NXT History

Not all NXT graduates end up with gimmicks as awesome as The Shield or The Wyatts.

NXT is considered by many wrestling fans the best television the WWE puts out on a weekly basis. The Shield, The Wyatt Family, Daniel Bryan, Bad News Barrett, the list goes on and on of WWE's biggest stars who have been a part of the show's history. Originally more akin to a gameshow than the more typical wrestling show we are given today, NXT is the place where the stars of tomorrow learn their trade. Some of those would be stars have not been so lucky. Some of them have been so horribly mismanaged either on NXT or when WWE attempts to call them up to the big stage of RAW or Smackdown that they never recover. This list is comprised of the biggest mistakes and failures in the history of the WWE brand NXT as well as transitions from that brand to the main roster. Everything from the current Developmental TV show with storylines all of its own to the earlier Reality Season format is up for grabs. With all due praise the show has clearly deserved there are some glaring opportunities that were not only missed but have been thrown away. Hopefully these mistakes won't be repeated but as a longtime fan I'm sure most if not all will be.


6. Aloisia

In the history of the WWE there have been a long line of wrestlers to make their TV debuts only to quickly vanish. Few of them have ever had physical dimensions more coveted by Vince McMahon than Aloisia. Coming in at a stunning 6'9, she seemed like the obvious favorite from the day the WWE released a video hyping her as a participant in Season 3. To the shock of everyone that video would mark the beginning & the end of her time on WWE TV. Shortly before the first episode of the season, the WWE reported that Aloisia had gotten in an argument with her pro Vickie Guerrero and would be replaced. As fate would have it Vickie's new protege Kaitlyn would do what most thought Aloisia was going to do and win the season. Aloisia is no longer a part of wrestling on any level and may have been more Giant Gonzales than The Undertaker. It can not be argued however that she would not have held everyone's attention when she made her entrance. If scandalous photos of her had not be come to light right before she was set to debut she likely would have gotten more chances that any other woman who ever competed for the company. The fact that she was announced and then released cast a shadow over the entire season that followed. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGWbGZy8NHw Aloisia seemingly was working hard to become a competent wrestler and many of women in the history of WWE started out without any in ring talent. None of them possessed the attributes that would have made Aloisia a truly unique attraction like some other big stars in the history of the company. If given the chance she may not have amounted to much but denied it her potential never had a chance to be realized.


5. Emma

During her tenure on NXT Emma was amongst the crowd's favorite acts, even if most fans who only watch Raw and Smackdown may find that hard to beleive. Since her debut on the main roster, when she was in the crowd at ringside holding signs up featuring her catchphrases, fans have not known how to take her. What has been lost in translation? During NXT's debut episode on the WWE Network several vignettes aired with the intent of introducing characters to the new audience the show hoped to receive. Despite the fact that Emma had joined the main roster & new fans should have known her better than almost anyone on the roster, one of those features was about her. The vignette explained how she was a fun loving, goofy, clumsy Aussie who just so happened to be one hell of a wrestler with a funny dance. In less than a minute they got across everything there was to like about the character. How was her debut on Raw handled? Nothing about what had previously made her a success was explained to this new, much larger audience. Santino pulled her out of the crowd to do a strange dance that made no sense to anyone who didn't watch her in NXT and the only reason the crowd reacted to her was Santino's obviously prompting. If they aired the vignette that was shown on NXT, the audience would understand her character. As it is most fans don't know what to make of her and a talented performer is going to waste. Emma's recent legal troubles, firing, rehiring and lack of appearances on WWE televison at all are certainly not good signs of things to come.


4. Adam Rose

Within weeks of beginning to work for WWE the man who we see on WWE television today came to be known as Leo Kruger. Eventually settling on the character of a south african madman, Kruger formed an alliance with Kassius Ohno (more on him later) and sought the NXT Tag Team Championship. Unsucessful, the duo seemed to be going nowhere and soon after Kruger was repackaged as Adam Rose. Rose came to the ring flanked by a gaggle of other party goers and danced to a fun song. Rose got a fantastic response from the NXT audience and seemed to be on the way to stardom. That was until he was called up to Raw. From the start WWE Audiences did not know how to take the vignettes that aired to announce the upcoming debut of Rose. Vignettes are designed to introduce a character and make fans anticipate their arrival. Adam Rose does not fit this concept. He was never meant to be anything more than a fun distraction in the show. Once he debuted the Rosebuds (Adam's entourage) were now seen in the much, much larger venues he appeared in as paltry and the whole act was just lame. After a few weeks Rose became an absolute afterthought and stopped going out in front of the audience of the week. Now relegated to backstage segments that shamelessly shill the product of the week. There is no character that has fallen so far, so fast. Not appearing on a show has got to be better than this.


