7 Greatest Returns In Modern Wrestling History
Relive some of the greatest pops in modern history with these earth-shaking returns.
A wrestler trading one federation for another may do plenty to get the blood pumping, but many of the greatest moments in wrestling history are detonated when a superstar reemerges after a lengthy lay-off. The mind may go to John Cena's iconic 2008 Royal Rumble return at Madison Square Garden, or Triple H's 2002 return after tearing his quad muscle, but the modern era has plenty of adrenaline-fuelled returns that can now be considered all-time classics.
It takes something special to etch your place into fans' minds and into the history books, with all kinds of trappings threatening to foil these big moments. The daily news grind is more relentless than ever, and fans are usually way more informed than the likes of WWE and AEW want them to be. It's why the powers that be deserve all the credit for leapfrogging these hurdles to give us moments that will last a lifetime.
Storytelling is the true key to a great comeback. With characters and stories reaching sophisticated heights that have not been seen in many years, the following are the building-shaking returns that have written themselves into wrestling folklore - then, now, and forever.
7. Jade Cargill Returns At WWE Elimination Chamber 2025
"Who injured Jade Cargill?" is one of the best whodunnit mysteries to play out on WWE television. After dominating the women's tag team division with Bianca Belair and holding the titles for what seemed like an age, their reign together was cut short in shocking fashion.
On the November 22nd, 2024 episode of SmackDown, Cargill was found decimated on a car bonnet in the parking lot. Having been thrown from a large platform, her limp body was next to a shattered windscreen, as Belair and fellow friend Naomi were left devastated. No witnesses saw what happened, and months of speculation began.
After four long months, and with all signs pointing to The Judgment Day's Liv Morgan as the chief culprit, Cargill's music hit as all six participants were locked inside the women's Elimination Chamber at the eponymous March 2025 PLE. As Jade marched towards Morgan, dressed in all black and looking like a badass, she turned her attention to Naomi and laid in the mother of all beatdowns.
It made Jade Cargill look like The Terminator and started the most exciting run of Naomi's WWE career, too.
6. Sting Returns At AEW WrestleDream 2025
Of all of AEW's landmark achievements, the job they have done in returning Sting to legendary status ranks among the best of them. After WWE did their best to dilute the legacy of 'The Stinger', AEW has a plethora of Sting's all-time best moments in their canon. The hits keep coming on this front, as WrestleDream 2025's greatest moment was stolen by Sting's triumphant return to save Darby Allin.
At the culmination of an I Quit match with Jon Moxley that felt more like a war than a wrestling contest, and after Darby had suffered everything from being launched like a lawn dart from the ring by Claudio Castignoli to nearly being murdered by Moxley attempting to drown him, the lights in the Chaifetz Arena in St. Louis, Missouri went pitch black.
Suspicions were instantly aroused that Darby's old partner was set to return, but the lights coming back on to reveal 'Old Man Sting' was as joyous a return as it's possible to enjoy. With his beard and hair looking like Gandalf The Grey if he liked Black Metal, Sting took his trademark bat to each of The Death Riders before demolishing Moxley to lead Darby Allin to victory.
5. The Undertaker Returns To WWE WrestleMania
The end of WWE WrestleMania 40 is one of the all-time great pro wrestling moments. As the whole world united in wanting Cody Rhodes to fulfill his family destiny, end the never-ending reign of Roman Reigns, and lift the World Championship that his father so famously never got the chance to, the action came thick and fast.
During a match that incorporated Bloodline Rules, John Cena, Solo Sikoa, Seth Rollins, and The Rock all played their part in setting up the spectacular climax. After all of the run-ins and beatdowns, it seemed as though 'The Final Boss' was set to get his way again, with Rhodes down and out, and The Rock standing tall. That was until that infamous gong hit, and The Undertaker wrote another chapter in his WrestleMania story.
The roar from the Philadelphia crowd was sensational, largely because it made absolutely no sense for 'Taker to be there. That did not matter one bit, as 'The Deadman' hoisted The Rock high into the night sky, delivering a thunderous chokeslam, and paving the way for Cody Rhodes to cement one of the best moments in WWE history.
4. Toni Storm Returns To Being Timeless
A little bit of creative license on this one, as it's not coming back from an injury or using any of the traditional tricks of the trade, but Toni Storm's masterful storytelling demands a place on this list. Perfect in its set-up and execution, the AEW legend's retransformation to being Timeless once more is one of the most satisfying moments in company history.
