6 WrestleMania Title Matches That Should Have Been Triple Threats
As opposed to one this year that shouldn’t be...
As hard as WWE are trying to convince us otherwise, barring any last-minute hiccups, the main event of WrestleMania 35 will be a triple-threat match between Ronda Rousey, Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch for the RAW Women’s Championship.
Putting her old rival, suspension and a knee injury in Lynch’s path to MetLife Stadium will only make ‘The Man’s’ inevitable coronation that much more satisfying but, however successful the payoff might be, this is not the story that fans were wanting WWE to tell.
On the back of Lynch’s Royal Rumble victory, there was a massive demand for WWE to revisit the singles match with Rousey initially booked for Survivor Series, one that we were denied by a wild swing of Nia Jax’s fist. ‘The Irish Lasskicker’ had done an outstanding job of keeping that fire stoked in the preceding months with her Grade A social media bantz, and there was certainly enough intrigue and narrative to keep this feud one-on-one.
But WWE were not prepared to let this milestone in women’s wrestling pass by without having Charlotte share that spotlight; a one for you, one for us, type of deal.
If Charlotte is the unwanted third wheel in this scenario, there have also been instances in WrestleMania past when WWE have missed opportunities to transform the fortunes of underwhelming singles title matches by making them a triple threat.
6. WrestleMania 33 - Bray Wyatt Vs. Randy Orton Vs. LUKE HARPER
One of the worst WWE Championship matches in WrestleMania history actually had a really good build-up, to a point. Randy Orton had destroyed the Wyatt Family from within and left newly-crowned champion Bray Wyatt to fend for himself at ‘The Show of Shows’.
It was a rare modern-day case of long-term WWE storytelling, that lasted over six months from start to finish and a narrative that WWE were so committed to that even a record-equalling 16th world title reign for John Cena was not going to change their 'Mania plans.
However, it was WWE’s refusal to budge from this narrative that was part of their undoing, as it was actually Luke Harper who came out of the Wyatt Family split as the hot babyface. Harper had always been a performer appreciated by the more engaged fans, and was starting to turn believers out of the casuals with his character and in-ring work over the course of his turn. Without him, the Wyatt-Orton match descended into farce.
Even when Harper accidentally won a battle royal to earn a WrestleMania title match, WWE wrote him out of the angle when they should have rolled with the punches. They felt that the promise they had made to Orton - the Royal Rumble victory and title triumph indebted to him after his SummerSlam pummelling at the hands, and elbows, of Brock Lesnar - was worth more than developing Harper, who they have only ever pictured as a support act.
5. WrestleMania 32 - Triple H Vs. Roman Reigns Vs. DEAN AMBROSE
As good as it was to see Roman Reigns healthy in the middle of the ring on RAW this Monday night, basking in the support of the crowd, that has not always been the case.
Nobody was interested in a Reigns championship coronation at WrestleMania 32. This may have been the peak of his unpopularity, having been forced down the throats of a WWE fanbase that was bitter in the post-Daniel Bryan and CM Punk era, no more so then when he took a third successive Royal Rumble hostage before losing the WWE title to Triple H.
Simultaneously, this might have been the most popular that Ambrose ever was as a singles star. Indeed, it was ‘The Lunatic Fringe’ who was last eliminated from the Rumble to give HHH extra heat, rather than the man positioned as the company’s top babyface. ‘The Game’ defeated Ambrose, cast as little more than Reigns’ sidekick, at Network special Roadblock.
Ambrose was given a marquee feud against Brock Lesnar but was ultimately squashed on the big stage, and would have been better used as main event bait. Even if WWE were always going to put the belt on Reigns at AT&T Stadium, having Ambrose in the match would have at least retained intrigue in a WrestleMania that had a lot of fans switching off early.
4. WrestleMania 29 - The Rock Vs. John Cena Vs. CM PUNK
Of all of the entries on this list, this is the missed 'Mania triple threat opportunity which stings the most with fans, and also the one which stung WWE the most in the long run.
CM Punk was in the midst of the best WWE Championship run of the modern era, but was shafted for a rematch of the ‘Once In a Lifetime’ showdown of The Rock versus John Cena. The Chicago favourite had held the title at the previous year’s WrestleMania, but his match with Chris Jericho was ousted from the headline position by The Rock’s mainstream appeal.
Main eventing WrestleMania is the dream of many wrestlers and one that Punk thought he had earned the right to fulfil, and yet was denied two years in a row - at WrestleMania 27 it was The Miz who faced Cena, despite Punk establishing himself as the company’s top heel.
