7 Rules WWE Should Bring Back

Rules are made to be adhered to.

WWE Rule Book
WWE.com

Looking at the superfluous use of foreign objects as well as underhanded maneuvers in WWE matches throughout time, especially during the Attitude and Ruthless Aggression Eras, it is easy to speculate that the current-day product is much cleaner than its predecessors. With most of the action focusing on athletic feats, it’s almost as though there are stricter guidelines in place, but that’s not quite the case.

In fact, as ‘Stone Cold’ Steve Austin often points out in his podcasts, there are fewer restrictions than ever, which can be more harmful than helpful. For instance, it is rather difficult to paint an upcoming superstar as the bad guy when there are no rules for him to break.

It’s no secret that professional wrestling is fixed, but rules are still important in terms of telling a story during the match. Some add realism. Some add suspense. More often than not, how a superstar wins or loses matters more than the victory itself. By reinstating or reinforcing a handful of rules from wrestling’s past, WWE could stand to round out its in-ring presentation.

7. Closed Fists

Big Cass Big Show
WWE.com

The closed fist was once banned in many wrestling organizations, including WWE, because it did not meet the higher expectations placed on their superstars. The idea was that someone won a professional wrestling match through a display of athletic dominance. While predetermined, pro-wrestling was based off of amateur wrestling, and to keep kayfabe, superstars could not throw clenched fists. The exception was generally a heel who broke the rule to garner a certain reaction from the crowd.

However, in WWE today, bad guys, good guys, and everyone in between throw straight rights. They are often the subject of many Yay-Boo chants. As a result, the punches have become detracting and ineffective.

Banning closed fists again would not only give villains another chance to generate heat by bending the rules, but it would also help suspend the audience’s disbelief, as many punches today come off unrealistic for two reasons: a) there is 5 feet of space between fist and face and b) a real punch straight to the face knocks most people out cold.


6. Choke Holds & Other Illegal Maneuvers

Curb Stomp Banned
WWE.com

Similar to a closed fist, blatant choke holds do not test the in-ring abilities of a performer and can be dangerous if applied incorrectly, which was why they were once banned. Although they require a bit more technique, moves such as the Powerbomb and Piledriver have hopped on and off the no-list due to the perceived risks.

Today in WWE, it’s almost as if any move is fair game. The Shooting Star Press is allowed, despite Brock Lesnar breaking his neck. The Styles Clash is allowed regardless of the numerous accidents easily found on YouTube, and The Curb Stomp/Blackout is allowed although it was once considered too “perceptually violent.” Even many chokeholds, beyond the age-old Sleeper Hold, are allowed.

While using a risky maneuver can pop the crowd simply because it looks painful or is against the rules, if everyone does so night after night, the effect is lost. But when a heel sneaks in an outlawed move on a distracted referee, it makes it that much viler and devastating.


5. The Pat-Down

william regal brass knuckles
WWE.com

A major championship bout often calls on more traditional tropes, such as introducing superstars in the ring rather than on the way down the ramp, and having the referee display the title for all in attendance to see. In most cases, the official also waits for both men to be ready in opposite corners before signaling for the ring bell. But one thing that is missing from many matches in WWE today is the pre-match pat-down.

From shoot-style wrestling all the way up to the Ruthless Aggression Era, the acting referee not only made sure competitors were ready for the match but also tapped along their clothing to ensure everything met status quo and foreign objects would be introduced into the match.

The benefit of having the referee inspect wrestlers for weapons and the like was that it adds a sense of realism to the bout. And for heels, it was a great tool to draw more heat from introducing a banned instrument into the match, as demonstrated countless times by William Regal.


4. The Tag Rope

Baron Corbin tag rope
WWE

Some superstars still hold the tag rope from time to time, but over the years, it has been rendered purposeless. Countless hot tag sequences see fresh partners leaning halfway over the top rope, and some wrestlers pace along the apron from one ring post to the next and back again without the ref once demanding they stay in their corner.