After losing the AEW Women's Championship to arch nemesis Mariah May at All In 2024 as part of their epic feud, Storm appeared to suffer from amnesia. Forgetting her entire run as 'Timeless' Toni Storm, she regressed to her old "sk8r girl" persona, flashing devil horns with amateurish glee, and being in awe of her big-time status at AEW.
This all came crashing to an almighty end, with Toni Storm unleashing as good a monologue as you will ever see in a wrestling ring. As Mariah May dealt out her latest humiliation to the fallen hero with infuriating enjoyment, Storm lay broken on the floor before grabbing a microphone and uttering the unforgettable line, "What makes you think I have forgotten?" Stripping to her underwear, smearing her lipstick all over her face, and bellowing, "For I am Timeless, Timeless Toni Storm" to the stars and anyone in earshot, it is nothing short of perfection from one of the greatest performers in the world today.
3. Rhea Ripley Returns To Confront Dom & Liv
After a full year of absolute dominance of WWE's women's division, and having recently disposed of future Hall of Famer Becky Lynch at WrestleMania 40, Rhea Ripley had established herself as one of the biggest superstars in any wrestling company on Earth. In an awful stroke of luck, Ripley suffered a legitimate grade-three AC sprain during a backstage attack by Liv Morgan. She was subsequently forced to relinquish her title, as the world mourned her upcoming absence.
During Rhea's time away from the ring, Liv dominated pretty much everything that stood in her way. Embarking on the Liv Morgan Revenge Tour, she won Ripley's WWE Women's Championship, retired Becky Lynch for a short while, and stole Dominik Mysterio from 'The Eradicator'. It was an unfortunate set of circumstances, but it did serve to elevate Morgan to superstar status.
That was, until 'Mami' came home.
After Morgan assisted Dirty Dom in cheating a victory over his father and Zelina Vega in a mixed tag match on Monday Night Raw, Liv and Mysterio writhed around together on the ring canvas until Rhea Ripley's music hit. Her screwface looking like somebody had just spilled her pint, her shoulders puffed up, and her stride like Jason Voorhees, Ripley's epic comeback reassured the world that 'Mami' was most definitely still on top.
2. Seth Rollins Returns From 'Injury' At WWE SummerSlam 2025
No stranger to a great heist, Seth Rollins took things to a whole new level in the Summer of 2025. Having been taken off screen with what was presented as a legitimate injury during his match with LA Knight at Saturday Night's Main Event, something didn't quite smell right about the whole ordeal. The reporting on the injury was vague, and the timing of it (the same day as AEW had their biggest show of the year at All In) felt more than a little suspicious.
After a spectacular bout between the two in the main event of SummerSlam, Gunther had been dethroned as the World Heavyweight Champion by Rollins' long-time nemesis, CM Punk. As Punk held WWE gold for the first time in 12 years, his elation turned to deflation as Seth Rollins' music boomed over the PA. Arriving on crutches and with Paul Heyman carrying Seth's Money In The Bank briefcase, the tension reached a fever pitch.
The sight of Rollins throwing away his crutches before stealing Punk's moment and the WWE World Heavyweight Championship from under him was perfectly executed. That Seth suffered a long-term injury just two months later is a cruel twist of fate from the wrestling Gods.
1. Darby Allin and Bryan Danielson at All In Texas
Say what you will about AEW, but when they nail a long-term storyline, they really know how to bring it home. After Jon Moxley had boiled the piss of everybody by holding the AEW World Heavyweight Championship hostage for almost a year, fans were desperate for somebody to set the title free. That was a sentiment echoed by members of the roster in the run-up to the company's biggest show of 2025 at All In Texas, as Will Ospreay threw his support behind 'Hangman' Adam Page after Page defeated the Brit at Double Or Nothing to earn the right to face Moxley for the championship.
Throwing everything they had at the match's finale, Moxley and his Death Riders were backed up by The Young Bucks in a crusade to keep the title. The final act was rightly given to Swerve Strickland, as he and 'Hangman' called a truce to their bitter feud for the good of AEW, and Page won the title once more.
However, arguably the two biggest pops of the main event were reserved for the company's returning heroes. Feeling like AEW's "Avengers Assemble" moment, Bryan Danielson came out of retirement to hit a running missile dropkick, and Darby Allin arrived from the rafters (and Mount Everest) to aid 'Hangman' in setting AEW's most coveted prize free.