3. Derrick Bateman

Before Derrick Bateman was announced to be a part of season 4 of NXT he had been in WWE developmental for 3 years. During that time he gained the respect of many main roster wrestlers, most of all John Cena was said to be a big fan of his work. In most cases the vote of confidence from the number one guy in the company leads to a long career. Just ask Brutus Beefcake, The Booty Man, The Man With No Name, The Zodiac & The Disciple. Ed Leslie the man who portrayed all those characters despite only the first being any kind of success if he was honest would tell you that riding coat tails can do a lot for you. His close friend Hulk Hogan opened dorrs for him wherever he went. In Bateman's case however when he was eliminated from season 4 & then NXT Redemption (The season that followed) his days were numbered. Less than a year later he was released from the company and shortly after he signed with TNA. In TNA he was rechristened Ethan Carter III and immediately became a major focus of their TV every week. This is the perfect example of one man's trash being another man's treasure. In TNA he has feuded with Sting, Bully Ray & Kurt Angle, some of the biggest stars that company has ever seen. He has quickly become one of the best promo men in the business. What he needed more than anything else was confidence. TNA has recently brought in Bobby Lashley, someone they clearly have high hopes for and his first feud was with none other than Ethan Carter III. With a roster with so few full time main event level acts WWE can't afford to miss out on someone as good as Carter has become. If their system was set up more to give confidence & less to require tenacity they may not have missed the boat.


2. Kaval

The performer mostly known either as Senshi or Low Ki has long been a fan favorite wherever he has gone. He has performed in TNA, NWA, NJPW, AJPW & ROH as well as many other places and he has always stood out. His gravely voice & martial arts influenced style have made him unique. When he joined WWE as Kaval there were a lot of reasons to hope for the best. There were however two main reasons to worry that things were not going to work out. In WWE, a size obsessed company, being 5'8 may be a big problem. You could say the writing was on the wall. That's why it was so shocking when Kaval went on to actually win the second season of NXT. Soon after being drafted to Smackdown he got a spot on a pay per view representing the his season against Raw. It looked like everyone's misgivings may be proven wrong. Kaval then used the guaranteed title shot he was granted for winning NXT for the intercontinental title and failed. If you can get a shot at any title and you don't go after the World title it really sends a message to the audience that you are not worthy. Kaval was never portrayed as a star again and was was given his release upon his request. Kaval was and is an incredibly talented performer who at worst should have been an upper mid card act in WWE to this day if given a proper chance. From the start he was never given much of an opportunity. Wrestling fans have lost out on many five star matches that could have taken place as a result if it weren't for the WWE's size fetish.


1. Kassius Ohno

Like Kaval before him Kassius Ohno came to WWE developmental with many years of indie cred wrestling as Chris Hero. Kassius Ohno signed with WWE in 2012 and was released in 2013 with very little fan fare. If you weren't a fan of his work pre WWE, his tenure and firing may have gone completely unnoticed. Reportedly he had been asked to take training more seriously and get in better shape neither of which he did. The WWE lost all faith in him as a result and it was only a matter of time until he was fired. The reason this is the biggest mishandling in NXT history is just how big a star Chris Hero should be for WWE. If he had been given half a chance he easily could have been the next big WWE prospect. Cesaro & Hero could have reformed their tag team from the indies instead of the Real Americans or he could have taken Seth Rollins place in The Shield. He is just that talented. In fact he could have been the next Daniel Bryan or CM Punk if the WWE higher ups had ever looked past his physique and instead looked at his wrestling talent, charisma & mic skills. Huge wrestlers who may not be great in the ring have their place in the business but it's never worked at the top of the card. Hopefully some day the WWE will value what makes a wrestler over what makes a Muscle & Fitness cover model.

Contributor
Contributor

Growing up in London, Ontario, Canada, my parents & brothers started a love for movies and wrestling in me. Discovering comics in my early teens, I've become a pop culture junkie. I love to write about the all of it and am incredibly happy to be able to have people read it. My entertainment writing for the site news for shoppers can be found here: http://www.newsforshoppers.com/journalist/matthew-thomas/