Punk addressed these frustrations on friend Colt Cabana’s Art of Wrestling podcast, in his now famous post-WWE departure rant, saying: "I kept asking what was going on for 'Mania and Vince kept very disappointingly telling me that it was going to be the rematch between Cena and Rock. I was just like 'That's going to be awful, how about we do this?'
"I mean, I guess if people want to call me a politician, I was trying to politic my way into the main event but it wasn't like 'Let me beat everybody', It was 'hey, let's do a three way, it will be elimination. Have somebody pin me in f****** five minutes, I don't care. And then I'll be able to be like 'Ha, I did the main event at WrestleMania' and I'll be able to move on."
This should have worked for everyone. WWE would have got Rock and Cena part two and still made money, Punk would have got his main event, and the fans would have been much more invested in the storyline.
As it was, Punk was out of the company less than a year later.
3. WrestleMania 27 - Edge Vs. Alberto Del Rio Vs. CHRISTIAN
The winner of the 2011 40-man Royal Rumble match opened up WrestleMania 27, showing where this World Heavyweight Championship feud between Edge and Alberto Del Rio ranked in WWE’s priorities that year.
Creating a new main event talent out of a Rumble winner was a refreshing throwback concept - the four previous winners had been The Undertaker, John Cena, Randy Orton and Edge himself - to paint a picture of the usual stature of the victor - but there was nothing about his rivalry with ’The Rated-R Superstar' that made it feel as though Del Rio belonged in his class.
The Mexican was a gifted in-ring technician but he was only six months into his main roster run and had not had the time to establish himself as somebody worth caring about. He was little more than a gimmick to most fans, and a gimmick that they had seen at the top of the card only a few years prior with JBL.
The insertion of Christian (who had just returned from injury to save Edge from a Del Rio beatdown at Elimination Chamber) into the match would have added layers of fascinating backstory. ‘Captain Charisma’ did float around the feud but as a bit-part character, so much so that having him in Edge’s corner at WrestleMania felt a bit unnecessary. He should have played a much bigger role.
WWE may have been building to a summer angle between the former tag partners, but this turned out to be Edge’s last match before his career-ending neck injury, and we never got to see them have a true singles rivalry.
2. WrestleMania 18 - Chris Jericho Vs. Triple H Vs. STONE COLD STEVE AUSTIN
Triple H had long been positioned to win the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 18 upon his return from a serious quadricep injury. Chris Jericho was the right type of slippery heel to get career baddy HHH over as a babyface, but lacked the star power to carry the weight of a main event that followed The Rock vs. Hulk Hogan - an enviable task for anyone, in truth.
If there is any wrestler who could have shouldered that burden it was 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin, who ended up being wasted at the same event in a throwaway match with Hogan’s nWo pal Scott Hall, a dead angle which contributed to Austin’s exodus from the company.
Austin and Triple H had spent the year prior to ‘The Game’s’ injury entangled in a bitter-enemies-turned-unlikely-allies storyline which verged on soap opera at times, but did deliver some memorable moments and collisions, notably a hellacious ’Three Stages of Hell’ match at No Way Out 2001. Their short-lived ‘Two Man Power Trip’ tag team would surely have ended with more of the same, a payoff we were denied by that snap of HHH’s quad.
It felt like there was unfinished business between ‘The King of Kings’ and ‘The Rattlesnake’, and exploring this at the SkyDome in Toronto would have been a better way to utilise Austin, helping the main event stay afloat, rather than drown in the aftermath of Rock vs. Hogan.
1. WrestleMania 15 - The Rock Vs. Stone Cold Vs. MANKIND
The least celebrated of the Rock-Austin trilogy, the previous months of WWE programming had been centred around ‘The Great One’s’ feud with Mankind and their back-and-forth swapping of the WWE Championship in a series of brutal yet brilliant matches.
One of the three faces of Foley was red hot off the back of his first World Title triumph in December 1998 - the ‘Foley wins the title’ episode of RAW that helped swing the Monday Night Wars. After losing the belt for a second time in 46 days, he stayed around the title scene but ended up being wasted at ‘Mania as a Special Referee for the Rock-Austin main event, beating The Big Show earlier the night in a seven-minute match to earn the stripes.
Because of Vince McMahon’s victory in the 1999 Royal Rumble match, which was effectively renounced in short order, WWE had a free pass creatively to throw anybody into the title picture, and Foley’s work in the proceeding months was worthy of that main event spot.
‘The Hardcore Legend’ would go on to headline WrestleMania 12 months later, but this should have been the time that he headlined on ‘The Grandest Stage of Them All’.