The use of the tag rope may seem trivial, but it can serve to add dramatic elements to team matches.

By having to hold onto the rope, the desperate superstar is even more limited when it comes to reaching for the tag. Competitors may only have five seconds to return to their corners when attacking opponents now, but they used to also have the five count to go back to the tag rope regardless of their involvement. While it may seem like it prevents some wrestlers from showing how antsy they are to come in and save the match, it always reminds fans that there is little the superstars can do besides cheer and wait without facing disqualification.

In addition, reinforcing the use of the tag rope creates more breaks for overlooked illegal tags, and it can sustain suspense by stopping the faces from being able to switch out. The tag rope itself can also be manipulated for heelish or comedic purposes, as seen on multiple occasions with Eddie Guerrero.


3. 3-Count KOs

Whenever Samoa Joe slaps the Coquina Clutch on his opponents, it usually means lights-out. The other superstar struggles to escape before succumbing to the lack of oxygen, and the referee soon lifts the arm of the incapacitated wrestler once to call a knockout.

But the referee used to perform a slightly different task during such situations, and it once added more drama to bouts.

Today’s representation of a K.O. in WWE does lean on more traditional combat sports, and in some situations, such as the Brock Lesnar vs. The Undertaker's SummerSlam 2015 match, the current rule can make the loser look like a B.M.F., as Steve Austin did at WrestleMania 13.

Further back, the referee often elected to raise and drop the debilitated opponent’s hand three times to certify they were out cold. As The Rock often did during the Attitude Era, superstars who found that second wind shot their arm up in the air right before it slapped the mat for the third time, lifting the crowd to their feet. The three-count K.O. was also reinstated for 'The Great One's' match against John Cena at WrestleMania XXVIII.

While in many cases, WWE benefits when they present their product in more realistic ways, the name of the game is entertainment after all, and it should be considered whether the added suspense from a three count is worth trading with a bit of verisimilitude from the current presentation.


2. Interference

Jimmy Hart
WWE

Interference plagues professional wrestling matches now and it always has. The difference is how it was once perceived by the audience.

In current WWE programming, you can catch at least a half-dozen instances of outside interference in a match. Tag team partners decide to help themselves mid-match to support one of the competitors. Guest commentators inevitably involve themselves somehow. Managers cause distractions in front of the referee and generally have three strikes before they are banned from ringside.

Further back in WWE history, though, there was a much lower tolerance for interference. However, that wasn’t to say the rule remained unbroken. The stricter regulations weren’t simply to add a realistic edge to the bouts; they also provided openings for managers and competitors to draw heat from the audience. Superstars, such as Jimmy Hart, found ways to interfere in matches without being caught, which more often than not, fanned ongoing feuds.

In a WWE where superstars are allowed to distract rivals with their entrance packages mid-match and do so weekly, drawing more attention to this rule would help eliminate the redundancy of numerous run-ins and create a bigger pop when they do occur.


1. Time Limits

ric flair sting
WWE.com

In the past, WWE matches often had a 60-minute time limit. It’s rather difficult to imagine many of today singles matches lasting nearly a full hour, but at one point, it happened quite often. If neither competitor was victorious within the allotted time limit, the bout was considered a draw.

The downside of such as rule was that, on occasion, it led to an anticlimactic ending. However, it was a great tool for both faces and heels.

If two fan-favorites were locked up in battle, especially at the end of a series, it was a way to deliver a hellacious match without either superstar sacrificing some of their luster by going under, and it also helped hint at a rematch with a more impactful ending. For dastardly villains, it added another champion’s advantage. They could win simply by surviving the time limit.

In a world of instant gratification, the fear is that viewers might not stick around if they have to invest too much time on one specific match, but imposing time limits does add a lot of opportunities for wrestlers to shine in longer bouts as the likes of Sting, Ric Flair, and Greg Valentine once did.


Watch Next


In this post: 
WWE
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Chump the Champ. King of the Ring Rust. Mr. Money Down the Drain.